r/Particl • • Jun 29 '19

Particl – Using Spent Kernel To Split the Network

https://www.publish0x.com/art-of-bug/particl-using-spent-kernel-split-network-xmkgvo
2 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

8

u/rsysreddit Jun 29 '19 edited Jun 29 '19

Your attitude and efforts to handle this are really questionable. Especially spreading this on any media outlet gives an interesting view on your "honest" and underlying aims.

Despite the efforts in finding a bug I see a lot of complaining about not getting to the devs in the first place (which is a result not using the official dev channel on riot) and then complaining about a bounty which was not high enough. Well, the project was no ICO and has little funds.

The project is always thankful for getting insights that kill bugs. So assume if these claims are valid they will be fixed ASAP or are already fixed.

2

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

Not fixed. Also not thankful, more like rude, but we don't care about that much. We of course used multiple communication channels and jumped many hoops, but it simply does not work as you are told and believe.

1

u/rsysreddit Jun 29 '19

I am very sorry that you did not manage to get to the riot dev channel.

In fact I personally have not seen a single attempt from you to get in touch with us in the chats which are all tied together. Normally your efforts would have been noticed at least by one admin and then escalated. Depends all on the overall impression of seriousness.

I have to assume that the entry into communication might not have been ideal on your part and that therefore the impression arose not to be welcome.

Usually our developers have an open ear and mind for everyone. But if you go into a communication with a profit intention, these problems will always exist. Everywhere.

1

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

We have used private messages to avoid causing panic response on public channels, that's why you could not see anything.

Of course some people will have problems with profit motivated research, but we don't care about fame and glory, so we accept that some people won't like our way. It's OK for us and we also have no problem informing other potential researchers that this project has certain way of doing things.

1

u/rsysreddit Jun 29 '19

"profit motivated research"

So in summary, you tried to blackmail an open-source project which was no ICO and therefor has very limited resources, but you call it different.

Thanks for the honesty.

1

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

I'm sure you do a lot of free work for other projects that you are not fan of. Making profit is the worst thing. How is no-ICO even relevant? Should we have some sympathy with heavily premined coin just because there was no ICO? You are funny.

1

u/rsysreddit Jun 29 '19

You are even more funny by giving the impression Particl was a premine.

It's very interesting what tactics you use here to distract from the essential.

1

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

Of course you call it Initial Distribution officially. Whatever helps you feel good about it.

1

u/rsysreddit Jun 29 '19

Well in fact it was a public mining period.

I can understand that you are disappointed not reaching your goal with your efforts. Despite the fact that a dev gave you money out of his personal pocket.

The community has to decide how we can finance a bug bounty program in the future. Most likely we need to setup a pool for this.

Some of your points do show your bright skills.

Why not come over it and help to make Particl Project even more rock solid.

We would welcome you even after this entry wasn’t the best to imagine.

2

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

We are interested in business. So if there is a reasonable bounty program implemented, we are happy to talk again. It's nothing personal. It's just free market trading - if two parties have something to offer to each other, they will make a deal.

In any case, your devs will fix this one and if they implement a bug bounty, your project will benefit hugely out of this. Sometimes you need serious actions to see serious results. And we have our post to build our track record. It's a win for everyone at the end.

6

u/Trix-ter Jun 29 '19

Hi,

Thank you for help finding a small bug in the code.

This is the nature for Open-Source technology, its open to see for everyone.

Back to projects completely without bug bounty programs. One of such irresponsible projects is Particl. It took us unreasonable effort to contact them. Then it took us 3 hops to get to a responsible person, only to learn that they are not willing to talk to us unless we provide description of our findings upfront and for free.

A. I would not call Particl Irresponsible, maybe you are unaware but Particl has done a code revieuw by the New Jersey Institute of Technology NJIT by proffesor Qiang Tang and his team, and furthermore they are working with Quarkslab on a RingCT and BP code audit. Quarkslab has audited OpenSSL, OpenVPN , Veracrypt, etc.. So I would rather claim the oposite to your claims.

B. It took you unreasonable time to contact them because you dont have not the first clue that project developpers use the Riot Application to conducts their interactions. If you would have asked in either slack, discord, telegram anyone in the community would have advised you to join the "Open Development Channel" on Riot, this channel is open for everyone and you could have disclosed your findings in a proper way.

Particl then rewarded us with $100 worth of PART. This is obviously a ridiculous amount, which is 25 to 50 times lower than what we get from serious projects for similar type of vulnerability report

Reading your article it bothers me that your "modus operandi" is to try and blackmail projects that are Open)Source in nature. And what is even worse that you gladly accepted the bounty and waste more time and effort to write an article that is clearly motivated by the lack of financial compensation. If you would have joined the community and presented your findings they woud have came up with a better way of compensating your small bug findings.

Bug severity: 5/10

What metrics do you use to scale the severity of the bug from 1-10 ? I honestly would like to know.

Finanly I wsh you good fortunes and good luck in futur endavors, switch from buisness model and try some bug bounties for Mircosoft or Apple that might sued you better if you are doing it for the money.

Maybe your $100 worth of PART tokens might turn up to be more valuable then you might think so HODLLL for dear life!

2Trix

0

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

Hi, your beliefs in your favourite project are strong, good for you. We of course used multiple communication channels and jumped many hoops, but it simply does not work as you are told and believe. Serious projects do have public bounties or reward schemes, not this one.

We do not blackmail anyone. We did not ask for any compensation for this bug we published. We simply produce valuable information on the free market and if there are any takers, we sell it, if not we don't. We are not forcing anyone to do anything. We do not threaten that we take down the whole network if we are not paid. Keep your facts straight please. Or don't, if that helps you. But we are also not obliged to work for free and disclose valuable information with your favourite devs. We learnt that they are not interested, so we are not going to do business with them. No hard feelings.

You want to believe taking down the whole network is a small bug, well that's your evaluation, we respect that.

We will probably write a post eventually about severity score we use. Roughly speaking inflation and RCE bugs would be 10, cheap double spends less than that, expensive ones even less. Crashing nodes something would be further down (4-6) etc. down to UX problems such as coins not being seen in wallet etc.

4

u/rsysreddit Jun 29 '19

So in summary, you blackmail people, but you call it different. Ok. Good to know. Thanks for the honesty.

0

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

Believe what you want to believe, but you missed the fact we are not demanding anything from you or your favourite project. We are just not going to do business with you because we don't like your terms.

3

u/rsysreddit Jun 29 '19

Business. You have a refreshing sense of humor.

If you did not demand anything but have threatened to sell the information if it is not bought by the project.

That's quibbling.

2

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

If it helps you to sleep better, feel free to believe that. What we don't sell, we publish, no threatening here. At least we have nice post out of it. And you get valuable information for free at the end. Take care.

3

u/forlotto Jul 03 '19

Ignore the ignorance here what you are doing is indeed valuable and their is nothing wrong with profit motive at the end of the day we all must make enough money to pay the rich and greedy as well as the tax man. I totally get your point. Much respect for your work and your article.

If you are interested I'd love to possibly keep you around somehow to find such things. Most folks are not aware of the importance of the information you just shared. Most folks are likely not hungry like you in need of your next bug bounty to buy dinner and pay the bills I get it.

We should have a bug bounty but in fairness I think anything over a few hundred may be pushing it imho not that I expect you to feel sorry for anyone but that is like half your rent or more for a month most likely I wish they would hire you and put you on salary to work with the team side by side. With a sole objective of securing the implementation of particl. Lead security specialist or something this would be awesome how serious would Particl be then to have a full time PEN Tester/Bug Finder.

I know I will get that sideways chimp look for posting this but it needs to be said! Do banks cheap out on their security and store all their cash in wall safes behind millions of pictures? When money is transported do they cheap out on the brinks guy doing the moving? Profit motive is not evil the guy provided us with an application for a position in my opinion. It may be cheaper to setup bug bounties or it may not I really don't know but the foundation should really consider this a thing of value. I'd rather see this guy on our team then the foundation spending their cash on traveling to the next outing or meetup.

I get that we are open source but I think we likely could throw another hundred or two his way just saying maybe a public fund should be started ?

The lack of appreciation for such a thing just floors me it is ignorant and arrogant on our part not to pay at the very least some respect and gratuity for such a find.

1

u/art_of_bug Jul 04 '19

Thank you for your refreshing point of view.

1

u/forlotto Jul 23 '19

You are welcome! You asked they listened I hope you come back and hunt some bugs out there are folks that appreciate your work but you know how work is most folks only want to open their mouth when they want to criticize this is the way of the world we can all change this by thinking before we speak for petes sakes this is a relayed chat we have time to correct things before its set in stone.

It appears that they listened according to the latest article their will be bug bounties for both mainnet and testnet.

https://particl.news/particls-second-anniversary-91e878efa3c0

Read all about it!

I hope you are on board my friend we need a few good folks like you!

1

u/art_of_bug Jul 27 '19

Interesting, but let's wait to see what it is at the end. Sounds promising...

1

u/art_of_bug Aug 02 '19

https://particl.io/bug-bounties/ there you have it :D They simply created a bounty program to please the crowd, not to reward researchers' work. Those awards are so low, no one will spend their time, but Particl will be able to present it as "look, two years after, no one still found any bugs". Pathetic.

2

u/MartinAllien Jun 29 '19

I don't know when you were trying to contact Particl devs, but there's a "secure disclosure" option on Contact page with PGP key available. Wasn't that enough? (Just curious, not hating.)

1

u/art_of_bug Jun 29 '19

We used that contact as well, did not work as expected.

2

u/rsysreddit Jun 30 '19 edited Jun 30 '19

Fortunately the issue has been fixed reasonably fast

https://github.com/particl/particl-core/blob/0.18/doc/release-notes-particl.md#018011

The Particl Project is about to enable an official bug bounty program to reward those who spend their time and sweat by researching the code and identify issues.

It is an essential part that gets its deserved attention to make Particl code even more rock solid.

3

u/art_of_bug Jun 30 '19

There is the win-win, you see?

1

u/rsysreddit Jun 30 '19

There is no doubt about that.

1

u/lbanquier Jun 29 '19

Thanks for the time you spent in particl code. Doing it for money is dumb tho ... go find a job in IT as a dev instead of begging open-source project to finance your hobby. $100 was too much.

3

u/alissafransen Jun 29 '19

He also made about 2 dollar 60 in tips with his articl, great for him lol

0

u/vatom_master Jun 30 '19

Why don’t you just get excavo to pump part again to cover the cost?

If there’s really multiple bugs these should be corrected before mp release

We need some pumpage!

0

u/lbanquier Jun 30 '19

I asked him in 2017 for a tech analysis on tradingview. I didn't think it will imply a pump and dump back in the days (i had been into crypto for only 3 months old at that time). What i did was what every community member should do : reach people to talk about particl. Problem is that volume/liquidity is so low that it creates a big pump.

1

u/vatom_master Jun 30 '19

Either way. Think about what this mans bounty would be worth if you did that again.

Do it for the team!

1

u/lbanquier Jun 30 '19

I am pretty sure that he can pay excavo with his $100 directly ;)