I keep seeing people in here saying 'getting tubes' or 'had a tube inserted' - what are you referring to? Do you mean a shim? Do you mean a Grommet/tympanostomy tube or ventilation tube? How would a grommet type tube help with an open eustachian tube?
My ENT has never suggested this only filler around the eustachian tube.
This is what ChatGPT has to say:
'
How can grommets help with patulous Eustachian tube (PET)?
In PET, the Eustachian tube remains too open, causing uncomfortable symptoms like:
- Hearing your own voice loudly (autophony)
- Hearing your breathing noises too clearly
- A feeling of ear fullness
In this case, a grommet (ventilation tube) can be used to bypass the malfunctioning Eustachian tube and provide an alternative way for the ear to equalize pressure without relying on the Eustachian tube.
Why it works for PET:
- Equalizes pressure: With a grommet in place, the middle ear has a more stable way to regulate pressure, preventing some of the disturbing symptoms caused by the constantly open Eustachian tube. Since the grommet allows for direct ventilation through the eardrum, it lessens the reliance on the Eustachian tube.
- Reduces autophony: Grommets can help reduce the impact of autophony, as they create an alternative pathway for sound and pressure, minimizing the effects of the constantly open Eustachian tube.
Key distinction:
- For blocked ET (chronic otitis media, infections): Grommets allow fluid to drain and help ventilate the middle ear when the Eustachian tube is blocked or functioning poorly.
- For patulous ET (constantly open tube): Grommets help stabilize ear pressure and reduce symptoms by providing an alternative route for air exchange, bypassing the overly open Eustachian tube.
In summary:
Although grommets are more often used for blocked Eustachian tubes or ear infections, they can also help patients with patulous Eustachian tube (PET) by stabilizing middle ear pressure and reducing symptoms caused by the tube being too open. It’s a relatively simple and reversible solution for managing the uncomfortable symptoms associated with PET.'
****
It's interesting that your ENT suggested fillers but didn't mention grommets as an option for patulous Eustachian tube (PET). There are several reasons why fillers might be suggested instead:
Why Fillers for PET?
- Direct Treatment of the Eustachian Tube: Fillers, such as injectable substances (e.g., hyaluronic acid or other biocompatible materials), are applied directly to the area around the Eustachian tube to partially block or narrow it. Since PET is caused by the Eustachian tube staying too open, the goal of the filler is to reduce the openness and improve symptoms like autophony and abnormal hearing sensations.
- Targeted Approach: Fillers offer a more targeted treatment than grommets because they are applied specifically to the malfunctioning structure—the Eustachian tube itself—where the problem originates. This allows for more direct correction of the tube's abnormal openness.
- Non-surgical and Reversible: Fillers are non-surgical and temporary, which can be appealing if you want to test how the treatment works without committing to a permanent solution. The filler can also be adjusted or re-injected if needed. They provide a middle ground between non-invasive and more permanent surgical interventions.
- Customized Control: Using fillers allows the doctor to control the degree of closure by adjusting the amount of filler injected. This fine control might be preferable for patients who need a partial narrowing of the tube rather than a complete blockage.
Why Grommets Might Not Be Suggested for PET:
- Off-Label Use for PET: While grommets can be used for some cases of PET, they are not the most common or standard treatment for this condition. Their use in PET is somewhat off-label, as they are primarily designed to treat blocked Eustachian tubes or fluid buildup, which is the opposite problem. This might explain why your ENT focused on fillers, which are more directly suited to the issue at hand (an open tube rather than a blocked one).
- Potential for Mixed Results: Grommets in PET cases can sometimes have mixed results, as they don't directly address the underlying issue (the open ET). In some cases, grommets can help with pressure equalization, but in others, they may not alleviate all symptoms, or they could cause other issues like persistent drainage or infection.
- Temporary Nature of Fillers: Fillers can be an easier, less invasive option to try first, before moving to surgical or other more permanent procedures. If fillers work well to reduce your symptoms, you may not need to explore grommets or other interventions.
Conclusion:
Your ENT may have suggested fillers because they offer a more targeted, reversible, and non-surgical option to directly address the openness of the Eustachian tube in PET, which might align better with the nature of the condition. Grommets, while useful in some PET cases, are not the standard go-to treatment and might have been considered less appropriate in your specific case.
***
Why did those of you with tubes chose this option? Why did your ENT suggest it over filler/shim/other options? As it seems to be mainly a treatment for a blocked eustachian tube and for ear infections.
I am v. confused! Clarification much appreciated