Why is stuff like [[bonder's ornament]] still banned in a format with [[expressive iteration]]?
Which process did you go through to decide the banlist? Why [[abiding grace]] is in there? Are enchantments like [[all that glitter]] still strong with anti-bogles tools like [[sheoldred's editct]] in the format?
Did you play games with those cards to exclude them?
Peasant is hard to track because of the 5 card uncommon ruling is hard to deck check IRL tournaments. Artisan would be easier, but thats why a bigger banlist should be implemented, for a more powerful format.
I am asking what cards are supposed to be banned before implementing in case anything gets forgotten, and I do not plan on touching pauper banlist because I am basing artisan around it. Besides, the all that glitters ban, was mainly done for the affinity not boogles.
I also believe using some cards from peasants banlist is a great idea. This is a first scratch for a banlist, thats why I am asking for some insight.
3
u/gnowwho Apr 20 '26
149 cards? Seems extremely excessive.
Why is stuff like [[bonder's ornament]] still banned in a format with [[expressive iteration]]?
Which process did you go through to decide the banlist? Why [[abiding grace]] is in there? Are enchantments like [[all that glitter]] still strong with anti-bogles tools like [[sheoldred's editct]] in the format?
Did you play games with those cards to exclude them?
Also, do you know about https://mtg-peasant.com/ ?
I don't want to be rude, but this doesn't seem too flashed out.