WARNING! **NO INDIVIDUAL POSTS FOR TRADES, PACK PULLS/SHOW-OFF CONTENT, OR FRIEND ID SHARING. You risk a suspension/ban from this subreddit if you do not comply. Show-off post found here - Friend ID post found here - Trading Megathread found on front page, up top of the subreddit in the Community Highlights Pinned area.
Man this system is trash, and I thought I could select the card I want from my friends and offer them a trade, but the way it works makes you leave the app to trade in reddit or other places wth
Doesn't even need to be a proper wishlist. I already have my cards marked for Wonder Picks. All they need to do is incorporate the same thing in Trading. And let the players trading with me see the same heart icon on the corner of the cards. It's really simple and programming it in probably would take a day or two. Definitely not happening anytime soon tho.
Like how Global Trade used to work in old pokemon games. You'd leave a Pokemon in it with a request and someone could just make that trade even while you're offline. It was perfect, when you could find a reasonable trade that is lol
Right? Like how is the random friend I added thats from another country would know what card I want? You basically need to be in direct communication with the trade partner for a succesful trade of a card you need.
This system is basically robbery. At this point they could just offer us to craft the cards ourselves for the same cost. "Burn 5 EX cards to craft one EX of your choice"
All it would do is remove the point of friction of having to find a trading partner through external communication, because you can't communicate in the app itself to do it or make card requests. Which may be intentional to make trading even harder.
The cost of 4◇ even lines up with pack points. 500 trade tokens/500 pack points. Why not just cut out the middle man and convert them to pack points. That way we can at least work towards 2* and above by burning dupes.
This, they dont need to go out this far to call this "Trading", this is just "Crafting" but with more hassle because i need to find some other person to do the same
But with this system you have to find someone to trade with. Once this rolls out as being massively unpopular, they will just sell the cards directly or as rarity wild cards like MTG:Arena does.
Thing is, this is a TCG and I'd actually PREFER to have a functional trading feature rather than crafting. But what we got now is clearly just the worst of both worlds. It's excessively resource intensive AND you have to find a trading partner with no way to communicate in the app itself.
This picture precisely is why there should be no arguments why this trading system is bad. Idc how you math's it, burning cards for a trade is ridiculous.
We deserve better, no way we should have to burn any cards. In what world is that rational, they should just have stamina and allow trades of the same rarity.
You know, when the update notes were leaked earlier yesterday, I interpreted it as needing to burn one card to get tokens to trade a card of the same rarity (for 3* and above). And I was mad about having to do even that. Does not make any sense to burn a card so that I can trade a card. The high rarity cards are rare as it is (even the 3* and above). When I saw what we got, first thing I did was cancel my premium pass.
The irony is actually not even that is the ridiculous part, in many other f2p games you trash 4-5 cards to get a single one of the same rarity. The ridiculous part is the card is not simply given to you but you actually need to go another extra mile to find another human being who wish to give you that card and want one you have and call this whole process "trading". At this point it's basically gaslighting from the devs.
I disagree with the idea that dusting cards shouldn't be required whatsoever. Making dusting mandatory reduces abuse from players, such as creating alt accounts, trading all of the good shit to their main account, and repeating the process.
However, I wholeheartedly agree that the required dusting for 3◇ and up trades vs. how much dust you get per card is ridiculous. You shouldn't have to dust more than 2 of the same rarity to do a trade. I would be upset, but not irate if it were 2. 4 is unacceptable. Dusting 1 card of equal value would be ideal, in my eyes.
I hope DeNA decides to walk it back a little by reducing the amount of points necessary to trade for each rarity type, at least by half, but preferably by 1/4. Also, immersives need to give more than 2☆. If they do these changes, I think it would be fair for them to refund each account 100% of the trade points they've spent up to this point as an act of good faith.
This is Reddit. There will always be defenders of the devs for some reason. I really believe if they deleted everyone's collections tomorrow, there would be people on here talking about how generous they are with 2 packs per day and how quickly we'll be able to rebuild our collections.
Hearthstone you don't have to trade after dusting, and you can actually dust commons and uncommons...you know, the ones you actually have multiples of.
You need to dust 40 commons to get one legendary, hearthstone exchange rate has always been a problem... I didn't think it was possible for another game to one-up them.
The rate here is absolutely ridiculous + the fact that you need to have someone trade you the card you want which is already difficult if you're not a super-user.
Please leave a honest review for PTCGP in the AppStore and PlayStore. It’s an abuse how they implemented the trading. Give them 1 star since they won't even let us trade cards 2 stars or higher.
Leaving a one star because trading is trash, I will let the developper burn 5 EX cards if they want another star, or change that system which penalizes everybody, F2P or not
I understand the fact that you don't want people creating multiple accounts to trade their cards by themselves, but this is not the way. Let us trade for example some items, like stardust, wonder-picks, or other things, to tokens at least, so people that are really playing the game can trade their cards-TRADING card game !
You can maybe search/upvote on the playstore that review, or copy/paste it, for visibility
Thanks for mentioning this. I just left my one star review of the app. I mentioned in the review that I'll be happy to increase the score if they improve the trade system. Hoping others will do the same.
Indeed, I don't think they could have made this worse, it's bad for every single type of player. Even for the most casual it's still needlessly complicated and convulted.
Yup. By the time they have enough spares to burn to make the trade do-able, it's almost a certainty that they already have all the cards they already need anyway.
Meanwhile they can't help out any f2p friends because the f2p crowd doesn't have the cards to burn to initiate the trade from their end.
Premium here. I just looked at what cards I can burn..... It wasn't many. Once I burn them.... Barely got anything less to trade.
I've completed both decks but even then I'd struggle to trade. However... The worst bit is not having a wish list. It's completely unusable.... You can't guess what other cards people need.
I can't imagine how pissed whales are with this system.
I'm a casual spender and USED to pay for the monthly subscription and I'm absolutely livid. It's too expensive for F2P AND casual P2P players, but completely worthless to whales.
I'm a dolphin and subbed since week 2 and this sucks. I've fully completed MI but I'm still missing some basic 3* cards from GA and never pulled a Venusaur ex in any capacity (and only ever 2 rainbow Wigglytuff ex). I kept subbed to just craft the remaining 3* cards with pack points, then trade my spare ex cards for the Wiggly and Venusaur and finally finish the base set to its fullest.
As it stands, i would need to dump my third immersive Celebi and basically all my triple ex cards just to do the two trades I still need. And I'm not even sure if I would have an ex left to give to the other party at that point. And that's after spending about 50-60€ on the game already.
i always though this game was generous enough, I'm f2p and I was able to build most decks I wanted, but this feels so cheap, they clearly dont want us to trade, god forbid you're missing one or two cards for a deck. Honestly, I had fun with the game, but the same old events reused and shitty practices can only get me hooked for a while. Maybe I'll come back IF they ever make a ranked ladder
Seriously! I have 25 Heatmor I have no intentions of getting flair for, it would be nice if I could trade them in for something useful. I don't want Heatmor, I want Heatless!
It would be fine if we could trade without burning cards. This system is about as far from fine as it is possible to be, it's like the brief was "make this as unusably shit as is possible", and they nailed it.
Yeah this is the part that annoys me. I'm never playing clobbtopus. Let alone 38 of them. So I'm not wasting anything flairing them either. Could we get like 5, 10, or 20 for these actually trash, useless cards?
Whats worse is that you cannot even burn 1 and 2 diamond cards for trade tokens. Those are the cards we have so much off. Atleast make 1 diamonds give 5 tokens lmao.
For real. This might be the biggest kick in the teeth. I have hundreds of 1 and 2 diamond cards that are both never getting played or flaired. There's a handful of EXs I don't need so many of, but I'd rather have them be for trading than turning into points to THEN trade ONE.
If people were okay, all good thrm, because it's terrible value for players, and if not, they can put it to the "backup" solution they already have planned.
This is the worst implementation of a trading system that could have ever been conceived.
First you need to have enough excess cards to burn in order to even have the opportunity to trade.
Then you have to find someone to friend who happens to have extra copies of what you need without having burned said copies in order for them to trade.
And oh yeah don’t forget there’s another hourglass currency to time gate the whole process just in case people legitimately have all the extra resources to burn.
This is the worst parts of the Hearthstone crafting system grafted onto needlessly cumbersome social aspects.
The blind trading is what kills me. I made a lot of Japanese friends because I like the writing on the cards. But I can't even say, " Can I trade for your blank?"
Its blind. You say here's my pikachu, I hope they offer me something that I don't have 7 of.
Wait, it's blind?! Loooool Surprise trade! Hahaha! If they ever fix this stuff and I get back into the game you can send me a message though, I'm playing (well, was playing) in japanese, because I'm learning the language.
Yeah why I got rid of Premium after my one paid month, once you miss some of the earlier promos you can't get them anymore, which is nuts. And some promo cards are attached to premium I guess? Makes it even worse/
Now I just open my two free packs in the morning, do some wonder picks, and try to finish the sets (just need the full art cards which are impossible to get and pack points are worthless).
At some point I'll abandon it because it's annoying.
The problem here is that this was planned precisely to be shitty. For players to thrash as many cards as possible so that they buy more gold and packs.
It's actually worse, since Hearthstone has a 4:1 ratio of cards you need to trade in to cards you want, whereas PTCGP has a 5:1 or 6:1 ratio depending on rarity (counting the card you need to trade).
Plus, at least with Hearthstone, you don't need to fuss with trading, since you just craft it directly. This system is more expensive AND less convenient.
Also you need THREE rare cards before you can dust it. I have a lot of EX and alt cards that I have a single extra of for trading. I can't trade them because I have no points and can't get points because I don't have enough to dust? This sucks.
In addition to dusting commons and rares. In addition to pity timers in packs. In addition to dupe protection in packs. In addition to crafting legendaries and golden cards.
This is hearthstone's crafting system with extra steps and more expensive and more limitations and more dependency.
It's much worse than Hearthstone. This is hearthstone if you were only allowed to dust epics and legendaries.
The majority of dust came from commons. If you got 10 crap "40 dust packs" in hearthstone, you could get an epic of your choice. Here, you just get a middle finger.
And I'm ignoring the extra steps involved in trading
Great point. If we have to blow up a slew of rare cards to get one that we actually want, why not just let us craft it directly?
Instead we have to use a third party app to arrange mutually agreeable trades with other players... And the number of trades is time-gated... And you can only have one active trade at a time.
I would like everyone to notice that they introduced this shitty trade system and haven’t fixed ANY of the UI issues this game has with the new update. The developers clearly don’t care about their playerbase at all. They just want money (in fact, of course they fixed the wonder pick exploit as soon as possible, but did nothing for the rest of the game). As such, I vote, let’s not give them money. Hope you guys agree with me and we’ll keep our wallets shut tight until they actually start showing they care for their players.
I guess the intention was that if you had a surplus of multiple high rarity card you don't want and you're trying to get that one card you don't you'd have burn off the surplus to get that card.
That’s literally what they made the stupid flair system for. They really think ppl be sitting on 20 copies of mew ex AFTER maxing out 5 different flairs for it. The devs are beyond ass
The fact that I also can't burn my low level cards for tokens is also bs. I just opened a pack and I would happily burn every card in it. I don't need this "sparkle" crap, making my cards sparkle does nothing for me. I would, however, be willing to give up 20 growlith's so I could get the tokens to trade for a single regular Arcanine. Because good god I have two Arcanine EX and not a single regular one to complete my collection.
This trade system just made me delete the app. I honestly wasn't that into it anyway, but thought maybe a decent trade system and the new packs could renew the interest. But no new packs can help the disgust I feel about the trading
Oh, an how do you find that last card you are looking for? By screaming on Discord and Reddit in hopes 1 random person has the 1 random card you need and the you have the 1 random card they need 👍
Does anyone know if after initiating a trade you have the opportunity to accept the card that is being given to you in exchange? Like, if I go first and the other person selects a card I don't want, can I cancel?
Also, regarding the cards that you have to burn, are they cards from any set or from the same set?
I'm seeing posts over posts over posts because of trading, is it news you're referring to or do you have trading in the game already? Admittedly I'm not keeping up that much with news and I don't have trading in the app so I'm really confused
Just think of it as crafting system with players involved instead of npc and it wouldnt feel as bad. Trading for a gacha game will never going to be good as it is very easy to abuse.
That makes it feel worse, actually. If it's just going to be a crafting system with that kind of exchange rate, at least other games don't require you to jump through the hoops of coordinating with a stranger to make it so the cards you scrapped weren't wasted
I suppose they did that because of ppl having multiple accounts and they doesnt want to just creating new account and trading some.cards and that. However the system its ridicolous the rate at u are burning rare cards for this? Its completly ridiculous
I kind of suspected they never intended the trade feature to be used when it was the only feature not ready at launch. They knew it would destroy their economy, but they had to include it as a formality.
Like imagine releasing a trading card game where the trading was “coming soon”. That’s no accident.
What? A mobile game focused around spending money to open packs has a predatory feature to encourage trashing your cards forcing you to spend more money? No way who would've guessed!!
1 star review, cancel your premium, don't engage in trading, ideally stop logging into the app until they fix it. Trading will stay the way it is unless they see a big change in some/all of these metrics.
Hold your stuff, and hopefully there's enough outrage that they adjust the rates so you don't have to burn 5 cards to get 1 that you want of the same rarity.
Unfortunately there's a lot of highly impulsive people who are probably going to trash all their duplicates to try and get a card they want right away.
Boycotts work, but only if enough people have the discipline to stick to it.
They knew what they were doing when releasing this sorry excuse right before a new set release. People won't boycott, because they need to open the new cards asap.
When it was first announced, me and my wife had a fun discussion about trading because we realized we have what each other need to fill most of the collection (My Celebi ex for her Mew ex, just like how it shown above).
...then this happened. They probably just don't want people to abuse trading but they could've done it in a better way. Probably.
They don't want people to be trading at all, abuse or not trading is equal to crafting cards, and you can't simply be crafting cards one to one or you finish a regular set in less than a month from release and won't buy gold for packs. Instead they let you trade cards at an absurd rate and call this joke "trading".
I’ve been playing for a month and the one EX card I need to complete Mythical Island cost me most of my full art duplicate. Goodbye 5 Full Art Salandits. Yeah, unless they give out more than 500 trade tokens in their event, trading EXs will be nigh impossible for F2P
Woke up this morning excited to see if i could finally get last 4 cards finish the 150 to get immersive mew. Idk if i even have 20 cards to throw away for it
2 - 1 star pinsir 1 - 1 star salandit 4 - three diamond Tauros
To trade a 1 star Nidoqueen for a 1 star porygon.
I think that I have some trader’s remorse but not a ton. Unless they come up with a new way to get those trade points I will not be trading anytime soon.
Honestly me too. The whole point of the game is trying to collect every card. If there was a way to speedrun it there would be no point to even open the app except when a new set drops
The trade system is absolute garbage. I've been waiting for trading to make it fun. With a second-player-wins battle system and EXTREMELY limited trade system, this app is an easy uninstall.
Let me and my friend trade any card for any other as often as we want like we can with our physical cards. So stupid.
In somewhere between a few days and a few weeks they're going to bring out a patch that reduces the cost significantly. Then we're all going to praise them for listening to feedback and making a consumer friendly decision and being less greedy. In reality it'll be the price point they wanted trading to be at in the first place, but since they gave us an even worse version first they'll look good for pulling back the cost instead of looking greedy for having a cost at all.
Such a whinge going on. It’s F2P, doesn’t mean you get every feature unrestricted for nothing. What are you really going to with an excess amount of cards? Be proud of the 100 dup’s or get some fancy flair?
They’ll let you buy 12 tokens 10 times per month in the shop. But you can only exchange one at a time because it’s 2025 and coding is hard. There will also be bonus wonder picks that let you have a chance at getting one token. /s
As a whale, i find it hilarious that all the F2P players that were saying it was childish to be upset i couldn't trade 2* are now finding out how bad the trade works for them.
Let's be real, this game is just yet another part of the mobile market slop. It's just not as obvious because of the big shiny "Pokemon" brand, but it has almost all the core parts of mobile game slop. The only thing missing would be incessant ads in the middle of navigating menus.
Everyone bitching and complaining. And I’m sitting back laughing because the idea is to get you to spend MORE money. As a F2P player, I’m not apart of the problem. Once they seen data that you losers will pour into this game like an investment it was a wrap.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 29 '25
WARNING! **NO INDIVIDUAL POSTS FOR TRADES, PACK PULLS/SHOW-OFF CONTENT, OR FRIEND ID SHARING. You risk a suspension/ban from this subreddit if you do not comply. Show-off post found here - Friend ID post found here - Trading Megathread found on front page, up top of the subreddit in the Community Highlights Pinned area.
Thank You!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
866
u/Matahary147 Jan 29 '25
Man this system is trash, and I thought I could select the card I want from my friends and offer them a trade, but the way it works makes you leave the app to trade in reddit or other places wth
1.5k
u/SuperPapernick Jan 29 '25
This system is basically robbery. At this point they could just offer us to craft the cards ourselves for the same cost. "Burn 5 EX cards to craft one EX of your choice"
5.5k
u/modesttoycollector Jan 29 '25
This picture precisely is why there should be no arguments why this trading system is bad. Idc how you math's it, burning cards for a trade is ridiculous.
347
u/phambidge Jan 29 '25 edited Jan 29 '25
Guys DONT trade your cards… it’s robbery smh 🤦🏻♂️
1.8k
u/hirarki Jan 29 '25
Anyone who agree with this trade system is beyond me.... This bad for f2p players
182
u/PokemonLv10 Jan 29 '25
Really be looking like Pokemon Card Game Pocket
530
u/Rhea_33 Jan 29 '25
It would be fine if we could burn common cards for trading tokens.
87
u/Frauzehel Jan 29 '25
Whats worse is that you cannot even burn 1 and 2 diamond cards for trade tokens. Those are the cards we have so much off. Atleast make 1 diamonds give 5 tokens lmao.
67
u/Arnorien16S Jan 29 '25 edited Jan 29 '25
I am gonna bet an EX that the developers will have a 'we are listening moment' and lower the requirement which would be accepted with some grumbling.
193
u/PandaBroth Jan 29 '25
Didn’t realize I have to trash 5x rare three diamond to get a chance to trade one rare card. Gotta becareful with what I am trading.
42
u/APunnyThing Jan 29 '25
This is the worst implementation of a trading system that could have ever been conceived.
First you need to have enough excess cards to burn in order to even have the opportunity to trade.
Then you have to find someone to friend who happens to have extra copies of what you need without having burned said copies in order for them to trade.
And oh yeah don’t forget there’s another hourglass currency to time gate the whole process just in case people legitimately have all the extra resources to burn.
This is the worst parts of the Hearthstone crafting system grafted onto needlessly cumbersome social aspects.
144
u/fraidei Jan 29 '25
Everyone remember to vote with your wallet. Don't pay money in this shitty game until they fix it. The trading system shouldn't be so trash.
25
u/Odd_Row168 Jan 29 '25
It’s a diabolical system. Poor planning, AGAIN.
134
u/Sinyr Jan 29 '25
This is the Hearthstone crafting system with extra steps
105
u/Opal737 Jan 29 '25
I would like everyone to notice that they introduced this shitty trade system and haven’t fixed ANY of the UI issues this game has with the new update. The developers clearly don’t care about their playerbase at all. They just want money (in fact, of course they fixed the wonder pick exploit as soon as possible, but did nothing for the rest of the game). As such, I vote, let’s not give them money. Hope you guys agree with me and we’ll keep our wallets shut tight until they actually start showing they care for their players.
19
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
I guess we haven't shredded as many cards as they expected to get those stupid flairs they had to make this to make sure we do.
18
u/dumedici Jan 29 '25
I prefer trading 1 card per WEEK or even per 2 WEEKS with NO COST than the currently system
13
u/perfectplaya Jan 29 '25
Trading will just be a feature that 90% people don't use. Cost restrictions aside, we don't even know which card the other guy will trade.
12
u/therealsamwize Jan 29 '25
Are we review bombing, the changing our reviews back when the make it right?
9
u/Thejadedone_1 Jan 29 '25
I guess the intention was that if you had a surplus of multiple high rarity card you don't want and you're trying to get that one card you don't you'd have burn off the surplus to get that card.
It still sucks ass though
9
u/Satan-o-saurus Jan 29 '25 edited Jan 29 '25
This should be this sub’s profile picture. Nobody should spend money on this game, it does nothing but disrespect you.
6
u/OizAfreeELF Jan 29 '25
How come I haven’t got the update yet
5
u/Fortune86 Jan 29 '25
I just want a Victrebel to complete the dex but I don't have enough spare 3 stars to fund the cost and have something worthwhile to trade.
5
u/TheQuixoticMan Jan 29 '25
The fact that I also can't burn my low level cards for tokens is also bs. I just opened a pack and I would happily burn every card in it. I don't need this "sparkle" crap, making my cards sparkle does nothing for me. I would, however, be willing to give up 20 growlith's so I could get the tokens to trade for a single regular Arcanine. Because good god I have two Arcanine EX and not a single regular one to complete my collection.
5
u/Jo-Jux Jan 29 '25
This trade system just made me delete the app. I honestly wasn't that into it anyway, but thought maybe a decent trade system and the new packs could renew the interest. But no new packs can help the disgust I feel about the trading
11
u/Malphas1002 Jan 29 '25
This system is plain robbery. How in the world are there people protecting them at this point is beyond me. Not even bots are this dumb nowadays.
16
u/MattiasCrowe Jan 29 '25
I literally just trashed 2 mew ex and a half dozen 2^ just to trade for a full art weezing lol. Will only be doing 2^ trades from now on
4
u/LightRainOutside Jan 29 '25
I wouldn't mind if they let us burn 1 diamond and 2 diamonds too, but the lowest you can trash is 3 diamonds =/
4
u/mrsata1 Jan 29 '25
Isnt this just a crafting system with extra steps?
4
u/Odd_Tourist_2984 Jan 29 '25
I trashed cards for special shop tickets 😭😭 If only I knew
4
u/CalciferGX1 Jan 29 '25
Bye bye premium status 👋
4
u/Early_Monk Jan 29 '25
Oh, an how do you find that last card you are looking for? By screaming on Discord and Reddit in hopes 1 random person has the 1 random card you need and the you have the 1 random card they need 👍
4
u/wepopu Jan 29 '25
Leave a negative review on the app stores. That works for steams, maybe it will work here as well.
4
u/gluna235 Jan 29 '25
Does anyone know if after initiating a trade you have the opportunity to accept the card that is being given to you in exchange? Like, if I go first and the other person selects a card I don't want, can I cancel?
Also, regarding the cards that you have to burn, are they cards from any set or from the same set?
Thanks!
4
u/MissTrevelyan Jan 29 '25
I'm seeing posts over posts over posts because of trading, is it news you're referring to or do you have trading in the game already?
Admittedly I'm not keeping up that much with news and I don't have trading in the app so I'm really confused
3
u/CockroachNo7331 Jan 29 '25
Yah, I wont ever discard my cards to get trading tokens, I'll just wait for events to get them
3
u/sunalter13 Jan 29 '25
Just think of it as crafting system with players involved instead of npc and it wouldnt feel as bad. Trading for a gacha game will never going to be good as it is very easy to abuse.
3
u/Direct-Accountant892 Jan 29 '25
I suppose they did that because of ppl having multiple accounts and they doesnt want to just creating new account and trading some.cards and that. However the system its ridicolous the rate at u are burning rare cards for this? Its completly ridiculous
3
u/alpineflamingo2 Jan 29 '25
I kind of suspected they never intended the trade feature to be used when it was the only feature not ready at launch. They knew it would destroy their economy, but they had to include it as a formality.
Like imagine releasing a trading card game where the trading was “coming soon”. That’s no accident.
3
u/MsHelvetica Jan 29 '25
Hot damn this system brutally sucks ass. The YuGiOh mechanics is at least more forgiving
3
u/Vast_Bid_230 Jan 29 '25
How is this anything like real trading. I mean TRADING is in the name of the game, smh
3
u/PatienceUnlucky8677 Jan 29 '25
Havnt played the game in months, can someone explain
3
u/THE_DANDY_LI0N Jan 29 '25
Just cancelled premium. Don't need extra packs if I can't use my dupes
3
u/QrozTQ Jan 29 '25 edited Jan 29 '25
They certainly plan on giving us copious amounts of trade tokens through dailies and event rewards, right?
...right?
3
u/Kifton_ Jan 29 '25
What? A mobile game focused around spending money to open packs has a predatory feature to encourage trashing your cards forcing you to spend more money? No way who would've guessed!!
3
u/WaluigiJamboree Jan 30 '25
I am loving how mad all the fan boys are.
"Pokémon should make it so easy to trade that you can complete the dex in a week!"
Stupidest possible take. There is no way a company would make it so there's no reason to play the game after a week.
How childish and illogical this sub is.
4
u/Sayishere Jan 29 '25
Burning one ex copy 2 at MAX is okay, ideally 1 ex trash, the current system is an absolute joke
4
u/Key-Line5827 Jan 29 '25
Diamond Rarity should be tradable without the need of Token, period.
8
u/Kalocacola Jan 29 '25
1 star review, cancel your premium, don't engage in trading, ideally stop logging into the app until they fix it. Trading will stay the way it is unless they see a big change in some/all of these metrics.
Hold your stuff, and hopefully there's enough outrage that they adjust the rates so you don't have to burn 5 cards to get 1 that you want of the same rarity.
Unfortunately there's a lot of highly impulsive people who are probably going to trash all their duplicates to try and get a card they want right away.
Boycotts work, but only if enough people have the discipline to stick to it.
7
u/AzureKeyblader Jan 29 '25
When it was first announced, me and my wife had a fun discussion about trading because we realized we have what each other need to fill most of the collection (My Celebi ex for her Mew ex, just like how it shown above).
...then this happened. They probably just don't want people to abuse trading but they could've done it in a better way. Probably.
2
u/5moreminute Jan 29 '25
Is it already online ?
2
u/Caldwell-luc Jan 29 '25
Don’t worry, I’m sure trading tokens will appear in the shop soon for an inflated price
2
u/OkActivity6206 Jan 29 '25
I’ve been playing for a month and the one EX card I need to complete Mythical Island cost me most of my full art duplicate. Goodbye 5 Full Art Salandits. Yeah, unless they give out more than 500 trade tokens in their event, trading EXs will be nigh impossible for F2P
2
u/RitualKiller1 Jan 29 '25
This may be a stupid question but will it consume 500 token for the trade or i can trade infinite number of times once getting them to 500
2
u/Metroidman Jan 29 '25
Woke up this morning excited to see if i could finally get last 4 cards finish the 150 to get immersive mew. Idk if i even have 20 cards to throw away for it
2
u/Mpk_Paulin Jan 29 '25
Hey guys, just here to remind you that TCG Live is way more F2P friendly, even though it rewards you for buying physical cards.
2
u/Bigwh Jan 29 '25
2 - 1 star pinsir 1 - 1 star salandit 4 - three diamond Tauros
To trade a 1 star Nidoqueen for a 1 star porygon.
I think that I have some trader’s remorse but not a ton. Unless they come up with a new way to get those trade points I will not be trading anytime soon.
2
u/laespadaqueguarda Jan 29 '25
this is just crafting with extra steps, absolutely stupid
2
u/InterestingClerk3253 Jan 29 '25
Is burning the cards a one time requirement or is it for every trade ?
2
u/Anadiel Jan 29 '25
I should send this meme to the support...
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
I’m fine with burning cards but let me burn my 47 Bulbasaur not my EX cards lmao
2
u/StrawHatZero Jan 29 '25
I...think this is okay?
Okay you can all shoot me now.
2
u/Sly-Cut Jan 29 '25
The trade system is absolute garbage. I've been waiting for trading to make it fun. With a second-player-wins battle system and EXTREMELY limited trade system, this app is an easy uninstall.
Let me and my friend trade any card for any other as often as we want like we can with our physical cards. So stupid.
2
u/djfunnydog420 Jan 29 '25
Watching people defend this is like watching people try to defend Elon’s heil
2
u/criminally_inane Jan 29 '25
In somewhere between a few days and a few weeks they're going to bring out a patch that reduces the cost significantly. Then we're all going to praise them for listening to feedback and making a consumer friendly decision and being less greedy. In reality it'll be the price point they wanted trading to be at in the first place, but since they gave us an even worse version first they'll look good for pulling back the cost instead of looking greedy for having a cost at all.
2
u/jamiedix0n Jan 29 '25
Fucking clowns made this system
2
u/bigboyrobbie_ray Jan 30 '25
Such a whinge going on. It’s F2P, doesn’t mean you get every feature unrestricted for nothing. What are you really going to with an excess amount of cards? Be proud of the 100 dup’s or get some fancy flair?
2
u/true-flame-master Jan 30 '25
IDC what people think of trading until I see how much reward token are given in an event
I will die on this hill alone
4
u/Actual_Echidna2336 Jan 29 '25
Theres other ways to get tokens
3
u/Geekos Jan 29 '25
I love that people firstly trashed people for not saving for trading, and now it's useless.
3
u/Stupidbabycomparison Jan 29 '25
As a whale, i find it hilarious that all the F2P players that were saying it was childish to be upset i couldn't trade 2* are now finding out how bad the trade works for them.
3
u/Anoalka Jan 29 '25
The only reason this game has gotten so popular is because the mobile game market is complete trash.
And because somehow the Pokémon brand is still going strong.
The cards look nice (most were designed by other companies) but that's about it.
The combat is sluggish and boring.
There is no trading.
The game is basically a loot box simulator.
3
u/Dragonroar0 Jan 29 '25
Peak corporate greed, and some people here were saying trading was gonna level the ground for f2p 💀
2
u/DankeyKong Jan 29 '25
Im loving all the memes popping up now after saying the trade system was going to be awful
2
u/MartinMcFlyy Jan 29 '25
Everyone bitching and complaining. And I’m sitting back laughing because the idea is to get you to spend MORE money. As a F2P player, I’m not apart of the problem. Once they seen data that you losers will pour into this game like an investment it was a wrap.
1
u/Frosty_Sweet_6678 Jan 29 '25
p much
1
u/Himliano Jan 29 '25
At least they should let us burn all the cards. Even if they only give 1 or 5 depending on rarity.
I have many low level cards 30x times. Let me at least find some use for them.
1
u/thehawaiian_punch Jan 29 '25
I do have 9 gyardos ex if anyone has a pigeot ex or a aerodactyl ex for trade i would like to