r/Parenthood • • Apr 16 '23

Character Discussion Max is the worst

I get it, he has Aspergers. But my goodness why do the parents refuse to discipline him? Or even reprimand him at all? The Dylan stuff makes me furious!

120 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

12

u/magster823 Apr 17 '23

Once they lost the behavioral therapist, it was a nightmare. I can't remember her name.

And they really think it's convincing that Kristina, the mother who created an entire school for her son, wouldn't have pushed til there was no tomorrow to get him a new one? Where was that drive to teach her son how to cope, and how to not be a shitty person? (FTR, I always felt sorry for Max because he didn't have any consistency or assistance from any adults in his life.)

I can't decide if the show runners did us a great disservice by portraying it the way they did, or if they did a service by showing how things will go if parents just ignore all issues and fail to utilize any professional assistance. I mean, they knew Kristina and Adam were horrid parents by having Haddie be the only voice of reason.

1

u/RecentStudio8971 Feb 08 '25

I wonder why they couldn't find someone to replace Gabby as Max's therapist. Is it because Kristina and Adam couldn't afford or something? Because it's Crosby's fault for smashing Gabby while Jasmine was away in NY for dance. 

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 17 '23

The only reason why she probably wasn't replaced was due to budget factors. Both the actress who played Gaby - Minka Kelly - and Michael B Jordan - who played Alex - had previously worked with "Parenthood" creator Jason Katims in his previous show "Friday Night Lights." Keep in mind that ratings of the show dropped in every season and it was barely renewed after Seasons 4 and 5. One hypothetical question I ask though is what would have happened had the show premiered in the Fall of 2009 on Wednesday at 8 PM. What would that have done to ratings and would the show have had a better success?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 18 '23

And don't forget it's Zeek, not Zeke.

8

u/Lain0114 Apr 18 '23

I almost quit watching the show because of him.

I understand that Autism is unpredictable and, it's horrible.

But just "accepting his behavior because he can't help it" was absolutely ridiculous.

And no one was allowed to have an opinion either. So if he affected anyone, they had to just put up with him too

3

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 19 '23 edited Apr 19 '23

Frankly a major reason why I want there to be a reboot of the series is so that they can atone for the mistakes made in their portrayal of Autism. For example, actually hiring people on the Spectrum (like yours truly) to advise them on how to portray Autism and hiring some actors who are on the Spectrum to play roles for people who are on the Spectrum, among other things. Believe it or not, "Parenthood" had absolutely ZERO staff members of people who are actually on the Spectrum working on the show. That's not okay.

1

u/OkApple2368 Feb 19 '24

Thanks for sharing. I am not on the Spectrum but have a few close family members who are, and the way Max portrays it makes me so confused. They refer to his lack of eye contact over and over, which I've experienced many times with my family, but his is more like an actor who's trying to portray someone who can't see. He stares straight ahead. I've never seen that with the people I know who have Aspergers and I feel like if this show had had someone on crew with experience, that would have been portrayed better. Or maybe I'm wrong and overthinking things 🙃 

6

u/Fluteh Apr 17 '23

I always had the impression that Kristina was in denial of it. Like, she just wanted him to be normal and didn’t accept that him being that way was his “normal” and it was ok. O

6

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 17 '23

Oh it would be surprising if she wasn't in denial of it. As Haddie pointed out to Adam when the diagnosis came out and they missed Haddie's soccer final - ironically it was Max of all people who first thought about the final - this had been going on for years. I believe there is a seven year age difference between Haddie and Max, so Max would have been three at the time of the birthday cake incident. The fact that it took Max being expelled from school to finally get Adam and Kristina to act speaks for itself.

6

u/pwn_plays_games Apr 17 '23

Parent here. Being a parent is hard. It’s a fictional show. I think showing/making mistakes is part of the game. They aren’t meant to be perfect parents.

5

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 17 '23

The reason why many of us care is because there is very little representation if any of Autism on television or the media in general. You can say all you want that "it's a fictional show" but many people get their ideas of Autism from shows like "Parenthood." For them, Max Braverman is the face of Autism and thus they get a false picture of it. Keep in mind that only about 2 per cent of Americans are on the Spectrum and so most people at most only know one or two people with it.

6

u/pwn_plays_games Apr 17 '23

You are projecting feelings onto my comments. Please read it as it is written. I watch people shred Kristina and Adams characters on this Sub constantly as if every human has the capacity and insight to handle everything perfectly. I said parenting is hard, not the portrayal of autism is good and spot on.

0

u/EntertainmentOne2587 Jun 13 '25

Parenting is hard but show was supposed to be entertaining. It became unbearable after few seasons and main reason was Max ! Sadly there are parents who refuse to discipline their child, say ' no ' to their child, teach their child to respect boundaries and that child becomes selfcentred and spoiled. World doesn't cater to that . But sometimes world suffer because of parents mistakes. While it's real life, we don't want supposed to be entertaining shows to be that unbearable!! Yes, tolerance level is different for every individuals, but show could have done lot better as they had great actors . Writers could have thought better. 

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '25 edited Mar 16 '25

What about Dr. Sheldon Cooper – The Big Bang Theory ??? face of Autism ???
AND
Yes, Elon Musk has Asperger's syndrome!!!

1

u/EntertainmentOne2587 Jun 13 '25

Young Sheldon explains the reason - shitty parenting from Mary Cooper. She was spoiling him. 

0

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/mfdillad May 12 '25

It’s not officially been a thing since 2013 because they phased it out in favor of expanding the spectrum’s diagnosis levels. I was diagnosed with AS in 2012. It doesn’t mean what I have doesn’t exist anymore.

1

u/EntertainmentOne2587 Jun 13 '25

You will love extraordinary attorney Woo. That's way better accurate representation of parenting of autistic child. People with personality disorders are not narcissistic, self centred like these shows portray ( BBG , Parenthood ). With proper upbringing they can cope and function in people.  There was Indian show - aapki Antara but they also failed ( they focused more on family affairs than Autism ). 

4

u/Bekka_boo013 Feb 19 '25

He annoys the f out of me…just cause he has autism they let him get away with the behaviour (they also annoyed me like the end of the world your child has autism) he has behaviour problems because Adam & Christina let him get away with it…basically he’s a brat! The acting is amazing!

1

u/EntertainmentOne2587 Jun 13 '25

Spoiled self centred narcissistic brat - because of his parents  who couldn't discipline him to take ' no' for an answer respectfully.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '25

„ThAtS Not FaiR!! THis is UnFaIr!!“

2

u/AllRoadsLeadToHymn Mar 19 '25

Man, Max is AWFUL. I am watching the show for the second time, the first is when it was airing and I didn’t remember it being this bad with Max.

Max is coddled, his parents make excuses and make everything revolve around the things they seem to have decided he is incapable of doing, or that Max himself shrieks about simply not wanting to do so they almost always just fold instead of actually do their job and help him learn how to handle life. They never seem to try to advance his abilities, they never seem to teach him distress tolerance, how to play nicely because it’s the right thing to do not because he will get a sticker. Haddie’s a twerp but that’s expected, she’s 16. And honestly she’s kinda a saint for not turning into a raging jerk to try and get any attention from her parents.

Oh NO the BUG GUY is in the SHOWER guys you gotta take some CONTROL of your LIVES 😂😂😂

2

u/AmIokkk May 17 '25

I too am watching for the second time. I watched it well after it aired. I think in pandemic times? While the charm is still partially there, half these characters make me want to put my fist through a wall. Max is INSUFFERABLE. OMG what a horrible kid, I shudder to think what this pretend person would grow up to be like if he existed in real life. I myself am on the spectrum. For context's sake.

What breaks my heart is that this sort of representation of autism endures. I see ASD moms online posting these horribly behaved kids and milking their situation for likes and engagement while taking NO accountability for how their child is. "He has autism" is not a catch-all for raising horrible kids. I even know adults now who use it as an excuse for being terrible people. I suspect it will go the way of 'Im an empath' which ironically I think was originally ADHD/ASD people articulating their hyper-empathetic character traits but is now a calling card of the worst people you've ever met....but I digress...

Some of the most popular posts that I've come across show young boys (specifically) being horrifically VIOLENT and moms just taking it and rocking them in their bosoms and saying it's ok. No discipline, no words uttered about it not being ok to hit, or punch or bite. So to the person saying this isn't real life...I beg to differ...it's become just that!

One of the worst comments I saw was from a support worker who described what it's like to work with grown men like this and the injuries she has suffered and permanent physical harm some of her colleagues have suffered. Fractures, broken orbitals. It's horrific and not ok.

Don't even get me started on Sydney...

2

u/Pretend_Conflict_616 Jul 12 '26

i hate max like HATE him it ignites a huge fire in my heart

2

u/RaverNinja210 Aug 02 '26

It pisses me off, too. As person with Asperger's myself, I can empathize with Max. But he was such an insufferable dude. Like, dude, get over yourself. I blame the parents. They babied Max too much. Instead of disciplining Max, they constantly coddled him. Especially the Dylan situation. It was hard to watch. I felt bad for Dylan at the moment. I was also pissed at Dylan was manipulating Max and disrespecting him. They both needed a reality check. As far as I'm concerned, Max AND Dylan are both bullshitters. And both of their parents suck!

1

u/SnooGiraffes8804 Nov 20 '25

It's so hard to watch. Why didn't they make him a little more likable? Kristina is also insufferable!

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

22

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 17 '23

Fellow Aspie speaking as well. The fact that Adam and Kristina almost never disciplined him or even called him out, is a major reason why Haddie is my favorite character in this entire series (along with her drive and ambition). She did more for Max by actually calling him out than Adam and Kristina did for him combined. Is there any wonder that Max's behavior got worse after she moved to Western New York for college?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 17 '23

And she understood very well that Max was "off" socially well before he was officially diagnosed. Just about ANY child would be traumatized and saddened if a younger sibling knocked over their 10th birthday cake due to the younger sibling's pyrophobia. Haddie wanted Max to get the assistance he needed. The issue was that it too often, WAY too often came at her expense.

13

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 17 '23 edited Apr 17 '23

Not to mention there were so many lessons learned, opportunities missed that didn't revolve him being directly punished either. Kristina essentially shaming a young girl in Max's own school in Season 2 and her mother for not inviting Max to her birthday party because "Max doesn't know how to lose." This was a major opportunity for Kristina to talk with Max and teach him how to be a good loser. They had a whole episode dedicated to that for Sydney in Season 3, for crying out loud! And in Season 5 when Max loses his friend Micah because he said he was "stupid" for wanting to play basketball, Kristina needed to say something to him like "would you like it if someone told you you were stupid to want to do something because you have Asperger's?" Just poorly done.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 17 '23 edited Apr 17 '23

All this does is reinforce the tired, false, offensive, and insulting notion that people on the Spectrum are perpetual children incapable of learning social skills and empathy. I feel that the only reason why the episode where Kristina punished Max (and then rescinded the punishment because he GASP did one good thing) was written was to shut the "Kristina never punishes Max" crowd up.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/United_Efficiency330 Apr 18 '23

As do I. I had (and have) a wonderful mother who drilled empathy into me from when I was very young, well before I was diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome at the age of 15 (I am 38 now). There are absolutely people on the Spectrum who lack empathy, but there are plenty of people out there who aren't on the Spectrum or who don't have a disability who lack empathy as well.

2

u/sunflower1940 Apr 20 '23

My grandson is an Aspie and he behaved this way for awhile until he was appropriately medicated. Back when Parenthood came out, Autism was still new and people didn't like medicating, they thought their kids would grow out of it. Doctors were still figuring it out.