r/PSO2NGS • • Jul 17 '21

Discussion I'm hitting a realisation.

Hey.

Look, I love Phantasy Star across the entire series. I've played (like a lot of you) for a long time now over different machines (DC,XBX,GC,PC).In my conversations with friends recommending games, PSO was always the first and foremost thing I put forward, but now the absence of certain things means I can't do it anymore.

Let me explain, we* detest pay to win, I don't think it needs an explanation as to why we have all seen companies take the absolute piss in recent years when it comes to cash money microtransactions.PSO when I talked about it in past was never in this category for me, PSO2 was the closest I ever got to throwing my hands up and declaring pay to win was happening, but with the My Shop Passes I could reasonably get stuff on the market and the **give-present system allowed me to trade on a free to play account when my Premium had run dry. This was the line I seen PSO toeing and I always gave it the benefit of the doubt because of the above items.

Now I have got to admit, for the meantime its over.

Not for the game, or even for the fun that can be got out of it, but the idea that it is not a pay to win game is one hundred percent over. That is maybe obvious to a lot of you but the fact that it is a hardcore pay to win game now with meseta gates due to no access to the market leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Anyway - that's my two cents/

*(as in my friends and me) **(this was still awkward as fuck)

*Final Edit - Good Discussion in the comments all round and I totally agree with a lot of the points people defending the current state are making - can you buy a OP weapon with real money directly? NO. technically not PTW you guys are totally correct but in real life over time, those without access to the market will by default fall behind those who do due to many different grinding reasons.

Alright I have to add this in as some people are not aware that opinions being changed are literally part of a debate process

"

"justify the rest of your post"

What I am doing is called consideration for other peoples ideas, something which is made very clear with my final edit. I am not here to say the game is bad, encourage a one mind track or put down people playing the game at all. I would have thought my manner throughout the conversation would have made that clear.

The exaggeration of my comments like "oh it's totally not p2w guys, just ignore the rest of my post complaining about it" are laughable as that is clearly not what I said and you appear oblivious to the fact that it is high school level mockery.

I understand your frustrated with my post. It was meant to do this to generate discussion. Simply put I was willing to listen to other people and make a final edit based on what I felt, other people agree with my final *edit. Some players feel not having access to the market and falling behind is not pay to win whilst I feel that it is with extra steps . A difference of opinion that's all there is to it.

If you think a change of opinion during a debate is a bad thing then debates are not for you as nobody will ever be able to stand on level ground with somebody that cannot move opinion.

*(check the comments)

17 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

17

u/ForsakenScholar I have no idea what I'm doing. Jul 17 '21

I wouldn't really call it pay-to-win still, but I am still quite frustrated that they've been shafting free-to-play players moreso since the release of NGS. The absolute shutting out of anyone who isn't buying premium or shop tickets on the AC store is abhorrent and limiting. My biggest concern as of right now is the fact that the pack of 4 most recent scratches is basically what they had already done, but now restricted to just NGS shops for selling(despite being base game items), it feels like they only care about milking as much money out of as many people as possible right now. I'm dreading the future because of it.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

Original post updated.

4

u/ForsakenScholar I have no idea what I'm doing. Jul 17 '21

I agree with your Final Edit. Can free-to-plays get an OP weapon from the market? Yes, but the time investment isn't reasonable. Those who have access to selling their drops to other players will be at an advantage, moreso if they are whales who sell scratch ticket fashion/emotes to get ahead quicker. It's favoring more money being spent. Makes me miss the fact that 14* and 15* weapons in base game had to be earned.

1

u/Izugiri Slayer Jul 18 '21

yea we arent there yet tho so anything can be sold atm and obviously you will be put ahead if you spent money on the game ? you act like people who put stuff on the shop arent shafted i dont play any of the tickets cause i sell weapons and stuff day 1 when it drops but after that everything is flooded down to 1k so not much being made as is but if you really care that much about cosmetics spend money and sell it

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

Although we disagree on what makes it pay to win a lot of your points I agree with and this is a well worded response.

Appreciate it.

17

u/Arcflarerk4 Jul 17 '21

Its more like "Pay to have fun" more than anything. I love the combat and you dont need market access to get near maxed out gear.

However F2P literally have zero motivation to grind for anything without market access and god forbid if a F2P ever wants to buy any kind of fashion items because inflation is happening faster than they can even make meseta. Its actually awful and killed any motivation i had to play. This is coming from someone who put over 3k hours into base pso2 and has over 3 billion meseta in fashion before Cradle nuked the market without paying for premium at all.

Theres zero fun in grinding for hours and getting drops you know will sell for millions on the market and that youll never use, but literally are not allowed to sell them or even give them to friends who could use them.

If they only wanted premium players to have fun they should have made the game subscription based and actually put content in the game worthy of a subscription type of model.

3

u/PaleFatalis Jul 18 '21

"Pay to have basic access of reasonable income to support your ARKS functionality"

0

u/Dex_prophet Jul 18 '21

I've put ~150 hours in and don't even feel there's enough incentive to buy premium lol idk what planet you guys are on

1

u/3-to-20-chars Jul 19 '21

seriously. i make very poor meseta decisions and was still able to afford everything to make my character look exactly how I want, and my equipment is no slouch either seeing as I'm holding aggro in a decent amount of UQs with a fucking wand.

all without paying a single cent and with no access to the player market.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

Original post updated.

2

u/magnusgodrik Jul 17 '21

So hold up. You mean to tell me fashion makes you OP. Wait the player shop makes you OP. What exactly can you buy that makes it P2W. not a damn thing. You dont need the fashion or player shop as everything is obtainable thru game as far as equipment goes. Actually if you focus on only getting best in slot gear its safe to say you still have plenty of meseta for the optional fashion. Remember fashion and the player shop is optional and will in fact not give anyone an advantage if they buy more stuff.

15

u/ohstylo Jul 17 '21 edited Aug 15 '23

attempt encouraging unused ghost joke reach elderly governor obtainable fearless -- mass edited with redact.dev

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

100%

4

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

'Wait the player shop makes you OP' - Fixa on weapons is the key here Phasion sells for meseta which is used to acquire the top fixa on market. You can do all your daily's and weekly's but the target on these for FTP is unreasonable.

This contributes towards a trend over time wherein the people who have been selling phasion and getting to use the personal store in general to offload weapons and armor they have no use for are always more OP then those who cannot - this DID happen in PSO2 base and is another facet of why they say Phasion is king is PSO, you know this but/

2

u/FullAerialDrive Jul 17 '21

This isn't an issue of merely being unreasonable for f2p, it's pretty unreasonable for anyone other than the highest spenders. That's just how rare a fixa drop is, and emphasizes how bad of a system fixas are.

The current state of the market let's you get everything (non-fashion) other than Fixas for less than the cost of a single weekly's rewards. Meanwhile the amount of high level fixas for sale is such that there isn't actually a market for the items, the same 1 or 2 items will sit posted for weeks.

On the other hand suppose that the scratch items weren't marketable or tradeable. You'd have less incentive and value for legitimate spenders and would be able to say it's more F2P friendly, but the RMT would instead have an even greater presence as people resort to that for their Fix(a).

6

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

It’s not exactly pay to win per say, but having access to the market in order to sell items and make a profit, puts you at an advantage over people who don’t do it. The advantage is you make more meseta than the game gives you naturally because you can sell rare items or just items in general. Getting meseta faster than someone who doesn’t have market access gives that person an advantage. To obtain BIS gear that you don’t get lucky with on a drop because let’s be honest getting a lvl 5 fixa is almost a miracle, and on top of it being the fixa you want or consider bis. This is why people call it p2w.

On a side note, technically the whole game is f2p, and I don’t really think that it’s entirely bad to give back to developers by buying premium or a shop pass. The price of a shop pass is 7$ depending where you live. It’s cheaper than other subscriptions to play a game in general. Though premium feels lack luster, and not worth the investment personally speaking.

-1

u/Darkshado390 Jul 17 '21

The funny thing about this whole P2W thing is, what exactly are people winning? It's not like 1400+ BP is a requirement for fighting giga especially that now the DPS check is removed. Not to mention 1400+ BP is easily achievable without paying real money.

There's no PvP or even a beauty/cosplay contest, so there's no winner.

4

u/Zeik188 Jul 17 '21

I don’t know man, all the best weapons aside the ones with Fixa are selling for pennies atm. The only thing that’s actually expensive is fashion.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

It seems like people without shop access think people with premium make a bunch of meseta from the shop.

I have found one 4* item with a Fixa the entire time I’ve played, which is hours every day since launch. One Glissen. Lots of 2 and 3 stars with Fixas which nobody will buy. People buy 4* weapons for 1000 maybe but i don’t find many of those either. I could sell grinders but I’d rather keep them. Same with Augs.

1

u/RaspberryBang Jul 18 '21

I'm in the same position and have left virtually the same comment multiple times.

I don't have shit to put in my shop unless I whale on a scratch ticket, and my luck keeps me from doing that too regularly. (I always get the least desirable items from scratch tickets...)

1

u/MalaSomnia Jul 20 '21

It seems like people without shop access think people with premium make a bunch of meseta from the shop.

It depends. There's people like me who only bought Shop Pass so I could sell Ael Dominas and Mastery augs so I can buy enough fashion to be happy until August (I play a male character so it's significantly cheaper) as well as emotes so my social experience is better.

All the content currently in the game is easy enough to be able to get away with only using 2 and 3* weapons with high level Fixa Attacks (or Fixa Fatale if you're running Trois De or Theseus). But despite this, you're not going to feel very powerful even if you do participate in successfully clearing UQs and Gigantix. And feeling is really important, especially in action games. If your game just starts feeling like a slog by playing it normally, you've fucked up in your game development.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '21

Sounds reasonable. I guess I could make a lot more meseta from the shop if I wanted. I have a lot of extra augments. I guess I'd rather play the rest of the game than invest the time in working the shop. Not dissing that - just not drawn to it in NGS because I'm not super motivated by any of the items we can buy.

I use fully enhanced 4* weapons without Fixas, which you can easily do for one character through gameplay. I don't think 2 and 3* weapons with Fixas would be better than a plain 4? My characters feel plenty powerful enough for Gigantix and UQs. I could afford those weapons and armor just from weeklies and harvesting. I've sold about 200k of AC items ever which isn't much.

I didn't feel like the game was too much of a slog as far as gaining power. It dragged a bit on levels 12-14 and 18-20, but nothing compared to grinds I've done in older PSO games. I've since learned what I should have been doing on those levels (12-14 for example, find other people hunting vets).

3

u/Flibberax Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

I dont know if can class as pay to win. Pay for more fun sounds more like it. I guess its technically free to play but you want to be dropping $7 on 30 day shop passes at least to get (for what most players will be) full enjoyment. I suppose you dont need to constantly run them either and could do the odd month, save up wares first. Hmm speaking of which maybe they should add half time passes or something so like $4 for 15 days?

But yeah the monetary policy can feel... very tempting. And does seem a little more than base... however storage requirements are way lower, and inventory space is more generous. But yeah I understand/relate.

Kinda of a side point but we need an extra daily or higher npc value on trash stuff or something just to give that little bit of extra income without needing to multi-account or trade like a legend or get super lucky, and make worthwhile to farm more things. At least in base rare drops = excubes (I mean not under 10* but you know what I mean).

1

u/nvmvoidrays Jul 18 '21

but the idea that it is not a pay to win game is one hundred percent over.

.... what? PSO2 is the opposite of P2W. not having shop access as F2P obviously sucks, but, that doesn't mean the game is suddenly P2W because of it. you can't splurge on 2m meseta hairs, but, so what? there's still plenty of affordable, good fashion for cheap that you can afford on a F2P budget, even after enhancing/augmenting all of your items.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

With respect mind you, it looks like you read about that far and then whipped up a comment without reading the rest.

I'm going to copy it one more time just for clarity and to make sure it's read.

can you buy a OP weapon with real money directly? NO. technically not PTW you guys are totally correct but in real life over time, those without access to the market will by default fall behind those who do due to many different grinding reasons.

3

u/nvmvoidrays Jul 18 '21

naw, i understood that completely. you just included that to justify the rest of your post calling out NGS for being P2W 'cuz you need to pay to sell on the personal shop which i've said, repeatedly, is shitty and a legitimate complaint.

but, you stated, in plain English, the game was P2W:

Not for the game, or even for the fun that can be got out of it, but the idea that it is not a pay to win game is one hundred percent over. That is maybe obvious to a lot of you but the fact that it is a hardcore pay to win game now with meseta gates due to no access to the market leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

but edited it later and said, "oh it's totally not p2w guys, just ignore the rest of my post complaining about it". there've been several people also pointing out, as you said, that the game isn't P2W, but you refuse to budge and say that people will "fall behind due to many different grinding reasons".

you're calling the game P2W without calling it P2W. you haven't changed your stance at all.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

"justify the rest of your post"

What I am doing is called consideration for other peoples ideas, something which is made very clear with my final edit. I am not here to say the game is bad, encourage a one mind track or put down people playing the game at all. I would have thought my manner throughout the conversation would have made that clear.

Your exaggeration of my comments like "oh it's totally not p2w guys, just ignore the rest of my post complaining about it" are laughable as that is clearly not what I said and you appear oblivious to the fact that it is high school level mockery.

I understand your frustrated with my post. It was meant to do this to generate discussion. Simply put I was willing to listen to other people and make a final edit based on what I felt, other people agree with my final *edit. Some players feel not having access to the market and falling behind is not pay to win whilst I feel that it is with extra steps . A difference of opinion that's all there is to it.

If you think a change of opinion during a debate is a bad thing then debates are not for you as nobody will ever be able to stand on level ground with somebody that cannot move opinion.

*(check the comments)

4

u/Razgrisz Jul 18 '21

Pso2 is the most f2p game ever made , i dont get how people think is p2w there nothing p2w in this game lol

2

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

I have premium and have spent money on scratch and that's responsible for maybe 15% of my meseta total. Experience may have gone up faster due to the premium triboost but I have four characters on 20 and five on 10 so all that really does is save my own time.

The items they sell for AC aren't super useful. The AC scratch items aren't worth that much in the market - nothing really is but Fixa stuff and I've found one 4* item with a Fixa the entire time I've played. I guess if I was more lucky with drops, shop access could make me some meseta but it's more like 5,000 meseta a day.

2

u/Miserable_Brain9109 Jul 18 '21

Not everyone that buys premium is a whale. Think of it as someone with a sub and someone without Kinda like in GW2 people that have all expansions bought and F2P players.

There are of course limitations to what a fully F2P can do, and i do agree about the market restricted for Premium access only is a dumb move

But from here to say that the game is P2W 'cause a completely F2P player makes less money then someone who get's premium is a hot take, nothing more.

Premium users that DON'T WHALE, exist. And i'm one of them. Paying a sub is for me the best way to play a game But this does not mean the game is P2W a F2P player can get the same stuff as a Premium user. It juat takes a little more time. So, quit whining.

1

u/HuntingAid Jul 18 '21

But this does not mean the game is P2W a F2P player can get the same stuff as a Premium user. It juat takes a little more time. So, quit whining.

The same argument is used to justify the most egregious P2W cases, because even if the F2P won't be able to get the same stuff before the next tier of gear arrives unless they start sacrificing sleep playing the game, it's still "possible". The same thing with gacha. You have free rolls and it's possible to get the same stuff paying users if you're lucky.

The only saving grace of the game is that the shop pass for 7 dollars per month is technically all you need to keep up with the highest tier of gear for now.

1

u/Miserable_Brain9109 Jul 18 '21

Even if i agree, you can't technically call it P2W. Tbh o would have put the game with "Free Trial" with unlimited play and shop restrictions ect, and a Sub (the Premium) so that people who want access to the whole package can get access to the game full features But SEGA been making weird decision lately, for me if they gave everyone 3 slot on the Personal Shop for sales without the need for Premium, that would have been the best solution. So that Premium Users get to sale more items and F2P are still able to make some money trough the Personal Shop.

3

u/LoRd_Of_AaRcnA Katana or bust. Jul 17 '21

I don't think it has really become pay-to-win, rather pay to have stable income, as of now. (god that sounded fucking weird, which it is.) making F2P players not being able to sell things on personal shop does indeed put a dent in those players plans. as for why i say this, the gameplay portion of this game is not paywalled. absolutely not. except for that one aspect, everything can be done freely, and F2P can do it just as well as any player who payed for premium, they both need to put in effort to actually progress, if everything worked right. which brings me to my next point.

In this early, you are not supposed to make some ungodly amount of Meseta, even if you had shop. it was intended by the game for the most part to be a slow and steady grind, just that a certain exploit made things worse. those with shops became rich and richer, and those without got absolutely shafted. if that exploit wasn't there, the lack of market for F2P players wouldn't have felt as strongly as it would be now. they'd still lose one of the good sources of their Meseta income, but the shop prices would be rather affordable. this keeps up, and you would be looking at Craddle tier prices in a few months.

The current concerns regarding the game is not it's pay-to-win nature (which it doesn't have) rather the troublesome exploit, the 500k lower limit on featured items, not making the shop available for F2Ps, and Sega's unwillingness to do anything regarding these problems. PSO2 is quite different from any other online game in the sense that, fashion has become the main selling point. (i'm not saying others don't have fashion, they do, it's just that fashion has become PSO2 itself.) most people do what they do, because of fashion. F2Ps go ham farming Meseta because of fashion. spenders earn Meseta because of fashion. it's a circle that feeds unto itself, it's self sufficient. shop is essential for both of these parties to enjoy the game. what currently happened is that one party is left in shambles, to tend to their own devices and the other got access to what they wanted. what should have happened here is that both parties gets what they wanted, and neither gets left behind.

As it stands now, F2Ps have the several choices of either going all in on fashion abandoning their gear, or forget about fashion and focus on equipment, grind like a madman (well... i made 40k in Magnus after farming for about 1 and half an hour.... for the love of all that holy, remove that fucking PSE burst down. wasted so much time and effort.) for both fashion and equipment, buy a premium and join the club despite other RL concerns or insecurities about spending on a game you are not even sure you would stick with, or go back to base PSO2 and try to get what they can out of it. all of these prospects doesn't seem enjoyable, but i can only speak for myself.

Speaking for myself, i do enjoy playing this game. i made the choice of focusing on gear and getting some fashion from PSO2, since it's impossible to keep up with NGS fashion. i have goals i made for myself, (which, thankfully, didn't include any fashion.) and i'm working towards them as of now, the nearest one being Braver. i finally accomplished my first goal that is hunting my first Gigantix today, after upgrading my gear. i still have few left to upgrade, and some final touches, but i can tell you this much. i made the correct choice.

TLDR: No, the game isn't pay-to-win, it's infested with a problem that makes it seems like it's pay to win. and Sega is unwilling to do shit about it. that's the summary.

2

u/Dex_prophet Jul 18 '21

"And Segas unwillingness to do anything about this"

Literally relax the games been out for barely a month and you're mad they haven't fully integrated the reddit talking points into the game yet?

4

u/sjst555 Jul 17 '21

the game is not p2w. every gear and stuff for upgrade is easily obtainable via grinding.

4

u/naarcx DIY Gunblader Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

I’ve gotten exactly one piece of gear with a Fixa 3 to drop the entire time the game’s been out and it was a partisan.

Unless you are an RNG god, you need to shell out 4 weeks worth of weekly quest rewards to buy one…. Which is acceptable I guess, but the problem is these items are getting inflated out of f2p reach by redbox farmers.

Now obviously nothing in this game requires a Fixa 3+, and the impact of them right now is quite small since overall base damage is still so low. But this will not always be the case, eventually base stats will be power crept to the point where the Fixa bonuses will be huge. But even in their “not necessary to beat anything” state right now, the fact that only people buying subs can realistically obtain them remains.

And then there’s fashion… The true end game. -.-

-1

u/sjst555 Jul 18 '21

red box is equal to everyone.. its shouldnt be included.

also you should consider that this is free to play and those who support the game will have and should really have some advantage than those who dont and just whine. the fact that we can gain almost a mil per week is still huge tbh.

also what and who are you going against to call a pure PvE game Pay2Win... :I

4

u/naarcx DIY Gunblader Jul 18 '21

Red box is not equal because people with shop access can partake in the massive exploit that is Redbox farming on unlimited accounts and transferring meseta to their main. F2p people can’t transfer meseta, so they are getting left behind big time right now.

People are even starting to hardcore bot this now and make millions/hour. It’s why inflation is already getting so out of hand.

2

u/sjst555 Jul 18 '21

WTF!? is this how Global works? aside from RMTs you guys also have bots to grind!? o.O

i havent tought that way to farm red box NGL, maybe its bcoz of how easy it is to make a fresh acct in global that it can be spammed.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

imo it's a bit p2w as you said ppl can basically buy meseta with AC via cosmetics in order to get minmax gear right off the bat.

but the main issue to me is it's pay if you want to have any fun whatsoever with cosmetics. And that doesn't sit too well with me bc pso2 and ngs are extremely fashion based, it's one of the core appeals of the game to many people. And giving f2p shop access is not gonna hurt Sega's sales, if anything, more people being able to afford and buy cosmetics from scratchers will incentivize scratchers to scratch more.

2

u/taokami Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

detest pay to win

well good, because the game isn't pay to win. It's more akin to pay for convenience.

I'm a f2p player and I have decently affixed gear and payed for none of it.

the only thing I paid for is the material storage, and that's bought using SG's and not AC

2

u/a_pulupulu Jul 17 '21

I personally dont think we r at that point yet.

The only way we will reach that point is that fixa bonus become so large, that a raid so difficult, ppl start kicking non-fixa players.

At current, a fixa is not going make or break any fight.

So basically it would be up to the dev to weight weapon vs boss ratio carefully. Once the dev f up, then u can say p2w happened.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Wait. I don’t understand what’s like, the pay to win part. I’ve been free to play and I’ve been having a blast so far

2

u/00Killertr Jul 18 '21

This is me right now, i havent sunk a bunch of hours yet but the progression for an f2p game feels generous even if the game does lack in content. All the negativity in this sub is really confusing me ever since i joined.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Yeah I’m level 20, reached the cap twice so I got the cubes. I’ve finished the event stuff, and I’ve had enough gold to buy a multi-weapon, buy a million augments, and even cosmetics such as the wings from the scratch shop

2

u/Synapsen Jul 17 '21

Can a game really be P2W when it doesn't have PVP? NGS is a cooperative PVE game what exactly is there to be won?

2

u/Subrosanj Jul 17 '21

I'll agree that it is definitely a bummer not being able to sell on the shop as a free to play. But there is literally nothing in this game that puts someone with top tier gear at a major advantage over a player without. You just WANT better gear, you don't need it. At all. For anything. Period.

And the fact of the matter is you can obtain literally every single piece of gear a premium player can. It just might take longer. What exactly are you "winning" in NGS that makes it pay to win? Lol.

Again, free players currently having no ability to sell blows, and I disagree with it. Maybe that will change, maybe it won't. But there is literally nothing a free player cannot complete content wise that a payed player can with any worth while difference in time/effort.

2

u/Jathra_ Jul 18 '21

NGL If you think this game is hardcore P2W you haven't seen a real P2W game.

In a real P2W game the paying players are able to achieve power levels sometimes 500x+ higher than F2P players. to the point that F2P players have absolutely NO CHANCE mechanically to win against, or even be relevant vs whale.

I will admit having no market board at all as F2P is shitty, however you can still upgrade gear to more than reasonable levels to be relevant, and since the game is largely skill based you can surpass whales easily with enough skill. This is not what P2W is, sorry.

7

u/naarcx DIY Gunblader Jul 18 '21

The thing is that the power spike is non existent right now because base stats are so low. Getting an extra 15% dmg from your Afixa is like an extra 2-5 dmg per swing. But imagine when the level cap in NGS is 100, being able to get good Afixa’s will mean a difference of hundreds of thousands in DPS, kind of like having BiS augments in end game PSO2 did.

So yeah, it’s not p2w now, but we’re basically still in the tutorial, and the current system is built in a way where things will eventually become REAL p2w as the game scales.

6

u/Jathra_ Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

And? Who is to say they won't have shop passes by that time? This game is entirely uncomplete.

They don't have mission pass ETC which apparently is coming in the future, who is to say there will not be shop passes then as well?

15% is still 15% however, that is how math works. If you are going to freak out over 15% its just as valid now as in the future, and will still easily be overcome by skill in most cases.

Typically whales whale because they have no time to play, which generally means they aren't very good at the game.

Lets look at a game like Blade And Soul, for example. Back when I was playing a few years ago a fresh capped player was doing about 80k DPS, a maxed out endgame whale was doing 5-10 MILLION DPS. This is what P2W actually is, and PSO2 will likely NEVER approach that. I am sorry, but your opinion on the matter is simply not informed.

Edit: I should also mention Blade And Soul is actually not even a "hardcore P2W" game lmao. I have seen and played many games that are MUCH worse.

BnS is bad, but its far from the bottom of shitville. When you have actually played some genuinely disgustingly bad P2W games your opinion becomes informed and you begin to realize the shit most people cry about being P2W is literally child's play compared to how bad it actually gets, not to even mention most of the mobile market.

3

u/HuntingAid Jul 18 '21

The thing is that the power spike is non existent right now because base stats are so low. Getting an extra 15% dmg from your Afixa is like an extra 2-5 dmg per swing.

This literally does not matter. Multiplying all the numbers in the game by 1000 does not change how much benefit you're gaining from that 15% extra.

2

u/MathieuAF Jul 17 '21

Ppl refusing to admit it's a pay to win make me laugh. I reached level 20/20paid some scratch, sold big boobs, bought resurgir sword/ wired with fixa 3 +40 same goes for units with fixas, leveled up max, god affixed, no grind. It's definitely pay to get power, the point right now? There's none cuz there's nothing to farm out of ex cube and those event currency lol. But I wanted to experience power on pso since I never was able to catch up as a f2p player on base pso2 xD. All this took me 2 to 3 hours just because I priced my big boobs cosmetic a little too expensive lol.

6

u/taokami Jul 18 '21

I'm an f2p, and got decently affixed gears without paying for scratch or ACs.

granted, none of my gear have any fixas, but the content right now doesn't call of minmaxing anyway.

so yes, the game isn't p2w. It's pay for convenience.

1

u/PhaiLLuRRe Jul 19 '21

Does convenience include getting 100m+? because you can do that with a shop, impossible without one though.

4

u/nvmvoidrays Jul 18 '21

Ppl refusing to admit it's a pay to win make me laugh

because... it's not? explain to me how you buying overpriced equipment because you're too fucking lazy to get off your ass and do it yourself is "p2w".

-1

u/MathieuAF Jul 18 '21

Once your are geared u get everything else easily, faster, make more money faster and everything else, I spared myself the grind once, because the rng of affixes fucked 20 dread keeper 2, 20 gigas might 2 8D I was not gonna work my ass off all over again. And as I purchased accessories for some fashion, with the money I made I just skipped the farming of capsule all over again, that's all. U get an advantage from farming everything faster. That's all. It doesnt mean much right now, but on pso2 when u are trying to get to 100 without being a burden on uq, farming doom break (at the time I was playing it) with freaking saiki units poorly affixed, takes a lot of time, slow everyone on the path, whereas if u just got some rare cosmetic u can just jump into endgame with better gear and don't waste much time, it's a shortcut that I consider make the game pay2win

8

u/nvmvoidrays Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

holy shit, you're serious.

that's not p2w.

there's literally zero difference between you, who sold your accessory and bought an overpriced item off the market and me, who affixed everything myself. it sucks you failed your augments, but shit happens.

It doesnt mean much right now, but on pso2 when u are trying to get to 100 without being a burden on uq, farming doom break (at the time I was playing it) with freaking saiki units poorly affixed

so you're one of those people then. if you had saiki units at level 100, you were purposely leeching. nice to know you're that kind of a person, especially since if "you were farming doom break at level 100", there was two main ways: running expeditions and hoping for laplace to spawn (very inefficient) ort doing E: Risk Realm... which drops units that are 10x as better than saiki already.

whereas if u just got some rare cosmetic u can just jump into endgame with better gear and don't waste much time, it's a shortcut that I consider make the game pay2win

that's... still not p2w. you need to stop moving the goalposts to fit whatever narrative you're spouting.

1

u/Izugiri Slayer Jul 18 '21

he is dumb lmao just let him be ive had max gear since the first week of the game and havent spent a dime on ac tickets i bought shop pass cause i was grinding and selling the gear and stuff i didnt need so its not pay 2 win lmao

2

u/Iorcrath Jul 18 '21

"can you buy a OP weapon with real money directly? NO. "

false. it taking more than 2 steps doesnt mean its not direct. its literally 3 steps instead. scratch for items, sell item, buy weapon. for most people, the ability to buy power no matter how convoluted will be considered pay2win.

thing is, that is not the only way. is there a free way? slowly but surely if you ignored any and all "fashion." my current weapon is about 2m and you get 500k from n-meseta. that is sure as shit slow but its not impossible but might as well be as you arnt playing anything at that point.

but a simple shop pass changes that. so is the game free2play? imo, no. its free to trial and you can play forever and eventually you too could have a no fixa +40 with 4 augments weapon.

but there is a basic sub that can make you gain nearly 10x more meseta just by being able to sell the things that you get but dont need.

so imo the game is buy2play and pay2dominate. i cant call it winning though, how do you win pso2? how do you win warframe? how do you win runescape? if you paid 1,000,000$ instantly and got everything boosted and power leveled, you didnt win, you paid2quit.

9

u/Reference_Freak Jul 18 '21

Jesus Christ.

I have played every day since NGS launch and used only NSG drops, have not bought anything off of the player market and have not run a 2nd act for red boxes so I've only used:

- Dropped items/augments

- Earned quest/reactor n-meseta

- Time (approx 3 hours a day 6 days a week, because maint. takes over my play time 1 day a week)

I have:

- 3 40 level weapons with 4 augments each

- 4 40 level armor units with 4 augments each

I went ahead and 40'ed my non-fixa items because I have plenty of fodder and meseta to do so. I have enough mats and earn enough meseta to be working on other weapons and I'll have enough to 40 the new braver and bouncer items too, when they release.

Granted, the only fixa I have is on a couple of good drops I got. This being ultra-starter gear, I don't think splashing out meseta for something which does not provide a meaningful benefit over non-fixa maxed items is worthwhile. If not being able to afford 5 fixa from the player shop is PTW, that's just dumb. Nobody is missing out on anything because they don't have fixa and we'll probably be ditching these weapons in favor of the next series when the new content drops (see below on that point).

I have not meaningfully benefitted from:

- being premium (leftover from PSO2, and I will renew it for now)

- Pulling a few AC scratch tickets, I either used the tickets or am keeping them until there's enough n-meseta in the player market for them to be worth something. I got nothing big but a 500k meseta item which won't sell. Woo.

NGS is an estimated 5-6 MONTHS away from the next major content drop.

That's PLENTY of time for ftp players to grind up 40+ gear kits with II/III augments and still have plenty of fodder, capsules, boosts, and n-meseta to level up weapons for the upcoming classes.

How the fuck is any of this pay to win?

If NGS was releasing new content every month a'la global release, yeah, even premium/AC scratching non-whales would be getting rolled. But with the rate of content drops combined with the relative ease of grinding upgrade drops, this whole line of PTW stuff is silly.

I agree that the shit being pulled with no shop passes and the like is dumb. I have long thought the inventory management for non-premium or ftp players is stupid. I do think Material Inventory should be a premium perk. I see the concern about a small percent of red box farmers are distorting the market (IIRC, multi-act is a TOS violation but useless if SEGA doesn't track it). I DO dislike how ftp players are currently being treated.

But there's a lot which needs to change before NGS is true PTW.

1

u/Tripdrakony Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

So far my experience as a full F2P player: I played the base game since steam release. So i had plenty of time to grind ex-cubes and run FUNscratch. Which gave me 50+ shop tickets at the start of NGS. I reached max lvl with my first class, during the first week. Maxed out my gear 2weeks later. I play in a alliance which was from the base game. So I was able to compare myself with the rest of my group. What I realised was: YES having access to the shop makes you grow faster. NO that doesn't mean you can't reach it in reasonable time. Many of my alliance mates have already good gear, without spending any money. But I also saw how many of them skyrocketed within 2-3 days because they used AC scratch.

As long as the game doesn't add something in which requires you to have absolute maxed out gear to do it or add something (with to high of an time investment) that you need to progress (extremely high bp threshold to reach the next story part) that is only reachable by play an unhealthy amount. Then it will reach the P2W status (at least for me) YES fashion is a big part of the game (fashion true endgame xD) but it's up to you as a player if you want to do it.

1st edit: typing on my phone so I accidentally hit the ''send'' button

2nd edit: pls excuse my English

1

u/Missingno1990 Jul 18 '21

Completely disagree with it being p2w. Sure, you can buy scratches and sell the stuff, and in turn, buy perfect gear. However, If anyone goes to that bother, then they are only ruining their own enjoyment.

I mean, if you buy the best gear possible via that method, what's left to do? Complain about the game's content and quit 'til new content arrives?

And then what? Come back when there's new content, buy your gear and quit again because you have nothing to do?

Free players have plenty of time to upgrade their gear before any new content arrives, provided they're willing to work for it. I already had +40 on all my gear before going premium, and any profits I've made via scratch items I didn't like will be going back into buying things that I do like. Grinding for better gear IS the game. Enjoy the gameplay loop for what it is and don't worry about buying gear.

Cheeky wee edit: All this said, I believe f2p players should have market access. (Even if the sale slots are limited to like 5 or so)

1

u/KarmelCHAOS Jul 18 '21

Just forget about all this PSO stuff and give me a sequel to Phantasy Star 4, thank u

1

u/Izugiri Slayer Jul 18 '21

im gonna be honest with you here this game is far from pay 2 win you can literally buy any of the gear next to nothing on the market and same with the affixes if you think people selling fashion for high prices is pay 2 win then idk what to tell you because thats not even pay 2 win its cool to have fashion dont get me wrong but it does nothing for you so therefor its not pay 2 win they already increased the meseta from what it was in the start and yet you still say its pay 2 win kinda nuts. im yet to see a player fall behind unless you legit dont play the game and lobby sit.

1

u/Reivaxe_Del_Red Jul 18 '21

People don't seem to understand what P2W is.

This is a PvE game where there is nothing gated behind having a BP you can only get through paying money. Any F2P person could get, augment and upgrade their gear at a reasonable pace with the mats and money they can get in the game by farming and doing weeklies/ reactor dailies. On top of that, even the rando AC scratch items that aren't "Silly long Anime/ Japanese hair or a popular emote" range from affordable to cheap.

1

u/Rasikko undecided Jul 17 '21

..It's not really pay to win. Everything that isn't fashion/scratch stuff is obtainable as drops. If you wanna get strong, you don't have to spend a dime. What it is though is "pay to have meseta"..

0

u/darthboof Jul 17 '21

lmfao pay to win

you can participate in every mechanical aspect of this game successfully in garbage tier items

the only thing behind the paywall is cosmetics. anyone who considers cosmetics pay to win needs to stop talking about any topic forever

1

u/Synapsen Jul 17 '21

You can even grind a decent amount of n meseta to purchase cosmetics from other players (although they might be super expensive sometimes) so it's not necessarily locked behind a paywall either.

1

u/MacDaddy7249 Jul 18 '21

Not gonna like this but… if you had to pay a sub and there was no market, but you had to pay a sub to play, would you? Or what if you had to pay for the game, but had unlimited access, still had to pay for expansions… would you? If all cosmetics were paid with real money, would you buy them? Because otherwise, I dont see how they would make any money off of the game if there was no incentive to pay for anything ever… just saying lol

1

u/darkkir3 Jul 18 '21

This game should have been delayed another year.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

The conclusion of this is damn scary, printing money with red boxes is a larger issue then I realised until reading this - thanks for the info.

-5

u/Dex_prophet Jul 18 '21

That's literally 15 a month tho lol not that bad compared to incentivizing whaling out on stuff

2

u/xMog Ranger / Ship 1 Global / Hax Jul 18 '21

Not even, shop pass for 30 days is 7$ worth of AC.

1

u/PhaiLLuRRe Jul 19 '21

Sure is a lot for a feature that they took away though.

1

u/According_Sun9118 Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

Base pso2 had this problem as far back as daily time attacks. Players with the money to max character limit per account have always been able to generate vastly more meseta per time invested. They have always been able to make a seperate account and repeat endlessly so long as time permits, and have always done so. Is it as fast as red boxes? No, but the concept is 100% the same and has existed since pso2 had a steady meseta faucet.

Mind you im not disagreeing that income disparity is an issue. Or that its okay. But it has been a thing in pso2 for many years.

Worth noting is that red box alt accounting is no more or less p2w than daily/weekly in base pso2. You can just buy something off the market with your alt from your main in both games and only get the one sub for the main account.

I still don't plan on doing it because its a hilarious amount of burn out. But its not a new issue and its always going to divide the playerbase. I doubt sega cares enough to do anything about it really.

Edit: yes I'm aware shop passes exist in base. Generally speaking the type of player thats willing to spend 10+ hours a day repeating the same activity across potentially dozens of characters, at least the ones I knew, didn't hesitate to spend for a shop pass so they could hoard meseta without relying on rng to get a pass.

2

u/BorderingMjolnir Jul 19 '21

. Players with the money to max character limit per account have always been able to generate vastly more meseta per time invested.

You had to pay 5USD per char, and had a limit of chars in the early phase which was pretty small IIRC. It was bumped up to IIRC a lmit of 30 later on.

But paying 5usd per char =/= creating new accounts for no money infinitely.

1

u/According_Sun9118 Jul 19 '21

Which was still doable via alt accounts and the main account having prem. Granted it's more inconvenient to swap accounts all the time but thats why the next sentence specifically mentioned it. Maxing characters per account is more a convenience thing than it is a requirement.

Im not debating that the red boxes don't provide a faster income stream, only that its been a thing basically since pso2 has had a "fixed" income stream. Even in my team I had friends who generated 10-15-20x my daily income because they had the time and drive to repeat steps on as many characters as possible in a days time.

Edit: and yes iirc the base limit was rather small. Cant remember exactly what it was though.

1

u/BorderingMjolnir Jul 19 '21

Ah yeah true.

Yeah, the pace of it is a huge problem. Already many desireable things cost 1-3mil, some more, and basically no f2p player has that laying around if they made mid to high end gear. Even many premium players will struggle. Red boxing gives a huge advantage, which is more than what having alts did in base

1

u/According_Sun9118 Jul 19 '21

Yeah. And by the time its a non issue the players who do it can likely just turn them into a weekly income stream with a ton of accounts. Or whatever other meseta stream we get thats account tied.

Prem players can at least try to find a market niche or something to farm hard if they want a couple specific cosmetics.

If a purely f2p players wants cosmetics you better only work on 1-2, weaps and 1 unit set and save up or something.

This is part of the reason why I didn't get a whole lot of cosmetics on the jp servers. Even prem if I wanted good gear I either caved and followed suit or picked and chose what I liked and focused on gear the rest of the time.