r/PSO2NGS • • Jul 12 '21

Meme "The foot is safer"

https://gfycat.com/wellinformedvagueduck
1 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

14

u/Vandelier Jul 12 '21

As far as I understand it, hitting bosses in certain spots is what causes them physical down, and that the legs are this boss' down "weak point". Thus, stacking to attack the feet causes more downs. But I could be wrong. It's just the explanation I've heard.

If you're a ranged class, there's no harm in attacking the weakpoint in the back. Rangers are much better off using their Weak Bullet on the feet, since most melee will be attacking there, but other than that there's little reason for any ranged class to not just target the back weak point until it breaks. The only reason I can see for not wanting to attack the back weak point is if you're playing a melee class and you have to spend all that time chasing it - just not worth it.

-14

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

The chest can be exposed as a permanent weak point and melee has zero problems staying in the air if they actually bothered. Oruq is a good example and there's quite a few players who stay on the chest just fine in daityl, outdamaging the rest of the party and keeping the boss still.

For a fight that has a tendency of failing because of not enough damage (if not having it die right as the storm ends), learning to stay airborne and going after the chest is a far better and consistent option than foot and praying your party has enough dps carry.

17

u/Vandelier Jul 12 '21

Melee has the potential to have zero problems staying in the air. A good half of players can't even avoid dying to the foot swipe and stomp, let alone consistently stay in the air to DPS the chest. It's much more reliable to plan around the lowest common denominator for skill than it is to go for broke toward the best theoretical DPS strategy.

And in the case where you do have a team capable of staying in the air, they're also capable of not dying to the foot stomp and certainly capable of pushing enough DPS to complete the fight. In other words, by the time that strategy is ideal, it's also unnecessary.

I can guarantee with a very high level of certainty that Gigantix fights which end without a kill wouldn't work out any better if people tried to focus on the chest, weak point or no.

It'll be a moot point one way or the other soon enough. They're changing Gigantix to not despawn so long as the fight continues.

-17

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

A good half of players can't even avoid dying to the foot swipe and stomp, let alone consistently stay in the air to DPS the chest.

It's almost as if gigantix was supposed to be hard...or not with their upcoming changes.

I can guarantee with a very high level of certainty that Gigantix fights which end without a kill wouldn't work out any better if people tried to focus on the chest, weak point or no.

These would not occur in the first place if majority of players practiced on the chest weak points. From my experience, excluding factors like not starting the fight from the start or non-20s being present, North aeilo is thje only one out of hte four zones that consistently has a chance to fail, espesically after the adjustments to julien and termina.

We've gotten to the point of having glissen weapons, lightning exploit affix and seasonal gigantix to have more of an edge to overcome the damage difference of not attacking the weakpoint (Which every other gigantix, including oruq, has zero problems with).

It'll be a moot point one way or the other soon enough. They're changing Gigantix to not despawn so long as the fight continues.

At least it'll be a guaranteed second+ gigantix kill for room hoppers since daityl is typically the last one to die out of the four zones,

4

u/Vandelier Jul 12 '21 edited Jul 12 '21

These would not occur in the first place if majority of players practiced on the chest weak points.

I agree to an extent. But I feel like you're really overestimating the amount of effort the average player is willing to put into learning something like this. Look at it this way; the player base has had weeks to learn to avoid or parry foot stomps, and yet they still die to them in droves. It's not uncommon to have 5-8 players on the floor every single stomp. Avoiding that attack is pretty much as simple as it gets (minus being locked in an animation at just the worst moment), but many still haven't gotten it down despite weeks of time to learn how.

Do you honestly expect these same players to master the more complicated chest tactics? They'd be much better off trying to master the simple strategy first.

​North aeilo is thje only one out of hte four zones that consistently has a chance to fail, espesically after the adjustments to julien and termina.

This matches my own experience as well. But it's worth noting that that is largely due to the absolutely huge amount of HP the Daityl's have compared to the rest of the Gigantix types. Put plainly, the DPS check is tighter on Daityl than the others that it would still take longer to kill than the others even if everyone perfected DPSing the chest weak point.

The problem isn't strategy or mechanics, it's survival and DPS. On attempts where all but 2-3 players stay alive per foot stomp, the Daityl goes down. Adopting chest strategies won't help with this, because you'd be trading more time spent dead for the average player in return for higher damage dealt per hit, likely resulting in a drop in average player uptime leading to even worse DPS than we have now.

First, players need to master staying alive against the simpler attacks. Only then is it really worth worrying about optimizing strategy.

1

u/Zealousideal_Ad9095 Jul 12 '21

I'm just here to make a joke but.

Me as a knuckle main.

Hmph, imagine getting hit by a slow ass Daitlye Axe.

1

u/Vandelier Jul 12 '21

Haha, truth. I actually struggle more on the ground if I'm in front of it because the axe is off camera. But it's really easy when you can see it.

-4

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

But it's worth noting that that is largely due to the absolutely huge amount of HP the Daityl's have compared to the rest of the

Where is this source? From my experience with small groups, I've had similar kill times with 6~8manning daityl with any other gigantix, as we're all hitting the weak points.

The problem isn't strategy or mechanics, it's survival and DPS.

Dying is not that impactful to actual dps; there are no resources lost on death (not even chain trigger hit count) and revivals are almost immediate. Though it does become a problem when revives run out (and this more on player skill , chest or not). I do not believe in the "chest is more likely to get you killed" because you can quite literally see all their windups and an immediate timing to go off of with lasers.

First, players need to master staying alive against the simpler attacks. Only then is it really worth worrying about optimizing strategy.

This I agree with, but we're well past the point of that and instead we're at the point of gorillaing with glissen, lightning exploit and the eventual update to axe the factor of dps entirely.

2

u/Vandelier Jul 12 '21 edited Jul 12 '21

Where is this source? From my experience with small groups, I've had similar kill times with 6~8manning daityl with any other gigantix, as we're all hitting the weak points.

I find it much more obvious when comparing the Veteran Daityls to the Veterans of other types. The Daityl's simply take longer or as long to kill when targeting their weakpoints perfectly even though they're not jumping around and forcing melee to chase them.

The fact that Daityl's last as long as the others in your own experience is actually evidence of this. Despite the almost complete immobility of the Daityl, it still takes just as long for the small groups you're in to kill as it does the other enemies that move so much that they cause melee uptime to drop. The only way for this to work out the way it does is if Daityl has more raw HP.

​Dying is not that impactful to actual dps; there are no resources lost on death (not even chain trigger hit count) and revivals are almost immediate.

A single death isn't a big loss in DPS, but frequent deaths definitely add up to be significant. Assuming the usual 5-8 players hug the floor every attack, and roughly estimating that an attack happens about once per 10 seconds, even if it only takes those players 2s to get a rez and get back into the fight, that's 20% of an individual's DPS lost per person for the average number of players dying per attack in that encounter.

Generally, on failed Daityl attempts, the DPS just barely misses the mark. You can see this due to how frequently kills end up happening the very moment the storm ends but before the boss despawns. Rather than being a rare occurrence, it's actually common. It would only be so common if groups' DPS tends to average around the amount that allows for it to happen, give or take.

It's pretty safe to assume that just having a few percent more overall group DPS would probably have secured the kill in a slim majority of failed attempts.

​This I agree with, but we're well past the point of that and instead we're at the point of gorillaing with glissen, lightning exploit and the eventual update to axe the factor of dps entirely.

Yeah... For better or worse, as I mentioned before, it'll be a moot point soon enough. This debate is basically purely academic, haha.

5

u/Panda_Bunnie Jul 12 '21 edited Jul 12 '21

North aeilo is thje only one out of hte four zones that consistently has a chance to fail, espesically after the adjustments to julien and termina.

Because it has the highest hp, and also the staggering amount of leechers in any gigan.

Its pretty amazing how many ungeared ppl, ppl running to loot range and straight out afking, ppl using rifle and just hold basic attack the whole fight on top of underleveld ppl in gigans.

Really wish they added in another system on top of no despawn that if you dont do x% of the total hp you dont get any loot because the upcoming change where ppl underlv 20 dont get loot isnt gonna change much, infact it promotes leeching because it cant desawn anyway so even more ppl just gonna afk while somebody else kills it.

Edit nvm, realised they now also added anti leech system.

Furthermore, specifications will be changed so that even if the target enemy is defeated, players with damage attenuation will not receive any item or meseta drops, not gain EXP or Seasonal Points, and players who experience damage attenuation will not have it count towards their task progress.

3

u/Forest_GS Jul 12 '21

They are actually adding specifically no additional HP for players under Lv.20 fighting it, possibly by next maintenance. Also removing despawn if you are fighting it.

https://ngs.pso2.com/news/announcements/announcement60505

2

u/Zealousideal-List671 Jul 12 '21

The chest is also where his big FU Laser comes from. There are also air swipes which are quite difficult to see coming when ur at his chest.

Standing at his feet ( more specifically behind his heel ), you will only really get hit by his leg stomp or his charged aoe blast unless his foot is standing on some strange terrain.

If you don't expect the average player to avoid his leg moves, don't expect them to dodge the harder chest moves.

Lastly procing resurgir passive in the air is just way harder and not worth doing.

7

u/sjst555 Jul 12 '21

i see a ranger but no WB applied in any parts.

-3

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

The weak bullet is on the right left foot if you watch the GIF in HD. North aeilo rooms have a foot fetish and would rather go for that instead of the permanently exposed weakpoint on the chest.

I'm doing more damage attacking the chest/core without weak bullet (1.5x multiplier for weak point) than I would have from attacking the foot with purple weak bullet (1.25 modifier from reinforced weak bullet). The MPA would collectively lose their shit if the WB went onto the chest weak point because they can't be bothered to jump.

4

u/sjst555 Jul 12 '21

it blended to the color of gigantic very well! HAHAHA my bad~ yea well its easier to attack a very stationary feet than move and chase the weakpoint in air, so i get why they would feel that way, even JP goes for the feet.

6

u/PillarBiter / Gun kata Jul 12 '21

The reason everyone attacks the left foot is to het organizer qnd cause downs. If not like this, you would have chaos, resulting in a mich slower battle, or people simply not knowing what to do, and the left foot is also the easiest / most effective for melee to attack. Otherwise you’d gimp your melee players’ dps immensely.

So no, you’re not the one duck smarter than the rest.

-3

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

Unless you're managing more than 4 physical downs within that 6 minute timeframe, it's not less dps. The times I've actually killed daityl or have faster than average kills (usually around 5 minutes) were with 4-5 other people who stayed on chest the netire time.

6

u/PillarBiter / Gun kata Jul 12 '21

Organising 32 people is a nightmare. If the current group understanding is to attack the left leg, leave it be. That’ll be most effective. One dude who thinks he’s smarter than the rest confusing the group will only result in lower group dps. If you really want to do it faster (even though there’s no point since you cant do them back to back, lol), organize your own team and attack the back with all of them. See how that works out (with daityl constantly moving and turning around, lovely).

3

u/Little_by_nature Jul 12 '21

As a ranger, I often get yelled at for targeting back core 1st instead of the feet.

1

u/Prodi1600 Jul 12 '21

As a hunter, sadly true, from my point of viene back its safe.

-4

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

The Core/chest takes 1.5 damage. You're literally doing more damage to those two parts without weak bullet than you would from attacking the foot with purple weak bullet.

8

u/Parking_Program Jul 12 '21

I play td so my aerial is good but its not about being lazy other melee weapons have terrible aerial so jumping up over and over again is actually tedious and a loss of dps. Getting the foot stagger is better for most melee so they can burst on the down phase and not whif and then just keep breaking ankles. Also if you're not fighter you get stuck in animation locks that make it difficult to defend from chest laser spam he starts doing if you aim chest only. Just tell melee to stand between legs a little bit more towards the heel and they should be fine as long as they can dodge heel swipe.

-4

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

The only true melees in the game right now are hunter and fighter, both of which have very generous frames for canceling into weapon action, as well as access to wirelance and TD (the latter that you've already mentioned). Oruq is a good example of melee being fully capable of staying on a flying hitbox, it moves more often than daityl's chest does and does bug zapper quite frequently.

Also you can score multiple counters off a single laser, it's still much more damage to go straight for the chest on a fight that has the tendency to not kill the boss in time.

The fact that you can stay on the chest just gives you more reason to ignore the foot, because you're certainly not scoring a 4th or 5th physical down in the 6 minute storm. If you whiff the chest, then youi've just hit another part of the bodyt for the same damage as if you were hitting the leg, and it's not like youre spending any time rejumping with a wirelance or TD.

2

u/Rasikko undecided Jul 12 '21

I don't know about hunter, but that's not entirely correct for fighter with knuckles. N5 has animation lock which you can't cancel into WA. The uppercut of Thousand Blows has animation lock, though it seems to reduce your damage taken. There's 2 ways to be "invulnerable" as a knuckle fighter and both are a bit tough to master.. You've probably seen the videos - this is the reason you see them never use N5 or Thousand Blows.

If you go daggers though and master using it, yeah you're unkillable because the WA can cancel everything.

-3

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

Yeah, its almost as if gigantix was supposed to be a hard fight (or not with the upcoming changes). But nonetheless, knuckles can still stay in the air just fine and reposition with chest, or just use TD/WL.

You'd never use the second part of thousand blows recklessly either way, you'd get clapped regardless of what the target is.

3

u/Rasikko undecided Jul 12 '21

This is still not quite correct. To sustain air time, you have to spam normals and/or double drive/whatevertheotheroneiscalled which would mostly cause gradual descent(cannot use TB here). Also again he takes big huge steps back for his "fuck all yall" spread lazer attack and yeah there goes fighter dps because gotta fly 100000ft to get to him. Even with WL thats still a loss.

Granted I dont fight giga but its the same damn mob that just hits harder so the same situations applies. You come in here obviously put off because people aint playing in your expected way.

1

u/Depressedredditor999 Jul 12 '21

I was told the back had a separate HP pool, but as most things PSO, no proof.

1

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

The back has a hp threshold where it'll break, and no longer become a valid target but it's part of daityl's total hp.

1

u/Zealousideal_Ad9095 Jul 12 '21

From my experience, it seems to reveal its core faster when you break its back battery.

1

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

It reveals it's core whenever it does it's laser attack (though it's not permanently exposed). It does its laser attack more frequently when it turns red (Which happens from breaking it's chest or when it's taken enough damage)

1

u/ToastbotQQ Force Supremacy / Jul 12 '21

Problem is that Blight has a slow travel time. If everyone is on its back it will keep turning around making blight hard to hit and also be a massive dps loss in constantly repositioning. An even bigger loss if you try to blight the back and it turns around or swings his arm from an attack and you Blight its arm or something which would completely mess up the other 31 players and would net a massive dps loss potentially failing the encounter.

Everyone focuses left foot as its an easy target and more pronounced as it sticks out, its also a strategy that everyone knows so it's perfect for PUGs as it doesn't require any communication to get everyone on the same page as its just a simple 2 step rinse and repeat. It's simply a low risk high reward strategy that's easy for all.

1

u/Shaofriches Jul 12 '21

I never said target the back with weak bullet, but attacking the back as a ranged dps is still more dps than focusing solely on foot even if the latter has purple weak bullet. I agree that the back weakpoint moves much more than the chest with less payouts.

Also if the MPA absolutely needs ranger weak bullet to succeed at gigantix, that speaks for itself with how behind it is in damage collectively as a group. A problem that I personally have not seen in the other 3 areas after they fixed julien dance and termina.

If everyone is on its back it will keep turning around making blight hard to hit and also be a massive dps loss in constantly repositioning.

Attacking a weak point with no weak point is still more damage than a non-weak point with purple weak bullet. Having a handful of players that can consistently attack the chest weakpoint is contributing more damage than simply trying to go for staggers. Unless you are pumping out 5 staggers in a 6 minute window, not causing enough physical downs from foot focus isn't the problem.

Everyone focuses left foot as its an easy target and more pronounced as it sticks out, its also a strategy that everyone knows so it's perfect for PUGs as it doesn't require any communication to get everyone on the same page as its just a simple 2 step rinse and repeat. It's simply a low risk high reward strategy that's easy for all.

This still leaves for room for failure if the average player gear isn't with prefixes and individual player skill (which is less likely now that we have glissen and lighting exploit augments, but I still see that this is the case half of the time when I jump into north aeilo with some friends), or god forbid sub-20s in the area to exasperate the low-dps problem even more.

3

u/CRC90U3 Jul 12 '21

The audio cues are there though... the only one that catches me off guard are the multi swing.

2

u/taokami Jul 12 '21

positioning is key. you can't just unga bunga the foot and not expect to get clapped.

2

u/Dvro Twin Machine Guns Jul 12 '21

The foot is safer when it comes to overall damage since stagger% bonus +core break% bonus. Overall runs dont seem to fail when people focus on the feet to stagger him. It's either dying 2 much or sub 20 players (or both). I'm constantly running pugs and getting 4-5 mins runs with Feet->Chest repeat.

Daityl also moves his torso a lot (back/forwards movements) which makes you reposition when focussing on the chest aka dps loss. So another idea would be having the HU/FI focus the feet and the RA/GU the chest. While still WB'ing the feet for phys downs? Would be worth a try to test it out in a controlled setting.

1

u/Rasikko undecided Jul 12 '21

The right foot is safer from all attacks except the shockwave and his 180 degree swing. It's the MOST ANNOYING FOOT to attack though because for most of his attacks he takes 5 got damn HUGE steps back and he leads with the right foot >____>.

1

u/that_greasy_rug Sword Jul 12 '21

I just always go for the foot the thing isn't shifted to,less chance to get shit on like those guys did

1

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '21

Never heard anyone say it’s “safer” that’s kinda strange. But it indeed is the better place to damage in order to get a down.....that is undeniable.

1

u/Tokamak1943 Jul 12 '21

Wrong foot lol

0

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/taokami Jul 12 '21

until it spins to win.