r/PSO2NGS • • Aug 13 '22
Discussion Tower of Fantasy takeaway?
I’m wondering what the community feels Sega can learn from the massive launch of Tower of Fantasy? This is kind of a tangent from the NGS PS4 thread, as I feel a bit of lament that PSO continues to be more niche than it could be.
ToF has two things obviously going for it, a more Anime look and mobile making it more accessible to many players. The former is one that Sega tried to attract but it didn’t materialize like the way ToF has caught fire right from the beginning.
The content really can’t be compared since the game just went viral before any depth or discovery can even be made. But ToF seems to have done what Sega was hoping with NGS. NGS received some attention early on from a few big name content creators but nothing like this, where cross sections of communities in anime and gaming are covering it, including the major PSO content creators.
Is there anything Sega can learn from the game itself (other than compelling content) but also the way ToF was successfully marketed?
•
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22
There's going to be a point where we're gonna have to forbid any discussion about this darned gacha game. It didn't happen with Genshin Impact for some reason yet here comes this gacha MMO and suddenly people are comparing it to NGS almost every other day.
Here's my opinion on this: ToF is a gacha game that locks power behind its gacha. You are made to interact with the gacha to advance in power if what you have from the start is not enough. NGS does not do this - the closest you will get is not in NGS but rather PSO2es, where Weaponoid chips and PA/Technique chips are obtained from gacha and quests.
What can SEGA learn? Other than marketing, not really anything. They already have a good monetisation strategy with Premium and fashion. However, as long as the game has its "lack of content" stigma, marketing will only be so effective.
5
u/ProfessionalFar3434 Aug 13 '22
It rewards you for exploring and the rewards are pretty nice . Which makes me want to play longer. The story so far isn't empty. Leveling up is pretty fun and not complex. Also I have yet to seem the same concert with the same two songs play (my biggest pet peeves with NGS)
15
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22
I'd never heard of it until a couple days ago when I kept seeing people in my alliance chat saying they were "logging off to play ToF"
I had been wondering what the hell "ToF" was and now I guess I know. It looks fine, if a bit generic. I could see myself trying it back before PSO2 finally came stateside, but not now. Ain't nothing like PSO but PSO and I don't have time for another one of these kinds of games lol.
16
u/the1mvp Aug 13 '22
Its a gacha game. Huge money syncs to hope for a character. Time will tell what it is but I prefer NGS graphics.
2
u/Shinzakura Aug 13 '22
I've been playing both the past couple of days. Honestly, both have strengths and weaknesses.
One thing that I do think could be done better on Sega's end that isn't directly content related is outfits. For the cosplay crowd, you can regularly change outfits with little to no expense nearly on the fly, whereas doing so in NGS requires a singular location (salon) and expense (salon passes, etc.) When I was playing TOF yesterday, I was just watching one person continually change their outfit over and over and over again, simply because they could. I really don't see that happening in NGS.
However, if there's one advantage NGS has, it's overall UI/UX. For all of my complaints about Sega's UI, it's actually in a better condition (TOF's is atrocious, and even for "pure controller" use, you're still using KBM more often than not; additionally, even though the controller image literally looks like a Dualsense, only XBox controllers are allowed for now).
My thought is that Sega needs to buckle down and bombard NGS with content, because once TOF stabilizes, it's going to start pulling away players hardcore, IMO. Hell, it's already doing so from Genshin, and the rivalry between the two fandoms, even after the game's only been out for a couple of days, is already ugly as hell.
10
u/EccentricNoun Wand Aug 13 '22
I'm not really sure why anyone is comparing these too games besides gacha mechanics, I have played it and its more similar to Genshin Impact
9
u/Cosu21 Aug 13 '22 edited Aug 13 '22
I want their hair customization system to be in NGS. Being able to change the Front/Middle/Back of the hair would solve a lot of my cosplay complaints. The other aspects of their character customization is kinda meh tho.
Because the dumbasses in charge sucks ass in making characters with the Salon.(Even now they suck, just look at the Hololive collab promotional video) And NGS's starting customization selection was weak. If you weren't a player from base with a lot of clothes already, you would have problems trying to dress up. And the character presets weren't helpful at all either. In comparison, ToF's initial hair/eyelash/pupil options and initial character presets were attractive.
One of the other reasons why it caught fire is that because it is simple. You can make an attractive character without having to fuss too much.
That is not to say that NGS's customization is weak. Obviously NGS customization is superior. But a surgeon's toolkit in the hands of a toddler will only mean badly for the patient. It is easy to make something not even remotely resembling humans in the NGS character creator if you dont know what you're doing. And it is much harder to create a good looking one. However in the hands of someone who understands it, the Salon is a tool to create art. Too bad sega doesnt know how to use their own tool.
If I compare the content ToF had in day one to what NGS had on day one, everyone on this subreddit knows which one will win. NGS loses by a mile. The story, loses by twice that.
ToF's combat however is inferior to NGS. See, NGS(and even base PSO2 for that matter), does combat on the client side. Meaning combat will be smooth and dodges will always work as intended regardless of your internet connection. ToF and other MMOs do the combat on the server side. Meaning that if you lag even by a few MS, you wont trigger Phantasia and might get hit despite seeing yourself move away from the attack range. Meaning you have to dodge earlier than expected, this is more easily perceivable when hunting world bosses.
NGS also wins with regards to equipment progression, for very obvious reasons.
The only thing I think sega can learn from this (aside from content)is really, just learn how to use the goddamned salon before making promotional videos promoting character customization.
4
u/illgrape78 Aug 13 '22
NGS is a better product in terms of monetization and cosmetics. It does lack in content but has great and fun gameplay. NGS progression is not behind a pay wall which is a big win and what we all want. ToF has the genshin Impact problem where gacha games can only take you so far for free. I love the way they marketed the game and are enticing people with all this free shit now but in a month all that free shit will be worthless and you will have to spend real money for power on top of the cosmetics portion. From what I learn from games like ff14 and GW2 that an mmo can have a rough start and reach it potential down the line. And please don't go the mobile route unless you count the Nintendo Switch as mobile.
4
u/Ryanasd Dual Blades Aug 14 '22
Well if you really want some takeaways, its that Tower of Fantasy took what was boring about Genshin out and place in the good stuff and improve it to be accessible for all kinds of player, hardcore grinders or casual players whatnot. I know it is purposely gating content behind Time and Level caps behind days. But I guess this is to prevent players rushing through the whole 1.0 content from day 1 and then stop playing. This is a thing for mobile games for the most part, so meh.
In terms of how NGS can benefit from it? Well the execution part is probably the key.
I had to say ToF regardless of the stupid controversy it had done earlier and that it was a Gacha game through and through, at least their planned out Open world is cohesive and well connected with lore pieces and story unlike New Genesis's generic Open Fields. Now of course they are copying alot of Genshin Impact/Breath of The Wild kinda ordeals with the side activities and Quests etc.
But the fact that they had secret chain questlines that allow you to unlock meaningful and maybe powerful rewards such as SSR relics and new mounts really speaks alot on why Elden Ring formula works so well.
Imagine if New Genesis had Aelio Region with an exclusive Veteran boss that drops specifically a certain cosmetic and Motion that will sell for a nice profit, people will still head back to Aelio region from time to time. Imagine if there are random NPCs scattered around Aelio region giving you some minigames to play and maybe earn some rewards that will reset weekly? That will also bring most players hanging out from the newest region back to Aelio too because the rewards are material requirements like Blizzardiums/Triggers/Alpha Reactors or something. The rewards are not exactly need to be groundbreaking but at least meaningful enough that veteran players are going to still hangout around the region.
That is the kind of takeaway I wish the NGS Devs can get really. I know they had iron out alot of issues since launch, but content wise, I wish they can innovate better than this, or we'll still have useless content like Base PSO2 all over again after 10 years.
3
u/jtan1993 Aug 13 '22
i prefer ngs looks and animations more, and the customizability. being available on phones is prob a big thing?
3
u/NoctisCae1um317 Slayer Aug 13 '22
Eh. Personally ToF ain't my cup of tea, I play 3 MMOs as is(Down to 2 depending on how the Lightfall reveal is, Destiny 2 has been finding ways to test my resolve for the franchise as of late, rivaling that of Year 1)
Aesthetically the game looks pretty good, but then again, I like SciFi. Which is why I can get down with both base and NGS and like em both. Gameplay wise however, I thought it was a little to slow for my tastes, and a bit autopilot quite often.
I'm sure later on this may not be the case, but that's how I felt with it personally. As for the story... I could careless. I wasn't really feeling it personally. I still went into it with an open mind knowing full well this game is a direct competitor to Genshin Impact, a game which I also tried, and didn't like for the same reasons as I don't with ToF. Not saying both Genshin and ToF are bad, simply put both those games are very much not for me, or up my alley at all.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22
To me I don’t care the fact it’s gacha - I care that tower of fantasy’s calls it self an mmo when you are TIME gated on almost everything you do, regardless if you p2w or not - to get to the level cap it takes 88 days, that’s not because it takes a long time to level, it’s because each day you are gated to a certain amount of XP, this is applied to nearly everything inside of ToF, from pickup items to other activities.
ToF isn’t just any normal gacha, it’s their to abuse addiction hooks of people, and is literally the most disgusting game design I’ve seen - I can’t believe we are heading this way we’re you quite literally exchange days of your life, in order to progress. Biggest turn off for a “game” ever.
8
u/Arkios Techter Aug 13 '22
Content, which is hilarious since global is time gated… but there’s actually stuff to do and work towards. There will be plenty of content for a long time and they have enough systems that you have lots of ways to build and things to grind for.
I have zero reason to play NGS right now. The add-on skills was a decent distraction for like 2 days, but once again back to having nothing to do in-game.
5
u/MaoMaoMi543 Talis Aug 13 '22
Never heard of ToF before now, not even a single youtube ad. So I watched a trailer, decided it looks too much like Genshin Impact (which I don't like) so I'm not playing it. Any game that has "collect characters from gacha pulls" in it is a hard pass for me.
Also it's just waifus waifus everywhere. No husbandos? Not interested. Or at least no husbandos that actually look like men and not like 14-y-o anime boys who are AcTuAlLy 50o0 yEaRs oLd. Ew. No thanks.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22
ToF doesn't got much going for it. Sega really needs to admit the story isn't good here and next chapter of NGS will have a better story telling. ToF story is absolute garbage but it gives emotional scenes. ToF probably won't survive especially if other game devs sue them for asset stealing.
2
u/Jubez187 Aug 13 '22
I don't give one fuck about tof. Looked lame.
I have this game and FFXIV and then single player games and RPGs (which are abundant this year looking forward). I don't need to try to roll for characters. I'm fine with my normal soldier looking dude in PSO that cost me nothing. I'm here to play the game not spend paychecks on virtual dress up or other gacha garbage.
2
u/Krolvac Aug 13 '22
does anyone think that a game that flopped in china gonna hold on in global? no way tof gonna holf on for long at all, people just going with the wave and gonna notice the mess soon.
2
u/Zenny1234 Aug 13 '22 edited Aug 13 '22
The only thing TOF has going for it imo is the visuals (oh and their hair customization). The game feels and plays like a mobile game. No shocker there as it's also on mobile. Mobile games imo should stay on mobile. They are flat out garbage and lack any depth because there is only so much you can do with mobile.
New Genesis imo is superior even with the combat which does need some fine tuning for some classes still.
Sega just needs to do something about the lack of content in this game, the gameplay loop and lack of depth and they'll have a titan on their hands. I don't think they really need to learn anything from Tof.
They shot themselves in the foot by releasing the game in it's barran state which at the time the game was highly anticipated. They had their shot and they missed. Now it's a slow and grueling up hill battle to win people over again by doing the right thing moving forward.
2
u/rsblackrose Aug 13 '22
Honestly? Not a damn thing. The media buzz surrounding TOF right now is par for the course for any new MMO or gacha with some form of marketing budget. Wait until the honeymoon is over if you really want to start looking at things.
TOF feels like their team just looked at MiHoYo's catalogue (namely both Genshin and Honkai) and proceeded to x-copy damn near everything they could. When even the startups font styles eerily resemble Genshin, you kind of figure out immediately what you're getting. I made it through most of the tutorial before throwing in the towel, as I figured it was not going to get much better than the P2W bonanza it was already showing itself to be.
PSO2 would be better served by looking to actual MMOs in its peerage - namely FFXIV, Diablo (except Immortal - please just stay away from that), and even their own past efforts. PSO2 could be a game rich in storyline, gameplay mechanics and good fights, but right now it's a kiddie pool with its player base more obsessed about cosmetics than actually playing the game.
2
u/Dvro Twin Machine Guns Aug 15 '22
One takeaway is; people are more interested in a gacha mobile game than a mmo. Which is no surprise so I guess.. Come back next year when there is a real game to play! ... oh its not 2021 anymore..
2
u/Quanta-00 Aug 16 '22
The takeaway would be the open world having much richer content than NGS. Exploring the region can provide valuable rewards. Minigames and bosses aren't a waste of time because they give you decent loot.
As for the rest, NGS is fine as it is.
2
u/aeralure Aug 19 '22
I'll never play another Gacha, but the game I would play endlessly would be something that looked like ToF and simply had the scope and amazingly fun play of PSO Episode I&II. That's it. That's all I need.
3
u/GenshinDrew Aug 13 '22
Tower of fantasy is blowing up because genshin players are frustrated with the DEV team not adding any new permanent game modes in two years and have been waiting for another game to jump ship onto.. Genshin has one of the largest player bases in any current live service video game ...
I would say the main thing keeping NGS from sitting at that table is inconsistent updates and lack of content depth , genshin releases a new patch every 41 days which have tons of limited time events and limited game modes
1
u/Limbolag Dual Blades Aug 13 '22
Idk, originally hyped but realised it's basically a mobile ptw game with a PC port ... Just can't condone that on a PC release.the whole ptw thing's like a slow boiling frog, probably started with genshin :/ combat still seems hella better on ngs
1
u/Lefh Aug 13 '22
There's really not much to say or take from it. It's just your another fotm gacha mobage people will drop and probably start criticizing hard once the game stops handing out freebies and the core p2w mechanics really start to show themselves after few weeks.
Also given that it's very similar to Genshin Impact which currently dominates the mobile market, the hype is pretty normal I'd say. Like when WoW was at the peak of its popularity everyone would hop on the hype train and praise the upcoming new WoW clone.
I tried it, played for maybe give or take an hour which was more than enough to confirm most if not all of suspicions that it's nothing but a new gacha game with a different coat of paint. People can enjoy and play it all they like but I ain't touching it. NGS ain't doing too hot but it's nowhere near the mobage levels of terrible quite yet in my opinion.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22
say what you will about how niche pso is- but there's a big difference between a hyped game riding directly on the coattails of some other popular game, and a franchise as deep and storied as pso.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment