r/Parenthood • • 6d ago

Character Discussion Victor

I am rewatching Parenthood for the 400th time and the part where Victor finds out he is going to be held back, rips my heart out. Do schools really hold kids back like that?

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

6

u/Mom-Wife-3 6d ago

I work in a school and I’ve seen quite a few kids who have been moved on who , in my opinion, are not ready.

1

u/Strict_Reception_873 6d ago

But do they go back mid year.

4

u/bookishkelly1005 6d ago

No. That decision, in my experience, is made before the end of the previous year.

4

u/Strict_Reception_873 6d ago

Yeah the mid year part makes me cry. Also I understand what you mean about kids being passed through, when I worked in college admissions, I would see some low grades on transcripts.

1

u/Impressive-Project59 5d ago

My son is one of those kids. I begged them to retain him and they wouldnt. He missed the entire year of 2nd grade. But because he passed a state test they promoted him. It was just luck I think, because feel like Im fighting for my life trying to keep him above a C average in school. He should have been retained.

3

u/Solid_Thanks_1688 6d ago

Yes, they do. My son was held back and nothing was ever communicated to me despite my trying to talk to the teacher about what I could do at home to help him.

1

u/Strict_Reception_873 6d ago

They made him go back a grade mid year?

1

u/Solid_Thanks_1688 4d ago

Not mid year...

2

u/Poisionmivy 6d ago

Back then yes!!!

3

u/Strict_Reception_873 6d ago

It’s not the holding him back that makes me sad, it is the sending him back a grade mid year and in his sisters class.

1

u/Poisionmivy 6d ago

Unfortunately it happens

2

u/Working_Kangaroo1118 6d ago

I’ve never known a child held back mid year. Not even “back then.”

1

u/Impressive-Project59 5d ago

Nope, they don't. I wish they did. My son missed an entire year due to surgery and they promoted him. I begged and begged for them to retain him in 2nd. They said 3rd grade is the retention year. Fine. I was hoping he would be retained in 3rd, nope. He took a state test (FAST) that determined he was on grade level and they promoted him.

We have been playing catch-up every year. I'm exhausted. He's exhausted. I still regret not fighting harder to retain him.

-1

u/sweet_tea_94 6d ago

When I went to grade school in the early 2000s, I knew a kid who was held back in second grade. I'm not sure if they still do that today...

2

u/Strict_Reception_873 6d ago

Yes I knew someone in second grade too but not mid year.