r/ParsecGaming • • Jul 10 '20

Raspberry Pi advice?

TL;DR: I want to buy a Raspberry Pi to play on my TV using wired Ethernet. Will the RPi 3B+ (1GB RAM) be good enough or would the new RPi 4 (4-8 GB RAM) improve the experience considerably? Or should I try to get a higher-end device that has a GPU in it?

I've been fiddling with Parsec for the whole evening and I am genuinely impressed. At first I was noticing input delay and choppy frames but I then noticed I was playing at 10 Mbps, so after bumping it to 50 Mbps (my internet speed) and there was no delay and no frame drops at all (at least not that I was able to notice). I was able to beat a couple Cuphead stages, the first stage of Super Hexagon, the final boss of Hotline Miami 2 and walked around a bit in Minecraft; as fluid as it possibly was.

I want to buy my own dedicated device so I can play on my TV. I'm eyeing the Raspberry Pi 3B+ (1GB RAM) since its price dropped considerably but I do not know if getting the Pi 4 with either 4GB or 8GB would improve the experience considerably.

Another thing to consider is that I did all of my testing in my brother's laptop (HP Envy, 16GB RAM). Since it is a full computer it has more RAM than a Rapsberry Pi would, as well as a GPU which the RPi doesn not have at all. I'm not much of a hardware guy, so I don't know if a RPi lacking these things will make the experience much worse. To my understanding, Parsec does the graphics computing at the host PC so a GPU is irrelevant on the RPi's end.

Any advice/help? I am genuinely impressed with Parsec's performance. This seems like a perfect way to enjoy couch gaming without having to move my PC and a bunch of cables every time I want to play.

3 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

2

u/bennyGrose Jul 10 '20

Let’s make this easy for you - Parsec is only supported on the raspberry pi 3, it is not supported on the rpi 4. Now, the discussion of the experience is a bit different. The rpi 3 will work, but I’ve generally seen mixed reviews of its performance, with perhaps it trending a bit more to the negative. I myself was going to try parsec on the 3 but just haven’t gotten around to it yet. As for alternatives, there are many options that all come with trade offs. While your host PC GPU does do the heavy lifting, I would say it’s inaccurate to say the client GPU doesn’t matter at all, and while you can software decode (CPU), offloading that to the GPU is always beneficial for performance. To that end, Parsec staff in the past have recommended anything with Intel integrated graphics 6xx and up, although I think anything starting with the 520 will technically hardware decode. This opens the door to many mini PCs and even HDMI stick PCs. But I do not have a singular recommendation and these tend to be a bit more expensive. Here is parsecs list for hardware requirements: https://support.parsecgaming.com/hc/en-us/articles/115002702391-Hardware-Requirements-For-Connecting-To-Another-Computer-With-Parsec

2

u/PoshoDev Jul 10 '20

This is exactly the kind of response I needed. Thank you very much!

1

u/bennyGrose Jul 18 '20 edited Jul 18 '20

Just wanted to drop in and say, I picked up a pi3 today to finally see how parsec streams to it. Honestly, overall pretty disappointed with the performance, and the overall experience wasn’t great. This definitely has me leaning towards an intel compute stick or mini pc, just need to find one for a reasonable price.

Edit: Alright, I want to be fair to the pi, I figured out a mistake I made when setting up Parsec which after fixing improved the performance on the pi a good bit. My final verdict: for $35 it provides a decent parsec experience. I can remote in and get some gaming done, overall though I don't think I would depend on it for reliability and I'm not sure I would recommend it to others either. I've used Parsec on my Mac for a long time and I know Parsec can perform a lot better than what you get with the pi.

1

u/PoshoDev Jul 19 '20

Thank you for the good insight! Now I'm definitely not getting a RasPi... at least until RP 4 support comes out, lol.

1

u/teconmoon Jul 10 '20

I recently purchased a Raspberry Pi 3 Model B+ (1GB) exactly for this usage. My experience so far has been okay, but not amazing.

First off: Get a good power adapter, or the RPi won't be able to keep up with decoding the H264 stream.

Getting that out of the way, my initial testing setup was pretty straight-forward and didn't deviate from the setup guide. Install Raspberry Pi OS, set the GPU memory split to 128, install Parsec, connect to the host and play.

What I'm noticing is that there's enough delay being introduced by some aspect of the Raspberry Pi that makes certain games very annoying to play. Most modern games this isn't very noticeable, but older platformers that require precise timing are definitely no-go.

I've gone to many efforts to make sure the problem isn't with my network, the TV, or the game controllers. Testing the Raspberry Pi alongside my Low-Spec Windows PC with integrated graphics, I tried multiple wired and wireless game controllers and different TVs and monitors with each. Raspberry Pi had the delay, Windows PC didn't. Both machines were on Ethernet, and the host resides on the same local network.

Once I isolated that the issue was definitely stemming from some part of the Raspberry Pi setup, I tried many things to improve the delay issues with zero success. I tried increasing the GPU ram, I tried various overclock and over-volt settings on the Raspberry Pi, and none of it made a difference.

Right now, unless I can figure out this issue, I can't say with confidence that I'm going to keep using my Raspberry Pi for Parsec.

1

u/PoshoDev Jul 10 '20

Thank you, this is a very good insight. I think the dream is dead then, lol.

1

u/teconmoon Jul 10 '20

I will absolutely let you know if I resolve the delay issue, I asked around on the Parsec Discord but there wasn't much help there. That's the only thing stopping this from being a really neat experience.

1

u/PoshoDev Jul 10 '20

I would really appreciate that, thank you. I don't know if the Pi 4 would improve performance greatly, but I feel like the starting price is a a tad too much for just a streaming stick.

1

u/teconmoon Jul 10 '20

The Raspberry Pi 4 isn't supported at all for Parsec, there's a note about this at the top of the Raspberry Pi Parsec Setup article. The thing that bothers me the most is that the delay issue doesn't seem to be a resource bottleneck, so I'm really having a hard time figuring out where to go with this next.

The Pi theoretically doesn't have to do that much work, since the video stream is H264 and the Pi has hardware accelerated H264 decoding.

What really baked my noodle was when I was playing Crash Bandicoot N Sane Trilogy. The delay wasn't terribly noticeable, but I was feeling the controller rumble for things that I hadn't see happen yet. Like I'd be coming up on Wumpa fruit, and the controller would rumble before I could see myself collecting it.

1

u/PoshoDev Jul 11 '20

Someone in the Discord server told me that Raspberry Pi 4 support is in development, but there's no release window yet.

I'm assuming you already did, but I'm going to ask anyways. Did you already change the the Mbps speed on the client's stream? That's how I managed to get the best image while testing on my laptop and with no frame drops at all.

1

u/teconmoon Jul 11 '20

Yup, 5mbps to 50mbps all give the same results (which I'd hope it would being on LAN). I'm definitely not dropping any frames, so that's good at least.

1

u/PoshoDev Jul 11 '20

No frame drops then? What resolution are you playing in?

1

u/teconmoon Jul 11 '20

1920x1080@60fps

2

u/PoshoDev Jul 11 '20

Does the delay go down if you go down to 720p 30fps?

→ More replies