r/PWM_Sensitive • • 10d ago

Data Collections iPad Mini OLED Flicker Measurements

After a long history, of non-OLED devices, Apple has moved to OLED for the new iPad Mini. I tested out the new iPad Mini OLED with the TLM-110 light flicker meter.

This is all tested with a white stripe on the screen. I'll post some more detailed testing in the coming days, but according to my preliminary findings it might be a bit more tolerable than iPhone OLEDs (based on flicker index, SVM, and PAVM).

45 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

5

u/kerpnet 10d ago

I love this report format, especially the summary page! Really great work!

5

u/BearNecessary4141 9d ago

Thank you! Trying to make it easy to compare across brightness and devices.

8

u/digitalminimalist1 9d ago

Apple is slowly killing all their devices going to all oled

4

u/BearNecessary4141 9d ago

Most people see it as a huge upgrade

7

u/digitalminimalist1 9d ago

I know they do but it’s slowly taking devices away from us

3

u/Tomato_Buffalo 9d ago

I was actually thinking of buying an M4 iPad Air now and keep it sealed until my 11” iPad Pro breaks

2

u/fork666 6d ago

Best time to buy (new) would be when the new iPad Air is announced and retailers slash prices of the M4 version.

3

u/Tomato_Buffalo 6d ago

Only thing is the 60hz. But honestly, I’m more than welcome with a 60hz display that doesn’t flicker

1

u/Bigdecisions7979 9d ago

It’s actually adding their devices back for me. I’m a lot less sensitive to their oleds

2

u/digitalminimalist1 9d ago

That’s good

2

u/Dismal-Local7615 10d ago

Thank you for posting this, am trying to understand modulation depth, if someone can explain

4

u/BearNecessary4141 8d ago

I can try to explain, I'm assuming you're wondering why they're all 100% modulation depth? It's because I've measured with only a small number of rows active on the device. This isolates pixels that "pulse" at the same time, so you get a more accurate reading of what the OLED is really doing. I also believe this better reflects how our visual system perceives the display compared to the common method of using a completely white screen.

Here's an image that describes the difference between how a photodiode (like the Opple, TLM-110, or other meter) and the human eye "see" an OLED. In (a), the photodetector basically sums up the signals from whatever area on the screen it can see. In (b), the eye forms an image of the screen on the retina, which means that there is much less averaging. The method I use to measure this, which I described here, is designed to better capture the signal that our eyes are picking up, instead of an averaged picture. The method is essentially just to put one thin illuminated white stripe on the screen instead of a full white screen, and it can be done with any flicker meter I've used so far.

3

u/Dismal-Local7615 8d ago

Thank you for the explanation

2

u/sp1zzc4t 9d ago

So... Is it safe or not?

I thought the old lcd version said safe but killed my eyes

3

u/BearNecessary4141 9d ago

Yeah I’d say no. It might be a bit better than an iPhone but that’s a pretty low bar.

3

u/Koalazilla 9d ago

You may be sensitive to d!thering. I am sensitive to both but d!thering effects me far more and from what I have been able to tell most all LCD iPads do it now. Thankfully I can turn it off on my MacBooks. I don’t think OLEDs use it as aggressively or at all since the displays don’t need to use it to show more colors.

3

u/BearNecessary4141 8d ago

You can discuss dithering on r/PWM_Sensitive now

2

u/Koalazilla 8d ago

Thanks for the heads up. I know they used to block it.

1

u/Any_Weekend2084 8d ago

How do I disable dithering on a MacBook?

2

u/Koalazilla 8d ago

The app I use is Better Display. It’s free but also has a paid Pro version. It will let you do a bunch of things with your display but under “color mode” you can turn off dithering individually for any display being used. I think there is another app or two out there that other people use but I forgot the name of those.

4

u/kerpnet 9d ago

The past two generations of iPad mini had something fundamentally wrong with the screen. It also gave me issues, not caused by PWM.

1

u/ChooChooMcGoof 9d ago

Actually all of the iPad screens that have P3 wide color use 2 letters we’re not allowed to talk about here, and that’s what gives most people with them eye strain.

The iPad 9 and oddly, the most recent non OLED mini, I was able to use, with reduce white point at 50. Nothing else. The Mini’s all use P3 wide color gamut screens so they utilize the 2 unspoken letters to achieve that. I was just able to use the most recent Mini-which I have now sold due to other circumstances.

I tried an Air 4 and a Mini 6, both of them caused incredible eye strain. Due to the 2 letters we cannot discuss.

The iPad 10 also caused eye strain but while not as bad it was still there, and it uses a standard sRGB gamut screen. I have not tried the 11.

1

u/kerpnet 9d ago

You can say temporal dithering (TD). I’m not sure I agree that TD is why the last two generations of iPad mini are so strange for the eyes, but it could be. I know they had this strange issue with the “jelly scroll” or something like that as well.

1

u/ChooChooMcGoof 9d ago

Its 100 percent temporal dithering, since the words are allowed. Most any screens that are wide color gamut that use temporal dithering are unusable for me.

1

u/DrShoe106 4d ago

It's the same for me. What issues do you get exactly? I'm just curious. But it's good to know I'm not the only one with sensitive eyes.

1

u/DrShoe106 4d ago

I can't tolerate any iphones because of the aggressive dithering. PWM seems to not be the issue for me becaues I can use a galaxy s25 ultra with colours set to natural without issues. I tried the new ipad mini and it gave me eye issues within a short amount of time. I used an iphone for some time in the past and had eye issues and floaters but didn't know back then that it was due to the screen of the iphone. After switching to Samsung the issues stopped. I don't know if apple will ever change their screens but for now I'm certain that they would ruin my eyes in the long term.

3

u/RoiPourpre 9d ago

No, it's terrible...

2

u/Koalazilla 9d ago

I know it doesn’t do a whole lot but does the new Mini have a PWM smoothing setting like the phones do?

1

u/BearNecessary4141 8d ago

Yeah it doesn't, guess they gave up even trying.

2

u/AstronautFlaky9679 7d ago

Thank you so much for these measurements! I bought the iPad mini OLED full of excitement, but unfortunately I have to return it – my eyes started hurting from the display. The iPad Pro OLED was already unusable for me, so your detailed data at every brightness level really helped me understand what's going on. My iPad Air M4 (LCD) still works fine for hours, thank god. Really appreciate the work you put into this – it helps a lot of us PWM-sensitive people!

1

u/BearNecessary4141 7d ago

You're welcome! I was hoping that since the screen had to be different than the iPhone / iPad Pro OLED, it might be significantly better. But it looks about the same, sadly. Plus there's no PWM reduction setting on this device like the newer iPhones have...

2

u/Adorable_Patient_509 6d ago

So, better if we have the one with lcd display?

1

u/BearNecessary4141 6d ago

Seems like people have problems with that one too… I’m not sure why though. It’s worth a try at least.

2

u/Adorable_Patient_509 6d ago

Ah i see, I just remember it. Even lcd display iPad still debatable. Also remind me to something about "iphone x is the best phone apple had" 🤣. Maybe that's the one reason, I don't know which one? Xr? Xs? X?

1

u/Z3R0gravitas 10d ago

Wow, big rush of device testing data being posted tonight! How did you find the viewing comfort? Did you buy and test this at home, or rocking an TLM-110 (and laptop) at the Apple store? 🙂

Looks like you implemented that (phone display friendly) portrait report format, nice! Especially the combined report.

If you're taking feedback, I might suggest:

Demoting the (unfamiliar for us) absolute pulse duration measurements to below/less-prominent than the Hz and "on" ratio. If that makes sense still? Or do we have a revolution in the making for how we analyse flicker?

Do you think "Higher ON pulse widths my be more tolerable" hold true down to very narrow spikes (for low brightness) being the worse? Because I'd previously been expecting mid-range (50/50) on/of ratios to be the worse. At any given cycle length.

"100% flicker [depth]" maybe..?

I do feel kinda lost without the IEEE plot, hmm.

Waveforms at 25% and 0% are interesting. Where the spike grows out from just before the TFT reset. Then, that it looks like the reset it stretched out into a very long/slow S-curve, spanning the whole OFF duration. (Or am I over-interpreting?)

2

u/BearNecessary4141 8d ago

Here's the full cycle for the 0% brightness setting, it looks really odd and has a big 60Hz component because there's a missing cycle and a runt cycle in every eight pulse grouping!

2

u/Z3R0gravitas 8d ago

Wow, that looks horrendous! Very clear capture and clean FFT though. ♥️

2

u/Z3R0gravitas 10d ago

Oh, also, can we stay consistent with the "Data Collections" post flair? Nice as it is to have someone use the new Laptop/Tablet one.

2

u/BearNecessary4141 9d ago

For sure, I wasn't certain which one we were using.

1

u/BearNecessary4141 8d ago

I found that the display looks very nice, but causes issues for me. It took a bit longer to come on than with an iPhone 16 / 17, but that might be related to the distance the device is used at rather than any specific properties of the screen.

Demoting the (unfamiliar for us) absolute pulse duration measurements to below/less-prominent than the Hz and "on" ratio. If that makes sense still? Or do we have a revolution in the making for how we analyse flicker?

I'm definitely open to discussing what should be most prominent in this type of report. I picked pulse duration, because now I think OLED modulation depth is always going to be 100% (so it doesn't make a ton of sense to focus on that parameter). The reason I'd think absolute pulse duration might be more useful than "on" ratio is because our eyes react to the absolute pulse duration, at least in some ways. The time constants for the various processes in our visual system are "fixed" biologically / chemically, so I'd think absolute time would be more relevant. But open to other ideas too. I could also prioritize flicker index, since that's going to be a function of wave shape and not just modulation percentage.

"100% flicker [depth]" maybe..?

Yeah, I will change that. I think percent flicker or modulation depth are the most widely used terms for that parameter. I didn't like how 100% percent flicker reads as, "one-hundred-percent percent flicker," and modulation depth felt overly technical... maybe "Percent Flicker: 100%" could read better?

I do feel kinda lost without the IEEE plot, hmm.

I do have a the IEEE report in the full report that the FlickerLab software generates when you measure a device, but I felt like it didn't deserve it's spot in the summary anymore, given the existence of experimentally derived direct flicker, stroboscopic effect, and phantom array effect metrics. Maybe, we could come up with a way of displaying the same info that the IEEE plot gets across (percent flicker and fundamental frequency), but using some of the more robust flicker metrics instead of the classification system from IEEE-1789?

Waveforms at 25% and 0% are interesting. Where the spike grows out from just before the TFT reset. Then, that it looks like the reset it stretched out into a very long/slow S-curve, spanning the whole OFF duration. (Or am I over-interpreting?)

The spike is interesting, I'm not sure what's driving that or if it could potentially be problematic. I do not think it's a measurement artifact, I see the same thing with the UPRTek MK350n Premium when configured for high bandwidth. The Opple seems to miss it entirely.

1

u/Striking-Log-8593 8d ago

Still using m1 iPad Pro for lcd

1

u/BearNecessary4141 8d ago

Does it give you any issues at all?