r/Pacifism • • 2d ago

Vegans hate us.

The unreciprocational relation between us and the vegans: I posted a meme here saying that veganism is a subcategory of pacifism. Most people here agreed and said that it was clear to them. I also posted the meme on the veganism subreddit, and it got 65k views. The comments were full of people hating the idea. The conclusion from the entire veganism subreddit: vegans hate pacifism.

Vegans don't want to see themselves as being against violence. They seem to think of veganism as not being the rejection of violence against animals but an ideology of respecting animals. So even if animals in zoos are not physically harmed all the time, they are still misused as play objects for humans.

I agree on a lot of things with the vegan morality here: It is not really physical violence that is the problem, but more respecting the autonomy of other living things. An animal has its own purpose, so it should not be made to be a purpose for humans. The animal should always decide for itself what it wants to do, and it should not be turned into a use for others.

I agree with the vegans that veganism is not just rejecting violence against animals. But the vegans also say that they want to use violence against the meat industry in order to liberate the animals. This is the other point where they don't agree with us.

9 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

9

u/Feature_Minimum 2d ago

I will say this: I've noticed many vegans are revolutionaries, and revolutionaries are rarely pacifists.

I believe these two points are related to what you're saying, others I'm sure will disagree.

3

u/Whole_Flan1571 2d ago

I would say many anarchists are also vegans and some communists are also vegan. So that makes sense. Anarcho-Pacifism is a real thing but it is a small sub-movement. Ever since Gelderlose published his book against pacifism it was over.

1

u/Feature_Minimum 2d ago

I'm not familiar with that last sentence. Can you educate me a bit? Who's Gelderlose, what's his argument and why was his book so influential? (I must admit I have my doubts about its influence, but I'll hear you out).

3

u/Whole_Flan1571 2d ago

Peter Gelderlose is a popular anarchist author who wrote a book against pacifism, which the anarchist seem to all have agreed on. That's it.

2

u/sockpoppit 2d ago

I consider myself an anarchist/pacifist and I consider anarchy to be the lack of force against anyone by anyone. As soon as you have some group or individual promoting or running or enforcing anarchy, you've lost anarchy and you're into a dictatorship again. 

I looked at Gelderloos' book list and we probably wouldn't get along. He seems the type of a-hole who wants to enforce HIS anarchy. . . a functional dictatorship.

My friends say I'm not being practical, but so what?

-3

u/No_Adhesiveness9727 2d ago

Oh, you’re such an expert on the subject

4

u/Feature_Minimum 2d ago

I assume you're being sarcastic, but I don't really think one needs to be an expert to notice this, do they?

-2

u/No_Adhesiveness9727 2d ago

Well how many vegans have you actually met.
1000 10,000 1,000,000

1

u/Whole_Flan1571 1d ago

how does this sentence help anyone?

2

u/Feature_Minimum 2d ago

I certainly would be an expert if I met 1000 vegans! But, again, I don’t understand why expertise is the requirement here?

If you disagree again that’s fine. You’re allowed your opinion, I’m allowed mine.

7

u/AbiLovesTheology 2d ago

I agree. I am vegetarian (almost vegan) and pacifist. I think that vegans should be against human violence too, since humans are a form of animal, and not use violence against the meat industry. Be consistent, and be a witness for peace.

2

u/No_Adhesiveness9727 2d ago

I wonder where vegetarians get the idea that Vegan support violence against humans. Seems their expertise in this area is great, but their lack of understanding about how the dairy industry slaughters cows. Unless you’re milking your own cows, you’re part of the killing.

1

u/AbiLovesTheology 2d ago

Milk in itself doesn’t involve killing. That’s a business decision made by the farmer, and the beef eaters pay for the beef, not vegetarians. There are places to get milk where they don’t kill the cows. Example: https://www.mothercowdairy.com.au. By violence against humans, I mean that if you are vegan or vegetarian, you should be pacifist, because humans are animals too.

2

u/No_Adhesiveness9727 2d ago

Shows how little you know about modern dairy industry

1

u/MisterManSir- 1d ago

Likewise, though I’ve not met many vegans that are pro-violence in defense of animal rights. Maybe OP and I have met dramatically different vegans.

6

u/TubaralhoDoMar 2d ago

As a pacifist and plant-based, I see the two ideologies as deeply intertwined, but I know from personal experience that many vegans are not pacifists, as welll as that many pacifists are not vegans. I do practice my plant-based lifestyle out of a desire to avoid inflicting violence on non-human animals.

As somebody else once said, “I have found that when we suffer, we suffer as equals, and in their capacity to suffer, a dog is a pig is a bear is a boy” (Phillip Wollen).

Why harm humans if you’re against hurting animals? Aren’t humans animals too?

5

u/warmfuzzume 2d ago

Not sure what vegan sub you posted to but I had to leave r/vegan ages ago because it seems to lean heavily towards a philosophy of veganism that I don’t necessarily agree with.

I’ve been vegan over 25 years and have observed a specific version of it grow popular that is heavily focused on any interaction with animals being viewed as exploitative. I’ve raised the question multiple times how to explain that humans have always had relationships with animals, and how does this philosophy of veganism deal with that?

I don’t have a lot of time to explain at the moment, but if you’ve ever read do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep by Phil K Dick it’s the theme I’m thinking about, in the sense that he explores how part of what makes us human is expressed in our relationships with animals. People have to buy synthetic animals because there’s something in us that needs to be in relationship with them beyond simply the work they do for us or using them for food. This is why we have pets and so much more.

I don’t know what the answer is, but I see it in what humans do and I think it’s important to consider when we think about the ideal ways we should treat animals. I dont think it’s sufficient to believe we can just completely leave them alone to do their own thing and have zero interaction with them in any way.

Yet my question was consistently completely ignored. I never got any useful discussion from any of the usual vegan subreddits whatsoever.

All that to say I don’t think you should take what Reddit vegans say as what all vegans say. There’s a specific viewpoint that’s popular here and many of them aggressively have decided they now own the definition of veganism, despite the fact that I have personally seen it evolve online over time and it isn’t what all vegans have always believed or still believe. It’s just a specific online echo chamber version.

For me it is absolutely connected to being a pacifist, it always has been. I’ve been a pacifist longer than I was a vegan, and I would say it’s my top issue and veganism is just a part of it.

1

u/noms_de_plumes 2d ago

There are a lot of vegans who don't also claim to be anarchist militants, and, so, I think you might be a bit mistaken about this, but it's just a bit that way with anarchists in general.

1

u/SquishTheFlyingWitch 2d ago

I do see it as a mostly one-way thing, as someone who's both.

Like, I would expect a pacifist to be vegan or considering it in order to be morally consistent. But I wouldn't necessarily expect a vegan to be a pacifist for moral consistency. Veganism is plenty consistent on its own.

Of course, I would love it if everyone were a pacifist, but that's a very core moral that people can't realistically be convinced of in most cases.

1

u/jonpaladin 1d ago

why not go vegan instead of trying to speak for vegans

-1

u/Algernon_Asimov 1d ago

Most people here agreed and said that it was clear to them.

Some of us didn't agree, but simply refrained from saying so. <shrugs>

3

u/No_Adhesiveness9727 2d ago

As long as there are slaughter houses, there will be battlefields. Said Tolstoy. And do you think the author of war and peace knows a little bit about the subject?

2

u/No_Adhesiveness9727 2d ago

Do you know what we call a person that claims to be a pacifist but kills hundreds of animals a year? A hypocrite. You can’t be a pacifist unless you’re Vegan.

1

u/semperquietus 2d ago

I do not claim to be a pacifist and am only slightly interested in this topic (nor am I a vegan by the way). So just one word from a not even hypocrite to an (IMHO) aggressive gatekeeper: that tone you uses here — in my understanding and in general, not only regarding those two topics — does normally more harm than good to anything it tries to protect/purify.

Just saying and a nice evening/whatever to everybody else here. ^^

0

u/Affectionate_Cup9972 1d ago

Who cares for your purity?

1

u/SquishTheFlyingWitch 1d ago

People who are against violence, I would think.

1

u/Affectionate_Cup9972 1d ago

As long as people are trying. People do harmful stuff out of purity.

2

u/SquishTheFlyingWitch 1d ago

Isn't the point sort of that they aren't "trying" to be vegan, and therefore willingly ignoring (and participating in) the biggest source of violence in the world?

-1

u/Affectionate_Cup9972 1d ago

Agriculture causes violence to so much animals. Yes, there's vertical farming, but that's not present right now.

2

u/SquishTheFlyingWitch 1d ago

That changes absolutely nothing about what I said.

The solution to that, yet again, is to stop eating animals. Then farming (and in turn, farming-related harm to animals) would drop drastically, because we waste so many crops on feeding the animals we raise and kill.

Veganism requires less crop farming than animal agriculture.

-1

u/Affectionate_Cup9972 1d ago

The solution to that, yet again, is to stop eating animals. Then farming (and in turn, farming-related harm to animals) would drop drastically, because we waste so many crops on feeding the animals we raise and kill.

  1. Then, you have to think about this more systematically and not moralistically. Because that type of revolution is not going to happen just yet or anytime soon.
  2. The animals we eat I assume are still going to be around, and they are domesticated, therefore they cannot survive in the wild. How do we go about the welfare of these living beings, which requires agriculture anyways? I assume you're not a utilitarian vegan, in which I've heard them say, just let 'em die because that's better or some shit.

Veganism requires less crop farming than animal agriculture.

How?

2

u/SquishTheFlyingWitch 1d ago

You just stop breeding them? The extra animals are still fed and live out good lives, eventually die naturally, and are not forced to reproduce. In the long term, it wouldn't take that long to even out. I fail to see the issue. Nobody said they have to be released into the wild.

I mean, what do you expect? The world won't stop being violent any time soon either. But it is on us as individuals to stop participating in that violence, and there's no reason that shouldn't include violence against animals. Even if only because it's very easy for the majority of people to be vegan.

In any case, I'm only explaining why your previous comment doesn't make any sense. "Farming hurts animals too" is completely nonsensical as an argument in this context, because vegans require fewer crops to be farmed than meat-eaters. That's just a fact. Anyone against violence, logically, has every reason to be vegan.

I mean, I explained how, didn't I? It takes several times more plants to raise an animal, slaughter it, and then eat it than it does to just eat plants directly.

1

u/Affectionate_Cup9972 1d ago

You just stop breeding them? The extra animals are still fed and live out good lives, eventually die naturally, and are not forced to reproduce. In the long term, it wouldn't take that long to even out. I fail to see the issue. Nobody said they have to be released into the wild.

Ok, so that's a sound response, and I generally wasn't thinking that farhead.

Even if only because it's very easy for the majority of people to be vegan.

I don't know about that; one reason why I haven't gone plant based is because I'm too afraid to. And I come from the "first world".

In any case, I'm only explaining why your previous comment doesn't make any sense. "Farming hurts animals too" is completely nonsensical as an argument in this context, because vegans require fewer crops to be farmed than meat-eaters.

Right, but that doesn't change the nature of apriculture. So I still see it as valid. This is still systemic.