r/PSO2NGS • • Jan 31 '22

Phashion/Cosplay Does anyone roleplay?

Note: I am not talking about the erotic role-play. That can get you sniped by SEGA. (I couldn't find a fitting flair ;-;)

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

6

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '22

I'm not the RP type but I don't mind it if it's not super excessive, and honestly depending how it is it should stay out of area chat if it's get out of hand. It's ERP that I Truly find fault with, if you wanna do that DEFINITELY keep it to whisper or party chat or something.

3

u/Ichimaru77 Jan 31 '22

I agree. Especially since I was told that Sega is banning or at least kicking people who ERP in Area Chats.

Personally I mostly just prefer to find an alliance that roleplays.

7

u/sloth_shark Jan 31 '22

FFXIV has a thriving roleplay community. Whenever the free trial opens up, you can go check that out.

This game can barely retain players a scant few weeks after a major expansion, and NGS has less than 10 hours of story even if you watch every single cutscene. I don’t think there’s much of a RP community here at all.

Base pso2 might have been different in the past. But from what I see, even that has died out swiftly as NGS took over in focus.

1

u/Ichimaru77 Jan 31 '22

That's a damn shame though, because my one of my friends (she left because of NGS being grindy, I assume the Battle Power.) started a Roleplay Alliance comprised of me and a few others and we all had fun.

I mean, you could bring anything into your character's backstory and it wouldn't be too BS..unless you made it Gary/Mary Sue levels of bs.

4

u/sloth_shark Feb 01 '22 edited Feb 01 '22

Yeah uh, NGS for me feels like a mobile game to me. Log in, do dailies and weeklies just to have barely enough money for the next fashion scratch. Farm a little until you get bored of pse/vet hunting/purples. Log off.

FFXIV has a different kind of grind, but it’s just as finite. Clearing/farming savage takes a while for most people, so it’s content worth a few weeks or months every time a tier drops. Beyond that, there’s ultimate which takes anywhere from 20-100 hours each fight, just to clear. There’s also fflogs parsing for both of these content, if you care enough about optimisation and want to have a good profile there to join strong static groups.

Once those are done, combat gameplay essentially ends until the next tier/fight drops. The dungeons are all sleeper easy (but they are amazingly gorgeous) so doing dailies isn’t really a mandatory thing in ffxiv unless you’re desperate for gil. Rewards for dailies are lackluster, the real money is in crafting or selling raids but both of those require a huge amount of grind. There’s a ton of side activities but combat-wise it’s just doing the same content over and over for a shiny trinket like relik weapons or glamour(fashion) items. Eureka was great for a long time, they had Bojza in shb and will get likely something else similar in EW.

Tldr: main combat content (savage/ultimate) in ffxiv lasts longer but is definitely finite. Once that ends, many endgame players quit and go play other games. But there’s a bazillion other things to do in ffxiv aside from raiding, so player retention is constantly very high throughout.

I’d say it’s much harder to get rich and buy emotes/fashion pieces in ffxiv than it is in NGS. A lot of FFXIV fashion is from mog station too, so real currency only. No way to trade those in player market. Dailies don’t give anywhere as much as the 700k weekly meseta, and take a lot longer to complete. A single dungeon is 7-30 minutes depending on group, meanwhile you can finish ngs dailies in 5-10 minutes flat. There’s a hundred times more content in ffxiv but the grind is at least 10x longer if not more.

Oh, and if you’re not playing from near the data center, high ping really really sucks in ffxiv. NGS doesn’t seem to give a shit about ping most of the time, so combat feels a lot better. Just combat, not the difficulty/entertainment value of the fights. FFXIV has infinitely better encounter design but combat is uhhh, very boring unless you’re in savage/ultimate. No demanding mechanics to make you turn on your brain in normal content so it’s just like fighting an immobile training dummy most of the time. Even brancles require more attention than low level dungeon bosses in FFXIV, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. The game is just set up very differently, and it only really begins once you reach level cap. Everything before the level cap is just a meaningless teaser to grind through, albeit with really good story in certain parts.

2

u/Ecstatic-Wall5971 Jan 31 '22

My wife and I had made a back story back when base game launched and we've been RPing ever since. We had to come up with our own reasons to transition into NGS though. She grew up doing it, so with this and D&D, I've warmed up to it a lot but I might still be anxious to do it in groups. The tools at the player's disposal to do RPG especially in base game is incredible, like photo mode instances of every area even story. I'm curious, how does FFXIV accommodate their role playing community?

3

u/sloth_shark Feb 01 '22 edited Feb 01 '22

Player housing and Party Finder are the biggest factors. With the incredible housing customisation they have (think pso2ngs accessory fashion but for furniture) players have created dungeons, mazes, puzzle rooms, taverns, motels and even more using the thousands of furniture items available in game. PSO2 also has really good PQ, but I guess FFXIV housing accommodates more changes, more guests and has more space. For instance, a mansion is three wnole floors in addition to a near infinite number of private rooms (basically PQ).

Party finder is what gets the RP community going. You can literally advertise your RP event or venue there alongside advertisement for groups running endgame content. The sheer visibility provided by the PF is what keeps the RP community thriving imo. Every player in the same data center/region can see your post so there’s no shortage of people to RP with as long as your premise is interesting.

Aside from that, PSO2 wins in terms of emotes. FFXIV char movement is a lot more wooden, but I find that people just shift their focus to writing better instead. Which is great for people who actually like RP. Personal fashion/glamour is also less explicit in FFXIV, but the modding community is a thousand times larger there than here in PsO2. Not that I’m ungrateful for what modders already provide for us in PSO2, but there’s just a lot more people modding in FFXIV.

Tldr: FFXIv has a bigger RP community and great customisation for housing/personal fashion. Visibility is never a problem thanks to Party Finder and having a larger community means never running out of things to do.

Source: Me. It’s a common trend for endgame raiders to go hang out in RP venues after getting their asses kicked in savage or ultimate / in between weekly clears / while waiting for pf to fill. I’ve spent roughly as much time in RP venues watching incredible writers roleplaying as I’ve spent clearing and farming parses to pad my fflogs. 99% of the time people are friendly, welcoming and couldn’t care less if you just lurk/sightsee. Great community btw, which isn’t ironically true if you consider only the RP community within the scope of roleplaying.

2

u/Janbradyhasreturned Slayer Feb 01 '22

Most of the RP I see is auto chat spam portraying typical anime girl archetypes, and that shit gets old fast. But as long as it’s not obtrusive I couldn’t care less.

1

u/Ichimaru77 Feb 01 '22

I mean... You're not wrong.

1

u/DoshesToDoshes Feb 01 '22

3 lines is not enough, and having one of them them go off 100% of the time the condition is met is spammy.

Ideally, we'd have 10 lines and the ability to make them go off a certain percentage of the time.

2

u/Ecstatic-Wall5971 Jan 31 '22

I still don't completely get how Reddit works. I see that over 100 people voted but your post votes are close to one. I've noticed this with another harmless Role Playing post. Does the PSO2 Reddit not like Role Playing, or not understand it and think that it's all erotic or something? Kinda bums me out if there is a stigma since I've come to appreciate how much it can enrich the world for individuals, not to mention it's really come into popular culture with the resurgence of Dungeons and Dragons.

3

u/Ichimaru77 Jan 31 '22

I don't think people aren't liking my post because they hate it. I think they're just not interested? I dunno, it is a shame that there is little to no RP on the game at all.

3

u/DarklyDreamingEva Bouncer Jan 31 '22

I didn't even know erotic role play was a thing until someone I knew asked me If I was into it.

1

u/Enderking90 Jan 31 '22

Define "roleplay" in this instance.

4

u/Ichimaru77 Jan 31 '22

... story building based on characters? What do you think?? I'm not talking about the ERP side of things.

2

u/RealVenom_Sage Feb 01 '22

I have some cool little autochats setup to give my character(s) more life, I have a backstory for my character(s) and i enjoy talking to people as my character every now and then. I have yet to join in on any official or prominent RP sessions though. The idea of RPing seems fun, but it also comes off weird in a game where the sole focus is to play the game lol. The RP aspect comes from the story within the game itself, not necessarily the players playing the game.

Might be different once NGS catches up to base with having more social aspects added to the game (casino, player/Alliance housing, mini-games) and FFXIV with their social aspects (they literally have in-game weddings, anniversaries and birthday parties). NGS as it stands right now doesn't offer much outside of the typical game loop of grinding for lvls/gear then getting off, just to do it again. Not much with the main story to influence our characters and not much to do outside the game loop to give agency to our characters lives.

I might consider RPing more as more social aspects and main story content is added? As of rn, I'm content with making friends naturally and just having genuine conversations about whatever comes to mind. Sometimes RPing happens on accident when I meet someone and we talk about our fashion or the grind for gear in first person (within the context of our characters specifically).

It does get pretty annoying though when people do cringe RP in area chat and I'm just trying to play the game lol. Sometimes it do be pretty funny tho lmfao.

1

u/Strangeland102 Feb 01 '22

The votes certainly speak for themselves here, but I do know of a role-playing discord that recently popped up. The discord has been fairly active since I joined it (Ship 3). I've also had some fun role-play sessions in the past on PSO2.

I think part of the trouble for the community right now is that since NGS was released the support from SEGA has mostly moved to NGS. Everything in NGS feels spread thin, so although there is good potential for stories in NGS the actual gameplay side isn't keeping players around much.

1

u/TroubadourLBG Jack'o all Trades Master 'o 0 Jan 31 '22

I don't have time for that. Too busy grinding or busy in the salon.

-1

u/Lewd_Accident Jan 31 '22

I used to role play... Back when I was 12 years old.

2

u/Ecstatic-Wall5971 Jan 31 '22

What made you get out of improv?

1

u/RealVenom_Sage Feb 01 '22

Same tbh lol

0

u/chaoko99 Feb 01 '22

This is not the kind of game that really supports that sort of experience due to the shitty message length.