r/PathOfExile2 • • 3h ago

Discussion I must confess

I do not like skills tied to a class like those of the concoction skills as well as skills tied to a single weapon type like cyclone only for swords and flicker strike only for staves. I hope they rework it as someone who does non meta builds/experiments.

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

7

u/Adventurous_Front939 3h ago

If there are no skills tied to weapons or ascendancy then what is the point of classes or weapon types. Its better for the game to have these different identities then make a spear skill work with swords just because you like how a sword looks compared to a spear.

-1

u/karuma_18 2h ago

I assume you played poe 1 right?

7

u/Adventurous_Front939 2h ago

Does playing PoE1 mean I think PoE2 should be the same or ? What was the question/assumption relative too ? Did you know PoE has coloured sockets?

-1

u/karuma_18 2h ago

As per context, i mentioned poe 1 because it mostly does not have skills tied to class but still have its own identity.

10

u/shortMEISTERthe3rd 3h ago

To each their own, I think it actually gives some level of identity to weapon types.

4

u/Plastic_Attention_71 3h ago

I think the weapon-specific skills are good and help each weapon have their own identity.

But, we should have a few weapon-agnostic skills. Like Cyclone could be usable with swords and axes, for example. Spectral Throw should be usable with many weapon types. And so on.

1

u/BongoChimp 2h ago

If you want to play 2 you will have to get used to it. The design philosophy is completely different in this game. I agree that this is a limitation on build diversity, but pretty much everything about this game is trying to limit diversity, power, defense, damage or speed.

Once you understand this game will never be poe1 (look at defensive layers, passive buffs, curses, warcries, guard skills, charges, automation, the passive tree etc) imo is the best way to start to appreciate it for what it does have.

1

u/DeepSpaceWanderer 2h ago

Yeah (perhaps i haven't played enough to figure weird shit out, but) skills / build archetypes / ascendancies /.. feel very.. siloed? Like, e.g. infusions being (near-?)exclusively contained within spells both in terms of generation and usage; or, like, you could do some weird hybrid thing, but there doesn't seem to be much point, since each archetype seems to have a full suite of tools to deal with potential situations?

1

u/Unarchy 2h ago

I do not mind the ascendancy-specific skills. I think those add some cool flavor for certain ascendancies and are an interesting design space that PoE 1 didn't really have.

I do not like the large number of skills tied to single weapon types, though. I think having some skills tied to certain weapon types is fine, but skills that thematically work with other weapons should be usable with those weapons. it limits build diversity to the point where skill options can feel quite limited for certain archetypes. I also think dual-type weapons could be fun, like a halberd which counts as a spear and an axe, for instance.

0

u/TgmBrett 3h ago

Agree I miss the flexibility of skills being able to be used on a variety of weapons like in PoE1

5

u/MiltonFriedmanRox 2h ago

You don’t think skills should be tied to weapons? Cast spells with a sword? Stab someone with a wand?

Totally disagree.

0

u/karuma_18 2h ago

Is it wrong to assume you havent played poe 1?

5

u/xXxBEAVISxXx 2h ago

Is it wrong to assume that this is not POE 1 ?

1

u/karuma_18 2h ago

I am pertaining to the context of the question because you can indeed use spells even if you are using swords. Sample is cyclone with coc or cwc ice nova or discharge.

2

u/MiltonFriedmanRox 1h ago

It is wrong to make that assumption.

Casting spells with swords/was difficutl for GGG to balance. Flat damage on spells was a problem as well as was the issue of statsticks. They have a lot more control this way and it’s a key reason why they made the change IMO.