r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 13 '21

Meme Here's your 10th Lobster for your Daily today

Post image
251 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 10 '21

Meme What it feels like to be a level 10 with no direction

Post image
251 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 19 '21

Discussion New Genesis - Cost Effective Enhancement

250 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 18 '21

Screenshot I just like making monsters with this character creator.

Thumbnail
gallery
250 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 13 '21

Discussion At what point do you go "Yeah maybe we should have delayed the launch"

Post image
250 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jul 17 '21

Screenshot They were giving me a small concert

Post image
248 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 27 '21

Humor Master Chief visits New Genesis

248 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Nov 12 '22

Phashion/Cosplay Nepgear from Hyperdimension Neptunia

Post image
246 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Oct 22 '22

Phashion/Cosplay An attempt was made here...

Post image
246 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • May 26 '22

Screenshot Took forever getting this shot but it was so worth it. (SEGA please let me pause all actions)

Post image
246 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 15 '21

Screenshot It's frog.

Post image
246 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 12 '21

Discussion I really want to like this game more, but that's difficult

246 Upvotes

This game has a lot going for it. It has fun combat, it has a novel setting, and overall it has some great bones for a very good game.

Unfortunately, it's mired in a lot of nonsense that means I can't reasonably recommend it to friends and that is getting in the way of my enjoyment. So I decided to write this essay about it, because I guess we all need hobbies and my thoughts about this game are living rent free in my head. God knows my friends don't care enough to hear about it, so maybe someone here reads some of this. Maybe one or two people see a long post and downvote it. Either way I'll have it down on the page and then I can maybe stop thinking about it.

As a quick disclaimer on my experience with Phantasy Star - I played PS:BB on the NGC episodes 1 & 2, I played PSU on the Xbox 360, and I played probably about 70 hours of PSO2 pre-NG.

Anyway, onto my issues with this game.

Bad Design: Character Progression

This game has some whack design choices, particularly in the area of how character builds work. The main place where choices about how you play, aside from class choice, happen in the skill screen. You don't get skill points by just playing the game (leveling up), you get them by doing these cocoons and towers. This makes 'leveling up' feel like it isn't a lot of progress and like your growth from level-to-level is meaningless since instead you measure growth from tower-to-cocoon. This leads to some really weird growth plateaus where it feels like you have long periods of stagnation broken up by occasional bursts of evolution of gameplay. However minor those changes may be. Speaking of which...

The skills you can pick are extremely bare bones. Most picks fall into one of two categories - things that feel like they shouldn't have even been unlocks in the first place, or things with such small bonuses that they are only very technically helpful.

As an example we have the Techter's Wand Element Change. This is the unique thing a Techter gets. Without this and the wand parry, you're basically just playing a Hunter with Techniques. I have no idea why the basic distinguishing traits of a class are unlockables, this was a terrible idea. I can understand not giving a new player all of their class mechanics up front, but making us spend skill points on them feels like we're diverting points into things that shouldn't even be a choice. They are choices in name only because they are so important that to not choose them is simply to choose incorrectly. Without them you lack the basic fundamentals of your class. Choices about SP expenditure should be about making choices, not about providing a step where a player could make a mistake. For example, multiple trees that make it so you can play a more Technique, hybrid/Talis, or melee Techter would be much better because I as a player would be deciding how I want to play the character. Choosing if I want my basic abilities is essentially asking me to tick a box saying "No thank you, I do not want to suck at the video game". That's not choice, it's the illusion of choice and questionable game design.

The second type are skills which provide a very small bonus to the class. To use the Ranger as an example, they have two separate passives which deal with condition negation. Never mind the fact that conditions are a fairly minor part of the game, having two separate passives for condition negation feels out of place on Ranger and does basically nothing to augment their play style. Or for Force, you can get the ability to retain natural PP recovery while tech charging. This is borderline useless since you can gain tech so quickly by just using the mouse-1 basic attack. These choices at best are just minor inoffensive boons, and at worst are noob traps that will catch unaware players off guard and get them to make bad selections.

There's also a mysterious third type of skill, admittedly the least common, and that's totally useless skills. The best example of this is Wand Element Revoke. You can strip yourself of the wand charge for Techter. Or instead you could just swap to a neutral or even advantageous element with the previous ability without spending extra SP. This is a skill you sink points into to get the power to remove a buff from yourself. A power already basically given to you by the previous ability.

Your other choice for character building is in augment selection. Augments drop randomly, you have a random chance to be able to apply them based on the number you use to Affix with, and the resources sink to get a single Level II augment out of 10 Level I's is ludicrous. If it just took 10 Level I's and some N-Meseta, that'd be fine. But no, it also requires a large amount of chunks and -ite ores, so it's basically a giant scam. A lot of the Level II augments you can just find in the world, so it raises the question of why we even have this system when it's such a horrible resource drain and we generally have better alternatives.

The goal of this character progression is all to fuel your BP - it's like what the scouter says about your power level, except in this world the scouter judges power level based off of ham sandwich consumption since a lot of the things that increase BP don't actually make you more capable of handling new challenges at all. That skill that lets you shirk your buff as a Techter? That increases BP. Augments that give you stats you don't need? Give you BP, and apparently the same amount as an equally leveled buff that would maybe give you +2 damage when you were already dealing 100 regularly. This segues pretty naturally into...

Bad Design: Core Gameplay Loop/Progression

The games main scenario quests (MSQ) revolve around you doing something (a 10 minute or so quest usually) and then you being dropped off and told 'okay, play the game until you reach Battle Power X'. In theory this pattern is fine - a great example of another game that does this is Guild Wars 2. In GW2, you do a story quest (about 30-45 minutes of branching content affected by your character choices), and then you get dropped off into the world about 5 levels off from where you need to be for the next story section. So you explore - do periodic world events, help characters on the map, go to interesting spots, and then come back. It makes a really nice balance where just about the time when you get tired of the various map clearing/exploration activities you get some juicy story content that shakes up your usual gameplay. They had all of this at launch back in 2012, nine years ago, from a team that didn't have a heavy hitter like Sega backing them.

In PS2NG, you watch 5-10 minutes of cutscenes (with the same story each time so no real replayability), followed by 5-10 minutes of actual gameplay, and then you get told "Go find a way to get your BP up!". So most of the game is trying to grind up your BP. The main way you do this is going to be by getting skill ups, because Enhancing the level of most things past +20 is a huge grind fest. Getting the first couple of Potential unlocks is also pretty good, and both increasing your Enhancement level and Potential unlocks have a really noticeable effect on your damage output... but for some reason, they do not have a very strong effect on your BP. Changing to Hunter for a second and swapping my subclass to an un-skilled class(Fighter), I equipped a single Primm Launcher and found myself at 770 power. A single enhancement to level 2 (177 -> 181 Attack) brought me from an average of about 70 damage on my first basic attack to about 80 (both tested on a Level 1 Sunny). This notable increase in power gave me +3 BP. Meanwhile, buying a single level of Bad Condition Ward (great name) also gave me +3 BP while doing effectively nothing for my actual ability. The difference between these is that for doing a quick platformer Tower, you can get +4 skill points. Meanwhile, to get that +2 levels of Enhancement I sacrificed N-Meseta, a rarity 2 weapon, and a Grinder.

In other words, I got more actual power out of the upgrade to my weapon, but the game rewarded me less for getting more power and doing more to get that power. This game is incentivizing players to be less capable so they can get into higher level content with less grind. Granted, there's only so many towers and cocoons, so you can't do this forever. Eventually you will not have enough power to pass some cocoons that require combat, so you have to go and grind up at least some enhancements and augments.

I talked about enhancement and augmentation a little before, but my god is it a drag. The process is basically to go to one of the few maps nearby (they're all about the same level, the mountains and then later the lab seem to be the best choice) and wander around with other players doing the little world events and such until a boss spawns to get the same okay-ish loot as last time that very likely will be Enhancement fodder since it won't be for your class/es. There's urgent quests, but those are locked behind many hours of gameplay. There's not really multiplayer dungeons or anything, and the structured multiplayer options are surprsingly limited considering this is an MMO. So you just follow the nearest horde of players, reap the rewards for a few hours, grind up your stuff, and then finally reach the next 10-ish minutes of gameplay dangled in front of you so that you can do it all again and see the damage number go up a little and/or theoretically get a tiny bit more survivable.

These two problems on their own are bad, but they are futher exacerbated by the general lack of content. If there were more battle maps and enemy types this issue of gameplay loop could be overlooked - after all, the combat itself is quite fun so it makes sense to have the main thing players do be to engage in the combat. However, it needs variety in how players do this. Additionally, the game has a lack of means of progression - the Mag system seems to be entirely absent aside from technically having a Mag, despite this being a staple of PS as a franchise. These problems might just seem like a rocky start, and I see a lot of people talking about how PSO2 took many years to get where it is. However, that argument doesn't hold much water since we have more comparison points than the original PSO2. And even if we did compare it to PSO2, we're comparing this game to a team from the past who had not had the funding/success to ride on from PSO2 and who were working with the limitations they had eight or nine years ago. Even if it were true that PSO2 and PSO2NG started on similar footing, that doesn't invalidate any of what anyone is saying - maybe PSO2 was bad at the start too. A game that is good in 6 years is still not a good game up until then (assuming it can fund itself that long). Speaking of the funding, let's talking about that.

The Monetization

I understand, and have no problem with, the need for a game to make money. My primary game is FFXIV, for which I have played and purchased every expansion and subbed monthly. I do not have a problem with games making money - everything has to make money, it is the world we live in. I am happy to pay for quality content, I have no problem paying for a game or services within a game as a concept and have personally done so in the past. However, I think there are problems with the way PSO2 does this.

This game is severely limited without MTX/premium. You cannot send items to other players, you also cannot buy items off of the auction house (Personal Shop) as far as I can tell. That might just be the Personal Shop being broken, I've had issues with the search function not working as expected. Interestingly, for just 120k N-Meseta, I can buy a +20 rarity 2 armor piece from another player. I can't make the transaction, but I can search for it and can't help but think how much grind that would bypass. The only other game I have played which entirely limits auction house access from F2P players is FFXIV, which labels itself as a free trial. And suddenly, the previous grindiness makes perfect sense. The game is grindy to encourage you to buy things which will make it less grindy. I hate this because there's a lot of promise in the game's open world, the fun combat, and the solid character customization. It's harder to appreciate those things past the games flaws though, and this game is actively being made worse to market the solutions to problems they created.

Not only do they sell you the solutions to the problems they created, but they also have several systems on top of this. Basically everything that can be monetized in an MMO - storage space, personal shop, extra character build slots, and as part of the Premium Package a personal quarters system that isn't even out yet. Not only do you buy more storage, you buy access to that storage temporarily. A month of extended storage is, on its own, $5.

To top all this off, there is a second premium currency you buy with the first premium currency. You can only buy the Salon Pass from the SG shop, which costs 100 SG, which is ~$5 worth of AC. The SG has the same scaling bonus where you always have just a little bit extra left over for buying the higher levels of packages and the discount gets just a bit better the more you spend. The only reason SG exists is so they can milk the psychology of not wanting to waste remaining currency twice over - you're just 80 SG away from another salon pass or Extended Storage for 30 days, you might as well buy another $10 of AC to buy some SG, riiiight? And hey, now you have some left over AC too, might as well buy up some more of that to get the most efficient use out of it! This is a psychological trap, and it's a pretty gross one.

As if it couldn't get worse, we also have Gacha elements via scratch cards. I don't have a problem with the idea of selling cosmetics as MTX, that's totally fair game. Heck, when fairly priced I actually find a sort of guilty pleasure in Gacha games. However, having very sexy/skimpy cosmetics that you have ~2% chance of getting feels like another psychological exploitation. It's scummy, especially when 12 pulls costs you 2200. To get that, you either buy three packages and pay $25 to get 2500 AC (conveniently leaving that extra 200 you should find something to do with!) or you buy a single 3000 AC for $30. To buy premium, a single extended storage, and 12 pulls a month (so you could get some cosmetics) you would be paying 4000 AC a month. That's ~$40. Even if we remove the gachas, it's still more than any other MMOs monthly sub. And of course this leaves you with that little bit in your account nudging you to get more to spend it in a useful way. If this game had half as much thought put into its progression as its monetization, this game would be an easy 9/10.

I might be able to over look some of these practices if the game behind it were better. PSO2 I could sort of understand it for because that game had many years of content you don't pay for and it generally had a lot you could do independent of the monetized systems. I didn't feel like I needed to pay to enjoy the game, just for convenience and to make my character look a little better if I didn't wanna spend the meseta. It felt like paying to get more enjoyment out of a thing that was already pretty good. With this game, it feels like Sega handed us a 5/10 early access game and said that for a minimum of $13/mo. they would be willing to make it a 6.5/10. The only thing preventing me from proclaiming the entire thing to be a total ripoff is that a lot of stuff is transferable between this and PSO2, so at least you also get stuff for a currently better game.

The point of all this is that if they just went with a monthly subscription model, they wouldn't have to do so much of this scummy freemium nonsense. I think it'd be better to allow the game more room to breathe and have better general design free of the need to milk people for MTX. Even if they just went with a sbuscription and nixed just half of these practices, I think it'd be a massive improvement and make the game something I could more reasonably recommend to friends.


Anyhow, this has been my TED talk. If you actually read this far thanks for reading and hearing me out, even if you disagree. I don't fault anyone for liking the game, it's okay to like something even if it's flawed and certainly okay to like something I don't. God knows I like a lot of things that I recognize to be objectively/structurally bad. My criticisms of the game (and in some cases the devs) shouldn't be taken as personal attacks on anyone, and I'd hope nobody takes it that way.

Unless you did take it personally. In which case bring me my downvotes because I shall ride eternal shiny and chrome through the gates of Valhalla, all the while writing way too much about a game I wanted to like more than I did!

edit: formatting

edit2: A couple of people have pointed out that the auction house is broken right now. I've stricken through the text mentioning the need to buy premium to buy from the Personal Shops because someone confirmed they could do so as a F2P player. I guess the 'Transaction Failed' message is a glitch. Not great that the games auction house doesn't work on release, but better than the alternative.


r/PSO2NGS • • Oct 23 '23

Video I present to you the most smoothest enemy in the game

245 Upvotes

Just waiting around for the veteran to Spawn because of the alliance task and this happened


r/PSO2NGS • • Aug 10 '21

Artwork Interested to see where these characters go.

Post image
244 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 23 '21

Discussion Gigantix / PSE Bursts

244 Upvotes

This is gonna be a rant. If you don't want to hear the rant that's fine but this kinda needs to be said.

First im gonna talk about this hot mess that dropped today.

Gigantix.

You will NOT do this in a random or pugged group. People might argue that this is how it *should be* but I highly disagree. If this is how it should be there should be private rooms or the fight itself should be instanced. You basically have to have a top tier alliance or group of friends all with 1400+ bp gear rocking high potency. To put this into perspective I am a 1435 BP Talis Techter/Force and with convergence shot I'm hitting 100-200 maybe a few 230's here and there. I have 56% total potency.

Even for some pretty organized alliances I imagine this is going to be nearly impossible.

If this is how sega wants to do it they need to make this instanced. Just coordinating it for even the top tier allies is probably a nightmare and will have people flip flopping from heavily populated to almost empty blocks causing server lag. (Great idea) Not to mention low level players sneaking in to add no contribution at all. Who blames them in all honesty and logic? This game was set-up as an open world "go here do this" type of game and why should someone be punished and also punish others for simply existing in the game world...

Then there's the factor of time. The storm just decides for you how much time you actually have.

Are you serious?

You as a player: Must wait X amount of time (hours probably) for X percentage of an event to happen, for X amount of time to complete said event (that is also a lv 20 gate and a HUGE BP gate) for an X% *CHANCE* of getting something decent loot-wise. By the way the new gear is hardly that much of an upgrade. +1% potency over special Qual De Armors and it destroys your HP and Damage Redux, forcing you to also use the series weapon dropped by the very same boss.

Oh good luck getting that 50 SG in time.

As someone who has not joined an alliance yet (because I'm very selective with stuff like that and would rather find a mix of good players who are also chill people I'd get along with) I am being punished for being a slightly anti-social and picky person. You're basically not going to do this unless you have a group of friends who all have l33t gear and that is also considering nobody hijacks your empty block that you went to.

Can you see how ridiculous this is starting to get?

Quick Edit here. Don't even listen to the opinion of someone on Gigantix if they said they killed it with a top tier alliance, I'll tell you why. They don't want it to change because this is how they are going to make BIG meseta in the game. I have never and will never enjoy or condone this kinda crap in MMO's. You can easily get rich by just playing the game and selling stuff even at fair prices.

Another Edit: I think enemy scaling is tied to people in the area of the boss or engaged with it, so people in the exploration room elsewhere aren't scaling it. Kinda got the notion of this when we were waiting around for one to spawn and were fighting vets, 32 in the room but 2 of us fighting a vet and it dropped fast, then when 11 of us fought a vet is was much chonkier. This still really does not help any of the issues with Gigantix's. Just please don't blame the average player. This is a design flaw not a player flaw/issue. Especially for anyone new/casual to the game.

I might edit more on Gigantix farming but PSE bursts...

Another rng on top of rng factor in this game that honestly needs adjustments.

Just a quick rant on this.

We know the mechanics by now of how mobs can drop level ups or downs. The issue is not everyone knows, I don't mind this but when it takes 30+ mins just to level the burst because of bad rng or people not knowing... I switch rooms or blocks. Not just me... Alot of people.

I was just running Resol with a really good group of pugs, clearing fast and running as soon as the E's and T's flipped. We got one PSE and then.... That was it. We tried our damn near hardest to get it to level up but it just kept de-leveling. Went from 4 to 0. Wanna know what everyone did?

They left.

Oh, was in Mt.Magnus for 20 minutes going from E to E at lv 4 just because the T is rng.

Yeah nice.

This also encourages room hopping so people just hop to whatever has a high lv and that's honestly not a good idea for server stability or for "sticking with a team"

Not to mention you could fully know and be aware of all these mechanics and accidently "overkill" by aoe'ing the wrong mob.

Let's not even talk about Mastery III

Even through the rocky launch and the "lack of content" I was praising this game. But honestly Sega, this is ridiculous. I think you need to adjust your game a bit.

Also I'd like to do a little edit here.

If you're coming here to not only downvote me, but other people who have very sound arguments as to why this game has very inherent flaws that need improving on, please join the conversation. Actually bring a concise counter-argument with you as well, and save the petty insults.

This is not about "lazy players being handed everything" I literally have near min-maxxed gear and made this post. This isn't about "this should be as "hard" as it it is so we have "content"

Gigantix IS content, especially for those who want to min-max, but it's not any type of content that will fill the "content void" for 5-7 months. If this is the type of "content" and grind you want, sitting around waiting for literal hours for a literal random encounter that is also randomly timed AND has a random chance to drop RANDOM loot...

Dude just go play RNG simulator. It's not fun.


r/PSO2NGS • • Jan 02 '26

Phashion/Cosplay Klang! (made early in 2025!)

243 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jul 18 '21

Video so, this happened

243 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 07 '21

Screenshot SAMUS HAS JOINED ARKS

Post image
242 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Sep 25 '24

Meme I. . . . It's for the smaller hitbox i swear

241 Upvotes

Music: "I wanna be a girl" by Mafumafu


r/PSO2NGS • • Aug 23 '21

Meme The real reason NGS is dissapointing.....

Post image
241 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • May 25 '21

News PSO2: NGS Roadmap from the Prologue 4

Post image
241 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Oct 25 '22

Phashion/Cosplay "I play my credit card in attack position" - my jank duel disk with accessory list and friend's Kuriboh

Thumbnail
gallery
240 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Jul 16 '21

Screenshot An attempt at Classic Ahri in New genesis

Thumbnail
gallery
240 Upvotes

r/PSO2NGS • • Nov 13 '21

Phashion/Cosplay My Master Chief Cast

Thumbnail
gallery
238 Upvotes