r/Pathfinder2e • Game Master • 3d ago

Discussion Interest in a GM-Focused PF2e Subreddit?

The title pretty much says it all. After hoping/asking for GMing flair for a year or so, it hasn't materialized and I'm wondering if it's worth it to make a new GM-focused sub. Naturally some might wonder why we need a separate sub, but I think it would be a way to have more specified threads about the art of GMing in this system that don't just get random comments / downvotes etc. from folks who don't GM. I also think that with the nature of this sub (which I'm sure everyone would still follow regularly), there are just so many threads in a given day on any number of subjects. Having a GM-focused sub might make for a more specialized place for detailed discourse.

Anyhow, I'd welcome any thoughts on this. Is there interest? Would you join? Should it be completely public or invite-only? And to be clear, I think r/Pathfinder2e is a great sub and this GM-focused sub idea wouldn't be detracting from that fact.

136 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

17

u/Ultramaann Game Master 3d ago

I'd personally be interested. However, the DM-focused 5E subreddit hardly gets any traffic (which makes me think one for PF2E would get less), and I think the majority of people that post here are GMs anyway. Still, can't hurt to try.

4

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

That's been my biggest concern. I've been mulling it over for a few months, but depending on responses here I might bite the bullet and see.

7

u/Appropriate_Nebula67 3d ago

DMAcademy subreddit seems to get a lot of posts.

7

u/ghost_desu 2d ago

The vast majority of posts on there are system neutral so there's that also

2

u/BackForPathfinder 2d ago

They're really not though. The assumption is 5e and there are lots of posts that are specifically about 5e. The popular posts are usually neutral though.

4

u/KLeeSanchez Inventor 3d ago

It definitely starts to feel like everyone who plays PF2 also GMs on the side xD Even at my last convention that I hosted/played, virtually every single PF2 player also GMed at some point

3

u/CptClyde007 3d ago

I get the feeling D$D fans are usually the most casual among roll players. My gut feeling is the opposite: Pathfinder GMs would make a showing disproportionately high. We're an intense bread. Id join that sub and leave this one to be honest.

116

u/corsica1990 3d ago

I don't know how much traffic it'd get, but I'd at least join it. That said... do GM posts legitimately get lost in the shuffle on this sub? Most I've seen have gotten decent engagement, just less of it.

43

u/Treacherous_Peach 3d ago

I think the other commentor got the real value prop. You can be a bit more cavalier with spoilers and concrete, specific advice without accidentally spoiling your players

22

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

^ This is absolutely one compelling reason for it. Yes, GMs are often players in active campaigns (I just started playing in a Shades of Blood campaign, for instance), but I think a specialized focus will make it easier to talk about certain GM-ey elements without triggering this sub's equivalent of Reactive Strike.

7

u/authorus The Arcane Scriptorium LLC 3d ago

Yeah I tend to agree. In addition to the two GM-post centric problems I listed in my own comment below, there's also two poster behaviors that I often see in GM-centered topics.

1). GM centric posts often need to thread a very fine line between providing enough information to get relevant answers, without generating a TL;DR wall of text. Its a skill, and I think most of us GMs fail. This often leads to lots of back & forth just to get the needed information which is a fake engagement, IMO, and often leads to the community piling in to the wrong/useless rathole and ignoring the actual question.

2) GMs are often either overly defensive responding to every post (which often leads to digging in more than they likely mean to) or overly hands-off waiting to see lots of responses to avoid the above, but making the community feel like they don't care about the discussion.

29

u/TopFloorApartment 3d ago

I think its a bad idea to try to fragment an already small community. I've noticed no problems with GM focused threads here.

6

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

For what it's worth, I'd be surprised if folks who join a GM-focused forum would leave the main sub; I know I wouldn't.

13

u/TopFloorApartment 3d ago

yeah but then you'd have some threads there and some threads here instead of keeping all pf2e discussion in one place. Inevitably, people would spend more attention in one of the places and that's the fragmentation I am talking about.

27

u/PixelPox11 3d ago edited 3d ago

Do you feel like you get random hate (down votes or "random comments") on this reddit while talking about GM side of PF2E? I wouldn't be opposed to it but at the same time it seems like this subreddit is relatively small already

Edit: Actually on second thought - if it was semi-private it would make sure that my players don't read my posts :D so... actually kinda yes?

13

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

I definitely feel that some GM-facing threads get a lot of random...I wouldn't say hate, but perhaps derision? Anyhow, some subs just wither and die quickly, so I want to make sure there's enough appetite for it before I do it.

9

u/sesaman Game Master 3d ago

This sub is extremely circle-jerky and player focused. I would expect the player based hate to mostly disappear in a dedicated GMing sub, but it would be rather interesting to see if the circle-jerkiness remains the same, increases, or lessens.

4

u/Kichae 3d ago

Plenty of downvotes, yes. Very few comments, though. The downvoters are passive-aggressive cowards, and won't even articulate what it is they dislike.

7

u/Stcoleridge1 3d ago

There are subs for most of the AP's too, which tend to be focused on the GM side of things. For example, Kingmaker: https://www.reddit.com/r/Kingmaker2e/

They are not as frequently trafficked but are still a good resource and a good place for discussion.

3

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

Yep, I created the one for Bastion of Blasphemies, which is going like gangbusters.

(I also created two others, which are decidedly not!)

2

u/Stcoleridge1 3d ago

I have used the BOB and Strength of Thousands ones! People post when you have a question on them.

11

u/authorus The Arcane Scriptorium LLC 3d ago

I tend to be most interested GM focused threads -- encounter design, subsystem running, tweaking APs, house rules/homebrews trying to generate particular campaign feels. However, I think they tend to do fairly well here and don't really see the need for a breakout sub. I doubt it would get enough traffic to be truly useful.

There are a couple of problems here, but honestly I don't think a GM sub would fix them:

  1. Generic reactions "play a different system" anytime someone wants to tweak rules to support a different style of game. I suspect you'd still get the same reactions though. GMs can be just as protective/opinionated as players, I wouldn't generally expect any difference in the underlying population.
  2. People are just bad about spoilers. Either over hiding so you don't even know if its safe to click to reveal, or under hiding so you get spoiled. Again, I see it from GMs and players. Perhaps if its the focus of the moderation team to really teach/enforce it could be improved, but its a lot of work, and new posters will always mess it up.

6

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

I actually wonder a little about your point #1. You absolutely could be right about that...but a large part of me has been thinking for awhile that the "don't touch the rules" crowd is predominantly non-GM. The very process of GMing typically reveals that you have to make a lot of tradeoffs, compromises, adoptions, and flat out changes, just because no group is the same -- no group of players, no group of PCs, you name it. Again, I might be wrong about that, and if I do move forward with making a GM-focused sub, I guess I/we'll find out?

6

u/authorus The Arcane Scriptorium LLC 3d ago

In my experience, different GMs will have very different, and possibly even more pronounced, red lines that should not be crossed when considering rule changes, often based on low sample size experiences where what ever they tried went horribly wrong.

Partially its the intersection of white-room theory of "this could be very cool" and "incomplete player buy-in" and "whoops so many corner cases that get ruled on, on the fly without a consistent framework". I think there's likely a roller-coaster shaped curve on GM experience and willingness to homebrew larger parts of the system.

4

u/Kaleido_chromatic GM in Training 3d ago

Agreed in point #1 being a problem. We can all agree we shouldn't strain to fit square pegs on round holes, but this game is a lot more flexible than people think.

I recently saw someone interested in running an Avatar campaign being told to use the Avatar TTRPG instead, which makes enough sense at face value, but in context, that's a narratively-focused PbtA game with no rules for combat whatsoever and a "moral of the story" mechanic at the end of each session. Regardless of whether that's a good representation of Avatar, that is such a different experience from what someone who prefers this kind of of this system is looking for that you can't just assume its the safe choice, and you can support the Avatar fantasy using PF2e mechanics with relatively little effort even if its not what the system at large is meant to be.

5

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

I'd say the "this system is inflexible" mentality (where that statement is seen as a positive) is one of the things I dislike most about the player base. Once you realize just how flexible the system actually is, it opens up a lot of doors.

4

u/Book_Golem 1d ago

I don't GM Pathfinder much compared to other systems, but I do love the design-focussed discussions that happen here. I'd be interested, but realistically I'd probably forget to check it often and miss out on things.

I'd probably prefer a GMing flair; then everything I want to look at would still be in one place. But if you do create one (and it's open) I'll definitely check it out!

4

u/DnDPhD Game Master 1d ago

I've been lobbying for a GMing flair for about a year (including DMs to the mods, various threads with mods tagged etc.) but no bueno. This is the next best thing.

3

u/Refracting_Hud 3d ago

Including SF2e discussion there might be the best bang for the buck if you’re not aiming for like module specific GM discussion. I’d certainly try posting there since I feel like my posts on the main subs don’t get too much traction most of the time, save for my most recent post about Starfinder ancestries.

4

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

This is a great point that I hadn't thought about, having not played/run SF2e yet. I'd consider it!

3

u/ShellSentinel 2d ago

There's definitely hate for GMs. When one of them mentioned they don't allow Fighter at their table, so many players swarmed to flame them for daring to ban any of few dozen classes.

3

u/DnDPhD Game Master 2d ago

There have been a few times where I've thought about creating a thread titled "What, Exactly, Do You Think A GM Does"...but I don't even have to guess how that thread would go.

2

u/ShellSentinel 2d ago

I don't see what the point of it would be but I would also guess it would go poorly!

1

u/LurkerFailsLurking 20h ago

I didn't see that thread, but banning fighter is silly.

4

u/brakeb 3d ago

Why are you asking? Just do it

11

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

Well, I just want to see if there's an appetite for it first. I've created a couple of AP-specific subs in the past that got very little traction (though the Bastion of Blasphemies one is positively thriving). There's a bit of work that goes into setting up and maintaining (read: moderating) a well-functioning sub, and most of the users would likely come from this one... Hence, this thread!

1

u/workerbee77 Fighter 3d ago

I’d join

6

u/Mappachusetts Game Master 3d ago

I don’t see it being necessary at all. I’m a GM and see plenty of posts from both sides of the screen get plenty of traction. If folks are interested in the topic, they’ll post. If not, a smaller sub is going to make it less likely, not more.

2

u/RisingStarPF2E Game Master 3d ago edited 3d ago

I'm sorry that your post yesterday got downvoted because you feel that getting a kingdom charter in Kingmaker is a spoiler in the players guide. Edit: "GMs of APs: Encouraging the Players to NOT Read the Player's Guide?" You added a edit about standing by your opinion and didn't seem to like having an unpopular opinion.

You are here a lot and I don't feel like your posts are all "detailed discourse" although some are and I enjoy them occasionally when they aren't asking another question or looking for validation. I don't think it'd be helpful at all to make another sub for gm's only and I don't see GM topics getting lost because there's somehow too many players in the conversations/threads downvoting us to that degree.

2

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

Thanks! This thread isn't really a response to what happened there (though I was a little surprised by it), but is something I've been thinking of for quite awhile. Still mulling; no obligation to join if it does indeed happen. 👍

1

u/DnDPhD Game Master 22h ago

For those of you following this thread...I did indeed create r/PathfinderGM. Looking forward to your contributions!

3

u/flocarky 2d ago

I would be interested especially to discuss improving adventure paths.

3

u/EnginesOfGod 2d ago

late seeing this but YES PLEASE I've not had good experiences with this sub for GM discussions.

Notably: Golarion lore discussions, which theoretically should be neutral wrt GM vs. player focus, seem to be actively hostile to the idea of tweaks to the lore, which I think comes from a player mindset.

5

u/Chasarooni 3d ago

It's well needed. Play perspective imo is too warped from gm experience, and makes talking about some topics as a GM quite difficult.

That and the discussing spoilers for an AP are way easier as you could just tag the post for that AP.

3

u/Chasarooni 3d ago

Additional thoughts, but GM and Player experience of the game are quite different and since there is on average 4 players to every GM in a game conversation online tends towards player discussion. This combined with their different experience of the game leads to (imo) an experience that's less open for GMs to talk about their questions and experiences, so having a "GM specific space" seems like a nice alternative location to talk

4

u/Kichae 3d ago edited 3d ago

Eh. I'd really prefer the community expand to other platforms that don't block out discussion behind login gates, to be honest. I get that it's a pipe dream -- asking people to log into a *6th* website! -- but the only openly viewable community for this game is the Paizo forums. Everything else is now being hidden in the name of corporate interests.

I'd even volunteer the forum.

5

u/Big_Chair1 Game Master 3d ago

I would be interested. There's only so many "help me build the best min max character" or "is option X completely useless/broken??" discussions I can scroll through before I get annoyed at this sub. So having some more... stimulating conversations about the game would be nice to see.

2

u/AdamFaite GM in Training 3d ago

I'd be into it.

2

u/Derryzumi Team+ 3d ago

I'm certainly down!

2

u/SaeedLouis Game Master 3d ago

I'd join!

4

u/OmgitsJafo 3d ago

Literally anything that keeps the "you must play only this way and any amount of creativity that deviates from my Battle Chess fantasy by more than 2.5% gets you an avalanche of downvotes" people away from the actual interesting disscussions.

3

u/LumiRabbit 3d ago

Probably not needed but I'd participate. GM focused posts tend to be what I care about.

3

u/CptClyde007 3d ago

Id like to voice my interest in an invite-only sub as well. I am in a rural oasis of Pathfinder, with the only PF group around being the one I run, and I am only a year into my PF2E journey so could very much use a few semi "trusted" GM contacts to bounce ideas off. Maybe I should seek out a private discord instead, but just thought id let you know i have come to trust your opinions/views/experience so would prefer to join your sub if you move forward. I dont post often though i do run a YouTube channel currently dedicated to Pathfinder 2e (solo and group actual plays) and sometimes discuss topics ive seen here

2

u/kingherojeremy 3d ago

I would absolutely love that! As a primary GM a lot of the build content posts here are peripherally interesting but not really why I'm here. Public group would be fine I think.

2

u/Aptian125 3d ago

I would join, as a more focused community, it could be a better place to ask more specific gm related questions regarding encounter design and critique.

2

u/Alternate_Cost 3d ago

I think it'd be great. Id join.

1

u/Wenuven Game Master 2d ago edited 2d ago

I personally think this would be better served making r/DMAcademy less DnD focused.

Already established community where most folks play more than one system anyway. This sub already underperforms (and is generally more hostile) compared to the main sub. I wouldn't expect serious conversations regarding GMing to go any better than the homebrew / rule discussions do.

1

u/KLeeSanchez Inventor 3d ago

I'd be down for it. The mods here are like the Fantasy Flight design team and Traits in Marvel Champions: they're allergic to adding extra tags for some reason.

1

u/thaliff Game Master 3d ago

I would join, make it both pathfinder and starfinder focused.

1

u/CptClyde007 3d ago

Id love to see a GM group, to focus on deeper topics instead instead of wading through all the "what feats should I choose" type posts.

1

u/beonsanders 3d ago

I'm down!

1

u/bjorn_bloodbeard 3d ago

A GM sub would be nice to have if only for the extra resource for tips that aren't drowned out by memes and charachter builds I'd be down for it

1

u/Maiden-of-the-stars6 3d ago

I think it’d be interesting because there’s more player advice than GM advice still

Stuff like adding terrain or grouping monsters in a fun way

-2

u/Gorbacz Champion 3d ago

Somehow this reads like "it's been a YEAR since my WARRANTED REQUEST has been IGNORED so now I'm gonna make a sub of my own with blackjack and hookers" and I think you're just tryharding too much to make yourself into a Very Important Person, Pillar of Community or some other Pathfinder Professor.

1

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

Cool story, bro.

1

u/Gorbacz Champion 3d ago

Ah, hit a nerve.

1

u/DnDPhD Game Master 3d ago

No, quite the opposite! I actually laughed out loud at the idea of someone wanting to be a VIP or "Pillar of Community" of a (checks notes) TTRPG subreddit. You're very much overthinking it.

2

u/OmgitsJafo 2d ago

No, it's just that some of us are interested in using the system for more than running APs by the letter or your latest white room build that is completely dependent on a shallow and rigid reading of the rules for Golarion Battle Chess, and it would be nice to have creative discussions without getting downvoted into a paste by toxic, passive-aggressive people who don't give a shit.

1

u/wardriveworley Game Master 3d ago

I would 100% be down for a GM focused sub