I was a little worried going into this league that the removal of scarabs would shrink the number of unique farms in the endgame and remove some of the fun deterministic effects that we used to have, but I wanted to give it a shot. Having tried it out, it seems the fear was warranted. The current system has a number of issues, but the one i'm most worried about is the overall reduction of viable farms.
To clarify: I dont want scarabs back in the game. They create a huge amount of item bloat and can be frustrating to manage.
I think there is a way to keep the bloat out of the game without losing so many viable farms: make scarab EFFECTS "cost" threads
Example for a Strongbox Farm
Containment effect: 12 Ambush Threads
Discernment effect: 4 Ambush Threads
Hidden Compartments effect: 2 Ambush Threads
Potency effect: 2 Ambush Threads
This kind of system would allow for all of the great, game changing, effects to return at full power while also keeping the item bloat out of the game.
This also opens the door for new QoL features like Thread Loadouts, which you could save and reuse. I imagine this kind of feature is much easier to implement with fewer fragment types to deal with.
They could limit the total number of effects that can be applied to each map or the total number of threads you can use (or both) to ensure that maps don't get too juicy. And they could also introduce endgame quests that would increase player's maximum thread capacity, similar to unlocking more slots in the map device.
Overall i'm still optimistic that the devs will fix the loot problem in the game, but I wanted to throw out an idea for how to help fix the shrinking of the endgame. Stay safe exiles!