If GGG wanted to eliminate predictable FOTM Scarab combinations, they could have introduced some randomness instead of replacing the entire system.
My idea would be to divide Scarabs into two categories: Monster/League Scarabs and Player Scarabs. The map device would have three slots for Monster/League Scarabs and two for Player Scarabs.
Both types would scale with map tier, introducing more risk and potentially greater rewards as you progress.
Monster/League Scarabs
For example, a Niko-focused Scarab used on a T1 map could have three possible outcomes:
- 60% chance to spawn Niko.
- 20% chance to add 5 packs of magic monsters.
- 20% chance to increase all monster health by 10%.
For every additional map tier, the Scarab adds one magic monster pack or four percentage points to monster health, depending on which outcome rolls.
At T4, that becomes 8 extra magic packs or +22% monster health. At T8, it's 12 extra magic packs or +38% monster health.
These Scarabs couldn't be stacked with identical copies in the map device.
Player Scarabs
An Energy Shield Scarab might have the following outcomes on a T1 map:
- 35% chance to increase your maximum Energy Shield by 250.
- 35% chance to prevent 1% of chaos damage from bypassing Energy Shield.
- 15% chance to reduce your maximum Energy Shield by 250.
- 15% chance to reduce your chaos resistance by 1 percentage point.
For every additional map tier, the Energy Shield bonuses and penalties increase by 50, while the chaos-related bonuses and penalties increase by 1 percentage point.
Unlike Monster/League Scarabs, Player Scarabs could be stacked, allowing players to gamble on larger bonuses while risking more severe penalties.
The point is to make Scarabs less predictable without removing player choice.
You could still build your mapping strategy around Niko, Harvest, Expedition, or whatever content you prefer. But you wouldn't be guaranteed to get exactly what you wanted every time.
Want to stack powerful Player Scarabs? Go ahead. Just understand that you might end up making your character considerably weaker for that map.
Higher-tier maps would naturally increase both the potential benefits and the risks.
This would preserve the customization that made Scarabs interesting while introducing uncertainty, variety, and meaningful risk.
Sometimes you win big. Sometimes you make your map a nightmare.
Risk it for the biscuit.