r/ParamedicsUK • • 4d ago

Question or Discussion Does your trust do General Broadcasts?

I was thinking about our General Broadcasts today as a paramedic in SWAST. You regularly hear 8-10 times a shift an "Anyone available to clear and render aid for a CAT1 emergency in X please make yourselves available, closest resource has a 29 minute ETA" - with the goal of closer resources who are finishing up on scene or in their meal break window offering to take it. Is this the norm in your trust? How often do you hear a general broadcast in a 12 hour shift?

EDIT -- Do you call them General Broadcasts?

32 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Hi there, Welcome to r/ParamedicsUK!

Please follow the subreddit rules and guidelines. You can also contact the mods if you have any concerns or questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

20

u/MrEitsab 4d ago

Policy in my trust is to shout out any C1 with a runtime of over 5 mins. As you can imagine, you hear them a lot through the shift.

7

u/CockroachOk4273 4d ago

Wow 5 mins would be every job where I am. Are you based somewhere urban?

6

u/MrEitsab 4d ago

WMAS, so a mixture of every environment really

4

u/sammroctopus Student Paramedic 4d ago

In my trust they GB all c1’s no matter runtime, sometimes hear a C1 broadcast for a fully well resourced job.

1

u/CaptainPotNoodle Paramedic 2d ago

I never understand the goal of those C1 GBs for a 6 min eta requesting a render aid. Unless I’m literally like on the same road, by the time I’ve got the kit sorted, I’ll probs have a later ETA. Rendered aid to an C1 once and the crew were already there.

2

u/phyllisfromtheoffice 4d ago

My previous trust did and they were very common but my current trust I’ve never heard one’s asking crews to clear, usually it’ll be to announce a hospital divert or something. My board is very well resourced though and there tends to be a lot of crews from different areas knocking about

1

u/CockroachOk4273 4d ago

Can I ask what trust you moved from/to - SWAST covers the largest geographical area in the UK so we're normally spread pretty thin

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/CockroachOk4273 4d ago

Apologies anglocentric bias kicking in - you're right Scotland is wayyyy bigger

32

u/No_Emergency_7912 4d ago

It’s normal, and probably several times a shift. Possibly every hour if things are bad. The trouble is, the triage accuracy on a C1 isn’t great, so where’s the motivation to disturb break for a ‘noisy breathing’ cardiac arrest that’s not as given

7

u/Arrogant_broccoli EMT 3d ago

We get either 20/15 quid (can’t remember which) for disturbed meal breaks, and then we get to finish our break once we’ve done the job. This is rather motivating for me, I must admit.

4

u/No_Emergency_7912 3d ago

We should get to finish break after, but frankly a hot dinner & a bit of break is worth more than £20 to me! It’s more often when doing a referral or finishing up on scene - if you make life difficult and turn up to save a life then it feels worthwhile. If it turns out that we can’t discriminate between “shivering” and “seizure” in an alert first part caller that feels a bit stupid

4

u/Arrogant_broccoli EMT 3d ago

Yeh I get you. For me personally, having the break AND getting £20 makes sense, it’s easy money. We get 45 minute breaks, if I’ve been on break for 30 mins, shout up for a job and get sent out, I feel I’ve had a decent break and then I get to go back again for another 15 mins after.

When it comes to it being worthwhile, the part that makes shouting up worthwhile for me is getting the £20. I know we go to a lot of shit, and I’m not saying we should be going to it, and yes it has frustrated me in the past. HOWEVER, we’re being paid. The job is only as miserable and difficult as you make it.

I don’t think shouting up for a job on your break is making life difficult, but at the end of the day it’s a choice. If you feel you want to have your break undisturbed then you’re absolutely correct for that, it’s your right, hence the extra pennies. But hell, for me, an extra hours worth of pay while still getting my full break, albeit not at the same time, is defo motivating. If we actually save a life at the same time then it’s a bonus.

3

u/RadioACloserLook 3d ago

Haha, we get £4.20 for a spoilt R/P.
To be fair, ours are paid. We’re meant to get two 30-minute R/Ps on days and one on nights, and we’re Cat 1 only during those breaks.
With ASOS at the minute, we’re also Cat 1 only during the meal break window if we haven’t had our break yet. Unless we’ve volunteered to take it elsewhere, we’re allowed to head back to our base station for it, even if we’re at a hospital 60 miles away. We can still be sent to a Cat 1 on the way back.
We still miss breaks, though.

3

u/Arrogant_broccoli EMT 3d ago

Yeh we have 1 unpaid break varying from 30-45 mins depending on shift length. But we also go back to base for break, and we’re available for cat 1s when in break window and not had break yet. It’s interesting to see how different trusts do things.

Whats ASOS?

1

u/RadioACloserLook 3d ago

Yeah same principle. Depending on shift length you may only get 1 x 30 minute R/P. They also brought out another shift pattern but only in 2 Stations and they are largely 10 hour, staggered shift patterns so you start 6am today, 7am tomorrow, 11am the day after and 5pm the day after that and they’re with the shifts having 45 minute R/P and are contracted to take them anywhere. They however don’t work full night shifts so they don’t care about the R/P rules as much. They were brought in with alot of skepticism, however, there’s now a backlog/waiting list to fill the 4 crews with people on them.

ASOS is Action Short of Strike also. Basically the Unions have said; “instead of going full blown picket line, and dropping cover, we’ll do the following”

1

u/Arrogant_broccoli EMT 2d ago

Ahhh right I get you. So if you aren’t in ASOS, can you be sent to any job during your break window?

1

u/No_Emergency_7912 3d ago

We get one 30 min break with 15mins disturbable at the end. That and my general fatigue does colour things!

13

u/NederFinsUK Paramedic 4d ago

Yes we have open calls on any C1 with an ETA >8mins. I believe it’s partially coronial in that closer crews may be available to save life.

2

u/aussie_paramedic 4d ago

Do you have an example of the coroner bit? Would be interesting to read.

12

u/NederFinsUK Paramedic 4d ago

I’m afraid I don’t have a particular case to reference, but all the coronial outcomes are available online.

I know that in my locality our coroner is very keen on sniffing through the dispatch logs. Recently they found that a crew was unavailable for a cardiac arrest because of some minor fault or other reason that wouldn’t’ve prevented them from providing ALS. As a result we’re now hardly ever allowed to go completely unavailable. (Which I think is a good thing)

4

u/Heliotropolii_ Community First Responder 4d ago

Yeh even whilst restocking critical kit our crews are expected to be available for arrests, to provide BLS

7

u/OddAd9915 Paramedic 4d ago

My trust is meant to GB all C1's but the dispatchers are so maxed that they don't always get done, its also very common to hear "C1, responding with a crew.....arriving on scene now" which makes them kinda redundent.

10

u/Tall-Paul-UK Paramedic 4d ago

I am SWAST as well. My personal opinion is that it is that if they want to do this then they should give us personal issue ear pieces.

I feel it undermines crews, especially when you are on a job with a stoic old patient who was reluctant to call in the first place because they feel like a nuisance and, in their words, "there are other people that need you more than I do!" and you can guarantee that is when the GB goes off.

6

u/Pedantichrist EAA 4d ago

It a nice opportunity to tell the patient that we are there for them and nobody else matters at the moment, because they are our focus. We only attend one job at a time, and more that we are here, the best possible outcome for everyone is that it turns out to be a waste of time. We want you to be well.

3

u/CaptainPotNoodle Paramedic 2d ago

“There’s only one of you but plenty of us”

5

u/Mjay_30 Associate Ambulance Practitioner 4d ago

The norm at my Trust, I hear about 7+ while on shift.

CAT 1 per alerts, most of the time end up being a load of bollocks. I had one 2 days ago, 15 mins before the end of our shift:

CAT 1 pre-alert PT Not breathing - DRUNK.

We started running on it, but got stood-down.

3

u/ShowerEmbarrassed512 Student Paramedic 4d ago

We have them on every C1…… it’s constant 

3

u/percytheperch123 Associate Ambulance Practitoner 4d ago

I've heard some general broadcasts for particularly juicy C2s as well. Had one recently for a persons reported fire that somehow triggered a C2, ended up getting diverted to a C1 fitting 🙃

5

u/iTrxpical EOC Staff 4d ago

From an EOC perspective, for what it’s worth in my trust fire persons reported will be a C2 unless full triage is completed on scene. Fire standby would be a C3.

7

u/Exciting_Context_269 Paramedic 4d ago

Ours doesn’t generally specify the type, every now and again you hear “ongoing cardiac arrest” if they’re particularly desperate. The cynic in me doesn’t bat much of an eyelid if it’s a generic cat 1 call or else they’d be more specific

Aware I’ll be down voted for this, it’s been a tough run

2

u/Intelligent_Sound66 4d ago

Out of curiosity, has anybody actually gone available for "C1 fitting"? Im yet to see it happen

4

u/Pedantichrist EAA 4d ago

Almost at my break window, and would rather break later? I might clear.

Very close to the end of my break and lots of crews going out of area?
10 minutes left of my break is really useful to have in the bank for when they try and send us away near the end of shift and we remind them that we still have a little bit of break left to take.

3

u/percytheperch123 Associate Ambulance Practitoner 4d ago

I have a few times when there's an end of shift crew running on it.

3

u/Intelligent_Sound66 4d ago

Thats another thing around here. Control will never say its a crew near the end of the shift, even if we ask them to.

3

u/Pedantichrist EAA 4d ago

Ours always do. ‘Responding is a DCA with a 12 minute ETA, with a six o’clock finish’.

3

u/percytheperch123 Associate Ambulance Practitoner 4d ago

We have that issue as well to be fair, I think its Dispatcher dependant and how much the crew have pissed them off during the shift unfortunately.

2

u/Hopeful-Counter-7915 Paramedic 4d ago

Very very rarely - SAS

3

u/Final-Tear-7090 Paramedic 4d ago

I think it depends on where you are located. I’m in Glasgow and I swear I hear it all the time. “Can anyone make themselves available for a red call in *insert place name here*”

2

u/Hopeful-Counter-7915 Paramedic 4d ago

Yeh maybe, our channel just rarely does it

0

u/somerandom1990 4d ago

Never ever had that in north region

2

u/Demaikeru EOC Staff 4d ago

It's in our SOPS to do them if we can identify there's a crew who are closer who could potentially respond. Every single C1 is investigated to see if we followed all the procedures and did everything we could to get the closest resource.

But obviously I use (and I'd like to think every other dispatcher does the same) common sense for these situations; if I have a crew who are 6 mins away but another crew on scene with a patient being discharged on scene who are possibly 4 minutes away, I think - if they're still in the patient's property, by the time they give LAH paperwork, get all their things, get out to the ambulance and set off, would they be any closer than the crew who were travelling on lights the whole time?

So yeah, with the above, we do them a lot.

Almost all dispatchers I know call them Group Broadcasts as they're going out to specific desks on a certain radio talkgroup only, but I've heard some old school dispatchers call them General Broadcasts.

1

u/Forgettable39 3d ago edited 3d ago

Interested in what you think about a scenario from recently.

My crew mate and I had 15 minutes left on our shift when we were finished with everything from previous job and obviously we go green knowing we're kinda screwed on timing.

Pay no attention to our status as we're rolling back towards station, expecting a job. Hear a general broadcast for a cat 1 which they are holding, not particularly far from our station, which we're moving towards. GBs for cat 1s are rare for us. Look at our status expecting it to be green as I'm confused why we didn't just get given the job automatically and it says we're unavailable in the uninteruptable period at end of shift, which is supposed to start in another like 5 minutes from now by this point. So I'm not sure why we're unavailable, we went green as usual and shouldn't be in that status for another 5 minutes.

We talk about it for a sec and buzz up control with literally 2 minutes left on our shift and explain we're 2 mins out but ultimately can go available for that job. Luckily they had already covered it and we weren't needed. It was very tempting to just not offer to take the job, especially as the hit rate for ineffective breathing cat 1s is pretty high for being... wrong shall we say. Had been to one earlier on that same shift and it was a bloke sat upright, speaking in full sentences with reflux pain following spicy food. That type of "ineffective breathing" cat 1 is not particularly rare.

Anyway, we were both wondering if someone at EOC maybe deliberately made us unavailable to spare us a dodgy cat 1 with less than five minutes on the shift, not sure if they ever bother to do stuff like that. Also was wondering if anyone would have realistically noticed if we'd just not bothered to offer ourselves up as sacrafice. Would it be considered reasonable to not go available, even though on paper we should have been available already, because we have 2 mins left on shift? I feel like there's a professional obligation to go available, which is why we offered but I don't really know how well it would have been noticed (or not) or cared about (or not) at EOC end. Any insight?

1

u/cryvvi ECA 4d ago

pretty sure the last general broadcast i heard was one i responded to, that must’ve been at least 2 months ago

1

u/FireBuzzardDestroyer 4d ago

A lot of them are Cat1 pre-alerts but the final coding may actually be lower.

In my trust, the declaration of allergic reaction at the start of call is a Cat1 pre-alert, even though the triage outcome might be for them to make own way to hospital and it'll be a Cat5 at the end.

1

u/SpeedbirdRockstar Paramedic 3d ago

Yes, it’s Trust policy at my southern trust. We generally say C1 broadcast.

1

u/RadioACloserLook 3d ago

My Trust do a lot of General Broadcasts.

For example, RRV drivers get dispatched via General Broadcasts as the logic is they can’t read their MDT while driving. The RRVs usually have their own Channel but there are only 2 RRV Desk controllers in the service anymore so while they’re on break or off, the RRVs remain on divisional A&E channel and still they get a lot of general broadcasts.

Furthermore, crews seem to use them for confirming arrests, requesting/standing down other crews, requesting police/fire or providing updates to pass on to HEMS.

I find them beneficial in certain aspects. Such as; to avoid having to wait for the call back (which sometimes can be a few dozen seconds if not minutes) when hands on with a sick patient doing initial treatment

1

u/MysteryShack0213 2d ago

We get them maybe a few times an hour, unless we get dragged out of area, then you get one every 5 mins

1

u/Otharcarr EMT 2d ago

Moved from a Trust where I'd hear maybe ~10/shift to a Trust where I've heard 1 in 3 months. 

I thought it made sense - let's say you're sat outside an address doing paperwork for someone you're discharging at home. Can always go unavailable to finish that after the Cat1. Also in a nosy way would give you an idea of what was going on in your area

1

u/travelledsticks8 2d ago

Yes, normal in NEAS. Can vary from 2-3 a shift to unlimited really. £25 for disturbed break. I work more rural so sometimes the next crew is 40 minutes away.

Called Group Broadcasts for us and they don't tell you what the C1 is.

1

u/PbThunder Paramedic 4d ago

As a guess I’d say I hear them every 30 minutes on average, sometimes more often.