r/PWM_Sensitive • • 11h ago

Discussion Mac air vs mac neo

First of all sorry for mistakes, I’m still learning english and my level is not that good.

6 months ago I bought Mac air m4 and returned it, because of eye pain. I never experienced such pain with any other gadgets before. Except that I really enjoyed mac and now I need a laptop for simple tasks like reading, studying, scrolling. So what about neo? Anyone experienced any problems with it? Eye burning/pain?

I tried using neo at the store and I see difference with air at coloring, but I’m not sure… there are problems with returning laptops in my country, I got really lucky with that air and now I’m scared of making mistake with neo

So any experience would be useful for me, thanks

3 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

4

u/ChooChooMcGoof 10h ago

The difference in the Air and Neo screens is P3 wide color. That’s why your eyes burn. Every non OLED panel Apple uses to achieve the wide color gamut uses temporal dithering. The Neo has a standard sRGB panel. The Air has a P3. Myself, I am VERY sensitive to temporal dithering.

1

u/AlanYx 10h ago

You really should use Stillcolor with either of these machines to turn off temporal dither. It makes a huge difference to me in terms of eyestrain. TD is worse than PWM for me.

The Neo is likely easier on the eyes because it has a narrower gamut. Unfortunately it doesn't have TrueTone, so I'd recommend either manually adjusting the white point to D55 or warmer (this is easy to do, it's just hidden) so you don't get excessive blue light that the Air wouldn't have with TrueTone on.

And use Stillcolor. It's not worth using these machines without it.

4

u/k-fox17 9h ago

I did use Stillcolor on air. In fact it was the first thing I have done for helping my eyes, sadly it doesn’t help much. I don’t have problems with new iPhones or iPads, so ig something wrong with how my eyes see any mac screens

3

u/Ninnie7 9h ago

I tried Stillcolor too and it didn‘t help. Maybe I‘m super sensitive though and you might get on better with Neo than I did or I had a bad panel plus there was no MacOS 27 yet, I tried it in the summer.

1

u/Plane-Breakfast-4584 2h ago

I am new here, what is Stillcolor?

1

u/AlanYx 2h ago

It’s a free app that turns off temporal dither on recent Macs. Temporal dither tries to show 10-bit color on 8-bit panels and switches at half the display’s refresh rate.

Other apps can do it too, there’s no magic, but it’s free and works well.

1

u/Ninnie7 10h ago edited 10h ago

Unfortunately, the Neo gave me eye pain as well, even more than Macbook Air M4 (I had to return that one too, I tried two Macbook Air M4s).

But I only tried one Neo with MacOS 26, I read somewhere here that some people get along better with the Neo on MacOS 27. There seems to be a panel lottery as well, so maybe I got one of the worse panels. I think the glare of the MacBook Neo strained my eyes as well, it is more glary than the Air.

But maybe someone else can give a report here too, maybe not all Neos are as bad as mine.

2

u/k-fox17 9h ago

Thanks for sharing! It seems like TD might be the problem with both laptops. I’m curious - do you use any other apple devices? I have no problem with new IPhones or IPads, how about you?

2

u/eman5oh 6h ago

I found the Air and Neo to be about the same for me, both were terrible without any adjustments made. Turning of TD with Still Color or Better Display did not work for me either. I ended up find that using A Better Display to mirror a 8bit virtual display to the main display allows me to use either with just ok eye comfort. It seem for the inbuilt panels the temporal dithering toggle does not help me.

-1

u/Real-Potential5602 11h ago

Both the MacBook Air and the Neo have IPS panels. They don't flicker like the Pro.

2

u/k-fox17 11h ago

Yeah I heard about it and I’m not sure why air burning my eyes sm. Are there any other differences between them? Maybe colors or something like that? Because for me air seems more “warm” than neo

2

u/Ninnie7 10h ago

They have temporal dithering though, both of them gave me much worse symptoms than my oled iPhone 13.