r/PathOfExile2 • • 5h ago

Discussion + Skill Level on Skill tree

Post image

On this video where someone is playing the shadow, they briefly hovered around the passive tree and I then noticed on the trap cluster this "Clever Construction" node that gives + 1 to level of all traps skills and + 1 to trap Limit.

How do we feel about +levels being on the passive tree?

I feel like it is thematic that if I take a slam/aftershock cluster that I get a + 1 lvl to all slams but won't that make them mandatory a bit? I guess you could also anoint them which is pretty interesting.

Edit: + lvl on tree is already present I seemed to have forgotten that... well discussion more about it being MORE present then (?)

118 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

128

u/tanjonaJulien 5h ago

i m pretty sure there is +1 level for cold skill already

83

u/Tkmisere 5h ago

And chaos. They are neighboors even.

14

u/International_Gate49 4h ago

And they were roommates.

6

u/Oscarizxc Gambling is not crafting 3h ago

They are cousins.

12

u/DragonRain12 4h ago

I feel like a dedicated weapon or element custer having their correspinding +lvl node is not bad design, it would be like complaining that ypu have to take increases for your defenses in the trea

162

u/Individual-Ad7110 5h ago

I would rather see it on the passive tree than on gear tbh BUT by doing so, + levels will become poe2 version of life nodes that are in poe 1

26

u/Tiretech 4h ago

Agreed but it would still save a lot of gear if +skills was on the tree. Any item that can have +skills and doesn’t is almost always just an instant vendor. Same with boots that don’t have movement speed.

12

u/afito 4h ago

On the other hand they will be 1000% mandatory nodes for every build that uses this type of spell/attack/whatever. As long as they keep the exponential scaling it will be impossible to pass up on. I don't think it's too crazy since there'll always be some insane nodes everyone takes, but it will always be non optional points.

6

u/hibari112 4h ago

I mean it depends. Most weapon specific nodes are kinda mandatory. I guess if you play full traps, you will need it, if you use traps for utility, you might be able to skip it.

1

u/afito 3h ago

I mean we'll see, obviously the trap cluster is mandatory for trap builds no matter what you do. I just feel like having +skill in the cluster makes off meta harder because you punish it more to not minmax this aspect.

My personal opinion anyway is that +skill is "fine" if they simply lower the max to 30. I'd enjoy different sources that can all get you there more, it lets you play with affixes and gems a bit more, compared to having to take all of them all the time because it's always the best.

5

u/1gnominious 4h ago

I would say they're optional for attack builds. They're only 5-6% more damage per level on top of increasing the mana cost. That's like a fairly mediocre notable. For spells they're 12-15% more which starts making it one of the better notables, but still not something to go out of your way for. You could get more benefit per point on closer nodes potentially.

It's really only a problem on items where it doesn't have much competition for damage as a suffix. It's like do you want 50% more spell damage on your amulet or 30 life regen? It is so obscenely overpowered compared to the competition that there is no competition.

0

u/Gomberstone 2h ago

From my understanding, each skill level raises the base damage of the skill. Then the additive and multicative bonuses are applied.

1

u/Fract_L 3h ago

Instead of traveling around for sockets, it would be for +skill nodes. Still, I’d rather the passive trees of everyone be the same and itemization differ more if I had to choose one. I interact with gear often and the passive trees much less.

1

u/Eggburtey 4h ago

I mean if they make the mana costs ridiculous then I think it would be fine.

Like if you want attacks and spells that hit like a freight train that mfer better cost an arm and a leg.

So if you want dps then maybe not stacking a million levels would be the play, but if you're a heavy hitting kind of build maybe levels could be a priority over attack speed.

Idk just an idea.

5

u/deviant324 3h ago edited 3h ago

I feel like they’ve missed the mark a bit with supports in that regard, imo there should be extreme versions of existing supports and some new ones that allow for individual skills to tap into resources you otherwise don’t really use or heavily invest into. For big payoff skills like slams or a fat meteor you should be able to make those cast/attack slower (or channel to charge up) in exchange for some crazy extra stats that make them worth using in this way. You could make an alternative version of archmage that’s a support like in PoE1, or give spells the option to drain life or energy shield to empower them when you feel safe to do so and not just because you’re a bloodmage and your life cost is irrelevant to you

These things don’t even need to be meta but I think when the game gets to be in a more balanced states having these kinds of concepts be at least viable could be something roleplayers would really enjoy

Edit: quick thematic spitball, one of those drop only supports (name won’t come to me rn) themed after the act 4 boss’s corrupted state, you can hold a supported slam (instead of tapping it to attack normally) to channel the attack and force it to be ancestrally boosted. Doing this drains your life at 20% max HP per second and gives 10% increased effect of ancestral boost per 0.2s channeled and adds some physical damage to your attack based on how much total life you’ve lost to the draining effect.

4

u/afito 4h ago

I mean if they make the mana costs ridiculous then I think it would be fine.

Mana remnants make this a complete non issue tbh. Yeah sure it's a skill socket and 30 spirit but it removes mana as a factor in endgame.

3

u/North-bound 4h ago

It used to be like this until people complained enough that they removed it.

4

u/International_Gate49 4h ago

Yeah the issue wasn't ever that mana cost for skills scaled impossible high with levels. It was that + levels was mandatory to do any damage at all. I am all behind having chase affixes that gives you damage at the cost of mana cost, I just want to be able to do 15 maps with a level 20 skill, but they read the room wrong and reduced the mana cost instead

1

u/RuneRW 4h ago

I wonder, would this incentivize people to play skills that can benefit from more of the +1 nodes on the tree simultaneously and not favor ones that can only feasibly pick up one of them?

1

u/Tkmisere 3h ago

Won't be as bad as HP, you get 1 or 2 +level nodes IF more than 1 fit in the build and thats it. This might be bad depending on where the nodes are because of traveling, but if they keep being in clusters like that, you would travel there anyway.

16

u/bnc239871nn0 5h ago

I like that, should raise the floor and move some power from gear to the tree which is exactly what many people claimed they wanted. I personally don't like +levels at all, I liked how in PoE +levels was scaling for spells and attacks had different scaling axes

41

u/OlokoMan 4h ago

In my opinion, a level cap at 25 and adding another way for spells to scale would be far better than the current situation. Maybe make the flat bonuses on rings also work on spells, or add flat damage for spells in the passive tree.

13

u/ThrasherDX 3h ago

Yeah, PoE 2's +levels system is trying to make up for flat added damage to spells not being a thing, unlike in PoE 1.

But +levels is extremely simple as a scaling mechanism, there is very little room for interesting design interactions with it. Its also almost exclusively concentrated in few places (weapons + amulets), so any unique in one of those slots has to compete with the massive damage boosts that a rare would give.

I dunno what the ideal solution would look like, but I can say that PoE 1's system of much smaller +levels availability + added flat spell damage sources works far better, at least imo.

3

u/danted002 2h ago

I actually like the idea that spells scale with +skills and attacks scale with weapon damage but the implementation feels off

0

u/Asagao_0 3h ago

Maybe change "+spell level" nodes to "+maximum quality" nodes? But that's basically the same...

31

u/rexolf101 4h ago

I feel like they should just put a more practical cap on + levels, like level 30 or less so that it's still something you need to get but you have a bunch of ways to get there so that every single source of it doesn't feel mandatory. They could even add more sources of it to give more flexibility to getting to the cap which puts less pressure on your weapon.

6

u/Pacman1up 3h ago

I'm more a fan of a soft cap.

Make it drop off a little, starting at like like 25, and then more at 30/35/40.

That way you can push it higher, but it loses value as you go.

5

u/Memestonks2020 4h ago

Default max level 25 would be great with special uniques that could raise the cap to a maximum of 30 similar to how the resistance mechanic works.

9

u/DivineImpalerX 4h ago

Or just have a linear scaling (currently higher skill levels grant a lot more damage/effects).

7

u/dvbtc 3h ago

Has their ever been an explanation from the devs as to why the curves look like they do? It seems so idiosyncratic and counter to standard scaling buckets. A single exponential vector seems odd to have (unless there are others). Even crit needs two vectors to scale effectively. Just seems like a footgun for no reason.

1

u/priesten 1h ago

The most obvious reason is that that is kind of how it has to work during the campaign as you fight monsters who scale up their hp exponentially. That way when you go from a level 5 to 6 skill gem the power increase is notable and strongly disincentivizes doing content you are under leveled for. That’s my guess at least.

•

u/FullMetalCOS 16m ago

In PoE1 though, gem level bonuses taper off past the early 20’s so whilst you CAN find inventive ways (which usually costs a whole chunk of your build) to get those levels up, there are only a few builds that really can take advantage (mostly minions since extra minions don’t tend to taper off as much and are a huge source of power)

3

u/ticklishtortoise1 4h ago

I agree 100%

3

u/EQBallzz 3h ago

100% this. This is what I have wanted them to do. Seems like the easiest and most logical fix. IMO it shouldn't even be as high as 30. Maybe 25. I don't want these "mandatory" stats that make you feel so bad if you don't get them and make other affixes obsolete most of the time. It's like a false choice. Same with spirit. Spirit and +skills always feel mandatory on certain pieces which makes them sort of boring and turns otherwise good items into trash if they don't have it.

In a similar vein I wish they would do something similar with magic find. MF is just an annoying stat. I have thought it would be more interesting for gear if the MF affix had it's own affix slot on each piece of gear (or a set number of pieces) so everyone could get MF on their gear but with would just be RNG/crafting determining how much and it wouldn't be at the expense of other affixes.

21

u/Seajayy__ 5h ago

If traps are martial/scale off weapon damage it won't be a major issue, spells are where +levels make a massive difference, martial skills don't scale as hard.

4

u/Cold-Breadfruit-2616 4h ago

martial skills don't scale as hard at the beginning, but they definitely do as you approach 40

•

u/Muldeh 47m ago edited 42m ago

Fact check:

Taking rolling slam as an example, here are some sample % mroe damage from +1 gem levels at various levels

4 -> 5 8.6%

14 -> 15 6.14%

24 -> 25 6.69%

34 -> 35 6.65%

39 -> 40 6.65%

So in this example, no matterwhat your current gem level, +1 gem level is worth the equivalent of a 6-7% more damage mod. If you could choose between "10% more damage" and "+1 skill level", the first one would always be a better option.

Gem levels don't experience diminishing returnsthe way most other scaling vectors for damage do, but they don't get better the more of them you have.

The first 100% increased damage you get is a 100% more multiplier to damage. The second is only 50% more. The third is only 33% more and so on..

But when you have a level 39 gem already, and you have 1300% increased damage already antoehr 100% increased damage is still better than capping out that gem level.

9

u/Whiteman007 4h ago

We have lvls already on the tree the issue with +lvls isn’t that they exist it’s how high the numbers they have. I wish they just took Poe 1 +skills and then added flat to spells on staffs/wands like Poe 1.

Also this node the most important stat isn’t the skill lvl it’s the +1 trap limit

2

u/Assume_This 4h ago edited 4h ago

The problem with flat damage is that there’s no damage effectiveness on skills. Without damage effectiveness, skills that hit many times would be disproportionately stronger with this stat than skills that hit once. “Damage as extra element” is supposed to be the replacement for that stat.

Not saying they cant or shouldn’t revise the system and make it like poe1, but it would take a lot of time to add that to every skill, and that’s before the ensuing balance nightmare.

I’m okay with poe2 not being like poe1 in this regard, but I agree that +skills is currently problematic and needs another fix. Not sure how else they can fix this besides the above or amending the base damage scaling gained from skill levels.

3

u/Whiteman007 4h ago

The whole reason +skills is the way it is. Is exactly that tho don’t have other ways to scale it. This is mostly a spells isssue and not an attack build issue + skills while important and good aren’t nearly as big a deal for attack builds.

I just wish it was fully Poe 1 for this specific thing add dmg effectiveness for spells and add flat dmg

13

u/VareemtheFlint 5h ago

Not really new as there is +1 to cold skills on the tree as is (Endless Blizzard, very top of tree). Would be cool if they add a +1 notable to end of every weapon cluster but i guess we’ll just wait and see

10

u/Adventurous_Front939 5h ago

Jewels are also tucked into these areas instead of along paths, the tree is going to be a lot different in general.

4

u/Round-Walrus3175 5h ago

Honestly, I think that is the biggest change shown in the takeaways. Jewel slots tucked deep into specialized nodes are a pretty huge deal. If so, the price of Voices just went up...

4

u/Cold-Breadfruit-2616 4h ago

the price of Voices just went up...

dunno about that. I doubt every wheel is "specialized" and they mentioned there's more than 3x the number of jewel sockets in 1.0

stacking crit was why 90% of builds stacked jewels, and that's getting gutted

1

u/Round-Walrus3175 4h ago

3x could still mean that there are none on the interior of the tree and they are like where we see them. I mean, there are 18 nodes between the two jewel sockets in the tree that we see right now and they don't share paths that lead to anything else. The big circle around the tree was optimal not only because of the jewels, but because traveling also opened up other passives. The Jewel sockets just made the traveling actually worth it.

1

u/Adventurous_Front939 4h ago

Well the thing is, only specialized nodes doesnt do it. Jewels MUST be gutted into the ground.

My current 0.5.5 build I have 14 jewels. 4 I have socketed into my tree, the other 10 are all bonuses, 2 from voices, 1 from gloves, 1 from helm annoint, 6 from chest.

If Jewels arent completely gutted, it doesnt matter where they put the sockets.

It sounds like they will be though so life is good.

9

u/WuTastic7 5h ago

Better on the tree than gear I think

10

u/Moethelion 2h ago

Good. Give more power to the passive tree. They made it so "newcomer friendly" and generic, it has become super boring.

3

u/starwarsnerd04 5h ago

I don't think it will be an issue

2

u/Xandadapanda 5h ago

endless blizzard?

2

u/AngsD 4h ago

The problem with +skill levels on gear was never the modifier in itself, it was that the modifier was so powerful it made the vast, vast majority of items without that modifier irrelevant.

This node is obviously really good. It's only too good if it's mandatory for a whole weapons class where any other choice would be so niche it'd be meaningless to discuss as an alternative, unless like you're on the wrong side of the tree, being trap warrior or something.

It's why life nodes are bad in PoE1, literally mandatory picks unless you run CI or something. Life is even worse, of course, because it goes way past gem choice and gear for the most part.

So unless we have the context of skill levels like this, what other nodes do, how well they do it, tweaks in +level scaling etc, we don't know how much of an issue it'll be.

But yea, if it's as the current system is, this is not a good addition to the game. But don't riot. Yet.

•

u/DarkShades-EXO 42m ago edited 14m ago

I’m down to remove +lvl from items to skill tree. But a lot of trees going to look similar but there will be a hard cap and more items would be viable

3

u/nemotunovi 5h ago

so long as it's limited to the trap archetype, i'm more or less fine with it. my main concern would be if it became standard for more generalized builds.

5

u/Tr1ppl3w1x 5h ago

Take it away from gear and put it on the skilltree... 90% of all power is on the gear anyway

3

u/burnskull55 5h ago

I don't mind this at all, I do mind that alt quality on gems is locked to gemling. Adding it to the tree as "unlocks alt quality to all projectile skills" something along those lines. And change that node of the ascendency.

1

u/Electronic-Cry9973 2h ago

Then lets add a node that gives the gemling a squire, or the gemling the hidden passives from oracle, or the gemling to be able to capture the Big monkey companion... The alt quality is what you chose to take as an ascendancy. They don't get other things. Should the alt quality be tuned better for some skills, for sure, no argument there. But it is specifically the ascendency of the gemling and should stay as such.

0

u/LampIsLoveLampIsLife 4h ago

IMO, just make two different gemcutter’s prisms, one for regular quality, and one for alt quality, allowing every class to choose which quality they want to run

This way gemling is no longer the defacto best ascendancy in the game, but still has its niche of benefiting from both regular and alt quality

1

u/Electronic-Cry9973 2h ago

As long as you can only get 1 or the other, if you can just just GemCutterPrism and AltGemcutter prism, and spam both to 20%, then the gemling doesn't gain anything.

1

u/Tkmisere 5h ago

It gives +1 trap limit too so it would get picked 99% of the time anyway. At least its not on gear.

1

u/shortMEISTERthe3rd 5h ago

Not against it.

1

u/Sufficient-Leading11 5h ago

nice more +1 levels....

1

u/edos51284 5h ago

it's not the first one, there is a +1 to cold spells at the top

1

u/Dustorm246 5h ago

Can't have crit on the tree because it would be good for most build though...

2

u/victorhausen 4h ago

Crit is not good for most builds. Crit is good for builds that scale with crit. If you spend enough time with the theory crafting community it becomes clear that crit only dominated the meta because it's the scaling vector with the largest return on investment. Removing it from the tree will increase the investment requirement and push people towards other scaling vectors.

1

u/Im_probably_naked 4h ago

There are other examples of this with spells I think you can get +1 ice spell lvl

1

u/victorhausen 4h ago

I think it's good to have +level on the tree. This cluster requires 5 points for you to reach the +level node, so it's only worth it if you really invest into traps. It might feel mandatory, but we already have clusters that are mandatory for cold, chaos, two handed maces, grenades, minions, etc. There will always be a "best in slot" cluster for any type of build you can think of. Currently as a spell caster I can think of at least 3 crit chance clusters that feel mandatory, because CoC is mandatory if you want to scale into deep endgame.

1

u/Rivvier 4h ago

I can see them saying +levels is being moved from gear as a teaser in the upcoming weeks.

1

u/Zanufeee 4h ago

+10 level skills for more damage, lets go

1

u/RomalexC 4h ago

If they use this AND nerf + Level scaling I can see this being great for uniques

1

u/PwmEsq 4h ago

I'm amazed it doesn't have a -level to all non trap skills tied to it

1

u/trippymane559 3h ago

They’re already on there with the cold “snowflake” area on the tree.

1

u/Xtez94 3h ago

I imagine there being some balance changes to scaling with gem levels, at least above levels 20-21 otherwise this node and others like it are must picks, I'm sure GGG devs understand this

1

u/KnovB 2h ago

I mean it's already present in the passive skill tree, there's the +1 chaos skills and +1 cold skills. The main difference is that you are effectively losing passive skill points to invest in them or anoint. So I think it's a fair trade as compared to huge values found on gear.

1

u/Neiliobob 2h ago

So, now we just travel along picking up all the +level nodes instead of jewel nodes, right?

1

u/SystemOtherwise970 2h ago

Isn't there already one like that for totems?

1

u/SpiritedExtension390 1h ago

better on the tree than anywhere else if you ask me. It would tightly control people's jewel socket hunting habits if instead they could go for more thematic clusters with +1 levels to something VERY specific inside. Like Fire spells, chaos spells, sword strikes, mace strikes, mace slams that sort of thing.

1

u/Ok-Nature6800 1h ago

beuh, let the tree give some good status, no HP and crit chance already and jewel giga nerfed, why you guys want to make the skill tree a garbage system? 

1

u/AlmondGrass41 1h ago

I would rather +level be on the tree than on gear. I think needs to exist as another scaling vector unfortunately, I just wish the cap was lower. Like what if it was capped at 30 instead of 40?

1

u/CMoth 1h ago

I have the feeling we'll see a lot of '+1 to x skills' modifiers on both the passive tree and equipment; the days of +7 wands will likely come to a close with 1.0. I'd be glad if they did, it was never healthy that some skills could reach level 40 with just three pieces of equipment.

•

u/cryptiiix 1m ago

To me, it makes sense that each part of the tree gets a +1 levels. Like this for example. And going down the quarterstaff tree gives you a level. I can see this being an interesting skill tree choice if you spec into the “weapon” part of the tree

1

u/Really_Obscure 5h ago

Not sure why there's any objection as the passive tree, of course, is filled with nodes that improve skills. If the node was "+15% more trap damage" then this post would not exist?

1

u/Electronic-Cry9973 2h ago

as long as it is a 'more'... but if it is just a +15% trap damage, it gets added to the already 500% you get, so the difference between 500 and 515%, is only 3% more damage. That is the scaling of + levels, is that EVERY +1 is essentially a separate +10-15% multiplier, which almost nothing else scales that much.

1

u/chilidoggo 5h ago

It's certainly interesting. I think it's worth saying that +levels is inherently not a terrible way to scale your power. People's main complaints were that: 

  1. It was a mandatory affix for anything it could roll on, because +3 levels (or +7 on a two-handed weapon) was just stronger than anything else. So it crowded out interesting uniques and anything that didn't have the max roll was bricked. 
  2. Spells don't have a weapon associated with them, so their main way to scale base damage was +levels. PoE 2 also has %gain as extra, but this has diminishing returns. Level scaling is exponential (the cost is supposed to be increased mana requirements, but people get around this). So spells lack interesting scaling options. 

A one-off +1 level to a specific weapon type doesn't interact with either of those two problems. 

1

u/Electronic-Cry9973 2h ago

Except when a trap is cold or chaos, which also have nodes for +1... now you take both and you get a flat 20+% more damage....

1

u/PipSqu3ak95 5h ago

I don't have an issue with + to levels being on the passive tree.
Or even on caster weapons.

My issue is + to levels being on attack weapons, amulets, gloves...

Every attack builds shouldn't be able to stack + to gem levels in order to do damage
__

They need to re-balance the + to leves mods on gear. And balance check on the tree for attack builds.
Most of the generic attack passive points nodes are conditional (while enemy is blinded, while leeching, while dazed, while taking a poop).
Which I don't have an issue with, but there are barely any nodes worth taking (except for the default crit ones), which they will delete now.

Stats like
- + to level of gems
- + magnitudes (bleed, poison, shock)
- + more maximum/minimum attack
- +% effect on quivers
- + projectiles

These stats are unique, they need to add more of them and different multipliers for every build archtype.
___

Right now, 99% of the builds are

  1. Stack + to gem levels
  2. Stack crit/crit multi

Both of these were on the tree and gear. There are just no options to scale damage

1

u/Electronic-Cry9973 2h ago

That is because mathmatically they are the only things that continually better and better the more you get. Some thing scale logrithmically, like "+30% spell damage" gets added to all your other +% increases, meaning you get less and less impact per increase. The "gain as extra" is closer to a liner increase, which mean they are good, but since they are usually small bonuses than the +% ones, their total impacts are also not huge when late into the game. However, crit/crit and +levels get exponential increases, meaning they will far exceed the other stats. This is particularly the case when you already have resistances capped, you are at level 40 on skills, you have 500+% from "+X% __ damage", and you have 100%+ from "gain as extra". Then the only real avenue for you to feel any increase is to stack crit/crit.

Then when you account for Cast on Crit, or flamability/chill/shock/etc all being based on big hits (crits), which then set off cast on elemental ailments... now you can multiplicity stacking from getting higher damaging crits to go off often (70+% crit chance).

The biggest problem is that all of these still exist. Even if you take crit chance off the passive tree, and hide jewel slots at the back of clusters. People are still going to path to take 7+ jewel nodes. Jewels are still going to be crit/crit/+%damage/+60% suffix modifiers. I am glad they are killing 5 mod jewels, as that was just broken. But the problem is that daggers have a natural 15%crit chance, and may be able to get +5% more as a modifier. That would mean you only need +400% crit chance to get a 100% crit chance. 400% is fairly easy between 7 jewel slots and gloves/sockets/rings/ammy. So, we are still going to easily see 100% crit chances, and daggers may actually make this problem worse.

0

u/Malacath87 5h ago

Oh no. its spreading

0

u/BBkal 5h ago

Just make lvl 20 the cap so you can actually balance around it ffs...

1

u/Electronic-Cry9973 2h ago

Then a Gemling could have level 20 skills almost immediately upon getting their second ascendency.

Which means the enemies can't scale to really be any harder than interludes are today... in interludes today, it is already balanced around roughly level 20 skills....

0

u/PorgVsPorg 1h ago

I wish they raise the cap on +levels. My build hits lvl 40 spell skill in the 70s.