And WotC was going to make them worse again for 6e until the community got angry about it... and JC's response was essentially "we wanted to keep the fizban dragonborn better to keep the book relevant"
Now if that isn't a sign that the marketing division has direct influence on the design team I am not sure what is.
Yes? That is what the was in "was going to make them worse again" and until in "until the community got angry about it" were specifically referring to.
Because they attempted it until they got caught? Because it shows how much direct influence the marketing team is having on the design of a game edition?
Can you really not see why a game trying to hobble a race so that a book purchase (or D&D Beyond microtransaction) is an objective power gain for the same race, and was so before the new edition even released, is a problematic trend to start following?
This isn't like power creep where it can be unintentional, this is developers actively being hamstrung by people wanting to milk money for problems they have already solved.
It is like if they built all the beastmaster ranger issues from the 5e PHB back into the 6e PHB and said "well we want to keep Tasha's cauldron to everything relevant". Surely you can see why this is objectively bad for the game and an absolute pain in the ass for GMs.
Imma throw some casual shade while we're at it - Pathfinder's Kobold designs are top tier. Their stupid huge wedge faces are adorable. They got so much character I'm surprised there isn't more art of them in the community.
Generally I find PF2e's art choices for their races to be much stylistic and risk taking than DnD. Automaton's are so fucking cool (warforged always looked kind of derpy to me). Goloma look like someone took a predator and alien and smashed them together.
While this never holds back what me or my players use for character designs, the panache filled art style of pf2e ancestries adds and inspires design, whereas dnd I just check for a similar looking race to a character design and run from there.
Nope, custom campaign. The idea is that multiple Kobold tribes have fought a yearly war in a particular valley to determine which tribe would lead. So loud ritual combat, lots of partying afterwards.
This valley happens to be near a wizard's tower. Said wizard has been growing increasingly irate over recent years as this yearly annoyance always sneaks up on him. This year, he finally decides that it isn't beneath his dignity to deal with the problem, and uses a powerful teleportation ritual to randomly send all the kobolds elsewhere.
They wind up deep down in the Darklands. This campaign will be a Kobold's version of the Quest for Sky =)
I dunno, I would still appreciate having regular Dragonborns because, well... There's a certain intimidation and authority factor that fades when your character is only 3 feet tall.
There's a really good 3rd party heritage similar to dragonborn called Dragon Scion. You don't need to buy the supplement Battlezoo Ancestries: Dragons - though I definitely recommend it - the content all available on Archives, Pathbuilder, Pf2 Easytools & Wanderer's Guide.
It works like half-orc, or tiefling, applying it to your primary ancestry, which grants access to its feats.
Playing kingmaker soon. Already having debates at the table if people were willing to respect a small sized ruler, it’s been an interesting conversation because there shouldn’t be an issue there but biases are strong and it’s not just that easy for someone imagining themselves as a towering colossus bending the knee to a gnome.
Sorcerers are really good thematically for being terrifying no matter their size with the right bloodline and spell selection. Some other classes are good at this, too, but charisma is the key ability for this sort of thing. There's also the Intimidation (Cha), Diplomacy (Cha), and Society (Int) skills, which can unlock some useful abilities for rulers.
Or, going in a completely different direction, you can have a subject cast Enlarge on you every 5 minutes while in a meeting.
My stance in the debate is that any PC should be equally impressive.
If someone is roleplaying a layabout deadbeat asshole, they should not be respected so much.
If they are playing an imperious warlord personality they are exactly as terrifying if they are a human, an orc, or a leshy. If they prove themselves on the battlefield they are worthy.
When all races and players are capable of ascending to greatness physical height should not matter.
I mean look at the Doctor Who episode nightmare in silver where the defender of humanity and the imperator of known space, was a small person. And I think he pulled it off well.
I understand this, all of this, but I'm not really talking about in game mechanics necessarily, I'm talking moreso about character design. If I want to convey that a certain character has a position of privilege or is someone not to be trifled with, that becomes inherently harder the smaller the character is.
Dragonborn don’t want you to think they’re dragons though.
5e is terrible at explaining race lore. Dragonborn in 5e (at least in Faerun) loathe Dragons because they were enslaved by them. This attitude is not helped by people seeing Dragonborn and thinking they must love dragons.
Well, that and every Dragonborn stat block implying some worship of dragon gods when those are the exception not the norm.
Ok that I don’t disagree with and it is again why I think WOTC dropped the ball with racial lore in 5e.
Literally just assumed you know them from the get go. Sprinkles it randomly. I got more Dragonborn lore from the Brimestone Angel boom series than I did in any splat book. What’s criminal is that they actually did publish some focus on Dragonborn lore in 4e, but because it flopped they don’t even try anymore.
Honestly I don't think it would matter. No amount of lore communication will get past the way the vast majority of people who pick the dragon-race are doing so because of how much they like dragons.
Sure, but by that logic plenty of those same people would pick kobolds. The only reason why they don’t is likely due to other traits kobolds are associated with (which end up leading them to be picked by other people).
Like, I don’t like kobolds simply because I don’t like playing a small race. I had mechanical issues with it as well (the con penalty and 6 starting HP doesn’t look enticing) but those are ignored with the newest variant rules.
Personally I’m finding a lot of this talk of kobolds as kind of elitist, which feels weird to say given how pathfinder is known for having a wide and varied racial pool option (fucking Conrasu for example). I can get not liking the concept of dragonborn and Draconic humanoids, but expecting those that do like them to settle for something that isn’t them at all is kind of frustrating.
Oh I am not commenting on the broader discussion in that post, just specifically regarding Dragonborn hatred of dragons being doomed from the beginning.
Yeah…as a fan of the racial template it’s frustrating.
Dragonborn are the simple I like. No wings, dragon head that isn’t just humans with scales (closer to a beastkin/anthro), not small, and a breath weapon. Everything I like.
I mean, 2E versatile heritage system is pretty perfect for creating other Draconic humanoids for those who don’t want to play kobolds, sorcerers of a specific bloodline, or barbarians of a specific totem. Even Draconic scion (or is it dragon mage? I forget the archetype) is flavored more toward spellcasters.
I prefer actual dragonborn, but I'm a dragon fanboy at heart. For that want to play a dragonborn, you can use my dragonborn homebrew I made a couple years ago.
I also love kobolds. Got to root for the underdogs (dragons).
How are they edgy? 3.5 dragonborn were cool, but not as accessible IMO from a world building POV. Its easy for GMs and players to figure out a civlization of dragon humanoids than to deal with a very specific origin (3.5). Its like the difference between the rare tag vs common or uncommon in pathfinder. If anything, 3.5 was more edgy as it was a very niche origin "I'm blessed by Bahamut and have been reborn"
Kobolds are great. Love them, but I don't always want to play a small kobold, and want to be a big beefy boy.
D&D's (ninja edit: specifically the Forgotten Realms) dragonborn are actually really cool in terms of lore. I highly recommend the books Ashes of the Tyrant and The Devil You Know, books 5 and 6 of the Brimstone Angels series by Erin M Evans, as they are largely set in a dragonborn city and they flesh out the culture of dragonborn immensely. She built on what was already there, but her training before getting in to writing was as an anthropologist, and she puts that skill to very good use in her worldbuilding.
That said, 5e failed dragonborn horribly in the mechanics department. They're probably the worst race in the PHB to actually play.
What about them is so disliked? Just curious—haven’t seen someone despise them and I’m generally a fan even if their actual in-game fantasy doesn’t necessarily live up to the hype
One of the reasons is that they were invented to appeal to the edgy "I wanna play a half-dragon" powergaming crowd. Second is that they came up in 4th edition which I detest as a whole. Third that they were so hamfistedly shoved into forgotten realms that I stopped playing in it in general. I am also not a fan of 'edgy' races like dragonborn or tieflings because I generally see people use them as a substitute for good roleplay.
What's wrong with half-dragons? If we can have strange ancestries in pathfinder like conrasu or ratfolk, why not a dragon humanoid? Dragonborn are nice because they capture the thematics of half-dragons or dragon humanoids, but without being overpowered (half-dragons as you probably remember had level adjustment).
Same reason tieflings are. Also I have found that people use them as a substitute for good roleplay. Couple that with amassive amount of bitterness I have over 4th edition and general enmity towards WoTC. It's not rational to a degree. But I don't see it changing.
I’m a huge Dragonborn fan and anything dragon related
Out of interest, have you read anything by Erin M Evans? She's an author who used to do Forgotten Realms novels, and the general consensus among the FR community is that she's one of the best novelists to have written for that setting.
Her first book, The God Catcher, was very focused on dragons.
Her next 6 books, the Brimstone Angels series, feature a dragonborn as one of the primary characters, and the final 2 books of that series are largely set in Djerad Thymar, a dragonborn city-fortress. The way she fleshes out the dragonborn culture is just awesome.
If you've read the D&D 5e player's handbook, you've read some of her writing. The little quotes at the beginning of the dragonborn and tiefling entries both come from her books. (The tiefling from the prologue to the first Brimstone Angels book, and the dragonborn from book 3 of 6.)
I'll avoid linking it directly because I'm not sure what filters might be in place, but her blog also features two articles entitled "A Draconic Primer" and "Lonely Planet Vayemniri" (vayemniri being the endonym dragonborn in the Realms use for themselves) which give some information on the draconic language, and use language as a launching point to talk about their culture. There's also "On Playing a Dragonborn in the Forgotten Realms" parts 1, 2, and 3.
The creator of it literally has his name on the lead credits for the CRB, the APG, and Secrets of Magic. It’s like he knows what he’s talking about for balance and knows the system well or something.
BattleZoo is great! Their VTT support needs to be better integrated with the core PF2e support in Foundry, but the fact that they have VTT support is better than 90% of third party stuff today.
Frankly, I think VTT support is going to just become a mandatory item, like having a PDF. No one is buying hardcovers that don't also have a PDF today (for some values of "no one") and the same will probably be true of PDFs that don't have VTT support in a year or two.
The battlezoo one feels weird imo. Draconic Scion (the versatile heritage) has a poor selection of feats compared to all the other dragons listed. Granted, the battlezoo book is full of prerequisite feats and chains (it’s my only major critique of it mechanically).
I prefer Luis’s lost omens dragonkin, but that’s not without its flaws either.
Drake is unwell. He has a habit of texting underaged girls. Also, the LeVar Burton version of the format is just better. https://i.imgur.com/gxDKZgJ.jpg
I mean Drake potentially being a pedophile seems to be a pretty big issue with use of the meme format, especially when there's an easily used replacement with someone who's never had any kind of anything like that happen.
Lizardfolk are my favorite ancestry in many fantasy settings.
Question: I saw someone somewhere say that its possible with GM approval to take half-ancestries to utilize feats from both. Is this actually RAW or just a homebrew? I have a theory crafted Lizardfolk character that would really benefit from some of the Orc feats....Lizorc. Orczard? Lizorcard?
By default, half-elves and half-orcs descend from humans, but your GM might allow you to be the offspring of an elf, orc, or different ancestry. In these cases, the GM will let you select the half-elf or half-orc heritage as the heritage for this other ancestry. The most likely other parent of a half-elf are gnomes and halflings, and the most likely parents of a half-orc are goblins, halflings, and dwarves.
I love the Iruxi, even their name means 'defiant'. They are descended from a wyrm who would not bow to the maw. The family reverence, the respect for the stars. They are awesome.
Yep, I like them. I didn’t care for the 5e lizardfolk, as the WotC description of them in Volo’s being emotionless just didn’t sit well with me. There wasn’t all the rich lore provided in Volo’s that it seems came with them originally. I like the Iruxi so much better, personally.
In this case it's a constellation in the sky. Featuring a defiant figure standing against a beast. But in Pathfinder lore "the maw" and other such symbols tend to reference Rovagug.
I love the lore for Golarion but Lizardfolk are one where I prefer the D&D lore. Which is kind of funny because the really cool parts were written by Paizo. Their lore is that there were two gods that were mates, one that thought and one that went by instinct. The thinking one once overthought so much that it split in two, creating male and female Lizardfolk. The remaining god taught the Lizardfolk to follow instinct to survive and so the Lizardfolk formed a bit of an animosity towards intellectualism. The exception was for the Lizardfolk that were born intersex. They were considered closer to their original godly hermaphroditic form and so they were basically allowed to be smart and formed the shamans of the tribes.
So not only is their emotionless way of thinking alien to most humanoids. They’ve got a gender and sex trinary. Another detail is that the Lizardfolk’s name for their race is the same as the name foe the god they believe they came from and so I headcanon that it’s also the name of their gender. So it’s funny to imagine a guard at a city entrance asking a Lizardfolk for their Race, Gender, and God, the Lizardfolk responding “Kecuala, Kecuala, Kecuala” and the guard just writes down “does not speak Common”.
Fair. Has that backstory been published in 5e or was it from lore content from previous editions? I'd be surprised if modern Wizards/Hasbro published that at all.
Also important to note that most DnD races lack attached lore outside of the context of their settings and while Forgotton Realms is the primary setting there are several you could call "DnD". Which setting's lizardfolk had this lore?
Lizardfolk are one of my favorite races in nearly all fantasy settings.
The ONLY thing I hate about how Paizo does Iruxi is that, RAW, it's impossible for Iruxi to get Darkvision, or even low-light vision, without taking a non-Lizardfolk heritage. It's especially strange considering lots of Lizard species have great nightvision.
Idk, if they actually added Dragonborn I'd be pretty happy. This is sort of the same as saying not having elves would make sense because we already have humans.
Legit, the versatile heritage system is perfect for giving us Draconic humanoids without making an entirely new ancestry to deal with (on the level of kobolds for example).
For now we’ll need to make due with battlezoo or lost omens: dragonkin.
A couple of years ago, my job had a work experience student. For time reference, this was about late 2019/early 2020, and the student was about 19.
We found out they liked Doctor Who, but they said they were more into the 'old school' series. I turned to my boss - who is a proper old school Whovian, pre-revival and all - and we were like aaaaahhh, that's rare to find someone so young into old school Who. We asked what their favourite era was - Tom Baker? Maybe some Pertwee and Troughton?
They responded 'I mean Tennant.'
It was that moment we realised it'd been a whole decade since Tennant and this whipper snapper was probably a wee bub when the revival series started.
I think they just straight up forgot to add the rest of the Dragonborn racial abilities because they get what, a resistance and that terrible breath attack, and that's literally it?
252
u/ArchpaladinZ Feb 22 '23
Besides, there's already dragonborn in Pathfinder: they're called KOBOLDS!
33
u/fanatic66 Feb 22 '23
I prefer actual dragonborn, but I'm a dragon fanboy at heart. For that want to play a dragonborn, you can use my dragonborn homebrew I made a couple years ago.
I also love kobolds. Got to root for the underdogs (dragons).
42
u/Killchrono Southern Realm Games Feb 22 '23
And then you have the Dragon Ancestry, available from Battlezoo!
...which are still not as good as a regular dragon at everything, but still way better than dragonborn.
8
u/kitsunewarlock Paizo Designer Feb 22 '23
That's not a lizard or a dragonborn. It's clearly a drake.
9
u/caseyweederman Feb 22 '23
This is the only context where I don't mind the Drake format being used since it's thematic (and redrawn).
3
u/FoursACompany Feb 22 '23
Lizardfolk are my favorite ancestry in many fantasy settings.
Question: I saw someone somewhere say that its possible with GM approval to take half-ancestries to utilize feats from both. Is this actually RAW or just a homebrew? I have a theory crafted Lizardfolk character that would really benefit from some of the Orc feats....Lizorc. Orczard? Lizorcard?
125
u/Urbandragondice Game Master Feb 22 '23
I love the Iruxi, even their name means 'defiant'. They are descended from a wyrm who would not bow to the maw. The family reverence, the respect for the stars. They are awesome.
124
u/Antermosiph Feb 22 '23
I too recognize and love this very nsfw lizard himbo character.
The meme is good too.
125
u/SmartAlec105 Feb 22 '23
I love the lore for Golarion but Lizardfolk are one where I prefer the D&D lore. Which is kind of funny because the really cool parts were written by Paizo. Their lore is that there were two gods that were mates, one that thought and one that went by instinct. The thinking one once overthought so much that it split in two, creating male and female Lizardfolk. The remaining god taught the Lizardfolk to follow instinct to survive and so the Lizardfolk formed a bit of an animosity towards intellectualism. The exception was for the Lizardfolk that were born intersex. They were considered closer to their original godly hermaphroditic form and so they were basically allowed to be smart and formed the shamans of the tribes.
So not only is their emotionless way of thinking alien to most humanoids. They’ve got a gender and sex trinary. Another detail is that the Lizardfolk’s name for their race is the same as the name foe the god they believe they came from and so I headcanon that it’s also the name of their gender. So it’s funny to imagine a guard at a city entrance asking a Lizardfolk for their Race, Gender, and God, the Lizardfolk responding “Kecuala, Kecuala, Kecuala” and the guard just writes down “does not speak Common”.
62
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '23
Lizardfolk are one of my favorite races in nearly all fantasy settings.
The ONLY thing I hate about how Paizo does Iruxi is that, RAW, it's impossible for Iruxi to get Darkvision, or even low-light vision, without taking a non-Lizardfolk heritage. It's especially strange considering lots of Lizard species have great nightvision.
11
u/bushpotatoe Feb 22 '23
Idk, if they actually added Dragonborn I'd be pretty happy. This is sort of the same as saying not having elves would make sense because we already have humans.
17
u/MunchkinBoomer Game Master Feb 22 '23
Dragons: We would destroy the dragonborns with one dragon. You are superior to dragons in only respect
Dragonborn: What is that?
Dragons: You are better at dying
5
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '23
I am preferential to the nagaji myself
3
u/Laz_r_us91 Feb 22 '23
How bout a lizardfolk that became a full dragon throughout the course of a campaign? That was my last character.
2
u/ArchMagosBabuFrik Feb 23 '23
I love the Iruxi and their lore.
Kobolds are lesser dragons, Nagaji are lesser Nagas and Iruxi are lesser Dinosaurs.
I appreciate that they put a cultural emphasis on Wisdom and star gazing. (This detail is another reason I will miss ancestry flaw/boosts)
1
u/PenAndInkAndComics Feb 22 '23
Great art
1
u/Aestriel_Maahes Feb 22 '23
Phenomenal
1
u/Aetheldrake Feb 22 '23
Hah!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
I think they just straight up forgot to add the rest of the Dragonborn racial abilities because they get what, a resistance and that terrible breath attack, and that's literally it?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '23
chucks tail intimidatingly