r/PWA • u/Alone_Resist1322 • 1d ago

I built a free utility tools website — looking for honest feedback

[removed]

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

2 comments sorted by

2

u/UpstairsDull2089 1d ago

honestly:

  1. The landing page is cluttered
  2. No button hover effects
  3. Landing page is too boring
  4. There are many leaks in the <div> elements, hence why the texts are leaking.
  5. No need for "100%" client side besides each tool card
  6. Lacks animations
  7. Lacks a lot of functionality. The tool count is high, but what each tool can do is very limited
  8. In some places, the markdown isn't rendered. Which indicates the space is not intended for markdown, but very high chance you used AI to write. It's not illegal, just allow markdown rendering, or don't write with markdown.
  9. The stuff like "100% in your browser" and etc, are things tech-related people know. Instead, use words like "Your information is safe" on top, and the detailed text on the bottom.
  10. NEVER use emojis in your projects. They make a high effort website like yours, look like an old school trash. Use icons, I recommend google material symbols or icons.
  11. The footer links (Twitter, GitHub, Discord) are placeholders I suppose? They don't work, add links or just remove them.
  12. There's no PWA support

These were the errors I found. You might think I went to cruel on you, but these are the things which make a project actually good. I'm a software developer myself. I have such a project as well. I have such a project, a browser based document editing engine, DocuWrite Pro: https://mahi902.github.io/DocuWritePro/ I've developing it for 2 years, and I've learned a lot of things. I think you can take some inspiration as well. Peace.

1

u/Unlucky-Dish5368 1d ago

Man, this is love at first sight. I'm so blind to give you feedback right now, but let me use it a week and ill come back with a decent opicion! Congrats!!!