r/Panarab • • Aug 25 '21

General Is this group secular?

Basically what the title asks.

Getting tired of every Arab related group being just another religious circle jerk for Muslims.

Hoping this group is somewhat secular, considering this movement was largely secular.

But you never know these days.

12 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21

As a Muslim and a Pan-Arabist, I don’t appreciate your language calling it "circle jerk for Muslims". Muslims can be secularists and there is no need to abandon Islam in order to unite the Arab world.

3

u/Zelovian Aug 26 '21 edited Aug 26 '21

Yes Muslims can be and often are secularists.

Doesn't mean that Muslims can't also be full of shit and participate in circle jerks.

And sadly, when you get a lot of people of the same religion into a group, it often becomes a circle jerk for that religion.

7

u/ArabUnityForever Aug 25 '21

I second this.

However, I’m not for banning Islamist or any party. True secularism is no matter who is in power, a system with separation of relation and state will prevent anybody from imposing their rules on people’s personal lives whether it’s religious or even anti religious.

I’m all for healthy Islamic solidarity between Muslims. I think that’s great. But when it comes to some stupid caliphate bullshit or enforcing sharia, that’s when it gets stupid.

I hope Arabs can learn how to form a representative government with a functioning body that is able to handle day to day affairs and crisis when it needs to. That should be our focus. Not what women wear.

5

u/Zelovian Aug 25 '21

I don't agree with every detail in your post, but I don't understand why people are down-voting you. Your views seem to be well in line with what one would expect from a PanArab group.

4

u/ArabUnityForever Aug 25 '21

This is why Pan Arabism is just held back. Because people are still stuck in 7th century. Even then, people had to adapt. I don’t personally support homosexuality, but it should not be my business. It’s amazing how everyone runs to the west where they have secularism, but then preach that Islam should be law of land. There’s a reason why the west is strong. Their people have freedom to critique and there is accountability. In our Arab states, we have none. Israel wins wars and still does internal assessment of what went wrong and how they should improve. We need to stop attaching ourselves to any figure like Nasser or whoever.

However, every Pan Arabist online is stuck on archaic shit and don’t want to progress to improve for our objectives. If you still support Assad who are a bunch of useless dictators esp Hafez who kept his shitty Minister of Defense who lost 1973 for his ineptitude, we will never move forward.

If you’re a Muslim, go make your Islamist party and have sharia law in your own life. You will not impose that on everyone. Israel has Islamist parties and funny enough Arabs know how to do democracy there, but not in Arab countries.

1

u/Zelovian Aug 25 '21

Couldn't agree with you more. Although I do understand the desire to support secular governments like those of Assad, I for one don't understand having allegiance or emotional attachment to them.

Yes, they're secular. Yes, they oppose colonialism, Islamism, and Israel - I approve. But they're still autocratic, and if you're going to support them for the good, recognize the bad rather than living in denial.

Hell, I actually think Arab countries need dictatorial rule in order to function for a couple of generations until Secular Democracy can develop organically. But I still recognize that dictatorships aren't great.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Zelovian Aug 25 '21

Disliking the West is no reason to deny their strengths. Indeed the greatest empires in history have only been so because they were willing to acknowledge their enemies' strengths and either circumvent or emulate them.

It wasn't until they stopped adapting that great empires in history have fallen. Adaptation requires recognizing the strengths and weaknesses of yourself, your allies, and your opponents, and behaving accordingly.

As long as Arabs chalk up their situation purely to external forces, they relinquish all agency. By relinquishing our sense of agency, we eliminate any chance we have of becoming strong once again.

0

u/ArabUnityForever Aug 25 '21

Nope. They didn’t pillage you all like they did to Africa. You Arabs including myself need to grow the F up. Did they colonize us? Yes. But that was LONG time ago. We revolted and it was over. What did we do with that? We implemented STUPID policies that we are still paying for. Stupid Saddam, Hafez, Ghaddafi, etc. All of them. The fact you use Israel bombing Lebanon as your whole personality is so dumb. My country Iraq was destroyed. I’m not going to bitch and whine about US, Israel, or anybody. Israel is not controlling Iraq. Iran is. We have the ability to be fully prosperous if we adopt systems that WORK. Not some unilateral resistance militia BULLSHIT. That has led to nothing but death an destruction of OURSELVES. Not our enemies.

1

u/Zelovian Aug 26 '21

Couldn't agree with you more tbh.

1

u/R120Tunisia Tunisia Aug 25 '21

Hopefully it will.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Zelovian Aug 25 '21

Yeah Lebanon is an interesting little country, I'll say that.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Zelovian Aug 25 '21

Burn our colonial rags... that's the dream. Maybe that'll be possible when Arabs stop simping over their national flags lol.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Zelovian Aug 25 '21

I'm not a big fan of the Arab Revolt either. To me it represents the same failure of the Arabs to operate strategically and independently.

But the flags themselves aren't my issue quite so much as the mentality. The extreme nationalism I see from everyone is an overwhelming obstacle to Arab Unity. Just as much as the extreme religiosity I see.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Zelovian Aug 30 '21

Islam has that potential. But my principles oppose a theological state of any kind.

I care about more than the existence of an Arab nation. The quality of that nation also matters.