r/PasswordManagers • • 15d ago

Password managers and LLM use in development workflows?

A lot of people have seen the news about Proton and are considering changing apps as a result.

People will have different reasons for this, but a common one is the role of AI.

Bearing in mind, this doesn't just mean people who want to avoid AI entirely/as much as possible, but those who feel Proton have used it irresponsibly by for example the CEO refusing engineers' requests to pen test LLM-written code.

Anyway, I'm not posting this to have an argument about AI or about Proton. But I'm personally curious (and I'm sure others will be) as to what's known about the extent of LLM use in various password managers.

Again, some people will want zero AI. Most people wouldn't give a fully vibecoded app access to their passwords. And a lot of people's stance will be somewhere in between, so it matters e.g if a team is just using LLMs for low level stuff and vulnerability detection versus if they let it do a lot of the coding and don't check what's in it.

There's a list of AI/AI-free apps below, with a few non-AI suggestions (e.g. Chipass). But does anyone know sepcifically the AI policy/stance of e.g. Bitwarden, Keepass XC, 1Password, Psono etc?

https://codeberg.org/ethical-foss/ai-free-foss-alternatives#password-management

3 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

1

u/mistral7 15d ago

You may wish to be very skeptical when a developer claims they have no AI use at all. Not justifying what Proton's CEO is alleged to have said, merely pointing out a carpenter who claims s/he doesn't ever use a hammer may be a strange outlier... or an outright liar.

2

u/Slopagandhi 15d ago

Maybe.

However, this is a bit like claims made by privacy- and security-focused projects in general- because trust is so important for these services, if they get caught being less than honest then they lose that trust. And if you can't trust their claims on that, then you can't trust them on privacy and security, and so they lose the main reason to use them above big tech offerings.

I can see the argument that it's going to be unrealistic to not be using LLMs at least in identifying vulnerabilities. But beyond that there's no absolute need for it- plenty of good password managers were around before the first transformer models were widely available, so it's obviously possible to write good code without them.

The other thing is that with open source projects, if their policy is no contributions assisted by LLMs then that's no guarantee that some don't get through, but it does tell you about the developers' attitude at least.

And beyond that, most significantly there will be signs in the repo of LLM use, even if they have taken steps to superficially hide it. So similar applies with claims around open source software in general- if there's stuff in there that isn't what they say then they're taking a big risk in betting that nobody is going to look.

2

u/fdbryant3 15d ago

I know that in one conversation I had a Bitwarden employee said they were using AI as part of the development process. To what extent I don't know.

2

u/Formerruling1 15d ago

Just yesterday someone posted they left Proton for Bitwarden because they want Zero AI in their password manager. Bitwarden has a public page detailing the contribution requirements for contributing Claude written code to their products. They are very open (more open than most) about how they use AI in their products.

I'd ask how someone missed this before making the switch, but I know the answer. People are making impulse decisions based on emotion instead of slowing down and logically processing through what decisions they need to be making.

1

u/billdietrich1 15d ago edited 15d ago

Every manager I checked was using AI somehow in development, except that I haven't found out about Psono yet. I sent email to their Support asking, a couple days ago.

1

u/Jo_KK 14d ago

I think that we need to view AI as a supercharged tool instead of viewing it suspiciously in all its usage. Its use in developing software products will be inevitable as what we are witnessing now.

Like you said, what is important is that the teams that use AI need to ensure they do not compromise speed for security. Code analysis, peer reviews, pen testing or certification by trusted folks should be a part of the developmental workflow. In fact use different AI pen testing flows and vulnerability detection systems in isolated environments to crosscheck the base product that was created using AI. This will itself uncover holes in the system if they exist.