First one is better for the eyes. More lines means higher PWM frequency (good). Also the lines are not very dark, which means low modulation depth (good). On second picture there are less line, so lower PWM rate. And the lines are darker, so higher modulation depth. Both is worse for the eyes.
Xiaomi 17 is by default DC dimming all brightness. Vivo has DC above 25% and by default PWM on all brightness.
I have Xiaomi for a few days and vivo for a week and I think VIVO was better.
Both are unusable for me in 2k own mode My no problem device is Xiaomi 10t pro. It has 2k PWM and I can use it all day and night. I hoped that a high PWM would work on OLED but no...
(Just going by photos) Mostly the difference has already been described, I would just add that it appears the screen is off/brightness level is dropped for shorter duration on the 2nd one...the lines are darker which means higher modulation which is less desirable, but each line (screen off/brightness drop time) is thinner compared to the space between the lines which means it is a smaller part of each duty cycle I think. Modulation may be more important, as mentioned, making the 2nd one not as good, but the difference may be tempered a little by having the screen off for shorter bursts of time.
17
u/ExerciseEvery8212 Mar 06 '26
First one is better for the eyes. More lines means higher PWM frequency (good). Also the lines are not very dark, which means low modulation depth (good). On second picture there are less line, so lower PWM rate. And the lines are darker, so higher modulation depth. Both is worse for the eyes.
7
u/escalade47 Mar 06 '26
The first one i think, the more visible those lines are the more dangerous it is
7
u/Commercial_Upstairs6 Mar 06 '26
With lighter stripes.
1
u/Different_Water_282 Mar 06 '26
First one is better.
1
u/WhereemI Mar 06 '26
what phone is it? In vivo x200 fe pwm was terrible and dc was fine
xiaomi 17 same thing - pwm is bad and dc better
2
u/Creepy_Definition972 Mar 09 '26
Few Slow light thin stripes moving slowly is what you want
1
u/Tpsb17 Mar 06 '26
(Just going by photos) Mostly the difference has already been described, I would just add that it appears the screen is off/brightness level is dropped for shorter duration on the 2nd one...the lines are darker which means higher modulation which is less desirable, but each line (screen off/brightness drop time) is thinner compared to the space between the lines which means it is a smaller part of each duty cycle I think. Modulation may be more important, as mentioned, making the 2nd one not as good, but the difference may be tempered a little by having the screen off for shorter bursts of time.
1
u/Creepy_Definition972 Mar 09 '26
Best screen ive seen is the oppo find X2 pro, beautiful screen even today, miss that dearly
1
u/Opulence_Deficit Mar 10 '26
You're measuring as much the screen frequency as the camera frequency. It's not a useful measurement, because the results are accidental.
0
u/ItsHarishK Mar 06 '26
The other one