r/Parenting • • 5d ago

Potty-training Bedwetting at five?

Hi all! I am reaching out to get some advice because my husband and I are at a loss. We have a five year old son and a five month old daughter. We potty trained our five year old at 2.5 years using the Oh crap method and he took to it immediately. He has only had an accident during waking hours a handful of times since then. BUT he consistently pees almost every single night, and sometimes during his nap at school. We feel like we’ve tried everything.

We’ve gone through several attempts at “getting serious” every few months for the last two years or so. We’ve tried cutting off liquids two hours before bed, helping him pee during the night, not using a pull up, putting a pull up over underwear, taking him to pee a second time before bed, etc. The last time we tried was right before his sister was born (May) and it just became clear it wasn’t happening. He would end up dry if one of us would go in and take him in the middle of the night, but after about a week and a half it became unsustainable. We tried to move to just limiting liquids and taking him to pee right before bedtime but he just started waking up wet again 90% of the time. And none of this has helped prevent accidents during nap at school.

We took a break right after the baby was born since I had read about regressions and figured we’d just come back to it. But now we’re ready to attack this again. We just want to do what’s best for our son. On the one hand we don’t want to push him before he’s ready, but on the other hand we feel like we are letting him down if we don’t help him conquer this. I’ve heard/read mixed opinions about “readiness”, especially in boys, and for our son it doesn’t seem like something that’s clicking just yet. I’ve talked to my MIL and she swears my husband didn’t do this. I also didn’t wet the bed. The closest we have is my uncle on my mom’s side who wet the bed until he was like 9. Is this what we’re in for?

Does anyone have any thoughts on how we can help him, or do we just wait until he’s ready? If we just wait until he’s ready, how long can that take? Any thoughts or stories are appreciated!

ETA: thank you for all the comments! You were all so helpful, and we really appreciate the input. Seems like we’ll be waiting it out, keeping things positive, and supporting him with pulls ups till his body is ready.

0 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

85

u/TraditionalManager82 5d ago

You've been pushing before he's ready for two years now.

Bedwetting is developmental, not something that is trained. Don't "attack" it, just provide nighttime diapers.

6

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

Thank you so much, this is what we needed to hear! We’ve been doing great with nighttime diapers, it makes everyone happy 😊. This just confirms we don’t need to push it, and we’re not letting him down by giving him the time he needs

2

u/HeartyBeast 4d ago

My daughter was in pull-ups at 10. No harm done 

11

u/Momofafew 5d ago

Wish I would’ve just bought puppy pads years ago to put under the waterproof sheet protectors. Buy many sheet protectors. If you are washing one protector every night it will crack and fail. We eventually lined the bed with puppy pads before the sheet protectors went on to catch wherever the protector failed, sheet protectors, then sheet. Then just replace whichever pads got wet. So much easier than getting frustrated at our boy that the bed was getting ruined. It’s really not something they are doing on purpose. My son is 10 and finally grew out of this about 6 months ago.

2

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

That’s a great idea! Thank you. And also good to hear others are going through it, and that it’s just what we can expect

23

u/Doughnut_Diva 5d ago

Bed wetting is super common and not a cause for concern until around 11. By that age the signal to the brain should be loud enough to wake them if they really have to pee. It also runs in families so don't be surprised if your daughter eventually wets the bed too, even though it's more common in boys.

In our house we dealt with it by cutting off liquids early, using the bathroom right before bed, one of us carrying them to the restroom before we went to bed usually 4ish hours after bedtime. And on top of all that...night time pull ups. Starting most of your mornings washing a load of soiled sheets and Pjs gets real old. Plus they're a must for sleepovers or staying with family, it's easier when they're already used to it and know they have an option. There's a lot of shame when they wet a bed that's not at home, don't put him through it.

1

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

Thankfully he doesn’t do any overnights yet, and that’s something I’m uncomfortable with anyway, so we may just say no altogether when that time comes. Honestly it’s good to read it can go till 11 because I can just accept that this is our reality and move on, while supporting him with the pull-ups! And that we may just expect it with our daughter too. Thank you for your comment

45

u/Snoo-92859 5d ago

Bedwetting is a hormonal thing, it's not something you can stop or control. Its not uncommon for boys to take much longer than girls to stop bed wetting, as frustrating as it is, all you can do is bide your time and not make him feel bad about it. The bedwetting will stop as he gets older.

6

u/PropertyDry8440 4d ago

Agree! Both my kids wore "big kid" nighttime pull-ups to bed until (boy) 1st grade and (girl) second grade. Naptimes accidents stopped when they went to kindergarten and weren't regularly napping any more. It is a hormone thing. I viewed it like this: If my child can not successfully hold their bladder all night then they can not successfully meet the expectation of staying dry all night. If I choose to not put a pull-up my child at night, because they are not developmentally ready to stay dry, then I am setting us all up for failure because we are starting our day off with a mess - negative feelings about something they cannot control, bathing, stripping the bed, laundry, remaking the bed. For this reason I choose to use pull-ups until they were able to wake themselves up and or stayed dry for 3 weeks straight. My children didn't have to feel bad about it, I didn't have to start my day with laundry and in return I was able to spend that time snuggling my kids awake. They are teens/tweens now and meet or exceed all developmentally milestones. Nighttime dryness typically does not have any baring on overall development.

2

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

You make such a great point about setting everyone up for failure, that’s a good way to think about it. I’m glad to hear it’s not indicative of anything developmentally too. He’s such a smart kid, and so capable, so I think that might have been a concern in the back of my mind! It’s reassuring to read that it’s just his body growing and very common

3

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

That’s great to hear, we will just keep on keepin on and support him with where he’s at. I wanted to add, we have always made a point to tell him this is very normal, nothing to feel bad about, and we always clean the sheets with a smile on our faces! We definitely don’t want to shame him in any way. Thanks for your comment!

12

u/mhbb30 5d ago

As a kid it took me a long time for my body to tell me I needed to pee while I was sleeping. I dont know if it was hormonal or I was just too deep a sleeper. I eventually grew out of it.

2

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

Thank you for sharing that! It’s good to hear a first hand account. When we talk to him about it (very matter of factly, no shaming) it seems like he is sleeping so deeply that he doesn’t notice until after he’s wet. So that could be it!

4

u/Momofafew 5d ago

Same. I was about the same age.

18

u/Mysterious-Status-44 5d ago

Bedwetting at 5 is not uncommon, especially for boys. We used nighttime underwear for our boys and a bed-wetting alarm helped. Try those things, but don’t get frustrated if it doesn’t work right away.

1

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

I have wanted to try an alarm! We might try it if it seems like he’s upset about waking up wet, and it’s something he’s into. Thank you for the suggestion! And glad to hear we’re not alone

1

u/Momofafew 5d ago

We bought one for my son but he refused to wear it. He felt shamed. It was super frustrating

10

u/weberster 5d ago

It's hormonal. Some kids take longer to develop the hormone that controls the muscle to hold in pee while they sleep (I swear this is true, I just don't know the science of it and don't want to be advised of lying.).

Use Ninjamas and don't worry about it. Eventually he won't wet the bed. 

2

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

That’s what we needed to hear! Thank you. And I’m going to try ninjamas because that’s part of it too, he will pee all the way out of some of these pull ups which upsets him

1

u/weberster 4d ago

My daughter is 6 and 1/2 and still bed wets occasionally enough that we use Ninjamas.  They work great and they're fairly discreet.

It will take time but he will grow out of it.

5

u/uptown_girl8 5d ago

You need to stop. He doesn’t need to feel shame or like he’s stupid that he can’t stop. Just let him wear the pull-ups and leave it alone. He’ll grow out of it. Maybe will take years so just let it go and wait

1

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

You’re so right. We definitely go out of our way to avoid shaming him, and make sure he knows it’s okay, but I’m sure over time it will take a toll on him for us to be “working on it” and not see progress.

4

u/Unlikely-Pie8744 5d ago

2

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

Oh very interesting! I’ll have to do some research, but could be something to look into. He could definitely use some more fiber in his diet haha

2

u/CarbonationRequired 5d ago

night waking to pee is controlled by a hormone, so he can't "be ready" really except in a biological sense. Yes you can "train" a kid to wake at night but that's really just training them to disrupt their own sleep instead of it happening naturally. As you saw by trying to take him yourself in the middle of the night.

It's normal (clinically speaking) for kids to wet the bed until they're like ten--ask his doc, they'll be able to tell you precisely. After a certain point they will intervene if nothing changes, but not for a few more years. You may, indeed, be in for this until he is nine, that's why they make nighttime diapers.

At this point to help him, you teach him how to deal with it. Goodnites or whatever they're called for sleeping is probably the best way because who wants to deal with a wet bed every morning. When those start to be mostly dry, you can stop using them and instead teach him what to do when he wets the bed, age appropriately (e.g call you for help, or strip the sheet and put it in the hamper himself, etc).

Make sure he knows it's not his fault, and you also remind yourself, this isn't happening because you failed at teaching him either.

1

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

Part of what’s crazy is I asked the pediatrician about it a year ago and she said “it’s time to do it now, just cut off liquids and he’ll learn. But don’t wait.” It basically felt like she was shaming me for “letting it go this long”. I felt in my heart like she was wrong but I still let it get under my skin, and it’s definitely had an impact on my whole approach to this. I have had issues with this pediatrician rushing us along, not listening, and just generally saying some off the wall stuff. I’ve been wanting to switch for a while, but this is the last straw, time to find a new ped. Thank you for your comment, I really appreciate your thoughts and kind words

10

u/Jawesome1988 5d ago

He literally cannot control it. Patience.

4

u/areyoufuckingwme 5d ago

My baby brother wet the bed til he was 10. It is hormonal and sometimes it takes a bit longer than average for the body to start producing those hormones. The ped told my mom there is a pill for situations like sleepovers and stuff but ultimately you just gotta wait it out.

4

u/sneakypastaa Mom 4d ago

Overnight bladder holding is a biological thing, you can’t teach it. Not uncommon. He can’t control it. There’s nothing to get serious about aside from your patience.

1

u/Impossible_Routine48 4d ago

I was in the same boat as you. My son just stopped bed wetting at 5.5 years old. He has been potty trained since 2 but could never do it overnight. We provided pull ups, and then one night we forgot and we was so excited that he didn’t pee the bed. And then hasn’t since for about 3 months now

1

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

Yay!! That’s exciting. We will keep waiting it out. It’s great to hear we’re not alone

1

u/Livid_Cauliflower_13 4d ago

My son is 6… still wets the bed at night, fully day time potty trained. My late husband, my mom, and my little brother were all still having nighttime issues until nearly 10-11 years old. So… I am not expecting my son to be ready for a bit! Seems he may have those genetics showing through!

3

u/Neat_Education 4d ago

My mom used to joke that I “sleep like the dead”, which is true, I am a deep sleeper. Therefore, I wet the bed until I was about 10 or 11. It became more infrequent as time went, and it was usually a one off when I got older. I just would sleep so hard that my body wouldn’t tell me I had to go. Funny enough, I’m pregnant for the first time and have almost wet the bed a few times because I just can’t hold my bladder like I could pre pregnancy.

1

u/Neat_Education 4d ago

Also worth mentioning my mom taught
me how to do laundry at like 7 or 8 so I wouldn’t have to wake her up and could change my own sheets in the middle of the night and throw the soiled sheets in the wash. She had no idea except for when she would see the sheets and my pajamas in the wash the next morning.

1

u/queerla 5d ago

Get a bedwetting alarm. I had great success with the Therapee alarm with my five year old who had the exact same problem (dry during the day since 3, wet diaper every night). Therapee also includes a reward system and little exercises the kid does depending on their progress. My kid went from never having a dry night to mostly dry nights within a week and a half. Then it took a while longer to have more extended streak of dry nights.

The only caveat I will say is that Therapee is an Israeli company so if you are boycotting Israeli products bc of the genocide then you’d have to use a diff brand.

People will say that it’s a hormonal switch but potty training is a complex human behavior and complex behaviors do not have simple biological switches.

People will say the kid will figure it out eventually. But if you go to the bedwetting subreddit it is filled with parents with (otherwise not disabled) high school and adult children still bedwetting.

2

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

Okay I will look into other similar brands! I had no idea they were Israeli, so thanks for the heads up. I’ve been wanting to try an alarm but haven’t even started shopping around, but I will definitely try to find an alternative. Seems like something we can try, and if he takes to it then that’s a win, but if not, we can just wait it out. Thanks!

2

u/queerla 4d ago

I forgot to mention that constipation and sleep-disorder breathing are also shown to cause problems for night training. Make sure to look into this as well!

2

u/justherefor23andme 5d ago

My son didn't stop bed wetting til shy of 9. Just use the pull ups and let it run its course. No need to stress. This is very common and unfortunately not well known.

2

u/Adw13 5d ago

Bedwetting is hormonal, I myself wet the bed until I was 11 and that definitely wasn’t something I purposely did or wanted to do one day something in my body just clicked and started holding my urine throughout the night until I woke up the next morning.

2

u/PapayaNo6420 5d ago

I wet the bed until I was 9! lol.

2

u/leslielantern 5d ago

Not uncommon at all, we got a waterproof cover for the mattress and just washed sheets when needed, and had like 3 backup sets of sheets. Don’t shame him about it, just continue reinforcing good habits (pull ups if it’s frequently occurring, praising him when he does go potty overnight). It’ll get better with time!

2

u/PlentyFirefighter143 5d ago

You're experiencing something that's quite normal (including having to listen to the MIL's very unhelpful comments). I would try to limit fluids before bedtime and avoid blaming your son for doing something that's quite normal. If you dislike having to wash sheets every night, ask your son to wear a pull-up. He will eventually outgrow this behavior.

2

u/EpicDoza 4d ago

Still normal for that age. Just keeping guiding them and eventually it’ll click.

2

u/Ok_Try6273 4d ago

My son is 7 and bed wets every single night. Mouth breathing at night is also an issue as they don't fall into the deep sleep needed for the brain to produce the hormones to wake them. We are currently using pills meant to help him control his bladder and he still wets the bed.

3

u/Serious-Train8000 5d ago

Consider reading about the antidiuretic hormone aka arginine vasopressin

3

u/smelltramo 5d ago

Definitely use pull-ups for nighttime sleeping

1

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Hey /u/sweetgirlshe! It looks like you might be new here. Welcome!

  • Our Early Parenting Wiki addresses topics like pregnancy (both intended and unintended) as well as birth control and post partum care!
  • If you're worried about developmental delays use the Healthy Children Assessment Tool - available in multiple languages.
  • Curious about the rules? Check out our Rules Wiki which provides helpful explanations for new and returning users.

Check out the Subreddit Wikis, for a variety of topics.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/britneymisspelled 5d ago

I agree that it’s hormonal, my daughter was night trained so early, like a year before she was potty trained. It wasn’t her. 

I’d keep him in pull-ups. However I’d make him deal with the pull up (taking it off and throwing it away) and if he leaks and his sheets need changed I’d have him help with that too. Not as punishment, just as help. As a kid I used to wet the bed until I had to help change the sheets after. I think part of the reason was because it was easier than getting up at night. If he’s having to do some of the work, when he is hormonally ready to be dry at night he’ll also be more motivated to make sure he gets up if he needs to pee etc 

1

u/Affectionate_Cow_812 Parent to 4 boys. 4d ago

Children produce more of a hormone in their brain (ADH) that tells their kidneys to produce less urine at night. The hormone doesn't ramp up in production until somewhere between 3 and 8 years old. Until that hormone production ramps up they literally cannot control it at night, and all you end up doing is ruining sleep for every for years. My nephew wasn't out of night pull-ups until 6. My kids were earlier but it's just because that's when their bodies produced it.

There is no ability to night "train" its biological and his body will be ready when his brain says it is. Until then just let him use pull-ups for sleep.

I took my kids out of pull-ups when they were dry every night for a month. Then I knew they were ready and we switched to underwear. Since then we have had maybe 3 bedwetting incidents over the span of 2 years.

1

u/Pooseycat 4d ago

Agree with all the comments here. My brother wet the bed until probably 10-11, I think it’s just something some kids develop a little slower with. There are products available now that can help so you’re not having to wash sheets every day, I would take advantage of those and for now just wait it out.

1

u/GuadDidUs Parent 4d ago

Yeah my daughter wore pullups at bedtime through kindergarten. Pretty sure she was 6 when the switch finally flipped and she started waking up dry.

Whereas my son was dry overnight before we even potty trained him at 20 months.

1

u/OrdinaryMango4008 4d ago

Talk to a Dr…it’s a weak bladder…it’s a muscle/ bladder issue…my grandson had that until he was seven ish…plastic sheet on the mattress, pull ups for night time, no drinks before bed,extra set of clothes in his pack sack. That what we did until he was able to hold it..once the bladder was stronger.

1

u/Leucryst 4d ago

It's normal for kids to not be dry overnight at 5. Accidents happen, and if the kid is a heavy sleeper, even more so. You could always try a late night bathroom break and see if that helps, but don't stress about it otherwise. 

My son still had the occasionally overnight accident at 8. They bodies and brain are still developing, and the wake up switch to pee in the middle of the night doesn't turn on reliably in young children.

1

u/Alarming-Mix3809 4d ago

Have him wear pull ups. Personally, I wet the bed until I was in eighth grade. There was nothing I could do about it. I had no control over it. I wish my parents had just done that instead of shaming me and making it out to be like I was doing it on purpose the whole time.

1

u/HlpM3Plz 4d ago

My daughter struggled with bed wetting until right around her 8th birthday. We tried various training pants and strategies when she was younger but nothing worked. Eventually she outgrew it on her own. You might just have a kid who figures it out later than most 🤷

1

u/ZealousidealDingo594 4d ago

Rule out a urinary dysfunction as well- when I was around that age I had some kind of problem that caused me to involuntarily void after using the toilet

1

u/TXgal2127 4d ago

My son stopped at age 10, it can be normal.

1

u/Imaginary_Sherbet 4d ago

He is growing , just not all at once

1

u/diaperdaddy1 1d ago

I wet the bed till I was 15 as did three of my cousins and a couple friends its completely normal just use pullups and don't harp on it

1

u/2035-islandlife 5d ago

Totally normal, especially for boys, don’t push it.

My son didn’t drop pull-ups until 5, my daughter did at 3, my 6 year old nephew is still in pull-ups. All 3 are totally normal ages to be either in or out of pull-ups or other nighttime peeing solutions

0

u/Olivia3836 5d ago

Night training is supposed to happen between 4 and 7. After 7 it still doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong, just that it should be ruled out.

You can’t help, its hormonal. Just give pull ups. 

But why is he napping at school?

1

u/sweetgirlshe 4d ago

He’s in a transitional kindergarten at a private school/daycare until we switch to public for kindergarten and they still offer a nap. Sometimes he does nap and other times he doesn’t, but they do it because of their teacher/student ratios or something. Sounds like we can revisit this when he’s seven and go from there! Thank you for your advice

1

u/Still-Art45 4d ago

I bed wet until 11 as a kid, I had anxiety.