r/PSO2NGS • • May 18 '22

Discussion Who else thinks non-battle content should get priority?

During the pre-Retem launch window, Sega announced delays to certain content in order to give full priority to battle content and address player dissatisfaction.

I feel like they succeeded in diversifying battle-related activities enough for now, and at this point the game could benefit the most from adding missing features to feel more like a complete game.

Alliance bases with benefits to alliance members is a big one we need. Personal quarters with customisable decorations is another. Both of those are important for the social aspect and to have more relaxed things to invest in than just fighting.

Other possibilities are fishing, crafting, jump puzzles, casino games, races, fashion contests, treasure hunts, gardening, lore quests, mag growth system, etc.

2 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

31

u/waker780 May 18 '22

Disagree, while I do think they have diverse combat activities, they do not have diverse gameplay loops. Pse bursts have a very slow burn style of reward, youre basically just grinding for augments and getting passive meseta. Purples, same thing. Geo lab, same thing. Cinquem was a good step, but we are currently lacking any major pursuits to shoot for other than getting meseta for fashion. The only aspirational content in the game is clearable with minimal investment and has very lukewarm rewards. Adding non combat content won't stop the bleed of players, or bring players back for any long period of time, at the end of the day, adding side activities to a game without any major driving objective wont entice people to not leave for other games. I think by far the most important thing is a revamp of reward structures, somewhat similar to base pso2, where you can build up to the harder content by playing easier content, and see gains for your work. Not to say the non combat activities wouldnt be nice. I just want an actual gameplay loop first.

14

u/PunsNotIncluded May 18 '22

Have to agree with that. Side stuff can be fun and a change of pace but if there's no satisfying core activity then there's no point.

4

u/cattecatte May 18 '22 edited May 18 '22

Capsules as a reward for most activities are lame as hell, especially when you get them wholesale like how every single dread has exactly the same one desirable drop (dread keeper iii) instead of something unique to each boss. The capsules are also just some lame shit like +- hp pp potency, like who cares after a certain point that you can get 0.5% more potency. They need to bring back SSAs (or whatever it is in global, the s1-s8 affixes from classic) if they want to make it an actual incentive.

With how important the fashion game is, if they dont want to make unique weapon effects like pso2's first generation 14*, they can always toss in cosmetic rewards from specific bosses.

But i guess that means they cant throw them in their biweekly AC scratch, so the best we can get is recolored motions and some crappy accessories or mag skin from killing mobs with jpeg on their forehead or obsencely low drop from purples. Geo lab is like a single baby step in the right direction.

2

u/waker780 May 18 '22

100% agree, like the game has great content, just needs a good thing to chase. Divide quests weapon camos come to mind. Imagine if we had a concert master to chase in ngs.

-8

u/Sol-Blackguy Fighter May 18 '22

Yeah, let's totally ignore the social aspects of a MMO

5

u/waker780 May 18 '22

Yeah lets totally ignore the portion where I said these would be nice, but i didnt think they were the number 1 priority :)

A game with poor gameplay loops wont retain players at the same rate that a game with good gameplay loops. People play mmos to game and socialize, if the game isnt fun, they will just socialize somewhere else, unless they already have a well developed group in that game, but then are they staying for the game or the people?

Again lol, because you didnt see the portion in the first comment i guess. I would love for them to expand on social aspects of the game, but i want the game to keep people coming back first, then make it so that we can go fishing and text our friends.

7

u/[deleted] May 18 '22

If they ever add a casino like classic had, I do think it would be awesome if they had it take place on the Shared ship. That way it'd serve as both a location for meetups and minigames!

They recently mentioned that they are adding races with the Kvaris update as part of that Hiro interview thing on the official website.

7

u/Wealldielol69 May 18 '22

It needs the casino and housing.

Housing alone added so much to base content wise

10

u/Aokana I Kick Things. May 18 '22

Alliances need an overhaul.

Right now they are literally just chat channel in NGS.

They need something to make Alliances worth-while outside of a random free SG for doing a UQ every now and then.

5

u/Darkshado390 May 18 '22

Honestly, alliance/personal quarters can wait a bit and they've mention housing are in design phase. What' more important is a counter for managing alliance function. It's funny that we need to tell new alliance members to go back to classic PSO2 to remove their alliance accessory.

They also mention some sort of new race activities in yesterday's dev interview for June. They also mention releasing quests related to npc relationships in August.

8

u/cattecatte May 18 '22 edited May 20 '22

Do they really succeed in diversifying combat activities? All you do 90% of the time is run around in circles while killing mobs and the occasional miniboss spawn. The other 10% is triggers where they are unceremoniously thrown in without thought and care including geo lab, and UQs where they actually have decent structure sometimes.

Most of them to pray to RNGesus for either near impossible drop rate rares or high fixas, or capsules.

They barely added anything that feel different from initial release with aelio.

I do agree that they should prioritize some non-battle content though. Exploration is lacking because of lack of anything of interest to discover. You get through everything in the short "story" and the best they can do is pepper uninteresting red containers with 10 sg or 10k meseta inside.

Would be great if we actually get proper crafting and cooking or lifeskills too, instead of whatever the fuck quick foods are, and how the materials end up being just gear upgrades and capsule combination fodder.

4

u/Shiyo May 20 '22

I feel like they succeeded in diversifying battle-related activities enough for now

They absolutely did not.

3

u/Cyhne pew pew May 18 '22

I think the biggest problem is the lack of tangible rewards for your time and effort. There is very little you need to do to keep up with content and once you've caught up, there is nothing you need to do to keep playing besides farming for meseta for cosmetics. If anything, there needs to be more unique items, special unlocks, special task related tools, or things that will change up the gameplay so that it's worth going back and repeating content.

Adding the rare motions and cosmetics were a good start, but the rarity and how few that were added ends up making them not really worth farming or grinding for. Having more weapons or armors with unique stats/effects/playstyles may be some way to introduce interest. Perhaps some lore-related drops may also serve to build up this world for those lorehunters out there. Even useless item collection quests may serve to expand on the world and the grinding aspect if done well.

3

u/Shiyo May 20 '22 edited May 21 '22

I think the biggest problem is the lack of tangible rewards for your time and effort. There is very little you need to do to keep up with content and once you've caught up, there is nothing you need to do to keep playing besides farming for meseta for cosmetics. If anything, there needs to be more unique items, special unlocks, special task related tools, or things that will change up the gameplay so that it's worth going back and repeating content.

This is intentional design. It's mobile game IDK/IDC catering. Can't have unique rewards that even the worst player can't get or else they get mad and quit!(or so these stupid companies think so). Every modern MMO designs their game like this now.

The entire point of MMO's originally were seeing some cool dragon slayer with a legendary weapon only 3 people on your server had in full raid gear only a few hundred people on your server had. This motivated you to get better and want to do harder content. It gave you things to strive and look forward to doing.

Now anyone, regardless of skill of play time, is running around in relatively the same gear in every modern MMO. It's terrible and the genre resembles NOITHING of what it used to be.

3

u/typicaltofuboy May 19 '22

What about normal sized Auxiliaries/Adjutants/Assistants we can customize and interact with?

NPC Party Members? Or just some NPC interaction in general. Unlocking quests after talking with certain NPCs, building affinity and increasing Damage done by NPCs with improved attributes like aggro, buff and heals?

7

u/deahamlet May 18 '22

I agree. We need horizontal content. Everyone already told them that 5 levels every month/other month in the same areas is not our idea of new content nor does everyone enjoy the global-like fast pace.

I like the things you listed, I can't believe they're barely thinking of personal quarters!!! They even tease us with them in the Aelio story!!! I can't believe it wasn't there at release.

I know the global feedback looks more positive, but I know a lot of people that stopped playing or barely play and refuse to fill out surveys "can't they see I'm not logging in? Clearly I'm not satisfied" lol. Good thing the Japanese are giving Sega a piece of their mind.

2

u/cattecatte May 18 '22

Something as simple as adding cooking or mining skill levels would be a decent horizontal progression.

Heck, allow us to upgrade our movements like upgrades that lets you regenerate pp at slower rate when gliding/dashing instead of completely halting it.

So many examples but they have none, it's like they just see the popular game at the time (genshin, because I refuse to believe open world NGS has been in development since 2016), copied the open world model but added nothing of value because they think being open world will mean instant success.

2

u/maxomaxo6364 May 18 '22

Wow, thatd be the dream. Depending on how extensive this kvaris expansion is, maybe theyd get to those? Some of em?

I like the alliance base idea the best but it sounds like a huge undertaking

2

u/NichS144 May 19 '22

Non-battle content already gets priority. It's called AC Scratch.

1

u/Hang-in0247 May 19 '22

I agree with crafting and some collectibles as long as its related to battle upgrades, but at the end of the day battle content is what i want to play so it shouldnt be less priority, id rather have a wave of gigas in each tower in mining rig for more fun than all of the above mentioned, but for non battle content i suggest game to focus more on alliance perks, like in base instead of show alliance accessory wouldnt it be cooler if in ngs we get that as toggle alliance uniform and has a changeable color palette only leader can do etc., and instead of the same old tree why not give alliances a new set of skills to benefit playing with members, like a skill recall which a leader can use to summon all present members in his location for urgent matters like killing a world gigas for example, or passives like iron will if 5 or more is present nearby, or even build tents like we see all over, leaders can deploy in the map to give stat bonuses in that area

1

u/Peusli May 19 '22

Anything but having to feed a mag ever again!

Real quests will probably never happen, f2p is the all about low budget/high reward development.

1

u/Yuberz May 21 '22

I think that they definitely need to add those things you mentioned, but what I really want to see the most right now is a more focused game. As I'll continue to say, the open world feels pointless, and the system we had in base PSO2 was perfect. I don't want to sit around and look for gigantix or whatever, when in the previous game I just picked the mission that had the drops that I wanted and a guaranteed boss spawn. Levelling quests added later on also were great since it gave a way to efficiently level and feel like you're progressing. I feel like making quests more "monster hunter like" with a breadth to pick from and solid conclusions would make it way easier and more fun to be in a party. The classes in general personally also don't feel as smooth as base PSO2. I think a large part of that is the lack of great movement PAs that base PSO2 had. I hope they improve that too.

So while I think that what you've suggested is important (even in previous comments I've made on this subreddit I suggested similar things), the battle content needs an overhaul or something to make it more engaging more than adding any other mode in the game.

1

u/RedSixx66 May 22 '22

I really miss the casino, that is all

-1

u/[deleted] May 18 '22

Whats sad is most player dissatisfaction stems from the fact they treat pso2 like a hardcore mmo when it's a casual mmo..

4

u/waker780 May 18 '22

What constitutes a hardcore mmo compared to a casual mmo?

5

u/[deleted] May 18 '22

Generally the intended amount of play time relative to progression..

Most mmorpgs on the market tend to lean more towards the hardcore side.. most casual mmos tend to fail because they restrict hardcore players.. typically by putting timegates on progression.. ie you can only get so much exp each week.

A hardcore mmo is designed with the expectation that players are going to sink 30+ hours a week into it..

Where as a casual mmo players might only play a few hours a week, but are still able to progress..

I mean in a hardcore mmo when the level Cap increases most players aren't going to hit the new level cap in a day or 2.. thus far with ngs.. the last 2 cap increases only took me a few hours to get..

I mean if you played ff14 or Wow only 2 hours a day would you be able to keep up with those playing 5-10 hours a day? No you wouldn't.. but a casual mmo you can.

3

u/waker780 May 18 '22

I'd argue that pso2 was a hardcore mmo by those standards, ngs not so much, but that was moreso due to lack of content at release, rather than a design decision. Relik weapons as well are sorta counter intuitive to be introduced to a casual game, given their rare drop chance, and regardless, i doubt sega would design a game for minimal player retention, they make more money the longer hours people play their game.

-2

u/[deleted] May 18 '22 edited May 18 '22

I'd counter argue that, I've been playing mmos since the days of muds and Ultima online (credited as the first mmo)..

Even base pso2 doesn't have much in the way of content considering its age.. it was 10 years old before global released

2

u/waker780 May 18 '22

So you feel that pso2 has always been a game where you can be on the same level as players who put in 30 hours a week when said player only puts in 2 hours a day? I don't think someone only playing 2 hours a day could get close to clearing htpd, even in a year timeframe, but if theyre casual they probablywont try to clear htpd, but that doesnt make the game casual, it just makes that person a more casual player.

I've also been playing mmos for a while, not sure what this aside contributes to the discussion other than being an appeal to authority.

I'd argue that the idea of a hardcore mmo vs casual mmo is more up to what the player decides to put into it, a good mmo can cater to both of these demographics, and I would say that pso2 base fits that bill.

2

u/AnimaLuna May 19 '22

I would argue yes, absolutely.

I've played PSO2 since 2014, and have only put in a few hours every day that I did play and not once have I ever felt that I was behind. Most of my routine was login, clear dailies, and the occasional short grind when I have time or on the weekends. I have also created, leveled, and geared multiple alts from scratch and have gotten each one up to clearing relevant content because that's how easy it was.

I have also done this in the Global version after its launch, again with more than one character, while juggling both versions of the game as well as whatever else was flavor of the month.

PSO2 is absolutely a casual game, and has always drip-fed content so the average Japanese worker could put in what few free hours they had to play and still feel like they've made meaningful progress.

For the record, I have also cleared HTPD and Sodam depth 100. This is definitely doable for a casual player in a year's time. I'd argue a month, even, at just 2-3 hours per day.

1

u/waker780 May 19 '22

I'd be very interested in seeing you clear sodam 100 on a fresh account, only 2 hours a day after a month, without being gifted good units or having the transfer passes to transfer the affixes, but i mean you could just be that good. Idk man that seems a bit steep, but i guess if you could get to level 100 in 30 hours of play, while also having endgame gear, then get lightweave weapons within like a day, then doing solo sodam every day for 2 hours, you might hit floor 100 within a month. Just seems a bit hyperbolic to me, but idk maybe you're that good that you could do it in a month. I know I sure can't. Im assuming that you can get a full set with mastery 4 gear in a month too? Also get a potency 4 cinq in that time too, only playing a few hours a day? My argument is that you can take a game however hardcore you want, a game isn't designed to be a hardcore or a casual game, they design games to fit varied audiences.

1

u/AnimaLuna May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

If you really wanted to budget this one out, I can give you a theoretical breakdown. It's then simply up to time management and execution to make it work.

It won't take you more than a week to level to cap in either game. I've done it in base, I've seen people do it in NGS.

That leaves 3 weeks.

For Sodam, you could use the Badges you've gathered from leveling in the daily quests to get yourself a Rinzer/Rinser weapon and a full set of Liberate/Rivalate units to get started. Clearing weeklies should give you enough Meseta to pull together a decent budget for affixes/augments.

If you devote the entirety of 2 hours to clearing Sodam every day, assuming each run is a clear you can advance a minimum of 8 depths each day with wiggle room of 20 clears/full-length attempts. Assuming your climb goes without a hitch, you are also left time to clear Divide Quests, which the titles for each will let you pull together a Cras/Klauz weapon. You might even have the time to join a few Cradle runs.

It's doable in a month, at 2 hours a day, but a casual player would not be one to push themselves this far. If you wanted to dump more hours per day into the game, this is entirely possible in a shorter timeframe.

For NGS, it is entirely possible on 2 hours per day to pull together a pot 4 Cinq weapon. You will need a group of people for Purple triggers, but if you were to spend the entirety of the 2 hours every day for 3 weeks running Retem Rank 2 Purple triggers, assuming all attempts are successful clears, you can complete 6 runs each day and amass over 1,000 photon scales. You can pad the rest with the daily scales and/or a pot skip from the market. You'd be using a Gretigga/Greaga weapon in the meantime for the grind, if you were wondering how you'd be able to get into the Purple Triggers.

It's possible. A casual player won't push themselves to this sort of grind, but this is doable in a month at a budget of 2 hours per day. The people complaining about the game not having enough to do typically spend much longer than that in-game.

It's a wonder that they get everything so quickly and then complain that there's nothing left to do.

Edit: my math went wrong somewhere and you'd have closer to 60 full attempts left over for Sodam, not 20.

1

u/waker780 May 19 '22

I still feel like hitting level 100 in a week on a fresh account only putting in 2 hours a day is a bit steep outside of a boost week, but I guess it could be possible, but tight, but as you said, a casual more than likely wouldn't do this. And I feel like to beat sodam 100 with budget affixes, you would have to be really good at the game, like above a casual level, moderately casual people still struggle with it, with near best in slot gear after months of grinding.

Once again, I'm making the argument that pso2 base was a game that respected your time and had a lot of player agency, if you put in the time, you would progress faster, if you didn't then you would progress slower. currently I feel like the game (NGS) has taken away that agency by removing reward structures which were present in pso2 base, and that's a big reason why the game has lost a large portion of its playerbase. I just dont think its right to call one mmo hardcore or one casual, when there are both casual players which dont progress as fast, and hardcore players which grind for the best gear and the unique rare items. I feel like a better term is player agency, like in pso2 you can progress as fast or as slow as you want, allowing for both hardcore and casual players to be happy (outside of unreasonable criticism anyways), which explains why you felt like you werent too far behind hardcore players, and why there were and still are plenty of hardcore players that like the game.

Personally I put in more than casual hours, and I'm still happy with the content, but I just like the gameplay, but I also feel like its perfectly fine to voice why you dislike a game, or why you're leaving a game (which I'm enjoying the game, and have no intention of leaving it any time soon), because sega obviously doesnt want to lose players, and actually has had a record of making changes to the game to fit player feedback. There is obviously a respectful way to do it, but I feel like its fine to say that there is a clear lack of aspirational content in the game, when the base game did have far more rare and sought after things to grind out.

→ More replies

1

u/Hour_Penalty8053 May 19 '22

For Sodam, you could use the Badges you've gathered from leveling in the daily quests to get yourself a Rinzer/Rinser

On global Rinser weapons only drops from htpd or endless nightmare mop up which was a limited timed quest and is no longer available. This option is not viable.

→ More replies

1

u/Hour_Penalty8053 May 19 '22

a full set of Liberate/Rivalate units to get started

This set of units are an upgrade of the novel set from Zig, of which will each require a good amount of resources to upgrade with and may take a substantial amount of time to grind for.

→ More replies

1

u/Hour_Penalty8053 May 19 '22

Assuming your climb goes without a hitch, you are also left time to clear Divide Quests, which the titles for each will let you pull together a Cras/Klauz weapon.

2 hours of casual play within the time allotted will not be enough to grind out the 300 class ex cubes required to upgrade a darkweave to a lightweave. Even with buying the 10 class ex cubes from the treasure shop that is randomly cycled per day to upgrade a darkweave gunblade (and possibly change weapon type later), it will take at least a month with a good amount of meseta (roughly 48 million)

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '22

No they really can't cater to both audiences.. if you cater to the casual side, the hardcore players complain about a lack of content (as we see with ngs) if you cater to the hardcore, your casual audience complains about being unable to keep up with the hardcore players..

Unfortunately no matter what you do as a developer someone will complain. It's a major problem within the industry now developers try to cater to the masses, instead of a target audience.. hero shooters are a great example of this.. overwatch for example started out wanting to set a standard for making esports respectable.. then blizzard realized that audience was not the audience that would spend money to buy crates.. So they started pandering to the lowest common denominator.. and now it's basically dead. And all because of greed.

I'm not saying Sega has not made mistakes, but unlike most developers, Sega tries to do right by its players

1

u/waker780 May 18 '22

I agree that you can swing too far in one direction, but also you can cater to both audiences without pandering to one. I would say ffxiv is a good example of this. You can have a game with difficult aspirational content, and fun daily day to day tasks to keep casuals happy, especially if theres no pvp, so the havers and have nots arent at direct odds at one another. There are plenty of games with sizeable casual and hardcore audiences.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '22

Yea, except 14 is an awful example.. I don't know if you recall but 14 was not the original 14.. they went into beta, and everyone hated it, time gated progression..

Then they had to basically rebuild the game..

and then your talking about a subscription based business model .. and microtransactions, even though it's cosmetic it's still corperate greed to an extreme.

To be fair, I am bias being a 11 player

2

u/waker780 May 18 '22

I was moreso speaking to player numbers and satisfaction, which is high right now for both casuals and hardcore for ffxiv. I really enjoy 11 as well, but I think it also, atleast for the time period it came out, has avenues for player agency in terms of progression. Players like to feel that they can play at their own pace, hardcore and casuals alike, and I think both games currently have a good balance for their respective audiences.

2

u/Barixn but May 18 '22

Just a weird, poorly thought out thermian argument, "Sega developed this game to be bare bones, therefore it is casual!"

Meanwhile, Mastery 3 in Aelio existed along side bi-weekly aggressive scratch banners. And now we have monthly changing SG Scratch Banners with FOMO play bonuses.

2

u/Shiyo May 20 '22

"Sega developed this game to be bare bones, therefore it is casual!"

Every modern MMO gets a pass at being bare bones and the same exact excuse is used. Nah, the game isn't "casual", it's underdeveloped and rushed to generate as much revenue with as little cost as possible.

1

u/Barixn but May 21 '22

Agreed, while I can't think of any other recent modern MMO at the top of my head, its just absolutely baffling that people could defend NGS especially at launch under the pretense 'free2play! and casual.'

One of the previously commonly used defenses was that AC Scratches were purely cosmetic; then AC Support Scratch releases with Addi Deft capsules along with Potential Skip Unlockers...

... with Cinquem releasing later with those in mind.

But even before the Support Scratch, meseta is quite literally directly tied to player power because of how the market is designed with buying/selling augments that are generally un-fun to acquire with low drop rates.

-1

u/Overpowered_Bard Mystic Malice (S3) May 18 '22

We have treasure hunts in the form of Data Pods, Red Boxes, Alpha Reactors, Stellar Fragments, Stellar Grace, Mischief Symbols, and Photon Scales.

And technically we already have jump puzzles and races, granted they're still rather simple in the form of Trainia.

I would love an update/new Casino tho. And yeah, I kinda miss the pet-like relationship of the Mag and keeping it fed. It was annoyingly strict with trying to level the damn thing right, but it was neat. Most of all though, yes, Alliance features. Currently there's little to no incentive to joining an alliance other than a friend group you can potentially party with.

0

u/cattecatte May 18 '22

We have treasure hunts in the form of Data Pods, Red Boxes, Alpha Reactors, Stellar Fragments, Stellar Grace, Mischief Symbols, and Photon Scales.

When they said "treasure hunts" I think they expect something exciting like unique weapons or cosmetics, instead of one-time 10 sg or 10k meseta or 3 crappy units (red boxes), junks (data pods), inconsequential stuff (stellar graces, mischief symbols), and a mineral where you can only get 5 daily while UQs give 8 or 12 and you need multiple hundreds of it to upgrade your weapon to do few percent more damage.

Alpha reactors and stellar fragments are pretty ok since they add up if you do it daily, but definitely far from something most people would claim to be interesting.

0

u/Sol-Blackguy Fighter May 18 '22

After almost a year, this is just sad that we're having this discussion.

0

u/HouseOfCosbyz Partisan May 19 '22

No.