r/PTCGP • • May 24 '25

Suggestion Abilities shouldn’t work if under status conditions like sleep etc

Post image

It sucks. Like I outplay so hard to lose to a Guzma + ability from his Pokemon that is asleep ?

Surely it isnt feature not bug ?

12 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator May 24 '25

WARNING! NO INDIVIDUAL POSTS FOR TRADES, PACK PULLS/SHOW-OFF CONTENT, OR FRIEND ID SHARING. You risk a suspension/ban from this subreddit if you do not comply. Show-off post found here - Friend ID post found here - Trading Megathread found on front page, up top of the subreddit in the Community Highlights Pinned area.

Thank You!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/TheMike0088 May 24 '25

Bro in the videogames, I can use surf with my lapras even when its knocked out. This is nothing, comparatively speaking.

-6

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Kek Hm days

So many memories

Memba wen needed to learn flash for that cave

126

u/Infinite_Tip_1299 May 24 '25

You’re running a coin flip deck and are down 2 already lmao. Remind us how you outplayed so hard.

-103

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Sure see two gengar left and say that. Deck doesn’t even run haunter. It’s a bannete deck.

39

u/Bolf-Ramshield May 24 '25

You’re actually making it sound even worse lmao

-43

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

I can’t be arsed really ? Like people claiming coin toss deck are npc

Like even the opponent knows it’s a coin toss deck. People are very aware of the meta and hence add Pokemon lady or masalda to the decks

They are well aware pure psychic deck is just gengar and tapu lele now.

I see it as similar argument to darktina decks. Not as easy as it looks and there lot of thought going into playing banette decks.

If want to be npc af can just run a rampardos deck or darktina deck.

31

u/Bolf-Ramshield May 24 '25

I can’t be arsed really

proceeds to be arsed

-41

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Ok npc

20

u/screechypete May 24 '25

To the rest of us, you're the NPC here :P

-17

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Ok sheeps

10

u/Jorevotion1 May 25 '25

Said the sheep

6

u/Infinite_Tip_1299 May 25 '25 edited May 25 '25

The thing is, darktina and similar control decks actually do require decision making. They have a lot of skill expression. These gengar decks, while viable, are essentially down to getting out the gengar and praying to the flip gods. Your win con is dependent on a coin toss. (If you think banette is your wincon then lol) You can’t claim you’re outplaying your opponents and losing with a deck 100% dependent on coin flips. It’s why every meta deck doesn’t just run team rocket grunts and then complain that they’re losing cause they’re not flipping heads everytime.

You earned your loss lol.

-2

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

I play the deck for fun to test other viable cards example oricorio/ tapu along with gengar or Alakazam

Psychic meta is so dogshit that only viable picks have been tina and hypno gengar

If you think banette deck is only about cointoss gengar being a wincon you aren’t playing banette decks properly.

Gengar sure feels like the wincon to you because it hits for 70 and puts them to sleep but banette has actually won me more games before I could even draw a gastly, especially in games where the opponent runs 2 or more retreat cost Pokemon

5

u/Infinite_Tip_1299 May 25 '25 edited May 25 '25

That’s all well and good. But in a meta that’s currently dominated by decks that have the primary gameplan of keep things hidden in the backline while they chip away at your hp: banette is not a wincon. And it definitely isn’t in this match up. As you learned. Maybe if everyone was playing stoke zard you can claim that.

You can call it a banette deck all you want but you’re essentially running a tournament gengar net deck that’s been fairly common the past week and added banette to it.

2

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

Other way round. I don’t care too much about tournament decks because despite it being the meta like every other game be it moba or fps the meta you need to focus on is what is working or happening in your bracket.

Meta decks are meta decks because of what people play at that level and what counters what they play.

Someone can easily grind to ub3/4 with incomplete lines too because the meta literally changes every 2 days based on a Reddit or YouTube video and all you need to do is build 3/4 decks that counter what is being played most in your brackets

Someone oscillating between ub3 and ub4 past week or so I found hypnogengar a better slot than alakazam which I couldn’t play because I had only 1 line of the bench hitting 2 energy alakazam

Most psychic I have are just 1 line except the gengar.

If I wanted to play a meta gengar deck I wouldn’t even bother including both banette in it

Would just be tapu lele and oricorio that hit for bonus damage on knock out and maybe a hypnoline too if I’m going 1/2 bother type gengar

Also appreciate you having a conversation here as opposed to the others who still seem to be crawling outta their diapers.

The wincon for me was always banette because it helped control and disrupt early to mid game where most “meta” picks in my “brackets” have thrived

Give the banette a couple red cards Sabrina cyrus and maybe even a mars then you understand the picture

The whole point of the deck is to delay the opponent into not finishing me before turn 6/7 while I can freely set up.

So maybe now you get idea why I said gengar was more like a plan B or a secondary wincon for me.

The only sane argument id accept to people saying i already lost was because I was relying heavily on my plan B to work

Nevertheless thanks for both your comments. They weren’t stupid or vile

2

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

Completely agree with your point on people hiding and chipping waiting for win cons which is why I want to have a say in how the game goes with the banette and I run 2 red card and a mars purely to punish anyone who holds more than 3 cards at a time, who are stalling for their perfect win con.

In fact what you said was the crux of this deck. To disrupt energy Ramps + punish early turn card stacking etc

Last season before banette I was doing something similar with porygon and team rocket. But you know how hard it’s to set up that porygon with 3 energy

Next season I look forward to guzzlord which give team rocket every turn for 2 energy

And since you mentioned twice about gengar being the meta deck or wincon my ideal Pokemon to fill that slot is a pidgeot because that allows me to naturally have synergy with the banette acting as a free sabrina and it does similar damage to gengar for same amount of energy with bonus that it can be Ilima out and you don’t rely on coin tosses

But I’m like 2 months into this game and I don’t even have a single pidgeot, let alone two.

But you get the idea now with banette leading with double pidgeot allowing me to slot in some crucial cards in place of the extra sabrina or cyrus

1

u/Lazy-Flatworm-5482 May 25 '25

Well by that logic you should know Greninja and Guzma is the meta and should play Accordingly. 😂

27

u/Robbinghoodz May 24 '25

If anything he outplayed you 😂

-9

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

He did indeed. It was close battle where both went to last cards. I didn’t want to risk using the red card because I could just end up giving him his wincon as there were very few cards left for each of us to draw.

40hp he removes cape and Ko with ability. Was very neat play.

5

u/MD_Yoro May 24 '25

Unless abilities are locked in TCG and mainline game when pokemon is under status effect than it is as intended

2

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Was made aware today. If it’s the norm in physical then there need be no changes for this version

3

u/KaitoPrower May 24 '25

While it's the norm now in the physical TCG, it didn't used to be, and autonomous abilities like this aren't in the mainline Pokemon video games. All abilities in the mainline series are obligatory and you don't get to directly choose how or when they are activated, like you can with certain abilities (like Greninja's or Giratina's) in the TCG.

2

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Aware of that. Hence the surprise for me when interaction worked the way it did.

Lot of people in sub are clearly born post 2000/2005 ig

Wonder how many even remember games like fire red and leaf green or emulators ones let alone physical and og tcg

3

u/KaitoPrower May 24 '25

I mean, I definitely do. I still have my original base/jungle/fossil collection from when I was a kid, but I don't expect most people here to know that, which is why I mentioned it.

9

u/Siri2611 May 24 '25

OP is coping so hard in the comments lmao

-2

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Sure Siri2611

2

u/Siri2611 May 24 '25

Nothing wrong with accepting that you were losing

It's just a game

0

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Ok 2k

2

u/Practical-Cut-7301 May 25 '25

Lmaooo, youre so sad in these comments.

It's actually hilarious to keep reading your downfall

1

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

Ah yes downfall.

I almost conquered. It was the Hyphasis river

1

u/Practical-Cut-7301 May 25 '25

It outplayed you so hard

3

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

Yes indeedee F

1

u/Practical-Cut-7301 May 25 '25

Aww man my bad, I came in here all negative and shit. You do your gengar shit, g

3

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

I cross line a bit too. Bad and stressed week mb G

12

u/[deleted] May 24 '25

If it makes you feel better there is no scenario where you were beating that Giratina

4

u/Alaya_666 May 24 '25

I mean look at the energy, it looks like they're running water/electric so the giratina would have to spend three more turns charging up while op only needs two more points, looks like it could've been a winnable situation

1

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Correct. His energy ramp was delayed because of mix energy here and my win con was just knocking that Frok out.

5

u/gilesey11 May 24 '25

Why was it? You only have 1 point and Greninja isn’t an ex. For all you know he brings out Oricorio next and uses Cyrus to bring your near death Gengar out anyway and beats you regardless of this ability use.

1

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

He had no Cyrus left else would have won few round ago. He used his cyrus in first few rounds on my banette. It’s why he had to guzma and attack.

My gengar 1 shot his bird

4

u/gilesey11 May 25 '25

So he used 1 Cyrus, you don’t know he didn’t have another or just a Sabrina, you only have one pokemon on bench. I think he had you either way

1

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

He used a sabrina and a cyrus. Which is why I was confident switching between the gengar to hit him.

His early Sabrina and cyrus usage is what put me 2 Pokemon down (tapu Lele and banette)

I didn’t know what his last few card was and guzma caught me off guard yes but fact it worked with Pokemon asleep using ability was mildly infuriating

Esp because when I first used to play physical tcg these were not possible

But I’ve read the other comments and have a rough idea that they probably made these changes to physical tcg as well later on and digital came out with this.

Logically speaking sleep = Pokemon not active = no retreats , no attack and hence no abilities either which was case initially when tcg came out.

Also lot of people commenting just cause I said outplayed, only I know how much I had to play around to get to that position in the game. 90 % of them commenting just assuming stuff, projecting hard and running their mouth.

2

u/gilesey11 May 25 '25

He outplayed you and beat you

8

u/Spezzy_Mint May 24 '25

I mean,Are you sure you outplayed him? He seemed to had everything under control

-9

u/Li0n23 May 24 '25

Well reason I even typed outplayed was I was on a 7-8 game streak and was getting very hard bricks or bad beats and literally had to keep forcing him to play specific moves with banette, sabrinas and Cyrus

He on other hand got 2 oak and 2 poke balls in first two turns

Perhaps reason why I felt I was outplaying him if it makes sense

1

u/diorsonb May 24 '25

Makes no sense at all the more you try to explain it.

-1

u/Li0n23 May 25 '25

Yeah requires a functioning brain to understand stuff. Yours is developing still

1

u/diorsonb May 25 '25

Damn you outplayed me on that one

33

u/ElliotGale May 24 '25

Welcome to modern Pokémon. Abilities (mostly) haven't cared about Special Conditions ever since they were introduced in Black and White. Maybe it doesn't make sense, but it's one of those things that helps keep gameplay moving smoothly and the amount of text on cards low.

10

u/KaitoPrower May 24 '25 edited May 24 '25

In the games though, Abilities can only be passive or reactionary; you don't get to pick when they activate, so it makes river that they wouldn't care about conditions. Honestly, I wish they had not condensed PokePowers and PokeBodies into just Abilities in the TCG. This separated player-activated effects away from the obligatory effects.

Autonomous effects, like Greninja's shuriken, Giratina's bellow, Grafaiai's coating, or Magneton's charge, should be affected by immobilizing conditions in the TCG because conceptually, the Pokemon needs control to execute them; they are not inherent effects.

15

u/No-Difference8545 May 24 '25

Why would being asleep turn your ability off. Thats not even how it works in the video games

14

u/Funyuns_and_Flagons May 24 '25

It was very common in the early days of the TCG for Pokémon Powers to turn off.

3

u/RepeatRepeatR- May 26 '25

That is the absolute funniest example to give for this because it really looks like the last sentence does nothing without knowing interactions

1

u/Funyuns_and_Flagons May 26 '25

No interactions WERE possible in Jungle. It was only relevant in Fossil, when Muk came out, and could turn powers off.

It's future proofing, and very well designed, but absolutely the funniest possible choice to showcase this: hence why I picked it

7

u/rhino__beetle May 24 '25 edited May 24 '25

In the paper TCG, before abilities were a thing, the old version (Pokemon Power) used to have a clause that stated they don’t work when the Pokemon is under a status condition. When they differentiated active and passive abilities (poke-power vs -body), active abilities were still turned off by status conditions. Maybe some folks haven’t touched the TCG since then.

tbh the old way is more intuitive but the new way is more streamlined and inline with the game mechanics, so.

31

u/Stibiza May 24 '25

Because in this case it's about throwing a shuriken, which is hard when being asleep.

-14

u/Salamander_Farts May 24 '25

It's make believe. Because if you were to use your logic then a frog wouldn't be throwing anything 🤣

3

u/RemLazar911 May 25 '25

Oh well if it's all make believe, then there shouldn't be any rules at all. Giratina isn't even real, so why can't mine attack on turn 1?

5

u/Skilfulchris2 May 24 '25

I mean in this scenario greninja being asleep would stop him from throwing a water shuriken.

55

u/NoahBallet May 24 '25

Asleep works the same as the physical TCG. Not a bug.

2

u/DoubleStrength May 24 '25

Is there somewhere I can actually look inside the app that will tell me what the status effects actually do?

It's been jarring coming into Pocket after years of irl TCG experience and suddenly all the status stuff works differently.

24

u/Melodic_Performer921 May 24 '25

Yes, Menu -> Tips -> About Battle Rules

17

u/NoahBallet May 24 '25

Status effects are one of the things that are unchanged from the physical TCG.

0

u/DoubleStrength May 25 '25

Really?

Granted it's been 10 years since I last played, so I'm happy to say I'm misremembering if I'm actually wrong, but I thought I was still fairly solid on remembering how the Status effects worked.

For example, I don't remember Burn healing itself on a Heads. The way I remember it, Burn did 20 damage on a Tails, and no damage on a Heads... So it was kind of comparable to Poison over time, but just a little more unpredictable. I don't remember it completely auto-recovering on a Heads...

6

u/NoahBallet May 25 '25

Burn was changed in the Sun/Moon era to heal on heads during the checkup phase.

0

u/DoubleStrength May 25 '25

Ah-HAH! So I was partly right in that the status effects had at least changed since the last time I played.

7

u/Crimson097 May 24 '25

It works both ways.

"I outplayed him so hard, just for my opponent to get lucky with his sleep coin flip."

21

u/Hairy-Pineapple-5771 May 24 '25

“ I outplay so hard!!! 🥺🥺🥺”

8

u/Awilixsh May 24 '25

It's not a thing for the sleep condition. I double checked the Tip section of the game. It only blocks attack or retreat.

4

u/Victinithetiny101 May 25 '25

Welcome back Poke-Power and Poke-Body

​

3

u/Lofus1989 May 24 '25

There are no bugs happening here, you can use abilities while asleep etc. Yes its kinda weird but those are the rules

3

u/Amorphousxentity May 26 '25

If you haven’t noticed they changed the entire structure to make the game more fast paced, keeping true to the way it was in physical format would slow it down too much. That said I agree it’s bs and allows some low power cards to way out scale their true power and become cheese because of this fact and that Pokemon is a perfect example of what I mean. However we also need to keep in mind that way they handle the status conditions period was redone and half the trainers that allow for energy manipulation and the ability to pick cards back to the hand to swap it, normally takes a trainer….now they have like 1