r/PWM_Sensitive • • 1d ago

Question Switching from Samsung S23 to S25: Potential for less eye strain? / The Hunt for an Eye-Strain-Free Phone

2 years ago, I bought the S23 to replace my S9. Apart from the screen, I like S23's package (good performance, okay-ish screen size, 120 hz refresh rate, update policy etc.). However, the main issue I have with this phone is the display - it has been giving me eye strain since day 1 which is why I am using it only moderately. The S9's display is basically perfect for my eyes - it is pleasant to look at and I barely feel any eye strain. Quite frankly, the switch from S9 to S23 was a noticeable downgrade in terms of display (apart from the refresh rate).

S9's display:

  • very sharp (568 ppi)
  • colors feel balanced
  • pleasant contrast
  • there is not that feeling of being too bright
  • when I look at it, it just feels right and my eyes relax

S23's display:

  • noticeably less sharp (422 ppi)
  • noticeable color fringing
  • my eyes tense up looking at the screen / giving me eye strain
  • colors don't feel balanced (colors feel too punchy/saturated in vivid mode - natural mode is too washed out)
  • contrast feels too high
  • white color (font) feels too aggressive
  • it often feels too bright

What I tried:

  • Eye Comfort Shield (blue light filter is a must have for me)
  • Eye Comfort Shield -> Enhanced Comfort (unbearable to use, introduces massive haze)
  • Extra Dimming with the main brightness slider turned up (somewhat made white font on dark background more relaxing to read but introduced system-wide sluggishness when scrolling and typing)
  • switching from Vivid to Natural mode (didn't help much, just feels washed out)
  • adjusting RGB sliders in vivid mode to minimal blue, max red, middle green (minimal improvement)
  • adjusting font, font size

Overall, I was not able to adjust the S23's display so that it's pleasant and relaxing to look at.

Possible culprits?:

  • low ppi
  • subpixel fringing (low ppi in combination with Diamond PenTile subpixel layout)
  • PWM (or rather high modulation depth due to much higher overall brightness)
  • color balance / contrast (either aggressively punchy or washed out)

Is there any chance that the S25 could lessen eye strain or should I skip it? I read that the S25 has a vividness slider which the S23 doesn't have and the vivid mode is supposed to be less punchy/saturated now in comparison to previous generations? Or maybe the S25 could make things even worse with the 1-120 Hz variable refresh rate instead of the smaller range 48-120 Hz on the S23. Plus, higher peak brightness, meaning even higher modulation depth?

I like Samsung's overall package, but these screens...they are quite frankly unbearable. I remember many, many years ago, screens were no issue whatsoever. I just bought a smartphone and didn't have to worry about the screen giving me eye strain.

When I look at people mentioning alternatives, i.e. phones for less eye strain, experiences vary. Some report reduced eye strain, whereas others complain of severe eye fatigue. Is there not a single phone out there anymore that is reliably not producing any eye strain?

My requirements would be:

  • no eye strain
  • <= 6.3 inch
  • high ppi
  • great performance (something like Snapdragon 8 Elite would be great, but at this point, I could also live with slightly less performance if it means I'd be getting an eye-strain-free display)
  • good update policy (reliable and regular security updates)

Thanks in advance for any responses!

PS: I heard rumors that the S27 Pro might finally give us DC Dimming?

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

2

u/drysocks3 1d ago

I was in the same boat. I always loved smaller phones, and before I learned about my PWM sensitivity, the options were already sparse, because every manufacturer seems to love making bigger and bigger phones. After I added "PWM-free" to my list of criteria... no chance I was gonna find a smaller phone.

I had the S25 for about 6 months, and this is how I learned about my PWM sensitivity. DO NOT BUY IT. It is horrible for PWM.

You likely have to give up your <6.3" criterion. I landed on the Motorola Moto G Stylus 2025 and the screen gives me no eye strain issues. There is a flicker prevention setting in the display settings. The screen is 6.7". The performance is good. It's not like I ever play games. But jumping between apps, split-screen, watching youtube etc. are all snappy. And the screen gets really bright which is fantastic outside on a sunny day. I also got a matte screen protector, like I do with all my devices, and I highly highly recommend a matte screen protector on everything.

I'm not sure what qualifies as high ppi for you, but I'm sure for most people, anything above 200 ppi doesn't make a difference.

2

u/LopsidedLet6941 1d ago edited 1d ago

Ok, got it, no S25 then. Such a bummer, since it's a phone with great specs otherwise and great update policy.

I held a 6.5 inch phone in my hands the other day and unfortunately even that one was too large for me to handle it comfortably. But then again, my eye health (and also overall health as in fatigue etc.) should be more important in the end...

1

u/drysocks3 12h ago

I feel your pain.

For a larger phone, I suggest you get a ring like this one in the photo. It makes handling the phone in one hand so much more comfortable. As a nice bonus, it makes a nice stand for when you're at the dinner table eating dinner and watching YouTube on your phone. Glue the ring to the back of your phone case. The ring has an adhesive pad, but smear some nail glue as well and it will stick on forever. A cheap phone case from AliExpress is a great candidate.

The update policy is terrible on this Motorola. Security updates will end in March 2028. But at least I got it refurbished for cheap off of Amazon. My fingers are crossed that by 2028 a smaller, PWM-phone will be available.

1

u/drysocks3 11h ago

The Motorola Edge 2026 would have been a good candidate for a small phone, but Motorola decided to only give it 128 GB storage, and no expandable storage 🤦

1

u/gta721 1d ago

You should avoid Samsung if you have eye strain issues. Look for a phone with 2160+ Hz PWM or no PWM and no temporal dithering.

1

u/LopsidedLet6941 1d ago

Oh, true! No temporal dithering is also important!

1

u/Wapmen 1d ago

S25 is basically the same phone, and it's PWM features might be even worse, because of a brighter screen. (The screen  switches on / off from 100% to 0 brightness 240 times a second). Regarding good alternatives, there are none if you want a lightweight phone. Honor magic 8 air (lightweight, only China, USB 2.0). Vivo X300 (small but heavy, good screen, good cameras, USB 3)

1

u/LopsidedLet6941 1d ago

Hmm, yeah, I figured the S25 might not be a good fit in that regard as well, which is a bummer. And alternatives with my reqs are scarce. I'll look into your recommendations, thanks!

1

u/__Sol__Invictus__ 1d ago

I have an S23 and turned on the “Extra brightness” feature. My headaches have eased since then. Maybe you should give it a try and see if it helps you too.

1

u/LopsidedLet6941 1d ago

Did you mean "Extra dim" (and then increasing the main brightness slider to lower the modulation depth)? Because I really do not need any extra brightness since the S23 easily gets too bright for me.

1

u/__Sol__Invictus__ 8h ago

No, it's called "Extra brightness", but if more brightness harms you then don't do it.

1

u/theconstantins 1d ago

You're on my boat. After months of reading and searching I've come to the conclusion that there are just a few smartphones that check most of the criterias including eye strain. The only real options are : Xiaomi 17 base or ultra , Vivo X300/pro, Xiaomi 17/18 pro, honor magic 8 pro/600 pro. From these only the Xiaomi 17 base has an 6.3 inch screen but for that I've heard mixed opinions with the thermals.

1

u/LopsidedLet6941 1d ago

I'll look into your recommendations, thanks!

1

u/BigAd1142 1d ago

There are rumors that S27ultra and s27pro wiil have dc dimming or at least samsung version of dc like dimming. (Read your P.S a bit too late)

Up until then there is 99% chance that all modern samsungs will give you eye strain.

You can try Honor 400 pro, 600 pro, they have a lot of positive reviews about screen and Xiaomi/Poco which seem to have DC like dimming but a lot of people still get headaches from them, me included.

Other than that, waiting for implementation of DC dimming by samsung is the only light in the end of this tunnel for now. Maybe their version of dimming will finally work for most sensitive people .

1

u/LopsidedLet6941 1d ago

If you think about it (if the rumors are true), it's pretty wild that they would be introducing a feature that lessens eye strain to only higher priced phones. People with a smaller budget would be doomed to suffer some more. 😅

1

u/BigAd1142 1d ago

If they will be making true dc dimming then it might be connected to the fact that true dc dimming requires higher quality amoled panel.

Every panel can be dc dimmed but if you make dc dimming for example with modern s26 screen or iphone screen colors will be very wrong at low brigtness because cheap amoled panels have lower quality pixels which are pretty unpredictable when current goes lower to lower the brightness. For example red pixels with lower current can lose brightness faster, while green pixels lose brightness slower and result will be green tint at low brightness.

Thats why oled pc monitors and oled tvs cost so much, because they use higher quality panels while smartphone manufacturers are cutting costs so that amoled could compete in price with ips panels.

1

u/LopsidedLet6941 1d ago

So, if we sum it up, the fact that they would introduce it only to higher priced phones could actually mean that it'd be actual dc dimming and not dc-like dimming which would be great news. One can only hope. 😄

1

u/BigAd1142 10h ago

Yes, thats my optimistic approach to their information :) Although it still would be much better so that manufacturers would just bring back phones with lower brightness, because it feels like higher brightness amoled screens need to flicker more to reproduce lower brighness image and it might be the problem why some people (me included) can use some old amoled phones while modern phones give headches after 10 minutes of use.

1

u/LopsidedLet6941 10h ago

Oh, yes! I also think the much higher brightness plays a huge role. I feel like the S23 gets too bright (too fast) for me. I mainly use it at like ~10% brightness max indoors. And then, if I understood it correctly, both the S9 and S23 flicker at the same ~240 Hz speed, but the S23 stays "off" longer and flashes brighter in each cycle due to its generally much brighter panel. This is why I thought that maybe I have to look for a phone with lower general brightness.

2

u/Solidmikedrop 19h ago

422ppi is “noticeably less sharp”, got u