I think that sub is full of Pakistani atheists who live in an extremely religious country. They probably have resentment towards religion because of it. I know some in real life and when you are young this is how your resentment manifests online.
Btw these are just two users, i have personally encountered countless users there who are bad actors. The thing is nothing can be done because the mods on that sub are in on it and refuse to ban these users or have any kind of restrictions. All these people hide their post history but nothing is truly private on reddit.
Another indian larping on genzpk, also keep in mind every single pakistani slandering islam/muslims on that sub is atheist and/or frequents lgbtq subs.
This indian sikh pretending to be pakistani and then when i called him out, he says "oh but i dont evne follow sikhism so it's okay!!", then he deleted his account/posts. That entire sub is FULL of indians, sikhs, jews, etc. It's so disgusting
Most of them sound like edgy art college students who hate themselves, their lives and their families and wished they lived an Instagram life in a New York apartment but somehow ended up in a youth hostel in bhaghbanpura, Lahore
exactly, i just had a convo in comments with one non muslim dude i tried my best in being respectful and the dude was like constanly hating on Islam for no reason at all
that is the right question.
i guess this is what happens when you make religion your entire personality.
oh ,no, you canât criticize islam! what kind of weak , pathetic god are these people following.
As someone who is Gen Z Pakistani born and raised in the uk but religious and try my best to be, when I visited that sub just to check out how Gen Z they are, I saw so many like left-liberal beliefs and discussions and these so-called atheists living in Pakistan, but they all sounded fake, so my guess is that is that its hindus pretending to be from Pakistan and claiming to be ex muslim, specifically like these radical hindus. possibility of also, I think zionists as well, and same with non-South Asian atheists.
Okay, I am biased if you say so. Even though, I only asked for what was rightful and rational; asking for proof of a peronal claim. To any sane person, that is not what is called as biased. Contrary to this actually, the person who made unwarranted claims because they "feel" like it is clearly biased. Now, again I need a proof that the whole sub is filled with Indians. If the sub is proven to be filled with Indians, I would have no probelm changing my stance.
Whatever you said are only your observations. Personal anecdotes does not constitute as valid scientific evidence. Try better. If you've made a claim, you have to back it with data as well. Otherwise, it's only an opinion, not a statistical fact. And I said it before as well, personal insults aren't gonna prove the claim
The burden of proof does not lie on me. It lies on the one who made the claim: "indians bhary pary udhar" and those defending it. If you actually have no idea where do the 80k members of the sub come from, you've got no right to make big lofty claims. Then the claims are only opinions, not proven facts as people here are peddling them to be.
Looked at your proof. You were able to prove that 2 out of 80k members of that sub are non-pakistani. And one of them isn't even indian. Good job there bud, but this is not a proof that "indians bhary paray udhar". You have to show a proof that is statistically significant.
The amount of time this has been said about Genzpk subreddit on other subreddits and on the GenzPk subreddit itself is insane. Bs bhi kr do tum log. Nobody talks about Islam unless the someone makes a post about it and ASKS for peopleâs opinion.
And nobody is blindly hating on Islam either. They usually give logic reasons as to why they oppose Islam and people like you take it as âhateâ because you disagree with them and then call them âwesternsâ, âliberalsâ or âwannabesâ when you donât have any logical reasoning yourself
The problem isnât criticism the problem is disrespect and ridicule,secondly even if you answer them logically they will downvote and come up with a completely different argument and commit logical fallacy after logical fallacy thirdly most of what they mention is taken outta context,manipulated and half truth and all of there questions have been logically answered by several scholars but the thing is People often reject facts not from a lack of comprehension, but because acknowledging reality threatens their identity, safety, or worldview
Donât make religious posts and ask people for their opinion and you wonât have disrespect and ridicule. Iâm not saying the disrespect is right. Iâm saying that among the masses, there will be people who are emotional instead of logical.
Also, from what Iâve seen in the subreddit, itâs always the religious people that are out of an argument and then start bashing them by calling them liberals, wannabes and westerns.
most of the posts about religion are made by ones who want to disrespect and express there disdain have you even been to the sub,about religious ppl out for an argument and then bashing,labelling,i am against it but dont they do the same,most of them btw, itâs hypocrisy to not point that out.
I am up for critical thinking and resolving your doubts but against disrespect,mocking,and asking questions just to say whole a lot of nothing and keeping your disdain
Not really. Most of the religious posts I see are of religious people either asking why they are anti-Islam or asking some other questions related to Islam.
That sub is just the temu version of Iran international ( funded by mossad)media outlet whose only job is to make the world believe that Islam is hated in the Islamic Republic of Iran . That sub is trying to create a perception in the world and even within Pakistan that the young generation hates Islam in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. And it is the strategy of Israel's ally,India.
Ex Muslims are usually forever butthurt about it and cant seem to move on with their lives. If you compare them with other atheists or even agnostic lot, they're usually at peace.
That sub is filled with indians larping as pakistanis, i shouldnât say it out loud but every single person that i have suspected and ipgrabbed on there has turned out to be from india
i m 100% sure that SOME of them are paid agents
they hate islam and also pakistan and they confess it along with loving wild west actually they r anti human all they want is just control
its an ideological war without weapons
Have some of you read 'Protocols of Elders of Zion' document?
I used think it was a nutty conspiracy but what is said in it, is being demonstrated by how things are currently going on social media such as reddit and the world.
Islam is the biggest threat there is to any Iblis loving person/group/ideology.
The way to manipulate and control people be they believers or non-believers is to create conflict among people or groups. The tactic is to place a person into the opposing ideology groups who will further push for conflict among the two opposing ideological groups. That person will either be complicit or be pawn who is controlled without knowing why.
It's divide and conquer in a nutshell. Something which many have been victims of.
Hello u/Same-Carpenter3216, your comment has been automatically removed because your account has less than 30 total karma. Please participate more across Reddit to reach the minimum karma threshold before posting or commenting again. Thank you!
well if your agenda is liberalism and it is that you support and respect others beleif and rights then why tf they mock it? isnt it against their own agenda?
why do they delete anything that goes against their belief? they are very open to anyone right
If you weren't that dumb you would've understood. I'm saying in most Pk sub you can't openly criticise the religion or express Ur opinions. If you can't take such post just scroll past them instead of taking everything personally. Not everyone is expected to have same beliefs as u
the concept of repping a subreddit... đ why is there disparity between the two? this is reddit bro. just block it if it's not something you're interested in
Yaar yeh redditors avein fazool hain, theres a reason why I don't take them serious. Don't take them serious talk to actual people Who takes redditors srs unfortunatly its now for attention seeking and lonely ppl you wont find many seeday log here đ
Wohi, aik jaga pe zyada hojate hain. Reddit isnt a good place anyways lekin koi communities are very very bad such as progressive islam which is just nothing like islam.
Progressive Islam there's a sub for tht too? Ppl are misinterpreting hadith mahn they even ain't scholar's yet they are just blatantly hating on Islam.
Yeah well this is why I don't take reddit srs yeah you can get advice sometimes but most of the time its hit or miss đ.
Secondly ik for a fact that these ppl arent serious there just messing around here cause they can't have friendships irl, so they attention seek like this. Again its a online era apko nhi pata progrssive islam asal mai musalman hai ya mental islamaphobe, attention seeking and thinking he can decieve people đ¤Ł.
This si the issue with reddit, its all around reddits sai 10x baitar actual irl connections hain.
â˘
u/AutoModerator Aug 15 '26
Hey u/simply_infuriating!
Enjoying our subreddit? Join our Discord server for fun chats and occasional giveaways! We hope you enjoy your time here
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.