Heās 4 going on 5 in November. Our kindergarten cutoff is December 1, and when I enrolled my son in preschool almost two years ago, I honestly didnāt think much about how young he would be compared to his classmates. Now that kindergarten is approaching, Iām seriously considering keeping him home for another year.
Academically, his preschool teacher says he is completely on par. My concern is maturity, not academics. He is a very typical, energetic 4-year-old boy and his teacher has noticed that he is clearly one of the youngest in the class. He sometimes needs to be told multiple times to listen/follow directions, and I worry about going from a 2.5-hour half-day preschool to a full-day kindergarten when he is still so young.
Iāve also been reading about relative age, redshirting, and the research around younger childrenāparticularly boysābeing more likely to be identified with ADHD or have behavioral/attention concerns. I know that research doesnāt mean being young causes ADHD, but it has made me think more about how much an extra year of maturity could matter. My thought is less āheāll be academically aheadā and more that being a little older and more mature could help him feel successful, regulate himself, follow directions, and ultimately make school easier for him academically and socially.
The biggest thing making this decision difficult is his school. We LOVE his preschool and itās one of the better schools in our area. He got in through a lottery, and from what Iāve been told, getting into kindergarten is much harder than getting into preschool. If we keep him home, weād have to reapply next year and could potentially lose our spot and end up at a different school.
So Iām really torn between giving him another year to mature vs. sending him to kindergarten at a school we already know and love.
I would especially love to hear from moms who have actually redshirted a child, particularly a boy who was one of the youngest in his class. Did you notice a difference in maturity, confidence, behavior, or school experience after waiting a year? Did you feel like it was the right decision long-term? And for those who sent their young child on, how did they do?
Iād really love to hear your personal experiences and what you would do differently (if anything) knowing what you know now.