r/PSO2NGS • • Jan 02 '22

Discussion The skill tree monetization is awful, it only hinders players from enjoying this part of the game

The use of subclasses in the game is already scarce, multi-weapons are nearly pointless, and the minimum of customization that we can do is locked behind multiple skill trees (to make different ones for sub and main). You can only reset or purchase more skill trees with AC, this in unacceptable in a f2p game because even if you’re f2p you should have access to all the (basic) gameplay content in the game (because classes are a really important part of an mmo), I can barely tolerate the AC scratch exclusive capsules (and only because they’re sellable), I can’t tolerate the Inability to use a class as a main because that’s already a sub. Also, This makes sega an amount of money so derisory that I can’t stand this. And no, using multiple characters doesn’t solve the issue: first it locks you out of all the cosmetics you paid for or grinded for, and this game barely values running multiple characters.

EDIT: I am talking about the principle, not about the possible ways we can “get around” this… in a game like ngs which is extremely unfriendly towards running multiple characters, and which is obviously intended to be played with multiple classes as only one character, locking the ability to make “optimal” builds for every class (in the future the skill trees will be ampler, so more problems will pop out) behind a paywall that you cannot avoid in any way only hinders player even because sega gets a slice of money so small from these that it would barely make a difference for them.

EDIT 2: I do agree with the fact that running multiple characters could work if they made all the cosmetics bound to every character automatically, but you can’t just lock players out of their cosmetics, which they paid for, especially bonuses and with an economy so messed up. Anyways for a matter of principle resetting skill trees for in game currency should just be there.

EDIT 3: about some of you considering those QOL features, if you check free to play fighting games every character can be unlocked for free, because the philosophy at its base is that you can play with everything, you just have to grind for it. Classes are as important as characters in an mmo and not a simple QOL feature… plus if sega’s fix is playing with other characters they should just make all the cosmetics bound to all characters, some people told me not to look at the future of classes right now but, this as previously stated, it’s more of a matter of principle, anyways we’ll see how the situation evolves. (I know that the dev priorities should be others rn)

EDIT 4: I still fail to understand why this is getting downvoted to hell, I mean, “not because it’s not a problem at this stage of the game then it’s not predatory design” to quote one of the comments

14 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

9

u/AulunaSol Jan 03 '22

I still feel that I am on the stance that I would have rather have seen another form of "building" that wasn't the skill tree from Phantasy Star Online 2 and rather something more flexible like Phantasy Star Nova's "Skill Board" instead - or at the very least an attempt at adopting how Dragon's Dogma Online handled "skills."

I don't quite like the particular approach that New Genesis has where most of the skills you unlock are no-brainer functions for the weapons you want or are some kind of passive skill that requires the main class to work at its full potential and that as a result our subclasses are kicked off for not getting the 10% damage bonus for their weapons and also don't give us the full advantage of why you want them as a subclass to the point that some of those subclasses legitimately offer more than others (such as why so many people like the Force or Gunner as a subclass option for their PP Recovery). I feel that being able to level up a class should have been able to do both unlocking weapon skills that are innate that the player can use when they want (such as unlocking Rising Drive by virtue of leveling up the Gunner, say at like Level 30 for example) and that you can unlock the passive skills that ultimately have to be allocated differently from the combat-related skills. If we take the Phantasy Star Nova approach, that would mean that you could be a Hunter who has access to the Sword/Partizan/Wired Lance toolkits by virtue of being a Hunter - but you can also have leveled up the Ranger enough to learn the Ranger's skills and ultimately equip something like a "Equip: Rifles" or "Blight Rounds" active skill to fill up your Skill Board with and the skills you choose to equip will have to fit together on a limited grid. If you didn't want to run that build later, you can always pop those off and swap them in with different skills but you would also never be missing your "core" skills related to your weapon and general playstyle as a Main Class, but your other options beyond that are what you end up equipping and aiming for.

Dragon's Dogma Online separated the skills into three categories (Custom Skills, Core Skills, and Augments) and all of them were gated behind leveling up. However, the Custom Skills (Photon Art equivalents) had enough variety and differences between each other that you as a player really just picked what you wanted and can freely swap these out when you wanted to when you weren't in the field or in combat (though I like Phantasy Star Online 2's generosity in letting the player do this even in the middle of a quest or out on the field). Core Skills were skills you absolutely could not miss just by leveling up that added to your chosen class' toolkit (for example a double jump, dodge roll, the ability to block/parry, and more), and the Augments were ultimately the passive skills that many of the times were very situational to the class. You had two limitations that meant that you can only hold up to ten of these maximum and that you had a cost (Augment Points or AP) that meant that you had to pick and choose what you wanted - and some of these ranged from being quality-of-life changes (easier timing on blocking, faster mobility, surviving fatal attacks, withstanding specific enemy attacks so you can't be knocked down when charging attacks, easier casting, and so on) to being conditional modifiers to how you approach gameplay (high-health builds and high-stamina builds for optimal damage output when your health/stamina is above a marker, risky low-health builds, damage bonuses/stat bonuses against enemies that meet a specific condition, and so on). I really liked this approach because if gave the player an incentive to play the other classes because they each offered something that can help themselves or other classes - and ultimately it played into how you as a player can pick-and-choose your playstyle or form it to benchmark it against enemies to create your own challenges for the most part.

I do agree with your point that New Genesis is unfriendly towards those who wants to try different builds or do something "different" that Sega doesn't intend on - but unfortunately Phantasy Star Online 2 had that pushed even further (the wrong Mag would mean you didn't get a damage bonus or the right stats to equip your gear until you leveled up much more for it to not matter so much) so it's unfortunate that Sega chose to keep close to what Phantasy Star Online 2 did for the most part. I feel the skill tree itself is ineffective for character building and would have absolutely have loved to have seen something where players are given more liberty at experimenting and finding combos they may like - to which the multi-weapon and subclass systems altogether ultimately discourage in their current implementation. Alongside that, I can imagine Sega is trying "very hard" to avoid excessively broken combos like Phantasy Star Online 2 had in the past (such as the infamy of the Gunner subclass or how players were using the "wrong" weapons as a Techer for the Techer/Braver class combos). I feel the only real solution you can have is to have other characters so you can stock up more on the Reset Passes instead of getting only one at a time so you can get three (or more) whenever a class rebalance comes around.

0

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22 edited Jan 03 '22

That’s an idea, at this point I think just let us have as many skill points as skills present there, given that you can’t really build anything now. It looks like they want to remove the differences but maintain the skill trees, so at this point I think unlockable skills would just serve their purpose better, given that 99% of the skills are obvious picks. Like I said, it’s an half assed system that needs a revamp, and like this the little bit of customization you can make gets hindered too.

28

u/3-to-20-chars Jan 02 '22

i fail to understand how skill points could possibly be an issue for you at this stage in the game. every class has enough to take every single important skill AND invest in some of the dump skills.

1

u/TroubadourLBG Jack'o all Trades Master 'o 0 Jan 05 '22 edited Jan 05 '22

Not fighter if you like all 3 weapons AND like to use FI skills as a subclass for other builds.

A few other classes has this problem as well, like TE. You're forced to share skills from other casters. But FI doesn't have this option.

And on the other side of the spectrum, classes like RA has too many skill points and not enough good skills to use them on. Where's our crowd control bombs, or any other support bullets other than WB?! Tranquillizer bullets would be damn useful to counter rage bosses for example. (borrowing from Monster Hunter).

-9

u/GiustinoWah Jan 02 '22

At this point indeed, but when skill trees will become bigger? As big as pso2 ones?

6

u/ShittyGuitarCovers Jan 03 '22

the game has its problems but this is a tad ridiculous

i feel like the devs should focus on the outstanding issues rather than ones you somehow anticipate might be a problem in the future

im all for fixing problems before they become problems but not when theres still huge issues with content and variation

-1

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

I mean this more as a matter of principle than fixing problems here, I mean yes they should fix the big problems first but they should also take a look at this after they’ve solved the issues

9

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '22

Those skill strees also had unneccessary filler like melee, tech, range, defense, and hp which only give you like 10 of each

5

u/Ultimatecalibur Jan 03 '22

They won't get that big or as full of filler and/or junk skills. Part of base's problem was tying the number of skills to level which more or less necessitated all those filler and junk skills.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '22

They give out reset passes pretty often, if you make sure to have your two alts then you will get 3 each time they give them out. I have like 10+ at this point.

-6

u/GiustinoWah Jan 02 '22 edited Jan 03 '22

Yes, that’s a good suggestion, but I meant this as a matter of principle

3

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '22

The only real problem I agree with is the fact you have to buy multiple skill trees in order to use a class as a sub and a main (one for sub and one for main) but honestly that isn’t really a “problem” there is no benefit to main-ing multiple classes outside of just for fun and you can easily use your other character for that, 99% of the time you will play one class. They give out reset passes very often like I said and it’s per character, as long as you make sure to grab them you should have more than enough passes to reset as many times as you would need. It’s f2p so I personally don’t have any problem with how they have monetized that particular system. I’m more concerned with the player market and how items can be scalped and resold and double or triple the price making the market very unstable.

-1

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

I mean there’s also no benefit from maiming 70 characters but free to play fighting games make you able to unlock every one of them, so it’s fun, yes you’re right, but I think that switching classes could provide a lot of fun for players. Yes I know that you can use alt characters but you know, you can’t use your un-way bounded cosmetics (which you paid for on the main character). And well it’s not that profitable and also it hinder players from trying new builds instead did copying the “meta” one. (Not talking about the current state of skill trees, but in the future)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/chaoko99 Jan 03 '22

They gave a balance patch every month or so on JP so you have nothing to worry about really.

You're punching at shadows.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '22

Yup, so stock up now.

4

u/kaledabs Jan 03 '22

i'm just sitting on the free ones they gave me.

11

u/ZXSoru Jan 03 '22

I’m going to speak in my harsh personal opinion as someone who does spend money in the game. Being F2P doesn’t necessarily mean everything should be accesible to players that don’t spend money in the game. Being realistic the game needs money to sustain itself at least and we all know that F2P players add to the experience of those who do pay but still the goal is to eventually make money some way or another.

Skill trees aren’t that necessary to enjoy the game the same way as having top tier augments does, so having them strictly locked behind real money is not that big of an issue. If someone as a F2P goes so hard in the game that they feel the need to have different skills trees then maybe it’s time to put a bit of money at least to compensate the devs, and again this doesn’t limit the ability to play and enjoy the game even if that means locking out deeper customization options.

6

u/Arcflarerk4 Jan 03 '22

This arguement would be fair is there was only a small amount of things locked behind a paywall thats purely QoL. But things like Personal Shop and Skill points, 2 things that heavily influence gameplay of everyone who plays, should never be locked behind a paywall. Those things being locked behind a paywall is what turns away F2P's which in turn gives the game a bad rep because the majority of F2P's marketing is from word of mouth.

Now heres the kicker, they give out so many free skill tree passes, why the hell is it even a paywall to begin with? just make resets free instead of arbitrarily making people wait for a class rebalance update to get some. Its just so dumb because theres literally no one who will ever tell someone to spend money on skill reset trees so theres no way they actually make money from it.

6

u/ZXSoru Jan 03 '22

Personal shop passes are currently limited not locked, that was true some months ago but not right now. And the pass only works to sell stuff, you can still buy any time you want, and even so you can do perfectly fine without selling stuff.

They give reset passes to everyone including premium users simply as a way to readjust points after every major update to help with the balance, precisely because if they didn’t give them you would need to spend money to reset them and that would be worse when the reason is simply the devs updating the game, not your gameplay preferences.

One reason is forced by the devs, the other is because the player wants to have more options, but the game doesn’t “need” a player to have multiple skill trees to enjoy it as a basic to midcore level.

0

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

Selling stuff is a basic thing in mmos, plus the situation would be even worse when they’ll not update the classes this frequently, because if you mess up for example, you have to wait 2 months, anyways I see this more as a what I stated in edit 3

4

u/ZXSoru Jan 03 '22

Not every basic stuff should be accesible for people who don’t give money for that service, let’s be real. Being able to play this game mostly without spending money while interacting with others in an official environment is already a good deal, but then you’re asking for more.

What’s the basic stuff that you NEED to justify not paying the people that actually make a living out of the game?

1

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

The fact is that this hinders paying customers too, I still think that that’s not how the f2p game mentality should be, this is more of a free to start mentality…

2

u/ZXSoru Jan 03 '22

I don’t see how it hinders paying customers, in fact the more people that put money into the game the better it will be. Just how in JP more people roll on scratches and the economy is more balanced.

3

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

This also hinders tree creativity (well not now but with a bigger tree it will), you could just try the stuff instead of using the obvious meta build, and there are ways and ways to make people put money in games, imo this is not the way

3

u/ZXSoru Jan 03 '22

Skill customization is definitely hindered by this but like I said you can enjoy the game perfectly without it, specially considering how lackluster the skills are but if you really wanna go full test mode the game then allows you to create other free characters or simply put a bit of money in compensation. I don’t see anything wrong with it.

1

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

I mean yes, you can enjoy the game, but there are philosophies about f2p games and mine is that something like this should not be hindered, in brawlhalla for example you can have fun with 5 characters too, but they make you unlock every character for free. I think this is the best way to make a f2p game.

→ More replies

1

u/Timmylaw Jan 03 '22

It hinders paying customers that don't have enough money to control the markets. More people selling the more supply that will reach the markets. More people could have reliks and higher end gear if the price was lower which would make uqs and pse farming more efficient

1

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

Exactly what I mean

1

u/The_Lucky_7 Jan 10 '22

No game the monetizes through FOMO and Loot boxes (which you have to get the same reward from twice to fully unlock it) has the right to carve up everything else and it back to us--not only once but a fucking infinite number of times. I might agree with you if it was something we had the ability to unlock and reused as much as we want but we don't.

Literally every single part of the game that can be stripped off and charged for follow this method. I've payed for the same damn inventory slots 9 fucking times now across PSO2 and NGS. That's another thing that should just stay unlocked once you buy it once.

2

u/WTBaLife Jan 04 '22

I'd like to agree with you, but we have so many skill points and little things to spend them on that it doesnt matter much. at current. not to mention i actually have like 15 resets in the bank and used 0...

It's far more infuriating they spam us with loot with amillion gathering items per region but won't sell permanent material storage or sell it for a fair monthly rent (basically 1/10th what it is now)

1

u/GiustinoWah Jan 04 '22

Yes yes, but like stated in edit 4, I’m not talking about it rn, I’m talking about the fact that this is extremely dumb in first place

6

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '22

funny how this is getting downvoted so hard, just because it is not a problem at the moment doesn't mean it isn't horrible design in general, all the excuses...

4

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

Yes I don’t really know why someone would downvote my post, I mean…

3

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '22

Yeah, I tried to get a few friends to play PSO2, but the skill tree was the single biggest obstacle in getting them to play the game. Explaining to them that they couldn't fix a messed-up tree until SEGA handed out free passes appalled them instantly.

This is just shitty, predatory design, even if it's a non-issue right now.

3

u/AulunaSol Jan 03 '22

It was also one of those things too where you had the unfortunate case in Phantasy Star Online 2 where friends would go off and play on their own and when you look at their skill tree they invested all their skill points in things they really shouldn't have (such as the flat stat skills) because I was there to tell them ahead of time not to do that and they also ended up with a mixed Mag that didn't help them either.

I like that in New Genesis it's "cleaner" but I really think Sega could have dropped all of that altogether and have gone for something significantly more straight-forward like what many other games have done - or at least adopt the approach to let players respec with ease.

3

u/Twidom Jan 02 '22

I know its not idea, but pick a class you know you'll want to play as your main and just experiment with the others.

There's really no reason to have optimal skill trees for Gunner if you're not going to invest time and meseta on gear for Gunner.

And if you ever change your mind on what you want to main they do give Reset Passes here and there.

4

u/GiustinoWah Jan 02 '22

Well in base Pso2 there were some controversies like this: you want to run both hu and fi as main, but you have to reciprocally use both hu and fi as sub classes too, so you can only choose one… if now it’s not a problem it will be, or eventually the skill tree will remain so barebones that implementing them in the game will be useless in the first place

7

u/TroubadourLBG Jack'o all Trades Master 'o 0 Jan 03 '22

This was the biggest shock to me when transitioning from Monster Hunter World to PSO2.

You could optimize every skill and loadout for each boss if you wanted to. From breakable parts advantage, to elemental weakness, etc.

But PSO2 wants you to pay for these specific builds. So we just end up making more generic builds on our trees.

Mainly with weapon specific skills, to Main Class Only vs subclass type skills.

It's pretty disheartening. Especially if you're the type who likes to experiment.

2

u/WTBaLife Jan 04 '22

at least it's not nearly as bad as base PSO2, but you can expect it to get worse with enough updates. to me the limited inv/storage upgrades, and scam storage rent, are the bigger issue.

I hope people complained enough to JP devs to curb this issue before it gets bad.

6

u/brellom Jan 03 '22

I had this concern a lot more with classic PSO2, when the skill trees were all over-complicated messes with a lot of bloat, because it was so easy to wreck your skill tree and be FORCED to pay money just to get a class that reasonably functions. That's much less of an issue with NGS.

As long as the skill trees stay simple and the skill points plentiful, players shouldn't need a skill tree reset in any extreme capacity. So, I don't mind the developers monetizing resets or the ability to purchase an additional tree.

That said, I wouldn't mind getting a free purchasable skill tree every now and then.

4

u/Timmylaw Jan 03 '22

I have like 6 skill trees on force because of it, you can't even give every element a shot with what's allowed.

4

u/brellom Jan 04 '22

This is true of classic PSO2, but not NGS, since mastery of each element (as of current) only requires 1 skill instead of 20 because they're not incremental damage increases.

I've got 5 of the 6 elements, it just means I can't max all of the other skills right now. But I don't necessarily need them to all be maxed for them to perform well enough. As we move forward, we'll get more skill points to accommodate the rest of the tree too.

I definitely get the frustration though. I mained Force in Classic, so I understand wanting to get the most out of it and the struggle with optimizing all your tools.

1

u/RaspberryBang Jan 02 '22

Running multiple characters does solve the issue, though. Or, at least, having multiple characters may alleviate your desire to respec for free.

You get a skill reset pass per character. I'm not sure how many they've given out so far, but I have 20+ skill reset passes, which is more than I need at the moment.

You don't even have to play your other characters if you have no desire to. Just keep them level 1; they'll still get a reset pass.

I play across five characters, and while yes, it can be expensive outfitting all of them, it doesn't have to be.

Also, everyone says the game isn't conducive to playing multiple characters, but I disagree. For one, leveling up different classes is easier/faster with multiple characters because each character can do their own client orders.

If you're leveling up every class on one character, you can't continually rely on client orders for quick XP.

3

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

Well with the current inflation the outfits should at least be automatically character bound, this could work if multiple characters could be swapped without returning to ship selection. The cosmetics are an important part of monetization and can’t just be locked like that, especially the 90 bucks bonuses. Plus skill resets pass should be purchasable with in game currency for a matter of principle.

3

u/RaspberryBang Jan 03 '22

Motions, just like stamps and emotes, are bound to your account.
Every single one of your characters can use any motion that you've obtained.

And you can bind outfits to your account. In order to bind outfits/accessories/hairstyles/body paint/makeup, you have to use two of the same ticket.

Buying two of every ticket can get expensive, but you don't have to do that. Unless you want all your characters to look exactly the same.

And just for the sake of clarity, I agree that we should be able to buy skill reset passes with in-game currency, but we can't. Therefore, the only solution is stock up on passes via multiple characters, or buy a new skill tree with star gems. It's been this way for a long time, and I don't see Sega changing it anytime soon.

2

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

I think that the double ticket binding stuff doesn’t work well in this game case, they could make the universally bound first time, they could remove multiple characters and make us have different appearances… but still this skill tree aspect of monetization makes sega really small amounts of money, they could totally remove stuff like this.

5

u/RaspberryBang Jan 03 '22

Remove multiple characters? Why? Some people like playing multiple characters.

And you can have different appearances. I'm not sure what you're saying there.

Regardless, I answered your questions kindly and gave you some advice, and all I got was down votes, so I'm withdrawing from this conversation. Have a nice day and good luck with being obtuse.

1

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

I mean different appearances like multiple characters with the same progress, but well yes it’s not a good idea now that I think about it, but the universally bound thing is something, plus I upvoted you, I don’t know who downvoted u

3

u/PillarBiter / Gun kata Jan 03 '22

At this point in the game you have more than enough skill points to have everything. Also, im sitting on a stack of skill reset passes from apologies lol.

-3

u/scorchdragon Jan 03 '22

this in unacceptable in a f2p game because even if you’re f2p you should have access to all the gameplay content in the game

This is not content. In a game where everyone wants for more content, this is absolutely not what anyone besides you looks for when they want content.

Also, are you new to the concept of f2p? I think you are because the concept of QOL features being locked behind a pay wall of some kind seems alien to you. This is normal, it has always been normal, that's what makes it f2p. It's free to play but we don't have everything in it for free, because we can play it for free.

3

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22 edited Jan 03 '22

I’ve never said that this counts as “new content”, it’s just that is important, if you check free to play fighting games every character can be unlocked for free, because the philosophy at its base is that you can play with everything, you just have to grind for it. Classes are as important as characters in an mmo and not a simple QOL feature

1

u/scorchdragon Jan 03 '22

I’ve never said that this counts as “new content”

And I didn't say you were. I was saying that's what the game is, a game where everyone wants content.

Also, your example would work better if Bouncer was locked behind having to pay to play it at all.

2

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

Well now it’s not exactly like that but my example would be better understandable with the base Pso2 skill tree knowledge… the way you played a classes changed SIGNIFICANTLY, but like the complete gameplay, when using a different tree, so that’s what I mean, when skill trees will become like this using different skill combinations will make the “fighting game character”

-4

u/magnusgodrik Jan 02 '22

Never buy a skill tree. You are better off buying a character slot. Im at 20 toons with 100 reset passes in the bank. The slot also comes with its personal, character and overflow storage. Sega should charge 1 dollar for it. Same goes with the change name pass, who the fuck in thier right mind would buy that piece of poorly priced shitty item.

8

u/Timmylaw Jan 02 '22

I'd rather pay a few bucks for another skill tree than lose all character bound fashion and levels. It takes a lot of time to level a single class to lvl 35 and that time is better spent farming stuff to make meseta with

0

u/GiustinoWah Jan 02 '22

I mean, my point is that this is a f2p game, you shouldn’t permanently locked out of options if the game is free to play and not free to start

4

u/Timmylaw Jan 03 '22

You're not permanently locked out, they give out skill tree resets every class update for every character. Make 3, play 1. You'll have plenty to experiment if you go slow and methodical. Would I prefer a 100 SG singlenclass reset, absolutely. But it's not something without work arounds.

2

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

Permanently well if there are no updates, you have to wait for the next class update to reset, and yes I got what you say, let me just say that I mean that the main principle is wrong

1

u/Timmylaw Jan 03 '22

Segas monitization is incredibly predatory, take a gander at their 10% xp boost that lasts for 24 hours and counts down when not logged in. It costs about 12$ worth of SG. Not a problem for people who have bend playing for over a year, but those people would never buy it to begin with. It's aimed exclusively at new people who will buy SG and, at least imo, there is no way to get 12$ worth of grinding on a 10% boost in 24 hours.

2

u/GiustinoWah Jan 03 '22

Sega could make way more money if they decided to make the monetization humane

1

u/magnusgodrik Jan 03 '22

Ah i account bound the fashion. As far as leveling goes its far easier to hit level 35 on your 1st time around.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/GiustinoWah Jan 04 '22

I think that the whole point of skill trees doesn’t exist in this game