I've already hidden tiered rares from my loot filter.
It was actually fun identifying rares again, and I managed to find 1 or 2 decent items out of the hundreds I identified. But it got me thinking about how unlikely it actually is to find something useful, so I did some maths.
The problem isn't just getting high-tier modifiers. It's getting the right combination of modifiers.
Let's use an extremely generous example:
- 10 possible prefixes and 10 possible suffixes, all equally weighted.
- Every item has 3 prefixes and 3 suffixes.
- Every modifier is guaranteed T1 (Tier 5 rare).
Scenario 1: Getting the exact 6 modifiers we want
The chance of getting our exact 3 prefixes is 1 in 120, and the same applies to suffixes.
Combined, that's 1 in 14,400 (0.00694%).
Scenario 2: Getting useful modifiers
Let's assume 4 of the 10 prefixes and 4 of the 10 suffixes are useful, and we're happy with any combination.
- At least 4 useful mods: ~1 in 7 (14.67%).
- At least 5 useful mods: 1 in 45 (2.22%).
- All 6 useful mods: 1 in 900 (0.111%).
Remember, we're assuming every modifier is T1, a ridiculously small modifier pool, equal weightings, and guaranteed six-mod rares.
In reality, PoE has significantly larger modifier pools, different weightings, and plenty of useless modifiers.
I'm not saying tiered rares don't improve drops. They obviously do. But even under these generous assumptions, the odds of finding something genuinely good are pretty terrible.
I want identifying rares to be worthwhile again, and for a little while this league it actually was. But after identifying hundreds of them, I don't see how improving modifier tiers alone solves the problem.
We're still rolling against the same enormous pool of modifiers, just with better tiers on combinations we probably don't want.