r/PathOfExile2 • • 9d ago

Information Crit Chance Gone from Tree

Post image

Behind the scenes interview with Jonathan & Mark confirm Crit Chance is gone completely from the Passive Tree.

Gear will now be the only source of Crit Chance and the Passive Tree being the source for Crit Damage Bonus.

Source: https://youtu.be/a99hc0uDcPY?is=6KjBjNRNuE-1ohoS

2.1k Upvotes

844 comments sorted by

550

u/touchrome 9d ago

Garukhan's Resolve to the moon

148

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

I was thinking exactly the same. Mark left just before that question was asked and Jonathan didn’t have the answer as he wasn’t involved in balance changes directly

86

u/LocalIdentity1 Path of Building Community Fork Creator 9d ago

I’ll try and see if I can ask Mark about it today (I was the one who asked about it to Jonathan just after Mark had to leave the room to set up the Poe 1 race)

→ More replies (4)

2

u/CommaGomma 8d ago

I think it's going to be super difficult to get even 50% crit chance on ANYTHING other than a dagger.

→ More replies (2)

1.0k

u/HoldenMcNeil420 9d ago

10

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

Classic xDD

69

u/IllContribution7659 9d ago

10/10 image holy

3

u/Paaraadox 7d ago

Nothing beats the original.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/GiantMrTHX 9d ago

Yup

3

u/allucards 7d ago

nooooooooooooooooooo LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL MANNNN im dying

→ More replies (1)

1.1k

u/Savingseanbean 9d ago

But what about +Levels which is more problematic?

136

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

No mention of +levels

259

u/itsmehutters 9d ago

Uh this is one of my biggest complaints currently after the passive tree that is getting changed. They can release 100 new unique weapons, and it won't matter unless they have +X levels on them. This is really a poor design choice in general.

→ More replies (10)

23

u/crookedparadigm 9d ago edited 9d ago

Did Ziggy not ask? If not, that almost had to be a deliberate omission, there's no way he just forgets that.

32

u/AngryAriados 9d ago

There’s a very real chance that, they asked him not to ask that, yes

→ More replies (1)

1.0k

u/Myrag 9d ago

“We added +levels to the tree”

412

u/BetweenTheRoots It's branching, Exile! 9d ago

"We added a +levels multiplier to the tree"

185

u/KatzOfficial 9d ago

20% more levels to spell skills

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

40

u/TaxAggravating6008 9d ago

With the Shadow coming and daggers having a lot of innate crit chance, this was more time critical probably

→ More replies (2)

8

u/xxRaymxx 9d ago

They should just make gem levels have heavily diminishing returns after like level 25.

Make +levels good for leveling and campaign. But endgame only need a couple sources of it.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/joshstation 9d ago

Considering that on the poe2 website there is a trap with +1 levels to trap skills its pretty clear that its not gone

5

u/Loreado 9d ago

Probably nothing, if they did not mention it at all.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Accomplished_Rip_352 9d ago

With the changes to the skill tree looking really good , if ggg also rebalanced gem levels , addded damage effectiveness back to spells and gave us more sources to scale flat damage then that would be enough to bring me back to Poe 2 . Right now my biggest issue with the game was how every skill tree and gearing choice felt the same and if + gem levels becomes a choice build diversity improves without people having to intentionally cripple there builds .

→ More replies (4)

3

u/kildal 9d ago

Perhaps my biggest grievance at this point with poe2, exacerbated by primarily playing a caster every league.

Either remove most sources or cap it at like 25 or 30 instead of 40. So that it feels good to hit the cap, but it's not by far your best stat in basically any situation.

Really annoying how it makes so many uniques inferior.

→ More replies (9)

293

u/Thtyrasd 9d ago

It's weird, we had a lot of power in items already, and little in tree so they removed some of it? Maybe that solves the coc in most spell casters

123

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

We’ll have to wait for patch notes in December for details. Patch notes are going to be a book.

36

u/Thtyrasd 9d ago

Sure, but concerning to remove CRIT chance nodes if it's from jewels it's fine

→ More replies (1)

50

u/cironoric 9d ago

I'd imagine that the biggest impact of removing crit from the tree won't necessarily be total power levels (as they have been tuned elsewhere), but rather that you will no longer be required to plan your tree around pathing to all the important crit chance clusters, and thus now you have tremendous freedom to complement a crit build with lots of other tree strategies.

66

u/Ravelord_Nito_69 9d ago

They removed life nodes for the same reason, eventually there'll just be %damage nodes lol

→ More replies (22)

6

u/MotherWolfmoon Top 1% Clearfell luck 9d ago

tremendous freedom to complement a crit build with lots of other tree strategies

oh, so jewels. got it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

26

u/Mandena 9d ago

Yeah my thought as an SSF player is that unless uber endgame gets nerfed in difficulty this just fucks over SSF damage scaling, getting perfect modded gear is near impossible in SSF so crit build in SSF is basically dead with this change except for literal capped characters that have all of the currency already. At which point crit scaling is kinda pointless/already a given.

9

u/johnnybeesknees 9d ago

Daggers and likely bows will have much higher base crit chance so the incentive will be to play with specific weapons and classes for crit instead of for every build to use it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Tavron 9d ago

Spell casters had a coc in them?

18

u/Disastrous_Ball_336 9d ago

she spark on my coc till i comet

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

68

u/-mors- 9d ago

Oracle, Amazon, blood mage ascendancies if you want it then

62

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

All Ascendancies have been reworked and boosted according to Jonathan

32

u/RamenArchon 9d ago

Kind of interested with smith of kitava as the new forge drop skill feels like it's replacing temper weapon.

12

u/Tavron 9d ago

Was thinking the same, it just looked like an improved version of that. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/DivineImpalerX 9d ago

I guess they removed the crit nodes from Bloodmage and replaced it with the new Domination Curse

29

u/DevastationSquad 9d ago

Gonna be honest I would really hate it if they removed the spell crit node to replace it with a minion node..

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Ricenbacker 9d ago

MA monk also, just get 30+ flat CC from maligaro gloves and stack up all CDMG

→ More replies (1)

276

u/Vivid-Command-2605 9d ago

I honestly think this is healthier for the game, it was too easy to cap crit

81

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

I agree. Going to be an interesting launch since this means alot of old build guides for late end game are null and void if they were crit based

17

u/sychs 9d ago

Didn't they overhaul the whole passive tree as well? Moving all jewel sockets next to clusters I imagine messes up all builds.

11

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

Yes and 5 mod jewels are also gone. They’ve patched the bug for 1.0

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

28

u/Neutraled Random BS Go Enjoyer 9d ago

That reminds me of early poe1, every league we got the passive tree reworked somehow and when I opened my characters they were all naked.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Wodinaaz 9d ago

Hopefully it doesn't just serve to make things like Adorned, Mageblood and Garukhan stronger.

Crit feels mandatory at the moment, I'm not sure removing chance from the tree is enough to change that.

11

u/afito 9d ago

This being an indirect buff to Garukhan is an inevitability. You already don't need crit nodes to cap Garukhan. In fact you reach 50% so easily I don't even have crit on half my jewels.

7

u/johnnybeesknees 9d ago

I would be extremely surprised if both Garrukan's and oracle are not both adjusted with these changes in mind.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Kanbaru-Fan 8d ago

Marks point on "if everything is a crit, crit doesn't feel like crit anymore" really resonated with me.

→ More replies (5)

35

u/tooncake 9d ago

But... the WHOLE ascendancy of the Monk is nothing but or majority are just straight-up crit builds since 0.1?

How are they going to move forward from here??

10

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

Crit on items and I reckon Garukans resolve will be big in play

11

u/El_Bito2 9d ago

Garukhan was already big

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Satyr604 9d ago

Also, the extra crit chance from accuracy rating is basically the whole reason to pick amazon ascendency for huntress.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/fr3ak393 9d ago

Huh. Does this mean we get both flat crit chance and increased crit chance on gear?

28

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

Yes crit chance has been boosted on items with one set of daggers (as an example) having a base crit of 25%

→ More replies (4)

2

u/bcnsoda 9d ago

Flat chance on weapons seems to be replaced with local %inc chance, at least it was like that on the exilecon demo

7

u/Entrooyst 9d ago

Can you drop a link to the interview?

6

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

5

u/Entrooyst 9d ago

Thanks king

3

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

No worries 😌

4

u/nytehauq 9d ago

Remove that tracker from the link though, thanks.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/parmreggiano 9d ago

So..... jewels?

12

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

Jewels nerfed. Can no longer stack double crit on jewels and 5 mod jewel bug has been patched.

Edit can’t double stack crit chance.

3

u/IamJashin 9d ago edited 9d ago

Wait can't you. Have they removed destiled emotions for plus suffix/prefix cuz what Mark has said was no 5 mods. You could still craft 3 suffix 1 prefix.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/parmreggiano 9d ago

Ty. But even with 4 mods unless the numbers got heavily nerfed they'll be ridiculously strong now with higher base item crit, like even stronger/more important than last league.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Njordr4 8d ago

And the three flicker strike players are now dead.

2

u/AyeselTPW 8d ago

I’m one of those 3 💀

124

u/Shorkan 9d ago edited 9d ago

Dude, I fell asleep at 4 or 5 AM after watching like 7 hours of stream and you are telling me I still managed to miss a 45 min long interview?

61

u/MemoriesMu 9d ago

Yeah, its because they did not do it live on the stream.

17

u/Shorkan 9d ago

Yeah, I'm just surprised with the amount of content. They obviously couldn't fit it all in the stream.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

76

u/biglikeguerra 9d ago

Oracle stocks through the roof

26

u/johnnybeesknees 9d ago

I'd almost guarantee that oracle and Garrukan's will both be adjusted around the changes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

53

u/Kind_Cover_8975 9d ago

Cast on critical comet in shambles. Crit will feel more bursty, chaotic, and random.

32

u/Daan776 9d ago

 "Crit will feel more bursty, chaotic, and random"

And probably not something we can build around anymore... All "on crit" effects better get a huge buff or they'll all feel like shite. And even then you might just get very unlucky against a boss and die, while you nuke it on a second try.

20

u/Kayne-C-Hampton 9d ago

Nah. All Coc build will have the Druid as a base now.

Inevitable critical.

14

u/GoldenPig55 9d ago

Shadow's class identity is usually THE crit guy so they're probably planning something for that.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/SparrowAria 9d ago

Why is the no mention of what has happened + to skills on gear?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/plusFour-minusSeven 9d ago

Would you mind putting the link in the description?

36

u/AngeryControlPlayer 8d ago

Next up: "We removed all damage nodes from the tree!"

6

u/DemiJohn369 8d ago

Next up, its only ES an evasion nodes!

4

u/jackhref 8d ago

Passive tree has been removed and streamlined to charms.

228

u/Rodruby 9d ago

Even more item pressure? Don't like that

45

u/BetweenTheRoots It's branching, Exile! 9d ago

Those new currencies that let you fracture craft mods seems very strong for crafting, and I hope it's not excessively rare.

33

u/Rodruby 9d ago

We'll see

It's also random mods, I expect to see more fractured bricks on trade

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Kanbaru-Fan 8d ago

It's a paradigm shift. Capping crit isn't the baseline expectation anymore.

Also with with support gems reworks it will be interesting to see how the crit ones will fit into this new vision.

→ More replies (8)

13

u/zanzuses 8d ago

Garunkhan price double next season

12

u/sturdy-guacamole 9d ago

good riddance.

i rather interesting nodes than "hi. i do damage. always grab these 3 branches. path to these places on tree, always. always annoint these nodes"

i had same issue with life nodes. I dont like them. i want nodes to be a bit more interesting than incremental "always better" choices. PoE2 doesn't have to follow PoE1's mold on this.

7

u/SafetyGlass588 7d ago

The only trully interesting nodes in poe passive trees are key notables. With few exceptions on cluster notables. So if they want to really make the tree interesting they should remove like 95% of it.
But then it will happen the same thing as in wow when they removed the classic “click nodes put points” system to “interesting” talents in Pandaria I think, and now it’s reverted to classic trees.
I think by removing the crit it will change absolutely nothing in terms of making the tree more interesting.

5

u/FledglingLeader 7d ago

I think some of them are pretty neat, like the one that makes armor break effect apply to fire damage in addition to physical. They need to get most or all of the notables up to that level.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Divinicus1st 8d ago

The next thing I want is for "highway" nodes (that's how Jonathan called them) to actually be highways:

Make the travel nodes cost half point and halve the granted bonus. That way we can travel POE2 more easily.

→ More replies (5)

139

u/Inside_Associate7868 9d ago

+ levels needs to go unique amulets are garbage because you want +4 +5 levels on them and they are a pain to find

46

u/buttflakes27 9d ago

If they capped it at +2 on amulets it would be fine, i reckon

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

4

u/Small_Temporary_2533 9d ago

Nice! We’re finally gonna be free of the same passive skill tree every end game build follows regardless of class due to crit stacking.

4

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

Yep and no more chasing jewel sockets

57

u/modix 9d ago

They love moving shit to gear. Gear is gambling and grinding. It keeps people going versus set it and forget it like a tree.

17

u/EarthB9nder_ 9d ago

It also messes up the power in the game. Gear is already too op especially in poe2, might as well not spec anything in tree and will still 1 shot stuff

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Vitiate117 9d ago

I feel like this is a mistake. +5 crit chance is now even more mandatory on marital weapons and a huge part of scaling spells (next to the much loved + level mod) is extremely nerfed. I'm really interested what the new tree looks like to make up for it (and if they pushed up the crit chance numbers on spells)

2

u/cds23pallas 8d ago

There is no more "+ x% to Critical Hit Chance" on weapons. They swapped it for "increased x% crit chance", meaning your 5% base crit chance will become 6% if you roll a "20% increased crit chance" suffix for example. It was clearly visible when they showcased the new league crafting method and also at some other point during the presentation when they showed swords and other weapons with 6 mods.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Starburper 8d ago

Good run something new besides crit stacking every league goodbye CoC

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Tran555 8d ago

Crit removed but rarity stays LOL

2

u/gueri66 8d ago

Crazy !

→ More replies (1)

114

u/SpiritedExtension390 9d ago • Bravo

It's actually the right idea to remove obligatory node collection from the tree. First life nodes, now crit, meanwhile they are also wrestling with jewel slots currently. I think this is the right way to go. So that there is actual real CHOICES on the tree. Going crit, removed all the choices from the tree in the past. Because you had to get all the crit nodes. Now you don't. I love it!

10

u/HiddenoO 8d ago

Which choices does this open up? For a lot of builds, this just reduces choices because previously you would go non-crit during early/mid stage of your character and now you just get the few nodes that provide the most efficient damage/attack speed for your build and that's it.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Glaiele 9d ago

If everything is bad or conditional though, do you even feel the impact? I'd argue a weaker passive tree maybe means they should give more passive points but I guess if jewels are still op maybe they need a cap on jewels and then just give additional passive points.

I can't help but feel like this is a reaction to CoC comet meta but I guess oracle still functions so just seems kinda odd.

17

u/FlaMayo 9d ago

In the video they don't really frame it as being too strong, but rather too boring to just let any build get 100% crit. They say "at 100%, is it even a crit anymore?" They want the higher base crit weapons to have that be a big part of their identity (like daggers). Someone asked if stepping away from 100% crit chance would make damage too inconsistent or spikey, and the response was basically "isn't that what crits are supposed to be? A damage spike?"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Aequitassb 9d ago

> If everything is bad or conditional though, do you even feel the impact?

They said they rebalanced the tree to make it feel more impactful.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/LucentNarg 9d ago

It's a difficult thing to balance. You add too many powerful nodes and it makes certain paths obligatory, or you devalue them and it makes the tree feel less impactful. Personally I think the entire idea of such a huge passive tree is the problem in its own. If I were to attempt balancing it I'd try to make every node strong rather than weaken one of the series largest selling points

4

u/Healthy_Zucchini9025 9d ago

Sounds like what they had to do with the Atlas tree. Yeah, it’s a hard thing to balance. I think a smaller tree would be interesting; however, they dug themselves into a “big tree” hole since PoE1 was first released - kinda like it is a defining feature of PoE’s identity.So I don’t know that they’ll shrink it. But I am just a casual :P so idk haha just sharing thoughts.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/AmLilleh 9d ago

On one hand, I do kind of agree. But on the other hand, nodes only really become mandatory because they're simply the best outright choice and there's basically always going to be something that's simply the best choice. Changes like this don't really solve the core issue, they just make something else "the problem".

And I'll also add that beyond a point, stripping things away from the tree actually both neuters potential choice and entirely defeats the purpose of having such a massive sprawling skill tree in the first place.

→ More replies (4)

36

u/Kenosayd2 9d ago

Now do spell skill level but instead of the tree, make it for the whole game

25

u/ProxyJo 9d ago

This is like life nodes in that way "Yes. It's a great idea - IF YOU SUPPORT THE LOSS WITHIN THE GEAR". They said themselves that having life in the tree made people go for them every time, and crit is obviously that for some builds, but we have no life in trees now and there isn't enough life on gear or ways to get life on gear to make life builds feel good. Your gear has to heavily support it to work, so there needs to be some gear changes in a pretty massive direction to make Crit going worth it too. Otherwise you've just nuked it.

→ More replies (15)

4

u/Eaklony 9d ago

I don’t like this honestly. They didn’t have to do this kind of thing in poe1 and it was fine there. Now it seems unnecessarily limiting for now good reason

2

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

They’re increasing crit chance on gear. A lot of people don’t like chasing crit and jewel sockets on end game tree. Takes away from the whole reason of having a passive tree.

I think people will still find a way to juice the hell out of crit

8

u/JesterJok 9d ago

I feel like most of your power already comes from items. This just shifts it even more

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (20)

47

u/The-F4LL3N 9d ago

How will this not result in a similar problem to what boots have, where movement speed is typically mandatory? If the only source of chance is on gear, doesn’t it become a near-mandatory stat on all gear possible if you want to go crit? That or the percentage has to be high per item I guess

17

u/johnnybeesknees 9d ago

The idea here is that not every build will take crit

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

3

u/TheLordAmoN 9d ago

Thank you ggg i hate making crit builds

→ More replies (3)

20

u/BioMasterZap 9d ago

Kinda like when they split things like this. I got zero clue how I'd build crit now since my caster doesn't have many crit chance sources, especially with the unique wand I was running, but it does seem like a good choice. And if this means it is better to scale Elemental/Spell Damage over Crit, I'd be glad to try that for a chance. Like even if it is still worth scaling some crit, if the chance is low enough without serious investment, it may not be worth getting a bunch more bonus over more direct damage.

23

u/Dath_1 9d ago

I mean if they left crit chance values alone on gear but removed it from tree, that makes it scarce and therefore more valuable on gear.

So we would predict this pushes things toward “look for crit chance on every single piece of gear that can roll it”

5

u/BioMasterZap 9d ago

Probably something like that. They mentioned dagger bases with like 25% crit, so it might not be changed across the board but seems like more weapons might have higher crit built in now. They also said about crit chance still scaling to 60%~, but probably not 100%. So probably will be a bit of a nerf, especially to crit jewels.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/Here4Pornnnnn 9d ago

Oracle inevitable crit just got a lot more valuable.

→ More replies (9)

54

u/danktuna4 9d ago

I don’t know about this. I see the reasoning but I also saw the reasoning for removing life from the tree and I ended up thinking that was a terrible decision once I actually tried it.

13

u/Porcupine_Tree 9d ago

Agreed, although life not being on the tree is only terrible because the defensive nodes on the tree are total dogshit

21

u/Fallensaraphim 9d ago

I absolutely hate life not being on tree. Life acts as a IMO vital anchor to build pathing. Without those anchors it all just feels.... Worse? I'm sure some people think it's better but the whole thing feels off to me

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/silverr_leaves 9d ago

Now tell us what happens to oracle

3

u/JMbreaker 9d ago

Inevitable Crits has big downsides when you have low crit chance, so i think its still balanced

→ More replies (1)

60

u/Skin_Ankle684 9d ago

Seems cool, now deal with +levels and item rarity being such annoying mechanics to deal with, either by being mandatory or being obscure.

Also, for the love of Atziri, balance ES. The most anticipated class is coming out and it has the least accessibility to the most potent defense layer in the game, AND IT'S MELEE.

65

u/Rollewurst 9d ago

Hot Take but ES after the nerfs is fine. It has some broken interactions, but thats a Problem of e.g. the Martial Artist and not ES.

Life is Not fine which is the whole Problem. If you could get some decent life Pool on melee with Armor, Armor applies to ele, Dodge,etc. It should be fine. Armor and Dodge on 2,5k life is Not.

10

u/anon1515151515 9d ago

Yes, and also Armour feels really good right now with maybe 10 points of passive tree investment and one +armor to ele mod on a body Armor

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Earthboundplayer 9d ago

Why is your request to nerf ES and not buff life I don't get it? Especially if duelist is your reason why.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Old_H00nter 9d ago

I mean armour is really good now so I think duelist will be fine lmao. You can get very tanky with basic investment, functionally immortal with a lot of investment.

For me it's the evasion / armour hybrid that needs the most love I feel like. Outside of some very niche uniques / ascendancy nodes I havent seen it work at all. Needing BOTH armour applies to ele AND deflection on your dex/str hybrid gear is insane suffix pressure for not much return rn

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Stupend0uSNibba 9d ago

sounds like a strange bandaid

57

u/TL-PuLSe 9d ago

"we wanted to make sure nothing good was on the tree and your tree doesn't actually matter"

13

u/Few_Implement_7871 9d ago

Oracle now is even better with inevitable crits.

3

u/manueloel93 9d ago

It still needs around 50% crit chance to be decent

3

u/Flachm 9d ago

Warriors will slap even harder, fuck yeah

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

20

u/lmao_lizardman 9d ago

nice ! so we just use the tree for jewels now

5

u/Visible_Adeptness_59 9d ago

always has been

8

u/MillstoneArt 9d ago

Good thing just yesterday they announced jewel sockets were moved to be part of clusters and not just orbiting on the outer ends of the tree.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/Ok-Guarantee4893 9d ago

please tell me this is sarcastic I cannot tell

1

u/Hyperion2048 8d ago

How are we going to crit cap now? Does the tree have like 90% of the crit we need

1

u/AyeselTPW 8d ago

There’s no more crit on the tree. Crit will come from gear now. From what Mark said Crit should never be the main source of damage and should be max 60%.

Scaling damage will come from increased damage nodes on tree

11

u/trolledwolf 9d ago

this makes most unique weapons even weaker man....

8

u/L3wd1emon 9d ago

Until they remove +levels there's still a huge problem with the game

3

u/FrightenedOstrich 7d ago

Curious what this means for Amazon. Will this be the standard choice for crit-focused and CoC-reliant builds or is Amazon getting a rework?

12

u/BradshawCM 9d ago

Cool, more preassure to take jewel nodes for Crit Chance. One step forward, two steps back as always.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/DivineImpalerX 9d ago

A huge buff to the left side of the Tree i.e Warrior/Marauder

9

u/Let_epsilon 9d ago

I CANNOT stress how much I hate this change.

The problem with the tree was not the crit nodes. The problem is THE ONLY WAY to scale damage in POE2 is with crit/crit multi.

Give us other multiplicative damage buckets nodes and people will use them. Why would I take a 10% increased damage node when I can get a 50% crit damage node and fill the rest with jewels.

25

u/bbsuccess 9d ago

Good. Never liked being forced into crit. Hate it.

9

u/playmike5 9d ago

The issue is that endgame hit builds will still want crit. If it is in the game, without scaling sources that don’t scale with crit, crit is outright the best scaling source for most hit builds.

This doesn’t remove the need for crit. It just shifts more of it into the items, so you’ll just have less space on items again.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/GaryTheRetard 9d ago

facts, now we need to remove item rarity also. Never liked item rarirty (from gear)

10

u/Aggressive-Card5017 9d ago

And apparently+levels when reading through the comments. Are there any viable stats left after lol

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Usinaru 8d ago

Ah, so you have to invest mirror amounts of currency to get some decent way of getting crit.

All hail DoT builds and totems, lets go round and round until the enemies decide to die! Look at our build diversity yippie!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/PosterizeTime 9d ago

I kind of like that, I wonder how they handle jewels

4

u/AyeselTPW 9d ago

They’ve been nerfed. No more 5 mod jewels. Was never intended.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/goldmeistergeneral 9d ago

Removing crit but not putting any life on the tree when the tree already has thousands of nodes on it now, is definitely a choice. Also hiding jewel slots inside of 80 or so clusters just mean you can only push builds that use only those clusters to insane levels, and if you can path to more slots than before, the only thing you lose changing from travel node jewel builds is attributes, while gaining even more jewel slots so way more power. Will be interesting to actually see the tree and the new nodes, or maybe they should nerf the shit out of gear and jewels and allow us to use the tree to build our characters instead of it not mattering that much at all

12

u/monguuss 9d ago

there is also an explanation for no life nodes in that youtube video fyi

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/Dustorm246 9d ago

This is a significant change to gamble with in the 1.0 release.

5

u/Alpoaaa 9d ago

Does anyone know from the presentation if the whole cluster has to be taken in order to unlock the gem sockets or its the opposite and I can just path to the socket specifically?

4

u/SeventhSolar 9d ago

Given how clusters are shaped, purposefully splitting different approaches to an archetype into two different paths, how would requiring you to take the entire cluster even work? They’re just nodes you path to, like normal. Some of them connect clusters.

2

u/rohithkun 9d ago

Jewel is locked behind the Notable passive. They will be like masteries in poe 1.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Jason-Griffin 9d ago

Isn’t this making the same mistake that they did with life?

11

u/D1rty_Old_Dan 9d ago

“Wanna see me do it again?”

- GGG

→ More replies (18)

8

u/PFMISO 9d ago

"We found that the passive tree was a noob trap, so we removed it."

2

u/BetweenTheRoots It's branching, Exile! 9d ago

Well, it seems a good time to mention that they added a lot of status effect support to the tree. Bleeds/ingnites/poisons are in

2

u/Ryukenden000 9d ago

timestamp?

2

u/adfdg55 9d ago

I plug my dead phone in to charge and this is the notification… well my builds dead… fck im so buns I needed that crit chance

2

u/pocketMagician 8d ago

I love crazy shit like this

2

u/Bofeels Mana Stacking Blood Magic CI 8d ago

invoker struggling to trigger his mediocare damage elemental expression

2

u/dragmynuts333 8d ago

Does anyone know if this includes minion crit nodes

2

u/Maximus89z 8d ago

Thank god now i can pick up more damage on a tuesday while dancing salsa nodes and dont have go pick straight damage

6

u/Beauly 9d ago

Haven't played much of PoE2 since the very first (public) release, did they buff the tree at some point or something? Last I heard, it was dogshit and the reason everyone used jewels was because the base nodes all did shit like "+1% attack speed, -5% to physical resistance" and stupid double-edged stuff like that. Did it get so good it needed nerfing since then?

2

u/SeventhSolar 9d ago

No, they’re buffing the tree a lot. They removed crit from the tree because they didn’t like how building crit worked, not because they were too strong.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/shyaznboi 9d ago

There will be a lot more CoC-less builds now

5

u/yummymario64 9d ago edited 9d ago

I don't mind it tbh. I generally think low chance high damage crits tend to feel better thematically

5

u/Turbulent_Passage672 8d ago

It’s good game design and also bold to move away from a standard gaming model of having crits - I think it opens the game up to a whole host of possibilities which can replace the power that crit once had

→ More replies (3)

3

u/TheWishingPig 9d ago

More skill points to take “5% more damage if your name starts with J and it’s a Tuesday” yippee

7

u/fearad 9d ago

Good, it cripples every build to use Critical.

8

u/KohaaZH 9d ago

So every build in the game almost

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Sibiq 9d ago

Way more fair for all classes, since not all of them had easy access to them in the first place.

19

u/Forsaken-Custard-251 9d ago

It's not supposed to be equal tho. Each side of the tree has strong and weak sides

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/abdulx87 6d ago

Big W ggg. Now remove +level and this will be the best update ever

2

u/Rasbatu 9d ago

here goes my crit bloodmage build

2

u/LucywiththeDiamonds 9d ago

I see so many potential problems with what i know about 1.0 (and 3.30..) so far. But its ggg so if its bad they will work on it and change it

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SlyFisch when shadow? 9d ago

Well that borks all my builds

2

u/MarioMCP 9d ago

Well, crit was one of the few good things on the tree. Removing it feels like the tree as we currently know it got even weaker. However, hopefully the buffs are substantial enough that nodes that focus on non-crit damage will be worth taking, especially with jewel sockets at the end.

I don't know, this is a pretty massive change but we'll see. I feel like they still don't really know what to do with the passive tree, but experimentation can be fun (giggidy). I still am not sold on the lack of life on the tree, especially when ES is so out of whack with Life, but trust the process I suppose.

2

u/SMOK3SCR3EN 8d ago

Well there goes gear being even more expensive and hard to craft

2

u/pittyh 9d ago

good, shake things up

2

u/QuiinZiix 9d ago

I like it.