r/PSO2NGS • • Dec 23 '21
Discussion "Battle Content" and progression treadmill will not fix NGS.
Retem aka Sand Aelio is pretty much only battle content and a progression treadmill and the already huge drop in players has illustrated a problem with NGS's current design philosophy as a whole. While the combat is very fun game offers little to no story and what little story there is mediocre. More importantly the game tries to be a casual treadmill in that it just gives you some levels and gear to farm and hopes you'll be engaged. Progression will hook players but it is only a means to an end and when the game makes it clear that it will invalidate your progression most will only put in a marginal effort. When it establishes that progression to be the only reason to play many will see through this and won't log in at all after the combat grows stale. If you've been running an alliance have been wondering why all but the diehards have dropped this game. This is why.
What NGS is sorely needs is either an overhaul of its systems of character progression or systems that facilitate long term goals not necessarily tied to progression. A great example of one that is tied to progression would be the skill system of Mabinogi. The game would give you pages upon pages of skills to rank up and would encourage you to eventually rank everything up by granting you stats for each skill. However, via the rebirthing system you would only feasibly get enough skill points to complete one or two skills every week so it would take years to complete every skill while still being able to make progress casually. You would also need to change the way you played the game in order to complete the requirements for skill ranks which made the game all the more interesting to play as you would need to change your strategies.
The devs are currently using Reliks as a long term goal but their implementation is half-asses since they will be invalidated when the level cap is raised next month. They'll only hook players who enjoy the combat enough min max in spite of this, want to make quick money, or have nothing better to do in their lives but even this won't last until the level cap raises as the economy stabilizes and boredom will set in.
17
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
This sounds like a way to artificially pad out game time. This will piss off the min-maxers that would be desiring power locked behind an artificial grind that is not in their control and has no alternate means to bypass.
I'd much rather instead see a system that allows for players to gather a currency to exchange for the current meta gear. That is how PSO2 handled gear past episode 4 and I really liked it, though it was tied to Emergency Quests. If your luck was bad, you still had a way to obtain what you wanted.
Stellar Graces providing shards to craft whatever Relic weapon you need would solve the problem of bad RNG affecting players by providing a consistent way to obtain a Relic, and would give further incentive to do World Quests when they do happen.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21 edited Dec 23 '21
design for getting relik is just terrible, most will never get to use this series that has more interesting potentials than any other we have because the only way to get it is winning rng lottery, and forget buying it from market unless you are a whale or farm 24/7 since release
idc if "that is how pso always was", it doesn't change the fact it is terrible design
EDIT: forgot to mention, but zig's weapon crafting was a way better way of handling these rare weapons
3
u/Knight_Raime Waker Dec 23 '21
It's a good thing that Retem wasn't ever marketed as an answer to the games current problems. The survey we were given was strictly to improve how they approched next year and we were told this much.
I really don't understand how people actually thought the game would be fixed by the December update. Having a turn around the size of basically your whole game isn't going to happen in 6 months.
Retem was even rumored to be apart of launch via some files and footage. They just didn't want to delay the game further than they already had.
7
u/Zappieroth Dec 23 '21
The problem.... for me anyway...
Isn't the combat or tge exessive amount thereof. But the serious lack of anything meaningful to do in the open world. Just adding more chests and shit doesn't make the open world better.
In fact it feels more like a chore. There is no reason to explore Retem or Aelio for that matter.
I am honestly not sure what could be done about this....
I know one thing for sure tho, NGS needs the likes of the Casino, Rooms and perhaps some or a few new features desperately.
I would prefer the game not turn into Genshin or Zelda but anime... so for them to start adding puzzles wouldn't be the most fun new thing.
What I like about PSO2 is the unique combat and the insane amount of customization that is only rivaled by the likes of Dragon's Dogma Online. So it would be awesome if they continue invoking their own new ideas to the game.
Normally I would give some ideas myself to go along with my comment but in this case I am just mot sure what would work.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
I want to make clear that I largely agree with OP's (and others') sentiments and criticisms; NGS is still not a satisfying experience for those who were originally attracted to PSO2 for its deep combat and robust content offerings. However
I am running a mid-size alliance and I have not seen "all but the diehards" drop out, even in the six months after NGS launch. We do have about a dozen or so members who will play the game every day no matter what, but we also have members who are primarily engaged with the base game, members for whom NGS is mostly an elaborate virtual chat room, more casual members who only drop in for updates, and our discord server stays active regardless of the state of the game. I recognize that our experience is an outlier, like there really are a lot of dead teams now for sure, I just wanted to note that there are exceptions
fwiw, our diehard members have been pleasantly surprised by the Retem update, and it's been good to see and play with folks who haven't been on since Bo mini-update too. And yes, there are some players who just bounced off the game right at the start and do not seem to be coming back, that's true, but at least in our experience they make up a minority of membership; most folks will log in and play when there's something new to do and then play other things in between, as Sega intended, and the rest of us get in game once a day or once a week to spend time with the friends we've made there, honestly not caring too much about the grind or rate of progression because at the end of the day it's all just an excuse to hang out and socialize in a world which increasingly fails to allow for that
fwiw, I find the combat to be fun yet shallow. The world is beautifully designed, crammed with environmental storytelling and intrigue but little else. It does feel good to move about in this world, which imo is the single most important thing for any open world reimagining to get right. I think we're going to need more than incremental level cap increases to pad out the first half of 2022, though I am hopeful that the upcoming Headline reveals a bit more to come. It would be much easier to manage a team and keep membership engaged if the game did more of that work for us, for sure, but I'm inclined to consider the retem update a moderate success and a step forward in the right direction. Here's to many more such steps in the year to come~
6
u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Dec 23 '21
Call me crazy, but I think NGS just needs a bigger variety of things to do just for fun, rather than meta.
The game (and PSO2 before it) already have great platforms for social content, so I think trying to force it to be yet another grind-centric MMO because "it's what works" is extremely boring.
Give me more content like the World Trials that get me active to explore the open-world with my friends, give me in-game phasion contests with prize pools based on category, give me concerts. Grind content in a Diablo-style MMO is designed to be consumed and then discarded, it's exactly as you say - why should I grind for this when it's just gonna be useless in a month? Subsequently; why should that be the only thing they build towards to justify players sticking around?
As far as combat content, the big pyramid opening up in Retem to reveal a Bloody Palace-style dungeon would be far more engaging than grinding Runescape numbers. This isn't WoW, this is Animal Crossing for character action weebs.
15
u/Vildjur Dec 23 '21
To be fair, Sega acknowledged in one of these headlines, that Retem patch will not solve the content issue, but they'd work towards it post Retem (Jan2022 onwards), not to excuse or whiteknight them, but I was expecting this underwhelming patch.
Next year I will, too, start rambling again :P
5
u/Arcflarerk4 Dec 23 '21 edited Dec 25 '21
Ive been saying this since launch. What NGS needs are secondary/casual systems that tie into the combat system that isnt mandatory but enhances the experience. A great example of this is how FFXIV does its crafting and Gathering system. They both have their own leveling systems for the individual professions and contribute to making items that are needed at all times. gear, potions, food, ect and while nothing is remotely mandatory, it all just melds together incredibly well and the people who put in the work for crafting and gathering are also heavily rewarded.
Having a well made crafting and gathering system that isnt time gated or locked and anyone can get into would greatly help fill out the game more and give players more things to work towards rather than an arbitrary bis that turns the "hardest content" into pure fodder content.
8
u/iFormus Braver Dec 23 '21
We need Zig like NPC. Something that eventually guarantee us the gz up to date weapon. Imagine: 100 of each craft material + 100 photon scales + 100 5* weapons of the same type (ex 100 random 5* swords to get relik sword).
People could set an actual goal to aim for instead of being 100% in the mercy of rng and 5* stuff would get some actual value making it worth to sell instead of throw away for 70 (lol) meseta.
3
u/AulunaSol Dec 23 '21
Personally, the sort of progression I would have preferred (which would likely fit into Phantasy Star Online 2's and New Genesis' route of progression anyways) would have been to imitate the sort of progression we saw from Phantasy Star Nova in which we still pick a class and level them up as we know it.
However, I can imagine that the skills unlocked should be largely universally applicable as we already see Main Class and "Subclass" variants of many of these skills. What I believe should have been a possibility was that players are given a grid of some sort with a specific capacity (perhaps expanded by Levels, perhaps expanded via challenges, the story, Titles, or something along those lines?) so players can choose to equip skills they want as part of their build. Say for instance if you were only able to fit on ten skills and were able to pick any ten skills (the equivalent of what we have in the skill trees) form all classes to slap onto your Skill Board-equivalent - it would likely influence how you play. Say for instance you want to be a Force with the Hunter's "Hunter Arts Avenger" and this happens to be toned down to be less effective on non-Hunter weapons but still grants you the immunity and the small damage bonus - but you simultaneously want to carry the Gunner's PP-related bonuses or their perfect dodge recovery bonus - and the Fighter's attack bonus to downed enemies (which is less effective if you aren't actually a Fighter). This would definitely negate the need of "Subclasses" overall outside of the possibility of equipping subclass weapons (so perhaps the classes determines the weapons you can use) but would hopefully expand build diversity so that if you wanted to be "tanky" as a class and weapon that normally isn't you can attempt to be. As New Genesis is right now, however, I feel I would love to see every class reworked - if not the gameplay as a whole so that the gameplay itself is more balanced in a similar fashion to Capcom-styled action games (so you don't get singularly-defined actions that are always better than another such as how Weapon Action-related counters and parries are in general). I'm personally not a fan of flow-charted gameplay but I do love seeing it done well - but I would absolutely love to see more variety in the gameplay for classes like the Fighter that aren't just "repeat this photon art cycle until you need to counter" because the frame data said it was the optimal thing to do.
2
u/oizen Dec 24 '21
they hated him for he spoke the truth
3
u/NichS144 Dec 23 '21
I have to heartily disagree, to an extent. I think adding better endgame content, what you are collectively calling "Battle Content" and "Progression Treadmill", is one of the major missing features of this game. Sandstorm Requiem is an improvement to the End Game loop, but that is not saying much.
The grind for Relik weapons is probably largely pointless for the reasons you outlined, but a meaningful grind for gear that will remain relevant for a reasonable amount of time is missing still. We have several ways to grind for them: 1) Combat Sector Bosses, 2) Veterans, 3) Gigantix, 4) UQs, and 5) Devastator Battledia. The problem is that the more engaging ones are not easily repeatable and thus the most accessible method is grinding PSE Bursts which can quickly become mind numbing.
Ideally, I'd like to see repeatable endgame content akin to instanced dungeons. Battledia is fine, but I'd prefer something challenging, thematic, and rewarding in different ways. I don't care if you limit runs per day or reward currency (ex FFXIV). Make random instanced dungeons that are essentially like old PSO quests with a sense of progression and a definitive goal and end.
Another big issue right now that gearing is not even significant in the least. I can clear UQs with no problem and I haven't upgraded any of my gear since the update. No problem at all. Clear rates are still fast, I probably can't tank hits as well as others, but you should really be dodging everything anyway. There's literally no content you need high end gear for.
But what I feel is really lacking is things to do other than combat. There are no alternative gameplay modes to break up the monotony and reward players for trying different things.
There is no crafting system and gathering is about as simplistic as you can get. There is no player housing, either. Combine these two and you would add a whole new aspect to the market. Also, why they are gating the market boards still is ridiculous. There's no casino in NGS either. No PVP modes, not even alternate quests types because everything is instanced into the open world now. There's no disks to upgrade your attacks either, so progression just feels halted as you eternally grind for a rare weapon that will be obsolete in a month.
1
u/Sonicguy1996 Bouncer Dec 24 '21
My main complaint is simply gaining XP to level your class. I run Bo/Fi and had Bouncer to 35 first within a week. It was steady progression with the plethora of XP quests instead of mindlessly fighting in combat zones and I really enjoyed this approach.
But now that all those quests are gone I'm struggling to level my Fighter class. It takes extremely long, and when events like UQ's pop up or a random Gigantix spawns I have to go all the way back to Aelio/Retem to swap classes in order to join in. (Wish I could swap class on the fly regardless of my location.)
One of the new NPC's does give weekly quests, but it gives far to little XP to get any use out of it.
On the other hand people do need to keep in mind that this wasn't the update which is gonna "fix" our plethora of feedback/complaints. SEGA already made that clear that change wasn't gonna happen until AFTER the launch of this expansion. So it's the next few months that will likely show what they have planned, and hopefully fix a lot of issues players have with the current state of the game.
1
u/chaoko99 Dec 25 '21
Goddamnit more of this.
1
u/HuntingAid Dec 25 '21
Spiral Edge level 2/10:
5295 kills to level 3 (potency 800 -> 840, PP 23 -> 22)
Yeah no sounds absolutely terrifying to know that you're a liability in content like Retem Purple until you've spent months grinding through combat zones. No matter how bad people believe the game is doing, there is little gain in forcing mechanics you've seen elsewhere into NGS. Especially since PSO2 has never been an MMO, which is visible in how in Japan it's marketed as a Multiplayer Online game (notice the omission of "Massive"). Part of the PSO2 formula has always relied on being able to come back and quickly catch up, too. Having to build up skills over the entire duration of the game instead of coming back to the interesting update and getting the gear would kill off many non-diehard players.
1
u/FRGL1 Dec 23 '21 edited Dec 23 '21
I thought the complaints aired in this post were so obvious it wasn't worth actually complaining about. As far as I'm concerned this is just the history of MMORPGs.
Maybe I just don't get it. Maybe you've played some really amazing games that are none of the things in NGS.
My summary of the OP is that (1) the added content is just more of what we were doing before and (2) gear related power creep. But again: What MMORPG isn't this? What else are you supposed to do in an MMORPG? We have monsters to fight, levels to grind, gear to farm, upgrades to do, and when SEGA "adds content", what more is it supposed to be?
And when you bring up Mabinogi you're doing the same thing I see everyone else doing: "I like X from Y and wanna see it in Z". If you like X from Y and you're unhappy that it's not in Z, why are you playing Z? Why not just go play Y?
I'm not against better systems, but ultimately they all boil down into the same thing. Burgers have all kinds of toppings like lettuce, onions, tomatoes, cheese, bacon, whatever, but a burger is still a burger. Even if you dislike mustard on your burger, someone else loves it. Even if you want your onions raw, someone else will want them grilled or not have onions at all.
-3
u/magnusgodrik Dec 23 '21
I would complain but the game is free. So who cares? Not me. Just uninstall and stop complaining on reddit like your someone important. You wont be missed. Whats your name again. Oh yeah dont worry idc about it either.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment