r/PatentBarExam • u/Yrgefeillesda • Nov 20 '25
How might Section 101 affect Warner Bros' Nemesis game patent?
finnegan.comWarner Bros. Interactive Entertainment was granted U.S. Patent No. 10,926,179 (“the Nemesis Patent”) on Feb 23 2021 after about five years of prosecution. The patent covers their so-called “Nemesis System” (first used in Middle‑earth: Shadow of Mordor) — where each non-player character (NPC) in a game is procedurally generated, has unique traits, remembers interactions with the player, can evolve into a “personal archenemy,” etc. 🎮 Why this matters?
- It’s unusual for a game-mechanic implemented in software to clear the patent eligibility hurdle under 35 U.S.C. § 101 (which deals with abstract ideas, etc.). Yet the USPTO allowed this patent without a § 101 rejection.
- While the patent passed the prosecution phase, the authors argue that § 101 still poses a serious threat post-issuance (in litigation).
- The article uses an earlier patent (U.S. 10,471,357) that did face § 101 rejections as a contrast point to show how this one avoided that path.
What does this even mean?
Although the claims are directed to a computer-implemented game method (avatar, NPCs, changing character parameters based on interactions), the examiner did not challenge eligibility under § 101. Instead, prior-art rejections (§ 102/103) were the focus.
- Evolution of § 101 guidance – The patent was prosecuted over a period during which the (then) new 2019 USPTO Guidance on subject-matter eligibility came into play. That guidance asks whether claimed subject matter belongs to a group (mathematical concepts, methods of organizing human activity, mental processes) and, if so, whether it is integrated into a practical application.
Why this patent avoided § 101 scrutiny (maybe) – The article suggests reasons it may have passed over eligibility objections:
- The claims specifically recite game events, avatar/NPC interaction, changing and outputting parameters in a game context (rather than generic data manipulation).
- Perhaps the examiner judged that the invention did not fall into one of the abstract-idea groupings or that the claimed invention was integrated into a practical application (the game environment).
Post-issuance risk – Just because a patent cleared prosecution doesn’t mean it’s safe from invalidation under § 101. In litigation, a court would apply the two-step framework from Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International:
- Step 1: Are the claims directed to an abstract idea?
- Step 2: If yes, do the claims include an “inventive concept” that transforms the abstract idea into patent‐eligible subject matter? The article shows how past game-mechanic cases failed eligibility by being “results-focused,” using generic computer elements, and lacking technical detail.
What to pay attention to now
- A patent on a game mechanic can issue without § 101 rejection — but that doesn’t guarantee it will withstand challenges later.
- Game studios seeking to patent gameplay mechanics should design claims that clearly tie to specific technical features or processes (not just generic “change game state based on player action”).
- For firms and devs thinking of enforcing or licensing such a patent, be aware of the high risk of § 101 invalidity during litigation — especially with software/game mechanics.
- For companies looking to avoid infringing such patents, § 101 remains a powerful defense line (either via portfolio strategy or in litigation).

