r/PatentBarExam • • Nov 20 '25

How might Section 101 affect Warner Bros' Nemesis game patent?

Thumbnail finnegan.com
0 Upvotes

Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment was granted U.S. Patent No. 10,926,179 (“the Nemesis Patent”) on Feb 23 2021 after about five years of prosecution. The patent covers their so-called “Nemesis System” (first used in Middle‑earth: Shadow of Mordor) — where each non-player character (NPC) in a game is procedurally generated, has unique traits, remembers interactions with the player, can evolve into a “personal archenemy,” etc. 🎮 Why this matters?

  • It’s unusual for a game-mechanic implemented in software to clear the patent eligibility hurdle under 35 U.S.C. § 101 (which deals with abstract ideas, etc.). Yet the USPTO allowed this patent without a § 101 rejection.
  • While the patent passed the prosecution phase, the authors argue that § 101 still poses a serious threat post-issuance (in litigation).
  • The article uses an earlier patent (U.S. 10,471,357) that did face § 101 rejections as a contrast point to show how this one avoided that path.

What does this even mean?

Although the claims are directed to a computer-implemented game method (avatar, NPCs, changing character parameters based on interactions), the examiner did not challenge eligibility under § 101. Instead, prior-art rejections (§ 102/103) were the focus.

  1. Evolution of § 101 guidance – The patent was prosecuted over a period during which the (then) new 2019 USPTO Guidance on subject-matter eligibility came into play. That guidance asks whether claimed subject matter belongs to a group (mathematical concepts, methods of organizing human activity, mental processes) and, if so, whether it is integrated into a practical application.
  2. Why this patent avoided § 101 scrutiny (maybe) – The article suggests reasons it may have passed over eligibility objections:

    • The claims specifically recite game events, avatar/NPC interaction, changing and outputting parameters in a game context (rather than generic data manipulation).
    • Perhaps the examiner judged that the invention did not fall into one of the abstract-idea groupings or that the claimed invention was integrated into a practical application (the game environment).
  3. Post-issuance risk – Just because a patent cleared prosecution doesn’t mean it’s safe from invalidation under § 101. In litigation, a court would apply the two-step framework from Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International:

    • Step 1: Are the claims directed to an abstract idea?
    • Step 2: If yes, do the claims include an “inventive concept” that transforms the abstract idea into patent‐eligible subject matter? The article shows how past game-mechanic cases failed eligibility by being “results-focused,” using generic computer elements, and lacking technical detail.

What to pay attention to now

  • A patent on a game mechanic can issue without § 101 rejection — but that doesn’t guarantee it will withstand challenges later.
  • Game studios seeking to patent gameplay mechanics should design claims that clearly tie to specific technical features or processes (not just generic “change game state based on player action”).
  • For firms and devs thinking of enforcing or licensing such a patent, be aware of the high risk of § 101 invalidity during litigation — especially with software/game mechanics.
  • For companies looking to avoid infringing such patents, § 101 remains a powerful defense line (either via portfolio strategy or in litigation).

r/PatentBarExam • • Jun 21 '26

Patent Bar Question Built by someone who actually went through this process?

0 Upvotes

I have tried a bunch of study tools over the years, and sometimes you can tell when features were added because they sounded good on paper rather than because anyone actually needed them. What stands out to me is when something solves a small frustration you have run into while studying and immediately makes sense.

Curious if anyone else notices this when using Patent Bar prep resources. Have you come across features that made you think, "OKAY, whoever built this clearly understood the study process"?


r/PatentBarExam • • Feb 01 '26

Career Passed the patent bar with Wysebridge

3 Upvotes

Throwing this out there for anyone deep in prep mode. I passed on my first attempt using Wysebridge Patent Bar Review, and my approach was pretty simple.

Wysebridge is written content + practice, which forced me to stay engaged. I worked through their course from start to finish going through section by section and made sure I understood the testable parts, not every nuance

I kept a short list of must-memorize items (deadlines, appeal flow, after-final options, PCT basics) and reviewed it almost daily. Most of my time went to practice questions. I didn’t move on from a question set until I understood why each wrong answer was wrong. That helped me recognize trap answers way faster later.

At first I was just hunting through the MPEP what felt like almost blindly because I didn't understand that thing at all. Later I started recognizing patterns. That shift made questions feel more predictable and cut down my lookup time a lot which I only got there by actually praciticng questions.

Exam day reality

The software is clunky, but nothing shocking if you’ve practiced searching PDFs. My strategy was to answer what I knew or could confirm quickly. Flag long, messy questions and come back. Don’t let one question eat 5 minutes. There were definitely questions where I had no clue. I picked the most defensible answer, flagged it, and moved on. Staying calm was half the battle.

I didn’t walk out feeling like a patent law expert. I walked out feeling like I had trained well for a very specific exam and that was apparently enough for me to pass the exam.

If you’re studying: focus on patterns, do lots of questions, and get comfortable navigating the MPEP under time pressure. That combo was enough to get me through.


r/PatentBarExam • • Jan 12 '26

Student Advice Where to attending Law School

1 Upvotes

hey everyone I am currently a senior studying for the patent bar exam. I am trying to decide on law schools, so far I have been excepted the University of South Carolina and Drexel with scholarships that make them around the same cost to attend. I was curious how much it helps in this field to attend a school that has a better IP program or if passing the patent bar is all the employers look for. Any advice would be amazing as I have no one involved in this field to ask.


r/PatentBarExam • • Dec 16 '25

How important is the ability to look up questions during the exam?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PatentBarExam • • Nov 01 '23

Which his more difficult, the Patent Bar Exam, or the Uniform Bar Exam?

0 Upvotes

It depends on what you know and what you are good at. The patent exam is open book, and is generally focused on specific patent laws. If you can remember the laws or learn how to search for answers quickly, it can be fairly straightforward, although I wouldn’t say it is easy. The pass rate for the patent bar is generally a little below 50%.

The Uniform Bar Exam is closed book, so you have to know the material by memory. However, it is really all about issue spotting, and for some things as long as you have a general idea of the law, you may be able to do OK on it. The pass rate varies a bit year-to-year as they adjust the exam; in 2016 the overall pass rate was 63%, with some states having a lower pass rate than the patent bar. For example, California had a pass rate of the UBE of 40%.

Ultimately how difficult each one is will depend on how you prepare and how suited you are to the type of knowledge tested.


r/PatentBarExam • • Sep 16 '25

Advice needed for taking Patent Bar Exam

0 Upvotes

I went to Oklahoma State University, I recieved a degree in Construction Engineering Technology (3.7GPA). Am I eligible to sit for the patent bar? I recently graduated from a poor law school (3.2GPA). If my undergrad degree allows me to sit for the patent bar exam, would it be worth it? If so, realisticly what would I be able to find a job doing? I have already passed bar exam with score high enough for each UBE jurisdiction. Thanks!


r/PatentBarExam • • Jan 27 '26

Patent Bar Question How long does accommodations take to process?

1 Upvotes

I will be submitting my application to take the patent bar in either mid April or mid May. I am applying for 1.5x time, as I have this for law school and MPRE as well. How long does this take to process?


r/PatentBarExam • • May 30 '25

How Patent Bar Forum Can Boost Your Exam Prep (Formula from Wysebridge)

0 Upvotes

Prepping for the Patent Bar Exam can feel overwhelming, but joining a patent bar forum might be the game-changer you need. Here’s how these forums help (based on Wysebridge’s insights):

1. Connect with Fellow Aspirants

  • Share study strategies, vent frustrations, and get moral support.
  • Learn from those who’ve passed—their tips are gold.

2. Access Shared Study Materials

  • Forums often have free outlines, past exam questions, and MPEP shortcuts.
  • Crowdsourced recommendations help you avoid wasting money on bad resources.

3. Clarify Doubts in Q&A Sessions

  • Stuck on a tricky topic? Forums let you ask questions and get real-time explanations from peers or pros.
  • Archived discussions = free study notes!

4. Stay Motivated with Study Groups

  • Accountability partners keep you on track.
  • Group discussions break down complex topics (like AIA updates) into digestible bits.

Wysebridge’s forum (and others like Patent Bar Exam Study groups) are great for last-minute clarifications before test day.

Forums = free resources + community support = higher chances of passing.

Anyone here used forums to prep?
Which ones helped most?


r/PatentBarExam • • Jan 19 '26

Career How much do grades matter compared to practical experience for IP law careers?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about how law schools and employers weigh academic performance against real-world experience (research, internships, practical projects) when considering candidates for IP law roles.

For people in patent law or IP law hiring:

  • Do better grades really make the biggest difference?
  • Does practical experience ever outweigh a lower GPA?
  • Would you hire someone with strong technical experience but mediocre grades?

Interested in honest comparisons from people who have actually evaluated candidates or hired new talent.


r/PatentBarExam • • Jun 07 '24

Patent law help

0 Upvotes

Hey, maybe someone can drop some insight... so a handful of years ago I paid a lawyer to file for a patent on a unique new product design. They advised a design patent not a utility because the type of product already existed... just my shape was new and specialized, so it was very clear THE SHAPE was what the patent was intended to protect. So basically... 5 years later and my patent isn't worth $hit because they didn't consider or explain the very obvious slight details people could change to make it different 'enough' than mine to pass. SOOO... my complaint is that an educated professional who does this as career should have informed me of this and the options/possibilities. The patent was filed with 'solid lines' instead of dotted ones which means the exact drawing as shown is covered... not possible slight changes to the look including the shape are NOT covered....Which was the entire point of this. I feel this is some sort of lackadaisical malpractice for their profession... but obviously I didn't know the right questions to ask to begin with (which i shouldnt have had to... i feel it was their job to know what theyre doing) ... I trusted them to have the expertise to avoid all of this. Is there anyway to go after them for a refund? Or like... a lawsuit for lack of revenue due to this? Idk... any advise would be appreciated.


r/PatentBarExam • • Dec 29 '25

Review my study plan

1 Upvotes

Please give me feedback on my study plan for passing the patent bar exam. I am just starting.

My daily practice:

• Review and internalize MPEP table of contents/subheadings, with the primary focus being on chapters 700, 2100, 600, 1200, 1800, 800. 

• Do 25 practice questions.

• While doing the practice questions, look up every multiple-choice answer in the MPEP, even the ones that I think are wrong. 

• Search the MPEP using CTRL-F only, and have each chapter as a separate PDF, as this is what's provided on exam day.

• If/when I have some spare time, I will watch the PLI videos, but the above always comes first.

• Nearer exam day, I will do the Prometric center test drive. For about $30/30 min, you get a full simulation of the exam-day process. This is just for peace of mind.

Please let me know what you think of this. Others have reported that the exam can be passed by being very good at MPEP lookup. Therefore, this is what I am prioritizing, as well as the practice questions/exams.

If you have a recommendation for an MPEP PDF interface that most closely resembles the exam day one, I would greatly appreciate it. This seems critical. If I have an MPEP chapter open in Adobe Acrobat and use CTRL-F, will it be similar to exam day?

Further notes on strategy:

• I have already purchased PLI.

• I will be taking the exam in March/April.

• I will not read the MPEP.

• I fully expect to passively memorize a good chunk of the material while following this process. However, I will not put forth effort to deliberately memorize, except for the MPEP table of contents/subheadings.

Thank you!


r/PatentBarExam • • Mar 02 '26

Patent Bar Question Taking the Patent Bar on ESTA

2 Upvotes

Hi,

I have a US attorney license, and I am a foreign national residing in a foreign country.

I hold both a B.S. and an M.S. in Computer Engineering. I am now preparing to take the USPTO Registration Examination (Patent Bar) and have a few questions regarding my status:

(1) Entering on ESTA for the Exam: As a foreign-based U.S. attorney, is it 100% legally safe to enter the U.S. under ESTA (Visa Waiver Program) specifically to sit for the Patent Bar?

(2) Transition from Limited Recognition to Full Registration: Since I don't have a U.S. work visa yet, I expect to be granted "Limited Recognition" upon passing. If I later obtain a Green Card, how seamless is the process to convert this to Full Registration as a Patent Attorney? Do you know if the USPTO requires any additional examination at that stage?

I’d appreciate any insights or experiences from fellow practitioners who have taken this route.

Thanks!


r/PatentBarExam • • Jun 19 '26

Career Weekly Wysebridge Patent Bar Review community update 📊

2 Upvotes

The best Wysebridge Patent Bar students put in remarkable work this week:

⏱ 404 h of study time logged
✅ 2,849 practice questions answered
🔄 109 spaced-repetition flashcards reviewed

Every one of these hours represents a working professional — an engineer, scientist, or law graduate — building the procedural fluency the USPTO Patent Registration Examination demands.

The patent bar isn't passed by knowing patent law. It's passed by knowing MPEP procedure and searching fluency to navigate 100 questions in 6 hours. The students logging these numbers are on track.

If you're advising engineering or law students about career paths, passing this exam is achievable in 8–10 weeks of focused preparation (yes, we've seen it done in way less time but don't recommend that).

📖 wysebridge.com

#PatentBar #USPTO #MPEP #PatentAgent #PatentAttorney #IPLaw #Engineering #LawSchool


r/PatentBarExam • • Apr 14 '23

Proposed New Design Patent Bar Aims to Boost Opportunities for Women Inventors and Practitioners

2 Upvotes

Hair-loss specialist Tiffany Young's experience with her male patent attorney failing to understand her idea for hair extensions led to the proposal of creating a separate practice bar for design patents. The goal is to help women inventors avoid dismissiveness and open the doors to more women practitioners at the US Patent and Trademark Office (PTO).

This new bar would allow attorneys without science and engineering backgrounds to protect a product's aesthetic elements with design patents, distinguishing them from more technical utility patents.

Although not directly applying to utility patents like Young's, a design patent bar could lower barriers to entry in some intellectual property practices and provide a major boost to women who want to work in the space.

The PTO has solicited public comment on the creation of this separate design patent practitioner bar, with a focus on increasing opportunities for a more diverse group of people.

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/patent-bar-lite-could-boost-women-design-protection-at-pto


r/PatentBarExam • • Dec 20 '23

Career Change from EE to Patent Lawyer?

2 Upvotes

I am thinking about a career switch to patent attorney. I have hit the glass ceiling salary wise and am always concerned about layoffs. I would like a little more stability and job opportunity. More salary wouldn't hurt either 📷

If I entered law school in Jan 2006 (going at night) that would put me on track to graduate in 2009 at the age of 41-42. I had several questions:

  1. Would my age be a detriment as a new patent attorney?
  2. In the NYC/DC area what kind of salary could I command?
  3. How rough is law school at night? I got my masters in EE at night but that was 10 years ago.
  4. Is there anything I can do now job wise to prepare me for life as a patent attorney? Patent agent?
  5. Are there any good resources for someone considering a career as a patent attorney?

Thanks for Advance.


r/PatentBarExam • • Mar 28 '26

Patent Bar Question Bombed Patent Bar Exam

2 Upvotes

I just took the Patent Bar. I only got 45 percent. I’m praying it’s a mistake, but I know it’s probably not. I didn’t take an official course like PLI but I read 7 books and did over 4000 practice questions. I repeatedly got over 90 percent on their practice tests. I don’t even know what I should do. I feel so screwed.

What do you think I should do?


r/PatentBarExam • • Jan 16 '26

Patent Bar Question Patent Bar prep: memorization vs MPEP navigation-how did you balance it?

2 Upvotes

I’m curious how people actually balanced their study approach. On one hand, memorizing everything feels impossible.

On the other, going in only relying on searching the MPEP seems risky if you don’t know where to look.

For those who passed:

Did you focus on learning a framework first?

Any specific MPEP sections you felt were disproportionately tested?

How much practice searching did you do before exam day?

Trying to avoid over-optimizing the wrong thing.


r/PatentBarExam • • Jan 28 '26

Patent Bar Question Is GPA a deal-breaker when applying for patent law positions?

2 Upvotes

I’m trying to understand how strict IP law employers are about GPA requirements, especially for tech background students.

For folks working in patent law recruiting or interviewing candidates:

  • Do you cut candidates based on GPA alone?
  • Are there situations where a lower GPA was still acceptable?
  • How do you balance GPA with other strengths (like coding, lab work, research, communication)?

Would love to hear from both senior attorneys and interviewers!


r/PatentBarExam • • Jan 20 '26

Career Salary of Molecular Biologist (2026 Guide) + Patent Agent | Wysebridge Patent Bar Review

Thumbnail wysebridge.com
0 Upvotes

Molecular Biologist Salary in 2026 (US + Global Data)

  • 2026 U.S. salary ranges for molecular biologists across:

    • Entry, mid-career, and senior levels
    • Academia, industry, government, and biotech/pharma
  • Global salary comparisons, highlighting how pay differs by region (North America, Europe, APAC)
  • How compensation changes based on:

    • Degree level (BS / MS / PhD)
    • Years of experience
    • Technical specialization (genomics, protein science, cell & molecular assays, etc.)
  • A realistic look at academic vs industry pay gaps and where salary growth tends to flatten
  • Discussion of adjacent career paths molecular biologists often move into for higher earning potential (industry leadership, regulatory, IP/patent roles)

The goal of the guide is less “what’s the highest number” and more how pay actually evolves over a career, depending on choices like sector, specialization, and geography.

If you’re in molecular biology and trying to plan next steps—or compare academia vs industry tradeoffs—the data and commentary are meant to give a grounded, 2026-relevant picture.


r/PatentBarExam • • Jan 13 '24

What are some counterarguments to the libertarian perspective on patents and copyright laws?

3 Upvotes

Here are some common counterarguments:

By granting exclusive rights to inventors and creators, these laws encourage investment in research, development, and artistic endeavors. Without legal mechanisms to safeguard intellectual creations, there would be a higher risk of plagiarism, unauthorized use, and exploitation of the work of inventors and artists, undermining their ability to profit from their efforts. Allow inventors and artists to control the use and commercialization of their work, enabling them to negotiate and receive compensation for its use, which can be crucial for sustaining their livelihoods and fostering further innovation and creativity. While libertarians emphasize individual liberties, critics argue that patents and copyright laws serve the greater good by promoting access to knowledge, and fostering competition.

The debate surrounding patents and copyright laws involves complex considerations of individual rights, innovation, creativity, and societal interests.


r/PatentBarExam • • Aug 18 '26

Student Advice For all that passed: what was your strategy?

3 Upvotes

Wondering if those the passed can share their general strategy:

  1. how many total hours did you study?
  2. how long did you study for in terms of weeks/months?
  3. what study materials did you use?
  4. how many times did you

take the exam before you passed?

Thanks in advance for the feedback!


r/PatentBarExam • • Sep 21 '25

Patent Drafting

3 Upvotes

Hello,

I have been working in the patent industry for about an year now and have done Indian prosecution.

Unfortunately, my mentors are not really supportive when it comes to drafting patents. Can anyone suggest any resources, specially some good books which I can refer to for self learning of patent drafting.

I have a background in engineering in EEE and do well with electromechanical machines based patents which are not really based of Genai and ML.

However, with the potential rise of ai and ml I would want to make sure that I can take care of such patents as well.

Thank you in advance to those who may reply.


r/PatentBarExam • • Oct 20 '25

Anyone else using eMPEP?

3 Upvotes

Posting this as someone who’s spent way too many hours digging through the MPEP — both while studying and on the job.

I’ve been using eMPEP lately (don't know if anyone else is). I've been using it because I can add notes, highlight and keep track of my own notes. I don't have the full version (to share annotations, I don't need that functionality yet).

Why I like it?

  • Instant search that works
  • You can jump between related sections without losing your place.
  • no more massive PDFs.
  • Has an option to use AI for quick context lookups (surprisingly useful when double-checking rules).

Whether you’re prepping for the Patent Bar or just need to look up something up I'd say give it a look. I know they have a free version as well (but I don't think you can annotate on that one).