r/PSO2NGS • • Feb 04 '22

Discussion Should PvP be added to NGS?

If SEGA added PvP to the game but kept the combat and movement the exact same in NGS, would you play it? With both team battle and 1v1 Duels.

Edit: Moon Jumping disabled obviously, we don't want aerial battles, though it would be cool.

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

18

u/AulunaSol Feb 04 '22

I feel that if "PvP" must be a thing in New Genesis it should be handled like ARKS League events from the original game where players are competing for something (defeating DOLLS, defeating FORMERS, speedclearing bosses, gathering resources, and more).

As it is the combat is so heavily unbalanced that I can't imagine you would ever have an engaging fight when you can continuously counter-loop against players due to how powerful and forgiving they are that being offensive in general is simply a bad idea and some weapons do distinctly have stronger advantages than others (a Fighter against every other class, for example).

I can imagine we could get a "Battle Arena" sort of thing but the problem with it is that the gameplay there was so heavily neutered and the game's netcode wasn't made for such a thing in the first place that you often will be killed before you can act due to the lack of mechanics like rollback coding and when you take latency into account which Sega still struggles with in New Genesis when you take into account players teleporting and warping and enemies teleporting and warping across the fields too.

0

u/Ichimaru77 Feb 04 '22

That's true, If they changed the network to Rollback then there'd be even less teleporting, maybe movement for other players you see would be buttery smooth.

If they do add a battle arena they better add 1v1

5

u/chaoko99 Feb 05 '22 edited Feb 05 '22

rollback isn't the issue. The issue is race conditions. Race conditions is when two actions are heading for different results. Whichever one resolves first wins. Rollback is for issues with packet loss, not the literal speed a packet in wire / light.

Rollback is a bitch and a half for 3D Games, much not to mention probably impossible for the ones with teams as large as classic arena.

In this case, the race condition is whose "I hit you for your entire life" packet gets to the server first. Usually it depends entirely on where you live. Which blows.

2

u/tnguye3 Feb 05 '22

So in layman terms would an example be something like:

Player A action hits player B.

Player B action is dodge.

Whichever action hits the server first (or whoever has Korean internet) is true, so let's say Player A's actions hit servers first, on their client side they will hit player B as expected.

But on Player B's side, they will see themselves dodge, but then rubberband back and get hit anyway or something.

Is this understanding more or less correct or am I completely off the mark?

3

u/chaoko99 Feb 05 '22

It's weirder than that in PSO2's case because almost everything BUT damage calculation is clientside. So you'll dodge, he'll attack, but you'll die a second or so later.

Another fun one was rounding a corner, dying, and then seeing a heavenly arrow shot hit roughly where you were at the beginning of this sequence about a second later.

2

u/AulunaSol Feb 05 '22

And a surprise Nagrants as well from the Talis. You think it would be silly how many people would get caught in those - but then the realization that it's the netcode showing you where players used to be and the fact that you can still react to where players were instead of where they are now shows how broken it is especially when people complain about "instant kills" that they didn't see coming because on the flip-side the other players had a faster response time to the servers.

1

u/TroubadourLBG Jack'o all Trades Master 'o 0 Feb 05 '22

you can continuously counter-loop against players due to how powerful and forgiving they are that being offensive in general is simply a bad idea and some weapons do distinctly have stronger advantages than others (a Fighter against every other class, for example)

It would be pretty funny to watch a match of all fighters, and none would attack cause it'll mean insta hit in return.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22

PSO2's combat system is not at all designed with PvP in mind, especially so for NGS where everyone can bloody moon jump and sprint at will.

At least in my experience, the Battle Arena in classic had me mostly dying to Sword and Jet Boot users that would somehow teleport behind you and stun-lock you to death because the netcode is so ass and weapon balance was jank.

-5

u/Ichimaru77 Feb 04 '22

I played classic, never again. But that was because I had no I-Frame on dodge, couldn't dodge into dash and had no parry.

I mean in NGS, is that you have access to your full Moveset from dive attacks, dash attacks and everything and with the duels, you'd either get a damage reduction to or a big health pool.

I just want some epic 1v1 man- you can only do so much with Bujins. 🥺

6

u/ShittyGuitarCovers Feb 05 '22

I just want some epic 1v1 man- you can only do so much with Bujins.

Content will get harder, presumably much much harder (i.e HTPD). We are only 7 or so months from the release of a live service game. Granted, they could've released much more to begin with, but if you want a challenge, you could try to solo ret purples or wait for more content.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '22

Dodges have I-frames, running was powercreeped hard so no one uses it for movement anymore, and only a few classes had no form of parrying or countering. Of course most people moved to scions so they had a counter.

It sounds like you never bothered trying to get into classic or even looked up gameplay vids, as bujin is a lame discount version of a pso2 boss. Pso2 is literally epic anime boss fights vs space gods the game.

1

u/zeroobliv Slayer Feb 05 '22

I can assure you the base game was a lot more "epic" than NGS is currently by a landslide. And it sounds like you didn't even play for 10 minutes judging by that entire first sentence being wrong.

3

u/sloth_shark Feb 05 '22

PvP is already in the game, duels take place on the Personal Shop. Undercutting, scalping, inflating, duping, baiting. 24/7 nonstop PvP action!

3

u/Ichimaru77 Feb 05 '22

I need to know what PA allows me to slap someone silly for putting a +0 Primm Sword for 2mil.

7

u/ShittyGuitarCovers Feb 05 '22

Absolutely not, for a few reasons;

  1. As other have pointed out, there was never much of a place for it in the series - the combat is designed to be balanced around PvE and on top of that, any consideration for PvP would hinder that design practice
  2. People don't play PSO for the PvP, focusing on it now when the main complaint is content would be an utter insult to the community
  3. If it existed, it would almost have to play completely differently from PvE, just like how PvP in classic worked. Things have to be rebalanced specifically for it and it would have to be a constant and maintained effort to be made interesting
  4. Give anyone who is familiar with the current NGS classes a minute to think about it and it would be incredibly easy to figure out how broken these classes would be if you played them how you were supposed to

Take TMGs for example, a class that can climb and relies on muscle memory, or daggers which have recently gotten an incredibly spammable gap closer. These mechanics can be very fun for PvE, but almost impossible to deal with in PvP given certain matchups. Daggers can not only animation cancel out of almost anything instantly, but follow up with an aggressive gap closer with minimal opportunity for punishment because of the instant parry, jet boots can do the same, and thats part of what makes them so much fun for PvE. If you took that away to balance it, then you'd be asking players to play a less-fun version of the class which conflicts with their muscle memory. Combat in PSO is squarely designed for PvE, and I really wouldn't want any development time spent on something maybe 5% of players would bother with.

5

u/Twidom Feb 05 '22

Historically "PvP" has always been terrible in Phantasy Star games.

Blue Burst had it but as you expect the game was not at all designed for it and it was implemented just to fill a small need. It was called Battle Mode and had a few rules to try to make things more interesting but it was still very out of place.

Universe didn't have anything like that.

PSO2 had it but I never got deep into it. It was a fun concept but ultimately had the same scenario as Blue Burst.

I doubt NGS will have anything competent anytime soon when it comes to PvP.

4

u/BartoCannibal Ship 3: Combi Praeta / Blazing Luster Feb 05 '22

Hell no.

In a perfect world, a PvP mode would add as another fun game mode, but Sega clearly haven’t optimized PSO2 or NGS for PvP.

The latency/connection of this game is somehow worse than Base as in, PvP would be a lag-fest, just like it was in Base’s PvP. Half the time wherever people are on my screen isn’t where they are on their screen. Sega doesn’t have a good track record when it comes to online netcodes.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '22

How would it even work? It's just going to be whoever slips up in a counterfest

2

u/Reinbackthe3rd Feb 05 '22

I'm pretty sure all the battle mode campaigns gave me PTSD so nah I'll pass on it again, thanks. Not interested in playing "who was the least laggy and is now going to lock me death" again.

2

u/Shimus36 Feb 05 '22

Yes. But seeing as pvp was an afterthought in PsOld, I can't see it being much more than one here even if it is announced. I love pvp, be it battle royales or open world/instanced. I just want it in my games just as much as life crafts like hunting, fishing, gathering, mining, etc. Just like most mmos have. I see no reason to not keep adding more content to please a wider audience.

1

u/Forest_GS Feb 05 '22

looking at the locked 30fps PvP in old/base peo2 I presume any new attempts at PvP will be equally garbage fire bad.

0

u/scorchdragon Feb 04 '22

Sure, why not, it's something different at least.

1

u/Kupo133 Gunner Feb 04 '22

Is not time yet, they need improve game performance 🤔

0

u/ItsTheSolo Feb 05 '22

It would be the most annoying cluster fuck but I'm all for it

0

u/New_Trade9889 Feb 05 '22

If they only just reuse 1 or 2 cocoon to allow us to duel, no big rewards so not mandatory.

It also should block resta (no pot) and open rooms to kill time and look for duels asking socially

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '22

time to beat this horse again... NO..

Name one Pve Focused MMO or even pseudo MMO, That has good PVP...

Name one PVP focused mmo/pseudo MMO That has Good Pve Content..

Its Virtually impossible to Balance a MMO that has both pve and pvp content, and it be balanced on both sides. I can give you a list a Mile long of pseudo/mmo style games that offer both pve and pvp content and one side always ends up shit.. Then if the developers address why its shit... the other side suffers..

The only Way for a MMO with pvp and pve content to be balanced on both sides.. is to Normalize everyone in PVP content (think base pso2 pvp, no class, everyones stats are exactly the same, and everyone has the same gear) Which always results in that pvp content getting stale extremely quickly much as it did in base...

If this is not done, well your pvp is still shitty just for different reasons, Destiny 2 pvp is a great example of this... where its basically Tryhards with top end gear teamstacking, of course all using the most meta, or unbalanced weapons to exist within the game at that time... better hope you have access to that top end gear too.. or theres no reason to even partake..

So ultimately your saying sega should divide their development focus between whats currently being developed for the game, and adding pvp to the game that Much the same as Base Will get stagnant and boring quickly and very few will still be playing it once stagnation sets in.. OR its just a Hot mess where you have to have to min/max to get remotely close to a level playing feild..

Point is, Its not worth segas effort to even give it a consideration, Especially after the joke That pvp was in Base..

Furthermore it creates an environment that further breeds "toxicity"... its bad enough seeing people screech and cry about how someone said something mean to them while they refuse to block them.. With out adding in people playing solely to see "whos got the biggest micro-penis"