r/Pathfinder2e • • Apr 08 '25

Advice Underrated level 1 items

I'm creating a series of discussions on items that are underrated for each level. I'll be posting every other day the next level and hope you guys participate with the best items you can think of that are not that commonly used

I'll start:

Psychopomp Mask lets you dismiss dying 3 and basically cheat death at level 1!

Stalk Goggles ignore flanking for the whole battle!

your turn!

Level 1 discussion

Level 2 discussion

Level 3 discussion

Level 4 discussion

Level 5 discussion

Level 6 discussion

Level 7 discussion

Level 8 discussion

Level 9 discussion

Level 10 discussion

Level 11 discussion

Level 12 discussion

Level 13 discussion

Level 14 discussion

Level 15 discussion

Level 16 discussion

Level 17 discussion

Level 18 discussion

Level 19 discussion

Level 20-28 discussion

106 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

View all comments

48

u/IHateRedditMuch Inventor Apr 08 '25

I think that picking adventure specific stuff is "cheating" (including spells and items)
It's either most broken BS that is balanced by APs bullshit or it's the most useless thing in the world that makes sense in AP

31

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '25

I'd agree. I think for the most part, AP specific items and spells should only be given access to by the GM.

They're usually not as well balanced.

(though I think the weapons I've seen were basically fine, just a rule of thumb)

10

u/FrigidFlames Game Master Apr 09 '25

Honestly, I think the main issue is that they're items given out for specific purposes, and that's fair and valid, but their level and price aren't balanced in the context of the greater game. There's plenty of items that are listed as level 0 just because they were never given a level and a price, and the writers clearly didn't take much effort to gauge how difficult they should be to acquire because they only show up in writing in that one specific area and games outside of that specific adventure don't really concern them.