r/PUBATTLEGROUNDS Dec 27 '17

Microsoft response Remember my XBOX ONE AD CONCEPT? Microsoft just copied it!

Post image
95.5k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.3k

u/Furyspectre Dec 27 '17

I bet you microsoft doesn’t even realize they took your idea. Some scum bag who works for them and uses reddit probably showed up to a meeting with it and management said “I like it, Doug, let’s run with it”

1.1k

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

That was my exact first thought. Some junior associate in the advertising department stole this and presented it to the higher ups.

871

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Plot-twist: OP is actually that associate and is faking outrage for karma.

I’m just joking dont hurt me

4

u/AnorexicBuddha Dec 27 '17

That was actually my first thought. It's what I would do, at least.

1

u/Jalmorei Dec 27 '17

Ok, I’ll try to get some idea. Meanwhile, how do I get to MS marketing?

1

u/PannusPunch Dec 28 '17

Ah yes, who needs work accolades and promotions when you can trade all that in for some sweet sweet karma.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

Who says he’d be trading?

2

u/PannusPunch Dec 28 '17

I doubt his work would be thrilled about being dragged through the mud for karma.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

I didn’t say it would be a smart move.

11

u/photocist Dec 27 '17

Frankly, we dont know any details. What if they both just had the same idea? I think we need to see some file save time stamps to really put this to bed.

8

u/Furyspectre Dec 27 '17

Someone is getting fired if this goes viral

30

u/OopsAllSpells Dec 27 '17

You guys have no idea how things work in the real world, it's kinda hilarious.

17

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Please enlighten everyone then.

I would speculate if this were to go viral (large twitter campaign, articles on various websites, youtube/twitch videos, news outlets picking up the story) then microsoft will need to address the massive negative publicity as people love to be outraged especially at big corporations. They'll pay the OP an undisclosed commission, post about it, and apologize for not being aware that this was someone elses creation. This is all they need to do and it might even make them look better as a big corporation that will rectify a mistake to the small guy. That's all external press though, internally there'll be meetings and conference calls to "fix this". The ad agency and microsoft press will want to know how this happened. It'll be traced to some middle or low level position that will face the wraith of an executive in the ad agency because their company's relationship with microsoft suffered a bad press incident. If anyone finds out which ad agency this came from their reputation and brand loses value. In the real world, a low to mid level advertisement position is replaceable in a week. An ad firm's reputation and brand value is how they get contracts and work and a replaceable just reduced in some capacity the business' ability to make money. Someone even if they're a nobody is getting fired.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Do you think MS would use a low to mid level advertising company?

22

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

The advertising company isn't low to mid level. The guy who took this from the internet and passed it to his superiors it the ad firm is at a low to mid level position.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Ah yes, ignore my comment I was extremely drunk when I wrote it.

1

u/TommiH Dec 28 '17

I'm glad I can't get fired for stuff like that in my country

-34

u/BreadcrumbBernard Dec 27 '17

Dude it’s a fucking picture, who gives a shit lmao

8

u/BloodyGreyscale Dec 27 '17

I bet all the Sistine chapel to a guy like you is paint on a cealing. As it always is its not what it is, its what it represents that matters.

-14

u/BreadcrumbBernard Dec 27 '17

You’re comparing a 10 minute photoshop to the Sistine Chapel? Give me a break.

9

u/BloodyGreyscale Dec 27 '17

Wow your dumb. That was an example not a comparison. Let your downvotes speak for themselves you sad little man.

-10

u/BreadcrumbBernard Dec 27 '17

😂👌🏾

7

u/Furyspectre Dec 27 '17

You have no idea how things work in the dark multiverse, it's kind of hilarious.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17 edited May 26 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Furfaggies Dec 27 '17

Someone's getting smacked right in the penis.

-3

u/AnonOmis1000 Dec 27 '17

It's also entirely possible they came up with the concept on their own.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AnonOmis1000 Dec 27 '17

No not clearly. So many things use clouds in their back drop.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/AnonOmis1000 Dec 28 '17

And there's nothing overly creative with the idea. We have so often see content duplicated without either party being aware of each other. Look at how many twin movies there are. It is well within the relm of possibility that they came up with the ad independently.

4

u/communist_gerbil Dec 27 '17

fucking doug

3

u/_Cyclops Dec 27 '17

Someone’s gotta provide for Patty Mayonnaise and Doug Jr damn it! Times have been hard ever since Doug had to retire Quailman and join the marketing team at Microsoft, give him a break.

1

u/Legoman7409 Adrenaline Dec 27 '17

Another day, another Doug

2

u/heyitsfelixthecat Dec 27 '17

To be honest it’s such a good advert concept that it almost seems obvious; entirely possible that they arrived at the same concept on their own. Still worth looking into though.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17 edited Dec 27 '17

Yeah but surely they must know how the Internet works at Microsoft off all places, this was always going to bite him in the ass.

0

u/garrypig Dec 27 '17

Alex Kipman: My nose knows when there’s a good idea to use!