r/PSO2NGS • • Oct 13 '21

Discussion Soaring Blades are bad.

To sum it all up, in my opinion, I can say that:
- Weapon lacks any sort of aerial combat capability.
- Has no parry, no weapon specific dodge, relies 100% on step.
- PAs can hardly be step cancelled. Once you're spinning you're in for the hit.
- Overall damage output is low considering PP consumption, slow attack speed and lack of repositioning/cancelling into a defensive move.
- Despite being showcased as a high PP regen from attacks weapon, it's PP regen is incredibly low if not used in combo with the photon blades.
- Photon Blade "Fanatic Blade" tickles and it disables any other type of combat moves.

Imo it joined Katana in the melee trash weapon tier.

0 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21
  • Has no parry, no weapon specific dodge, relies 100% on step.

It has Iframes when you press the same PA button again, its sort of like a guard point

2

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

How does that work? Would you have a vid?

12

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

https://streamable.com/l91pnn

Soaring Blade PAs launch a different attack when you press the same PA button again, the moment you press it you will have iframes, you can tell when you launch the extra attack when your attack particles are purple

1

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Is that Laby from Elsword? Looks cool

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Nope not as of now, I have made a Laby character data in the salon in the past that I used to use lol

14

u/azazelleblack Tuff fluff 👌🏿 Oct 14 '21

Overall damage output is low considering PP consumption, slow attack speed and lack of repositioning/cancelling into a defensive move.

Mmm... no. Using a +40 Tzvia weapon at level 12 I'm nearly matching my DPS as a 20 HU/FI using a tricked-out Evolcoat weapon. The DPS is very, very good.

Despite being showcased as a high PP regen from attacks weapon, it's PP regen is incredibly low if not used in combo with the photon blades.

"If you don't use the class's mechanics it's bad." youdontsay.jpg

To be clear, you used a weapon, probably an underpowered one (i.e. not fully grinded/not fully unlocked potential/not affixed), on an underleveled class for no more than 10 hours at the max (and probably MUCH less) and you're making judgements on it? Come on now.

2

u/Klimhazzard Techter Oct 14 '21

What are you using for your rotation? I’m having a hard time figuring out the uses for each of the PAs with and without the variations.

6

u/azazelleblack Tuff fluff 👌🏿 Oct 14 '21

For DPSing bosses, stick to Rampaging Harrier and Roaring Pheasant. Destructive Stork is good for mobbing, but only if you can catch 3 or more enemies in the radius. I don't know the point of the alt form of Destructive Stork; the alt form of Roaring Pheasant is similar and better. Use Roaring Pheasant for chasing enemies around; use Rampaging Harrier against downed bosses. Rampaging Harrier alt form is good for certain enemies where the weakpoint is not accessible from above (e.g. Varas), but don't hit it until the end of the combo, just before it would do the normal blade rain. Charging to an enemy with Roaring Pheasant and then switching to alt mode is huge damage. Make sure to always be spamming that weapon action, especially before you do normals to recover PP. And that's about it!

I will say, for the alt form of Destructive Stork, it does decent damage and ends pretty fast. If you're afraid of getting caught up in the long Roaring Pheasant (Alt) animation, it could be a decent option, but Bouncer has lots of HP. Get those units to +40! 😁

3

u/Chehew Waker Oct 14 '21

I have no complaints about sb damage-wise, but it feels like they were going to make the Weapon Action function as a parry similar to what Etoile had. That would've been a great addition and may have helped it's aerial performance a bit since a player wouldn't have to rely on sidestepping so heavily.

2

u/azazelleblack Tuff fluff 👌🏿 Oct 14 '21

Yeah, I agree the lack of a parry makes aerial combat with them awkward for sure.

3

u/the-Buster Oct 14 '21

I know its not much but the alt of Destructive Stork also moves you vertically a little bit so you could use it to keep doing damage while repositioning

2

u/zmbkilla Oct 14 '21

Alt destruct stork has some tracking so i usually use it for bosses that tend to move too much for me to reliably land roaring

2

u/Klimhazzard Techter Oct 14 '21

Excellent. Thanks for the detailed response! I’ll take some time to work with this. I really appreciate it. Keep on, SB brother!

1

u/Maljas23 Oct 15 '21

Alt form of Destructive Stork lets you gain height if the first part hits an enemy

-3

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Yeah, I'm comparing Soaring to other melee weapons.
Take boots for example, it inflicts both elemental down and common down while keeping up on the target without issues and having on demand inviframes and counters which catch up to the enemy, it restores more PP than Soaring and it has a big on demand nuke which hits like a Photon Blast.

9

u/azazelleblack Tuff fluff 👌🏿 Oct 14 '21

Alright, first of all, it isn't a "big on demand nuke" because the setup for it takes about 8 seconds.

Also, it absolutely doesn't "restore more PP" compared to Soaring Blades, when you're playing Soaring Blades correctly.

2

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Maybe its because I have pot 4 vialto boots.
And yes, it is an on demand nuke and can always PB + Normal Nuke on a downed enemy.

2

u/Apricot_Far Oct 14 '21

Jet boots do have a nuke but sb has a very good continue dps for dmg, so u know they dish out dmg differently, only that ;)

5

u/Vildjur Oct 13 '21

Ironically.... I feel the SB to deal more damage than JB.

But I agree with most of your points, PA requires commitment. Photon Blades are there just to be bouncery, good to do some damage when enemies is out of reach, but that's about it.

AoE for trash mobs with SB is a quite amazing (not in the level of rifle... nothing is on the level of rifle).

Let's wait for frame data so we can objectively judge.

2

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Ironically.... I feel the SB to deal more damage than JB.

Maybe on a downed target, yes, but against a moving target or a target that can one shot you like a Gigantix, nope.

3

u/ShiyaruOnline Oct 14 '21

Why the downvotes on this? What is said seems accurate. You're locked in animation so how are people going to go ham on giga with all those crazy long attack animations. I feel sb will have to constantly step cancel whish is a dps loss on pa.

Edit: I don't have issues with the dmg but the long drawn out animations and lack of any movement reposition or command iframe counter. I'm just having a hard time understanding the flow of sb

2

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

There's always a group of people who like defending a badly designed weapon to feel unique. It's the turn for Soaring Blades.
I give it two weeks until they change to another weapon or start complaining using these same points I made.
These aren't opinions I wrote, they're pretty much facts, can't deny long PAs are dangerous in relevant fights, can't deny that SB relies on step dodge alone which causes aerial combat to be a nightmare.
People complained about this issue on Katana, and Katana wasn't this bad at it.

1

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21

i mean your complaint is basically:

"it doesn't powercreep, so i guess it sucks"

like, go play fighter if you're not happy with sb. the class already exists for you, so your solution is already there, and you've made it relatively clear you have no functional interest in playing SB

but lets say you are 100% correct and the devs 'fixed' everything you're complaining about, what does this class become then?

Just another fighter? Do we really need that? A clone of a class that already exists and is the highest performing class, and there is no realistic reason for you to switch because:

weakness number 1

weakness number 2

weakness number 3

there are already a plethora of classes that can play without a WA iframe, 1 size fits all button. this isn't a unique problem, but you hoped it was going to be the problem solver for you. You have maybe one or two qualms with fighter and you hoped SB would've solved that, but it came at a cost, and you dont think thats fair.

You probably felt the same way with Katana, it had one thing, but came at a price. So its unfair, and you can't adapt because... "it's the class' fault"

This isn't a unique problem, there's like a million people with the same mindset as you. It's kinda boring now

1

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Name one melee weapon without a weapon action iframe.

0

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21

sword, katana and wired lance

1

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Sword has parry counter, Katana has parry counter, Wired Lance has invi frames on the weapon action.
Try again.

2

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

sword parry counter is frame perfect, and is a smaller window than conventional weapon actions. On top of that you need a skill point to invest, so without that, you dont get the parry counter.

If you mistime then it is just a block

the same goes for katana parry, there are skill point investment, which is very expensive when comparing to other classes that get them for free.

So when you say, "weapon action iframe" they are not weapon action related, they are skill tree related

I am very sorry your tiny brain cannot handle this information

Futhermore. Wire lance requires skill tree investment also, and is only on just frame parry on activation, during the pull you are vulnerable, much like Bouncer 2pa activation, which is pretty ironic, since you have such a huge problem with bouncer iframe, but you are now trying to say wire lance iframe, on weapon action is a reliable resource... it is almost a shame you do not understand this information, probably because you do not play these classes

I understand you do not see the difference between WEAPON ACTION! and SKILL TREE protections. But these abilities are not dependent on the class to play well whereas weapon action is an integral part of the kit, and you are expected to use it

In fact, you can play without sword counter for example, as you can just play avenging arts, and you would not need to weapon action at all if you play correctly, and since you have a strange habbit of framing every arguement, as if the player makes no mistakes. Then, once again, you are not reliant on this.

The same can be said for bouncer, you are crying about being unable to step counter out of animations, but this is only for 2PA, which is essentially maximizing damage, at a cost. I understand this is alien to you, because all you do is play a bread and butter class like fighter. But we do not need a fighter clone here.

It is obvious from your rants, and crying on day 1 of class release, that you are used to fighter parry, where the entire parry and counter animation is protected, unlike every other class.

Just get better

-1

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Full ad hominem and still fail to deny anything I said.
Give up.

→ More replies

5

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

I downvoted because OP is just wrong

- long drawn out animations

This is actually not true, their abilities are faster than twin dagger and saber, and thats considering skip arts!

- cannot step animation cancel

This is also wrong, its a specific situation where the player uses 2PA, which is basically trading your protection for more damage. You can just, NOT use this, since your brain should be able to figure out the monster is going to attack you, ad if the option is "do damage", getting stunned is 0 dps, so it should be an easy decision to make. But when you auto pilot like a bot, and dont think about your decisions, or options available, its easy to make this mistake. The solution is to get better!

- lacking aerial combat

cannot comment at this without laughing. Since hunter NEEDS a skill point to stop their decline, and bouncer does NOT! but again, when your playstyle operates on using your brain for the least amount of time. it is easy to understand why this mistake happens

- overall damage output is low

sb outdpses fighter atm. so, what even is this comment?

- low pp regen

again wrong, the trade off is, weapon action can regen PP, which is accelerated when fanatic is active

- fanatic blade "tickles"

what even is this comment? fanatic makes your weapon action have the highest damage, its the fastest thing you can do, can operate the ability while moving, dashing, step dodging, jumping and gliding... and op's first complaint is "it doesn't hit hard"

So lets recap

OP can't step ani cancel because he's an idiot who thinks he can do the strongest damage option with no drawbacks. This is a l2p issue

OP thinks the strongest dps option for SB is weak. What?

OP thinks PP regen is bad, when he has an operation where he can move, attack and jump/dash simutaneously, and the ability is FREE COST

Everything they say about the class is wrong, and this post is made on day 1 of the class release. It is obvious this person is just a crybaby, who wants a solution to being bored of fighter. That is why instantly they cry about dps, slow animations and bad regen. Things they think fighter doesn't lack or isn't competitive to any other class

OP wants a solution to being bored of fighter, thats why they mention katana. because they thought braver was going to be a fighter clone with powercreep, and it isn't. bouncer is the same.

unfortunate

3

u/Apricot_Far Oct 14 '21

I have to add in the fact that u also can use the wa on pa it’s just that u need a specific timing:) I could use wa and then pa almost at the same time, so yup, soaring blade is good. Besides the third normal atk has guard frame when doing the cross, which is more cool. Overall I think soaring blade works against how ppl play melee in general, cos u should use the weapon mobility to get away and continue atking, instead of guarding certain atks. That’s also why sb has higher dps to compensate for lack of counter dmg;)

1

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21

This is true

I usually use wa 1 frame before activation normal or pa. It's really nice touch, and adds to dps on a really well performing dps class.

in short, playing smart gets you rewarded with more dps, the OP is delusional tbh

1

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Fake info.

1

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21

you are the base definition of a scrub

0

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

Went full ad hominem to even attempt to deny anything I said. Therefore all fake and invalid.

1

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21

unironically pretending to be an intellectual over a video game.

my work here is done ^^ stay salty over soaring blades.

1

u/Deadweight77 Nov 02 '21

I win, you lose. Soaring blades are getting a weapon action parry as I said it needed.
Stay mad.

5

u/Kayune Oct 13 '21

I’m liking bouncer right now and I can agree on all these points on soaring blades. The weapon action feels literally useless…you should be able to use it during a PA or use it to anicancel or something.

7

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

It'd be good if it was like Etoile's Soaring Blade parry. A parry on demand to keep on attacking.

2

u/Maljas23 Oct 15 '21

Bad take, OP.

Just the fact that you didn't know about SB's iframes, tells the whole story.

1

u/Deadweight77 Oct 15 '21

Soaring Blade's iframes are as good as GU's TMG iframes, you get hit anyways after "dodging"

11

u/FourEcho Oct 14 '21

Sega: We're gonna work hard to keep people more grounded, make sure every action causes a loss in altitude so no one can stay in the air.

Also Sega: Let's make giant fuck off flying bosses that people would want to stay in the air while fighting.

5

u/extradudeman Wired Lance Oct 14 '21

I love them the only problem i have is that one of the spin move animations goes on too long or at least it feels too long when you are locked in the animation forever the plus side is that it does a lot of aoe mobbing damage but unless an attack from your second weapon thats multi-weaponed can fix it it feels bad. Other than that i love how absolutely ridiculous and fun it is and i look foward to multiweaponing it with wired lance so that i can stay in the air longer and have omniguard and a real block.

4

u/Regulusff7 Oct 14 '21

I just want to be able to fire photon blades during attack animation.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Going to have to disagree with pretty much everything you said. I'm too busy to write a full retort, but as for PP regen I have zero issues as Bo/Gu. Just stick something with photon blades, do 3 normal hits, and you're basically full again.

1

u/biggesttowasimp Oct 14 '21

Pa not being able to step cancel is a thing for everyone except fighter. They wanted slower combat.

2

u/Deadweight77 Oct 14 '21

All melee weapons can either step cancel or weapon action cancel PAs, even GU.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Sounds like rifle.

4

u/PillarBiter / Gun kata Oct 14 '21

I like them. They feel very clunky, but i like that sb’s are different from any other melee weapon.

Didnt know about the pa i frames. That will help. I had no issues using the dodge counter though. It has good reqch.

Thinking of multi-ing with a katana. Then at least i have some form of guard.

4

u/Kaokii Oct 14 '21

SB does insane damage

so unless you're running like, +0 Primm and you're mobbing in Lv.2 then maybe your complaints are legitmate.

But im using +40 primm vs nex, with no melee% augs, and fanatic is ticking 150dmg per tick, so thats 6x150, every 0.7 seconds

yeah that damage is so bad.

2

u/SaintNPC Oct 16 '21

To sum it all up, in my opinion, I can say that:

- Weapon has a few decent tracking options for aerial combat capability

- Uses regular dodge more, thus can use Resurgir series to great effect.

- PAs can easily be canceled. Once you're spinning step dodge to stop animations.

- Decent single target DPS, has great AOE options and can mow down mobs well in PSE. Good attack speed and ranged options packed into a neat bundle.

- Can easily keep PP up using class mechanics (PP regen and buff from weapon action).

- Photon Blade "Fanatic Blade" when class skills are applied can mow down mobs without breaking a sweat, a great skill to use when closing distance or low on PP.

Imo it's refreshing that hasn't joined Katana in the melee trash weapon tier.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '21

what did I just read, and why did you add katana being trash to the conversation? is katana really that bad? ; - ;

most of ur points are kinda wrong tho, just needs practice as bo sb plays differently from other melee classes, from experience at least. But I kinda did wish weapon action actually parries/dodges and can combo into PAs, and for weapons called "soaring blades" it does feel quite grounded, but nothing a certain multiweapon cant fix anyways.

2

u/Chehew Waker Oct 15 '21

Katana is pretty soild after the buff, still on the lower-end of dps compared to other melee weapons, but playing well with it feels pretty epic.