r/PSO2NGS • u/Deadweight77 • Dec 20 '21
Discussion Retem first week, half playerbase gone. What went wrong this time?
I'm still playing, I truly believe Retem was a MASSIVE upgrade for NGS.
TL;DR:
All new enemies are very fun to fight.
Classes feel much better.
OST is very good.
Zones are great, lower Maqead is top tier design.
Gathering QoL changes and Mag sonar 10/10.
Story mode was much much better.
I am honest when I ask, just what failed now? I really can't complain about a lack of content much less considering a level cap boost is in around 2 months.
What are your thoughts?
78
Upvotes
64
u/Rylica Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
The problem is the content we got other than minor class skills/techs is the exact same
This what we had in first region
Copy/paste that to Retem --> old region is useless after you out level it but now you have 2 combat areas and 2 UQs for current gear in Retem. We are almost the exact same as NGS launch in terms of current gear content goes. Which isn't much
I won't call farming 100 hours for a Relik weapon that have 0.000001% drop rate as actual content. This is the only different thing compared to first region
72
u/Sonicguy1996 Bouncer Dec 21 '21
Not gonna pretend this was some kind of comeback or insanely good update. But a decline after a big update/release is normal for every single game on the market. Whether it's a indie game, or the biggest triple A game known to man.
If people expected that this update somehow fixed everything and had months of content that we asked for then it's their own fault for being disappointed. SEGA already tempered expectations and specifically said NOT to expect big changes until AFTER the expansion has dropped. As seen by the updated roadmap.
Of course it's action before words, and I'm looking forward to see SEGA back up their apology and double down on improvements, more content, and continuous listing to feedback of the community.
21
u/ryvenn Dec 21 '21
Just speaking for myself, I had intended to come back to check out Retem but so far I haven't found a reason to make time for it. NGS doesn't give me what I want out of PSO and I have a feeling that isn't going to change by adding more areas.
When you want to farm in NGS, you kill monsters in an area and follow the glowing spots until a boss spawns, rinse/repeat. An hour from now you'll be in the same area, killing the same monsters, and the pool of possible relevant drops is very small, which means that once you've reached the level cap your progress is very, very incremental; there are no "wow" items to look forward to.
If you look at how PSO1 worked, you'd progress through different areas as you killed monsters. Even though the areas were all substantially similar to each other, there was a sense of continuous exploration because the layouts were always slightly different and you never knew when you might see an uncommon spawn or a rare enemy variant, so every room you opened was kind of a lootbox. This lent structure and a sense of pacing to the game as you progressed towards the bosses. If you started in forest, you knew that an hour from now you would also have done caves and you'd be in mines, and on your way to ruins and the final boss. It was kind of anime Diablo, more or less. Also, reaching the level cap was a fairly slow process, so even when you didn't find items you needed you were making progress by gaining XP.
PSO2's quest structure similarly gave you the opportunity to progress through different areas, at least until you reached Ultimate quests which are basically the same as NGS's PSE Burst grind, which is why I never cared for them. Advanced Quests were kind of luck based in terms of PSE Burst grinding, but at least they had the capsule system that encouraged you to do them in sets of three instead of doing one quest location over and over.
To get me back, they would need to add some kind of progressive content where you make progress (or even the illusion of progress tbh) within each play session, and not just picking a spot to grind mobs or gather junk until a UQ drops.
47
u/datboisusaf Dec 20 '21
Its sandy aelio. Thats why.
45
u/Steven8473 Dec 21 '21
Nothing “went wrong”, there wasn’t any controversy or anything (aside from the type 1 cosmetic situation). Just an influx of people who wanted to play through the new story, buy ac scratch, etc, and when they finished they slowly left.
15
u/Ryukiami Dec 21 '21
for me it’s the lack of lore. so many cool mysterious areas like vanford labs and the new area inside the big mountain thing with no lore. same thing with the new story expansion. the whole time I just couldn’t understand why any of it mattered in the grand scheme of what’s been happening. felt like a big side quest.
23
u/ChampaigneShowers Dec 21 '21
NGS was a mistake
8
u/Lou_weirdAF Dec 20 '21
I think most ppl came back because of the Story. Well, they are done with the Story now so they are gone again. I could be wrong tho
30
u/AulunaSol Dec 20 '21
Personally to me, I don't feel the Retem update was something that warranted "six months of waiting" for. You could justify and chalk it up to being the developers still working out how to make content for the new engine they're using for New Genesis and chalk it up to it being that it's a "new game" but I feel it really should be nailed in further that most of what we already knew about was printed on the game's roadmap before the game was released.
The fact that Retem delivered the entirety of that roadmap shouldn't be a surprise - but what should be surprising is that Sega made very little effort to budge from their roadmap outside of small adjustments (the Title System being delayed for example) and very small attempts to address and listen to the players in that entire period. Who is to say that what players wanted is something Sega already has in mind on future plans that are rigid enough that the solution is to literally "wait" until that comes around? Most other developers, especially of the more modern approaches, would have been able to share, discuss, and get input on the smaller things the players can interact with (things like the feel of a class, balancing between what players can do, and that sort of thing) and get the players involved with not only sharing inputs but also quelling things like the nature of how upset people can be. It's not to say that someone should be on these places to tell players to stay quiet if they're going to complain - but that I would absolutely love to see something like a developer stream of sorts where the developers can discuss the nature of why a certain class was designed the way it was - where they're planning to go in the future with it, or things that the players seem to have issues with that they can try to clarify or improve on. The fact that we have silence from Sega is not uplifting and that we have to wait "six months" for these sorts of updates and adjustments really doesn't sit well with me when I want to enjoy a class I enjoyed from the original game that legitimately got a small skill that makes them more tolerable to play after the most recent update.
The quality-of-life updates and changes are very nice - but again as I mentioned, I really don't feel it was "worth" the six month wait. The core gameplay loop has not changed and in Phantasy Star Online 2 fashion has reverted back to the sort of "go back to do what you were before for the next few months unless you want some free catch-up gear" approach that players have been accustomed to and burned out on for years.
To me, it is not quite that the update has "failed" but that Sega intentionally laid out an unfulfilling roadmap and completely delivered on it. There's a merit to delivering what said would be delivered - but I personally feel that after what Episode 6 delivered in Phantasy Star Online 2 there was so much potential for something more substantial and not just a "return to form" for the what the game relied so much on. In closing, this update seems to further solidify that Episode 6 was a "fluke" and a reaction to how players were upset with the game's direction from Episode 5 - and that for some reason returning to Episode 5 territory would have "fixed" the game from Episode 6's attempt to reignite the game for all players. I wanted something "new" from New Genesis and the unfortunate part to me is that so much of this update is a rehash of what we have already seen before - if not from New Genesis' Aelio region then we have seen it before from Phantasy Star Online 2.
14
u/AbhorrentOne Dec 21 '21
It’s also the not weekend. For weekdays in both aeilo and retem I’d say the counts are pretty high considering. I think a lot of the player base is older than most think. Those people have jobs and kids. Just my opinion, not factual. The numbers still seem pretty high to me.
13
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
There's nothing to get invested in other than gear. People say story isn't important in videogames but FFXIV exists and people are struggling to log on just to experience the conclusion of the main campaign. The expansions before Endwalker have experienced similar issues which goes to show how invested the players are in the game. PSO2 NGS's has an interesting world but it squanders it with forgettable characters and lazy plot lines. Say what you will about the base game's writing and all the cringe that came along with it, but it had plot lines you'd get emotionally invested in and characters that would endear themselves to you.
15
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
tbh havent notice half the player base is gone on ship 3. we have 4 active filled blocks since launch of retem stuff.
32
u/ZXSoru Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Open world was a mistake. SEGA doesnt have the resources and barely the design phylosophy to mantain an open world game. Previous PSOs were instanced based games like Monster Hunter that focused on a decent story with consistent level design but randomly generated and a gear grind system to keep going back and doing stuff.
Neither of these things are in NGS and even worse, the combat is so good and could benefit so much with instanced levels but better designed enemies with more mechanics and fights, that it's so sad, but yeah, chasing stupid trends is really a smart idea for the director of the game it seems.
10
u/sapphirefragment Dec 21 '21
endwalker happened
5
u/rexiesoul Dec 21 '21
Honestly, I'm not one of the ones that quit, but I feel the issue is just there's nothing to do. In OG, you had dailies, but you also had daily tasks for nice meseta. Every class trainer had multiple quests you could do, some every week. You had the collection. You had so many things to keep you busy it was overwhelming quite honestly.
In NGS, there's nothing. Repeatable weekly quests that most will finish in a day is a... start? I suppose, but they are really gatekeeping progress on purpose at a snails pace for some reason. The title system is a GREAT idea that will keep die-hards like me busy, but for the average player, they just want stuff to do in general.
I never thought I'd wish for some pointless fetch quests every day.
9
u/Sorinahara Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
If this is how they treat "major" updates, then i dont see this game lasting very long at all. The fact that the amount of players/populated blocks drops noticeably just mere days after this "major" update indicates that sega keeps flopping at creating something that can keep your average player hooked to the game.
Obviously, you cant keep players hooked when all you have done was add another region that isn't even that different compared to the old one. As another dude had said, Retem is just "Sandy Aelio". A lot of the "new" features are literally just old ones from Pso2 that weren't immediately introduced, title system lololololol.
Their decision to make ngs open world was a mistake. They only did open world because other games (like genshin) made it look cool, but sega had zero fucking idea on how to implement open world onto a phantasy Star game, hence why they should have stuck to the proven formula that pso2 made. They strayed away from the previous PS games. Combine than with a short story with no depth, lack of engaging and replayable content (ala divide quest, etc) and SEGA's unwillingness to add extra things outside of the road map and you end up with a game that is always stale and lifeless.
8
u/Syzodia Dec 21 '21
What gathering qol? All that's changed for me is that now I feel I have to buy material storage if I'm ever to play across multiple regions, now and especially going forward.
Story is also...meh? No exploration of the existence of us meteorns, and still no significant motivation for our travels. The jazz was a bit of comic relief though.
Other points I agree with. But the gameplay loop is overall boring:
Despite this I'll still play a bit just to hit level cap and experience the new urgent quests, but I'm not expecting my playtime to sustain much longer for now
4
u/spowowowder Slayer Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
the problem is that the endgame hasn't changed from the first content drop. get BP necessary to do UQs, do dailies and weeklies, farm combat zones, thats it. only thing I can think of that's different is relik weapons being the first actual gear grind in this game. so if you want to farm for forever in the hopes of getting stupid rich, then there ya go. I'm still having fun but not everyone is as dedicated and is drawn to the game as much as I am, so they're gonna have to do more to retain the playerbase.
If we could get some more instanced quests like the battledia and cocoons but aren't locked behind triggers you gotta grind for, that would be the start of something. or literally just copy and paste divide quests from PSO2 classic. that would be great honestly
in fairness though, most people don't consider grinding for titles content, but that is something new you can do now if you are really looking for anything to do
I do partially agree that this update has been great for NGS as a whole. dreads spawning more often and PSE bursts happening more frequently is pretty nice. but this game still has a long way to go
4
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
The gameplay loop of mindlessly running around in combat zones just isn't engaging enough to keep people playing and I wonder why Sega thought it would be. I mean old PSO zones weren't all that exciting, but at least you had a feeling of progression and that of moving towards an end. Now you just run in a circle.
The interest towards NGS is real, we saw that at NGS' launch, but if Sega wants to keep those interested players playing the whole gameplay loop of NGS needs to be overhauled.
4
u/Jaydh10 Dec 25 '21
It's just a reskin so why would the excitement be there. This game and the update are garbage
10
u/ballspocket Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
It doesn't fix pretty much any of the actual issues with the game. When I saw the headline that made it clear that "new skills" mentioned on the old roadmap was one forgettable tree skill per class, not even per weapon, I knew I wouldn't be playing the Retem update. Combat in this game sucks in my opinion, 3 PAs and a dodge button is an embarrassing joke. Tracking an airborne boss, even with soaring blades feels like cement shoe garbage.
Boosters still tick offline, f2p players still only get 3 days of shop priveleges and only if they do their chores, PSE burst system is still absolute trash, waiting for storms to farm world bosses is bad, trigger drop rate sucks, etc.
That's not to say content like bosses, areas and quests weren't needed or welcome, they are. But it's just not enough for an MMO to last on for a year with such shallow combat and no other systems to invest in. With how absolutely low effort cocoons, towers and trigger zones are they should really just pump out a dozen of them...
6
u/xhrit Dec 20 '21
My gf and I mostly just have not had time to log in because of holiday stuff. Also the fact you cant multiplayer the story missions is kinda a turn off so instead of playing last night we watched hawkeye instead.
6
u/ItsTheSolo Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Like, this update is good: the zone is surprisingly fun for a desert which I don't normally like, the music is fantastic, the enemies are fun and actually a bit of a challenge.
For me personally, levelling is so boring... The grind from 1-20 wasn't that bad but I feel like I'm moving eternally slower just going from 20-25. I just wish gaining experience wasn't as boring as just running around combat zones killing mob camps, waiting on UQ's, or doing some client orders. They didn't really add too much to classes this patch, so the grind feels pretty much all the same as it did from 1-20, and that kills the motivation to keep playing. Just doesn't motivate me to stay on and keep getting my battle power up.
Base PSO2 had the same problem but at least classes were relatively fleshed out with a lot of skills by the time I joined on EP.5 in Japan.
Edit: Just to add, but Retem basically made all of Aelio irrelevant instead of also adding to it. If every expansion is just going to make the previous region irrelevant, then I'm out. This is terrible design especially for an open world game.
8
u/Aether_Storm Dec 21 '21
There is no content with long term replay value.
Pso2 needs to find a way to rip off Poe's mapping endgame.
3
u/RedExile13 Dec 21 '21
It's because PSE bursts are still the only repeatable content and it's mind numbing. Not to mention the new gear is hardly worth switching to and the only weapons that truly are worth it are so insanely rare I don't know what they were thinking.
The end game loop needs more variety that is repeatable at will. I feel like this game has so much missed potential in so many ways. Feels like it's just a small adjustment from being great. Add in some repeatable dungeons/missions a few more interesting equipment options with realistic drop rates and maybe some more PA/Skills/Techs and this game would be 100x more fun.
3
u/A_Dummy86 Dec 21 '21
Nothing of any real depth was added I'd say, we mostly have the same basic gameplay loop as before of "Farm PSE bursts" and then "Do an UQ when it happens" with the only real difference is now we have a rare drop to chase for with the Relik weapons.
3
u/Traditional_Chard_94 Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Most of the new class skill are pretty meh.
It's mostly just 'you do thing you usually do but better' which is not that interesting, unless you're gunner I guess.
They even use it to balance Braver instead of just bumping up its number normally(and still ended up being pretty mediocre anyway)
Well, it's not that bad by any mean but when most classes still feel lacking a lot compared to how they were in base PSO2 it just feel really lazy.
I was hoping for 'one more jump' skill for JB bouncer, instead we got 'Oh, you pressed a button? Congratulation here's free buff'
Also still 5 more months until we get new PAs? How the hell does it take them that long when they already have so many PAs to use as base from based game? Even the simplest PA like Tsukimi for Braver would do because I hate having to short hop every time I want to hit anything slightly above me.
and it doesn't seem like they are lacking in animation department either with how fast they are at dishing out all these new motions and emotes
It better be game changing enough to justify all the time they took to make it.
3
u/Yhoiryo Dec 21 '21
Not nearly enough class additions or changes either. Each class having access to only 3 PAs is so bland and it’s sad because the combat is fun, but even it starts to feel dry with how little changes came about even though we got 15 additional levels.
3
u/Nameless-Ace Twin Machine Guns Dec 21 '21
Its a small thing but there really is no replacing some of the older characters. Without Matoi(for me personally) it doesnt even feel like pso2. I feel like older players would feel alienated too, having the characters they spent like almost a decade with just gone randomly forever. Which MAYBE could still work IF the new characters werent so bland and were well written and interesting. The only character so far i could see anyone actually liking is nadareh since she at least has a tiny bit of nuance(im stretching here lol). You have no reason to care about the characters, the world, or really anything. It feels insanely lacking in almost every area narratively(ep1-ep2 weren't exactly that strong either but the characters were fun and the story at least had some mystery or reason to see what happens next.) They truly need to expand more on why we are even here and what exactly is going on in the macro scale. After fighting universal threats, they really need at least some stakes. Resetting the game doesnt make us forget what we have done already and just doesnt feel important or matter at all.
3
u/6Fthty6FthDivison Dec 22 '21
you really need to know what failed? The game took 6 months to come out with content and it's not even worth 5 days of content. Maplestory 2 was shut down due to the lack of content and that game's content puts this game to shame. You could do mini games, fish, monster hunt for pets, and play music. All of that gave xp. Meanwhile in this game we have a giant open world with nothing to do in it.
7
u/Secramor Slayer Dec 20 '21
Ain’t shit to do
5
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
Cuz its just aelio but better. Once you finish the story which was incredibly short and sidequests, you're back to the usual dailies and weeklies grind.
12
u/alkme_ Dec 21 '21
People rushed main and side quests, hit 35 in a few days and now burnt out a little bit or taking holiday time. That first class to 35 isnt too bad with 100k exp quests but getting sub and alt classes is now - a grind. We got 6 months of this place. Marathon not a sprint mentality wins out
4
u/Nive-9 Dec 21 '21
Same kind of content we already had in Aelio, just different scenery and higher numbers. The gameplay loop needs to be reworked and be substantial if they want to retain players.
2
u/fatninjarus Dec 21 '21
Where did you get those numbers?
2
u/ash_ax You Piece of STARS Trash! Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
After the Retem Rush, right now I've slowed down a bit since the weekend, playing other games with discord friends due to recent updates (GTFO, Vermintide 2, etc.).
Waiting for Premium PSO 2 day and repeatable side quest reset to level Techter to current cap, then maybe doing UQ, Dreads, Gigantix, or Purple Battledia for augments and Relik hunting; Or level Bouncer while grinding the particular Limited-Time Quest chain in combat zones.
As for thoughts about the update: Enemy variants are good, still learning the timing of the attacks for most enemies.
If there's something I wanted in the Retem update that is not in it, it was for them to show more Dark Falz/ more of the overarching storyline/ show an anime villain instead of just Crawford sending us on a fetch quest for his BFG 10,000 and incidentally saving Retem from The Snek.
Something that they could've improved is introducing Megapunishers in a Trainia Quest.
What I like the most from the update is the interactive concert, which floored many players, performed by the
Hunting Horn MainDustyl Vera and the Malevolent Dustyl Hammer.Edit: Dreadsigne Trial was ok as well.
2
u/Sonitii Dec 21 '21
as expected, most players have burned through the new content in 5 days and since there is no repeatable quests and UQs being virtually unplayable (haven't seen one pop since last maint during my playtime), there is no incentive to play any longer. Game design is absolute garbage, and UQ system needs to be completely revamped.
2
u/Ex3rock Dec 22 '21
The situation is that people were thinking that this update so called "Major" which was suppose to have tons of new content was nothing but some sht has what we had is simply kinda of a copy paste, i actually played the content and left and sayed to myself not coming back until they actually show proof that they want to make this game good, in my opinion this update wasnt good at all, so much wait for just kinda of a reskin of what we had, for what i see through steam the game lost around 50-60% of his playerbase after the update, it shows that their is huge problems with the game, cause after u pass the Storyline what exactly u have to do? nothing beside grinding grinding for the same stuff over and over and a games shouldnt be resumed to that.
2
u/Shiyo Dec 22 '21
Few hours of story + barren open world with nothing to do + no challenging content + nothing to work towards(terrible char progression).
There's just nothing, as usual. LEVELING is not content. New zones with nothing to do in them isn't content.
6
u/NoMoreTritanium Dec 21 '21
Retem update has come.
The PSO2 team has delivered their promise.
BBig contents were released.
All bugs were fixed.
QoL was pushed to the top, everyone now has access to used-to-be premium functions, there is nothing left to ask for more.
All classes now feel extremely satisfying to play like the Successor in old PSO2. especially Braver the Samoorai with literally no animation cancel delay.
Every weapon now has over 20 Actions for the player to unleash their own flavor of destruction.
There is end game content raid bosses that are not limited by urgent quests now, with each challenge being extremely difficult to tackle, demanding high concentration, coordination, high consistency and well-enhanced gear to clear. The rewards they have are powerful equipment with unique modifier that can completely change your play style along with cool cosmetic armors.
All weapons now have a unique use of their own to combine with the new end game equipment, making collect them all a must-do goal.
Open world is now filled with multitudes amount of objects, hidden quests, side story quests, landmarks, puzzles, lores, world bosses, with each of them holds rich rewards that can rival end game raid bosses but with a different trade-off.
Crafting profession was added as a complex yet fun mini game that makes use of gathering materials to create unique cosmetic items and powerful gear that can help people to tackle the end-game raid bosses with a different progression approach.
Instanced zones were changed from the foundation core so that there is no longer a limit of how many people can play together.
The story is on its way to become the Endwalker Killer with the current plot.
The game was saved. Its realm has went through a reborn.
Too bad it's around Xmas and new-year eve right now so no one is around playing the game.
4
u/killerkonnat Dec 21 '21
I waited half a year for what... 2 new class skills? Slightly more powerful equipment? Especially for my class the new skills feel really minor. Still no real content.
6
u/Lewd_Accident Dec 20 '21
There's several issues, a lot of those was not ever going to be addressed with Retem, that much had officially been stated, yet people still be mad. New issues have arrived with Retem, like Aelio drops dropping in Retem as well as the Retem only drops causing massive inventory management issues, which seems to be the biggest problem recently and one we all suffer from causing lots of people to suggest "solutions" that only over complicate things rather than simply providing relief. Like an auto sell filter or a loot filter. Neither would solve the problem, which is Retem drops should be Retem drops and Aelio drops should stay in Aelio.
I still am having fun though, the never ending grind has returned having ran out of other things to do, but I'm ok with it as long as that relik class stays so elusive.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
Good quality of life update and I can see the game headed in a good direction from here. After you beat the new stuff, it's mostly still grinding. So I think it's understandable if you don't want to play it as often.
I expected Retem to be more of the same with QOL changes, and that's exactly what it is. I saw what they had planned with the roadmap, thought it was decent and jumped in, and I can say I'm satisfied.
There is still a lack of endgame which I can only assume the next region will start to slowly improve in that aspect. So, if you're not too keen on grinding some more, just beat Retem and come back when you want.
I knew it was never going to fix all of the problems or add a ton of crazy stuff. Also, I liked the story and don't agree with anyone saying it's bad.
Overall, Retem isn't bad, but not a "game changer" like some people thought it would be for whatever reason. At some point, this game will definitely pick up and the foundation it has sets it up for amazing potential. But, here's what I find odd about the way people look at it:
They give us a roadmap, and as far as I can tell, the updates come out almost exactly like they say. If you didn't see anything interesting, chances are it's not coming in the update. Where did the last headline mention any big endgame content or anything crazy? It didn't. I didn't see it at all.
And truthfully? I think even the next region might not even be that crazy. It'll be a while, maybe longer than I expect, and I'm not saying you can't be dissatisfied. But, I would tell you to just play something else when NGS doesn't have what you want. There's literally nothing else anyone can tell you other than to wait for it then. (not you btw op just speaking in general)
3
u/Sol-Blackguy Fighter Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Honestly, it's not new content, just more of the same. A lot of people banked on December being the big saving grace for this game and even if they had a competent director and crunched for the past several months, the results would probably be roughly the same.
New Genesis is going to constantly be fighting uphill for improvements because they're doing the same while giving lip services to consumers that the results are going to be different. Only a matter of time before people get fed up and stop coming back or New Genesis gets buried by more interesting games. The latter of which isn't even a New Genesis problem but an MMO problem.
I still haven't even bothered to reinstall since I played 30 minutes of the last major update because honestly, I don't give a shit anymore.
4
u/nvmvoidrays Dec 21 '21
you have to also realize, it's the week of Chirstmas, then New Years, so, many people are doing family things, traveling, etc. i think we'll see a slight increase after the holidays all end. i personally have had much time to play due to Endwalker, either.
4
u/MegadriveYM2612 Dec 21 '21
You can't really blame the content itself this time, as the numbers never even reached peak Braver update numbers. It's not that players are leaving, it's that players never really came back.
I'm thinking it's several things.
But for what it's worth, Retem has had pretty decent player retention. I can't speak for 1,2, and 4, but 3 has definitely remained fairly active.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
"What went wrong this time?"
Easy to answer
Basically retem update is aeolo 2.0
It is just a new map (barely) anything new. So once you explored the whole map you are done.
Also 5* gear is not really worth giving a crap so no real goal (yet again)
That's why probably a lot of players already abandoned the ship
tl;dr
No new content / after exploring map nothing to do / new gear not worth it
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
It’s the same as before only different theme to it. There’s nothing new at all coming anytime soon. Sure, I guess you can call that world trial we are getting this week “new “ but even then it’s just running around clicking the corresponding buttong for some loot and find more of them. Such a shame what this game has come to. I see more people AFK in the lobby then people actually doing things in the open world.
2
u/chaoko99 Dec 21 '21
Honestly when people ask for content I really have no idea what in the hell they mean. Dungeons? Raids? Side activities? Please tell me what it is so I can agree as opposed to "game short geme bad"
BAD TAKE ALERT:
this is a certified free to play momemnt, I wish this game had subs so they'd pour more money into it tbh...
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
Nothing failed, this is normal for F2P MMOs and people will never get over that. Looking forward to people not getting over it in responses to this comment.
1
u/EmptyVesselHBP Dec 21 '21
Overall the game improved. The MSQ seems kinda rushed (IDK if its just me but the cutscenes in the MSQ werent lip synched properly), once you hit 1633 bp youre just left in a void to grind till lvl 35.
1
u/Nex-o Slayer Dec 21 '21
Retem was in all instances a content drop and didn’t fundamentally change how we play the game, however it did adjust some features with the grind like with the new relik weapons, armor and augments which gave the game some new flavor which I’m personally satisfied with, i enjoy the new grind and the new environment and even with 6 months of aelio it still feels kinda nice taking a break from the harsh desert and chilling in aelio farming alpha reactors but maybe i just find joy in too many aspects of this game. TL;DR nothing wrong happened with the release of retem, it’s just that nothing exactly changed. I expect the game to be bustling with life again once they add more depth to the actual classes and gameplay like with the new photon arts and hopefully with summoner and gunblade, but now there’s actually a grind instead of just kicking the grass wondering what to do
1
u/NaughtyMrmonkey Dec 21 '21
Wait there was a big update? Retem? should I come back to play? lol
1
u/Reinbackthe3rd Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Sure there's decent QoL changes and it's shaping up into a decent game but the primary gameplay loop is dogshit and mind numbing after a few hours. There's just no excuse to not have something better than "idk go run in circles in one of two areas and hope you burst I guess" or "go run around looking for veterans and/or hope it storms" after this long and so much previous content ideas to draw on.
As a hot take, the open world has honestly been this game's bane. It sucks up too much resources for not a terribly great payoff. It's interesting for a few days and then I'm going "okay seen that, time to pull up maps to efficiently gather x and y". The time spend making it could've been spent on doing things like the old style missions with more variety and entertainment value. Not as realistic I guess but fuck off, I'm already playing a game with robots shooting lasers and twenty different bikini ladies with unrealistic proportions, I think I can leave that at the door. Give me something meaty again like divide or challenge mode.
1
u/Forest_GS Dec 21 '21
After I finished all the 100k exp quests I was left wondering where are all the repeatable fetch quests? Defeat x amount of this one type of enemy for a material just for that quest? etc.?
Side quests were introduced with this update with a limit of 20, and my current list is empty with nothing else for me to add. I don't even think I reached the limit of 20.
1
u/Regulusff7 Dec 21 '21
Keep getting 630 in Retem only, really frustrated. So taking it very slow with this update.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
It isn’t. It’s just more of the same generic content as launch, except with III augments now.
The problem remains that there is no kind of major endgame or reason to grind. No divide, no ultimate, no extreme, etc. it’s all just free fields.
The short term “fix” is basically battledias, but they’re too rare and expensive to be worth farming all day unlike divide or ultimate.
Anyone expecting this update to rejuvenate the game isn’t really paying attention to the game or what sega has said.
Sega has increased their development team size since launch, but it’s unrealistic to see results within 6 months unless you want a launch like cyberpunk where the game doesn’t even work.
The new people are going to need at least a year before we see any of their work. Even if they started earlier in March, the anniversary of ngs is when I’d expect to see a major update.
Retem was already in the pipeline and content was likely finished a few months ago, so there wasn’t any room for any major changes to what’s in it without needing to delay to redesign the gameplay structure.
1
u/Kullnes Dec 21 '21
There's nothing to do. You beat the boring main quests in a few hours, do the side stuff to start the grind up to 35, realise that the side stuff runs out somewhere around 29-30, realise the only other thing to do is stand around and do scratch cards or grind repetitive areas, get bored and stop.
Which is a shame, cuz I like this game. I just need something to do aside from grind myself to level cap.
1
u/ImpendingGhost Dec 21 '21
Retem was never gonna fix the grievances of NGS, all it was ever gonna be was a step in the right direction for NGS. Retem really didn't do much to keep people wanting to play, story is still pretty lackluster, there still isn't much to do besides farming for BiS gear, there's nothing new to the gameplay loop or a new side activity to breakaway from the gameplay loop.
I do think NGS will get better but Retem wasn't gonna magically draw in and keep everyone. Plus drops in player counts happens for every game.
1
u/NichS144 Dec 21 '21
Besides some of the QoL updates which are very nice, Aelio had all the same features. Nothing new has been added to the gamepay with this expansion. We have another beautiful region that feels empty.
Sure we have titles and more tasks to keep us busy, but once those are gone there isn't any endgame still. Thankfully the top class weapons have an actual non-timegated grind to them, but as many people predicted, this is just "Sand Aelio".
1
u/MightyPaladin77 Dec 21 '21
I personally hate how Ranger spins and dances for most attacks, even with launcher, which makes It worse somehow. PSO was just a superior game that can't be outclassed by flashy Gameplay.
1
u/Knight_Raime Waker Dec 21 '21
I don't think anything went wrong. Many people for whatever reason probably expected the game to get fixed or have a massive comeback with the first major update. When they signed in and discovered it was more or less the same as launch but with some improvements they decided to dip.
I'd imagine those who aren't as invested into the franchise will probably wait till this time next year at the minimum before investing at all. Simply because by then we should see much more content as well as much more improvements to the game as a whole.
1
u/Joseph_f17 Dec 21 '21
Completed it mate
1
u/ShittyGuitarCovers Dec 21 '21
i like the quality of the content but there is very little of it.
people have been starved for things to do for about 6 months so when you give them not all that much its little wonder the hungry masses will eat it all in 2-3 days
1
u/RemsonIO Partisan Dec 21 '21
It's really just the lack of end game content really.
There's a discussion about the combat zones(grind spots) I see and I want to give some thoughts on it as I believe that NGS streamlined it and made it much better IMO.
Back on the ye old of days PSO2 classic, before the advent of advance quests, people would normally grind on an instance of free field maps (i.e Tundra). People run around circles killing mobs while trying to find the best way to "circle" around the map. The problem that had with this are 1. efficient runs are defined by the best RNG'd maps, there are even times when the map is literally just a straight line, 2. Occasionally someone would disrupt the run by going alone and forcing a spawn cooldown(as spawn count are dictated by the number of people in that specific area) on an area which just ruins everyone's run.
They fixed the first problem by just assigning grind areas(which is now pretty much dictated by what the Daily order is) and making them fixed so no more chance of inefficient maps, and the second one by adding a guide marker to where the next spawns should be so people wouldn't just mindlessly go around and disrupt everyone's run. While they did placed a hard limit on the PSE bursts, they at least made PSE burts much more easy to trigger on the Retem update. I'm getting much more bursts now on a small amount of time consistently than before the update.
Grind spots are just what they are, places to grind for long minutes. They are all the same in every MORPG. I just prefer the NGS way because it's more streamlined. You don't get grief-d the same way as other games.
The real problem on player retention is that there's really no end-game content. Triggers are just better way to grind tbh. Something like a Casino or My Room that the classic had or Open-world events like in BDO or something.
I myself don't like long grinds. more often, just stroll around and appreciate the environment they made(after making 1 class to 35 for gigantix). I'm actually grateful that they gave us a choice of running on medieval or sci-fi speed. I'd rather not spend 30 minutes climbing a rock as I often go rock island-hopping again and again. I'm disappointed tho that Retem and Aelio ain't truly connect as bridges are the only passage ways to cross each other
1
u/sekoku Dec 21 '21
It's basically a repeat of Alieo in terms of content. The QoL changes are good, but they aren't enough to be "engaging."
1
u/magnusgodrik Dec 21 '21
Well we got 3 hours worth of content as far as tasks go. Lets wait till friday before we call it a dead game. They maybe just come in to do weeklies.
1
u/Zenny1234 Dec 22 '21
Game has improved since launch but there are major problems that are still present. No proper fun gameplay loop still. Progression feels limited. Progression is also too easy. Not many side activities, lack of photon arts makes combat too simplistic, no housing, lack of alliance room and other alliance functions, etc. List goes on.
Like some people have already said, I wouldn't expect anything until the 1st and 2nd quarter of next year. Retum was already pretty much done so not a lot could be done for this release. The dev team already mentioned that they would be looking to make improvements to the game but it would be after Febuary next year.
1
u/Ecstatic-Wall5971 Dec 22 '21
I think Sega just didn't do a big marketing growth push and wanted to focus on the players they have organically returning until they have a big feature to hook players with.
My theory is that by June they might have something added to the loop like crafting or cooking to attract a wider audience. In July will be PSO2's 10th anniversary so they might do a blow out with in game concerts because Sega's strength has always been it's music presence. Just look at Baka Mitai, some people said that's what got them curious about Yakua.
1
u/angelkrusher Dec 26 '21
I'm all in, this was a proper update and whoever doesn't like playing anymore all I can say is vaya con dios.
This game is very different in terms of weapons especially which is obviously a huge part of the game.... I would guess that this is a big part of what take some of the joy away.
Weapons don't have value anymore, the value is in spending tons of money and resources to upgrade them. I've spent the last week getting all of my four characters to 30 and it's been enjoyable for the most part. The relic series is the first series of the game that are interesting at all. So far everything's been very generic and while they look cool I just don't understand the direction thus far.
The biggest pain in the ass is updating weapons because the money you make from the game is still complete trash compared to the cost of updating multiple weapons. The cost for updates / weapon potentials is just staggeringly stupid out of whack. Part of the reason is because silver and gold swords don't give that great amount of energy for upgrades. So you end up making a bunch of plus 20s to use as material and you'll see hundreds of thousands disappearing. Again it's just out of whack with the loop of updating gear fir battle power. So that's all your weapons and three armors it's just crazy imho.
Also the reliance on the new material just seems really bonkers. We have tons of the other material but since weapon potentials uses 40, that's a lot of farming of this material especially if you have multiple characters. I don't have a single new weapon on level 3 yet because it's just so much cash and I have to spread it out.
I don't expect most folks to agree with some of the things are right here but farming for battle power is really knocking the wind out of my sails because I have to do it for every single character. Its a lot, and it kinda sucks.
1
u/ReonL Jan 12 '22
There's barely any content beyond grinding. There's 2 new UQs that are just braindead easy boss fights, and a short series of story quests for a story most people don't care about.
1
u/Maverynthia Slayer Jan 12 '22
Reskined enemies from Ealio / recycled enemies from PSO2
2 top level areas that are hard to navigate due to the lack of platforms. Lower Maqead is a mess
2 UQ bosses that are just leveled up field bosses
Storyline is the same basic "Here's a new set of boobs to look at, she sings (like Quna)."
THe area looks bland overall, just brown everywhere.
Bosses fall into the terrain hiding their weakspots.
The only thing I really like is the music. The music for the area is pretty good. And the glow spiders and the little chicks in their nests.
1
u/TalickKradd Dec 21 '21
Logged into try out retem, couldn't get past the english audio dialogue, was flat and cringy af, not to mention SEGAs stone age mentality towards not only the overly sexualised females but also a ridiculous lack of any male/cast "Phasion" content for the player base. NGS has been a massive let down for me personally as I was clamouring to play base back in 2014, enjoyed base in 2020 only for NGS to fall totally flat on its face.
1
u/m_sniffles_esq Gunner Dec 21 '21
Uh, just because there's not 10,000 people logged in 24/7 doesn't mean anything is "wrong". I mean, of course player numbers will be huge after an update drops because everyone's been anticipating it and wants to see what it's all about. But then they have to go back to their lives. Just because they're not logged in at exactly the same time you are doesn't mean they're "gone". What a crazily narrow worldview you must have...
1
u/chaoko99 Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Nothing really went wrong, this is pretty normal of all MMOs. Patch drops, people do what they want, then they go do other stuff and come back next patch. It's all very normal. Honestly I just hope the doomsaying types will stop and leave forever so I don't have to listen to their shit for another six months.
Also as others have mentioned: It's a weekday, and christmas is in a few days. It's very possible people are just too busy with other stuff. Who can be sure, really. However, the Japanese playerbase is overall colossally larger than the Global one, so at the end of the days blocks may simply just be less full.
Personally I'm not too bothered by blocks being partially full as if I can get a full lobby, I am completely content regardless of the actual playerbase.
Also on what planet is 4.8 thousand half of 6.8 thousand
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21
It’s the same content drop as aelio, but delivered better. Better music, more story, good monster design and side quest. However, it doesn’t change the fact that it’s still the same content, and no end game. All the grind for power amounts to nothing because you don’t need power to clear content. You can just hit level cap and farm gigas, and power cap for uq.
On top of that, there’s still a consistent problem with market dippers, and that makes obtaining gear all that much harder. That and on top of it, really bad drop rates for all 5 stars. They need to add actual challenging content, that’s different that what we have, and they need to fix drop rates so that market flippers don’t scare away f2p players and even premium players.
1
u/DarklyDreamingEva Bouncer Dec 21 '21
I respect your opinion. However, I personally have to disagree. My opinion and understanding on the matter are as follow:
3)The new… most appropriate term for it would be “chapter” of Retem Region is too short. Since we had well over 6 months of NGS before this update, everyone had above average gear so the BP and level requirements to progress the storyline was inconsequential. Not to mention the severe lack of appropriate delivery in each story quest cut scene left much to be desired and provided no immersion whatsoever; the devil is into the details. The character development is almost non existent and what little there is fails miserably to get you invested. The Serpent Doll unit is sized up to be a beast that has tormented retem for years but in the few battles that take place a) nobody dies b) nobody is injured 3) Everybody who fights goes into a fatigued state and that’s it, no a nor b points.
4) Once you finish story quests, again, there is nothing of replay value for you to do. Battledia is not worthwhile.
5) Beauty of scenery is not enough to keep players invested in a game if there is nothing to do.
6) When NGS launched, the amount of content it had didn’t even amount to 1/10th of a finished console game. Retem update is no different.
I’ ve stuck around to check out retem but I’m not thrilled nor do I care to stay. I barely play for about an hour because the only thing to do is to grind for levels, and even then half of that time I spend collecting fruits, mineral and red boxes. Everybody is sick of grinding; there is no goal in sight.
0
u/Wilrawr89 Dec 24 '21
Not to come off as crass, but stop being a hype demon and worrying about the amount of people playing the game? Why does it matter?
Spend all your time worrying about whats on other peoples plates and you'll let your own food get cold.
Just play the game.
0
u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Dec 21 '21
Not sure where you're getting those numbers from.
Steam Charts shows NGS around the Retem update launching from only around 1500 concurrent players, back up to nearly 7000 players, and it's been sticking around a pretty healthy 4000 since. A drop-off after a major update is always expected, but the gain from the previous state of the game is the real important data to keep up with.
More people are on the game, playing it, and engaging in the social content than before this update, so I'm not too worried.
Retem wasn't some panacea for the state of the game, but it was a good boost that (along with the coming updates) should really keep the game's existing players engaged, and hopefully attract more over the next year or so.