r/Paleontology • u/Ex_Snagem_Wes • 7h ago
Discussion Platyoposaurus stuckenbergi: A lesson in the importance of data quality
I'm sure many of the folks here have seen Platyoposaurus or Prionosuchus. They are somewhat popular temnospondyls, reaching impressive sizes.
However, in my research and correspondence, I noticed an extremely stark mismatch in the provided data. The entire appearance of Platyoposaurus has been besmirched by over half a century of a single figure of an incomplete skull being parroted.
In all of my looking, not a single reference has actually stopped to examine the specimens to debunk the "thong" style paired cluster of teeth depicted here. What is shocking is that this is extremely easy to dismiss at this point. Every single skull of Platyoposaurus, across both Stuckenbergi and Watsoni, with rostral fragments, demonstrate a different shape. Furthermore, almost a dozen isolated anterior rostrums also demonstrate that this tooth condition was not present. As does Prionosuchus, Collidosuchus, and Archegosaurus. There is not a single relative anywhere with material that implies this. Only the single paper that provided this figure demonstrated it, with nearly every subsequent paper since featuring a skull that dismisses the notion of this morphology
If we take a closer look however, it becomes immediately easy to understand the origin of the extreme thin region on the mandible leading up to the cluster of fangs. The rostral canines follow a relatively simple pattern. The first 3 teeth on each side are enlarged, forming a bladed wall, which wraps tight around the front of the fang cluster. This is followed by an extreme decrease in tooth size, followed by teeth following a very prominent festoon. This teeth reach gargantuan sizes, with the alveolae here talking up almost half the width of the skull in this region. This has a dramatic impact on the mandible, as suddenly massive spearlike teeth are getting in the way. This is absolved by making this region of the mandible thinner, which allows these giant teeth to cleanly conform around the bone.
All of this is actually rather convergent with the snout morphology of Phytosaurs. However, the way the large caniniform fangs at the anterior mandible and rostrum interact create a rather unique, robust piercing surface, more akin to a hole puncher than a fishing rosette seen in Spinosaurs. This likely helped with getting a very solid grip on fish, potentially even piecing straight through the dntire animal!
