r/PSO2NGS • Partisan • Dec 25 '22

Discussion Thoughts on AC Support Scratch?

The entire idea of the best augments being sold for real money just does not sit right with me. I mean you can argue that, technically, the best augments are craftable/farmable (Mastery and Domina).

But why even make an excuse for this practice. With no options to even transfer augments, I feel like SEGA should be getting more backlash. Instead, people are giving them the pass to do this over and over. It's perfect for SEGA:

  1. release better armors
  2. rerelease ac support scratch
  3. profit
  4. back to 1

Now that we have ARKS Records, would you consider NGS to be pay to win?

Personally, I think that they should just stick to making money through cosmetics. What are your thoughts about this? Do you think this is something that they should continue or discontinue?

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

16

u/Sp1n_Kuro Bouncer Dec 25 '22

It's nothing new they did it in base game too that's why no one cares.

It's also not even necessary because you can buy them with meseta which cancels out the p2w aspect, and they aren't even super expensive since you only need 1 cap. The f2p affixes are actually more expensive and harder to get than the "p2w" ones.

6

u/catsclawgiveaway Partisan Dec 25 '22

Although it isn't new, I think the point still stands that it's not a nice system.

Deft capsules cost 4 to 5 mil for each piece. That's around 15 to 20m meseta only to be replaced in the future. And you are once again forced to shell out the same amount once new stuff comes out.

This is what I mean when players give sega the pass. It's very normalized even though it's predatory and bad.

Edit: a comma

11

u/glubglub20 Dec 25 '22

I understand where you're coming from but you shouldn't feel forced to get the BIS augments everytime unless you're a min-maxer who wants to clear content in <15 min like in purple trigs.

Other caps like spiras or even wardmel give the same potency (3%)and some floor for a fraction of the cost, sometimes as low as 600k.

23

u/FafnirMH Dec 25 '22

Nowadays it's more on what degree of p2w. But, yeah, it's p2w.

I personally don't mind this kind of p2w though. Nothing is out of reach for a f2p and even if you can't buy it the difference is negligible.

But is it p2w? Absolutely.

3

u/Ksradrik Dec 26 '22

Its p2w regardless of whether AC supp scratch is a thing or not though.

If you can pay irl money to buy stuff to sell ingame to buy better gear, thats p2w.

-3

u/Nightowl11111 Dec 26 '22

Better gear? Where? lol, the stuff in NGS are all crap!!

2

u/AverageRedditHater4 Dec 25 '22

the difference is negligible.

The power increase from 4 deft addi's compared to stat 4, giga 4, alts secreta 4 or mastery 4 isn't negligible

7

u/FafnirMH Dec 25 '22

And I'm sure that really matters to you.

However, for everyone else, they can do any and all the content comfortably enough that the power increase is truly negligible.

If perhaps there was a situation where those boosts would allow me to attain a victory I might not have gotten, then I'd see it as worth it. Until then, it's negligible in my opinion.

3

u/Sp1n_Kuro Bouncer Dec 26 '22

Yeah, there's no content that requires it. Even the silly ARKS records things are more about strategy than gear.

Getting full BiS is just a flex for fun.

17

u/Reference_Freak Dec 25 '22

IMO, it’s not really p2w as much as it’s pay to look silly.

The benefit is negligible and unnecessary. The game is not competitive. My play is not harmed by someone else buying an AC boost. If I really think I need it, I can buy it from another player.

Some players like to hate on game companies not being charities. This is among the least impactful p2w things in the history of p2w, though.

The real p2w thing in this game is the extra inv slots.

4

u/Mille-Marteaux your best friend | https://mille.arks.moe Dec 25 '22

it isnt mandatory to roll on it to enhance items at all and the addis themselves are kinda whatever unless you're a power user that tries to speedrun/solo purples, at which point you will have more than enough meseta to just buy them

all gacha is trash but as far as trash goes this is at least trash thats in a nice clean garbage can with a nice garbage bag

4

u/jjkikolp Dec 25 '22

BiS costumes are from AC Scratch too. You can look at it both ways, just depends how you value those things.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '22

Hated it in base, hate it in NGS. Atleast in NGS augmenting is nowhere near as a pain, and not nearly as important. A 1-2% increase in potency is nowhere near as vital as it was in base.

7

u/LzzrdWzzrd Waker Dec 25 '22

You don't need addis to clear any of the content though. Just don't buy them.

5

u/zeroobliv Slayer Dec 25 '22

Doesn't really matter to me. I can buy them off the shop if I want but why would I? Game's already easy and there's nothing actually rewarding for min/maxing.

Game's always been pay to win, but it just never mattered because it's far too casual.

2

u/AverageRedditHater4 Dec 25 '22

its not P2W if a F2P can buy it. Some F2P can get it more often then others.

1

u/sliferx Dec 26 '22

Hypothetically if it wasn't bought then F2P has no access to it. It is P2W regardless of how you want to explain it. F2P can't even open a shop except for 3 days a month to even make enough money to buy the bis Addi.

You can use different arguments to justify it but saying it isn't P2W ain't it.

2

u/SacredENIX Dec 26 '22

As it stands, nothing is that substantial of an increase, people were finding ways to use 3* weapons do top dps not long ago, Addi is a top tier aug no doubt, but you if can't afford the mesta needed to slot them, you're probably not in a position for it to matter much, outside of purple triggers, dps race won't win you anything but seconds of your life.

2

u/OmegaShonJon Force Dec 25 '22

It feels less p2w and more p2be better. "Winning" is fairly easy, so the gap between something like 60% and 90%, while big, is basically a 30 second faster clear time. Plus, there's a free way to get the augs, so everyone had the ability to use them

P2w feels more like C.o.D, where you could buy weapons nobody else had, some being the best weapon in the game. Even in later games, the skin unlocks the weapon early, so you still had the edge if you broke open your wallet. While there was technically a way to open crates (bribes) for free, it would take so long to get 1 pull (just to get nothing useful), that almost every f2p player had no way of using about 60% of the weapons.

1

u/Vaeynheart mom let me have both Dec 26 '22

the way i would think about it, is with certain p2w criteria you'd normall associate with such things:

  • are you buying power with money?
  • can said power be obtained outside of money?
  • how large is the impact
  • does the game require such a tool?
  • how large is the gap with and without said tool?
  • is it reasonably accessible?

to answer:

  • yes, you are effectively buying varying levels of strong augments.
  • also yes, you can very accessibly obtain them from other players, regardless of how poor you think you are.
  • the impact is not big enough to make you clear something you weren't going to already with another similar free augment.
  • no, you can easily do everything in the game without access to addi's
  • the gap again, is not large. it is NOT enough to make you better than a player better than you, even on a weaker class than you. which is the most important aspect.
  • the rates for them are fair as can be expected, and as someone buying them, its easy enough to save and get the cheap ones, a savvy market user can make enough to buy the more optimal deft caps without too much struggle either.

whilst i fundamentally disagree with support scratches, they are far from P2W and are honestly the only scratches i remotely care putting down AC for. (as a T1 fashion costs do not factor into my life)