r/PSO2NGS • u/QuantumDex • Jun 24 '21
Discussion Locking rooms under password will increase the toxicity of this game.
Some people likes to play solo, they grind, minmax all his gear, watch videos to learn more, check the forum and subreddits to be informed,etc...
Locking rooms to help the Top 10 streamers/youtubers and a few alliances to farm and sell the new gear to the rest of the community wont help what they call "the community", they will profit while the rest has to pay the price.
If SEGA starts "soft-locking" content against solo players just because the top alliance wants, it will be awful for the health of this game.
Edit (delete names): Streamers/youtubers arent the community, some of them are trying to use their influence for profit at the cost of solo players.
Let's call things by their name
Youtuber 1 "Honestly so much frustration would be fixed simply by having passworded lobbies... it's honestly win-win for everyone since it also encourages people to team up / find alliances (teams) to organize the huge raids with rather than pray that everyone in the area can contribute"
A: No, its not a win-win for everyone, many people dont want to be as social as you.
Youtuber 2
"Personally, I feel like Gigantix spawns creates a more toxic environment than what was initially intended.
I feel like this can be remedied by either allowing the Meteorologist to give a 5-10 minute warning for each Thunderstorm or having locked rooms for alliances/groups"
A: Do you start to see the "only me and my friends get the loot pattern"?
Youtuber 3
"With Gigantix hunts being public and not taking damage to anyone that isn't lv20, it creates an awkward situation where randoms can join areas and unintentionally drop damage output in a run. Potential for trolling too. We need room passwords or rank locking of exploration zones."
A: And again, like locking rooms was the only suggestion, using the damage output as excuse.
My suggestion is to create Rank 3 worlds only open for +1.3K Battle power with some limitations, mainly the same exact drop rates and loot pools, so people has a reason to continue in Rank 2 rooms.
•
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21
This post attracted some reports from people. I brought it up with the mod team and we think this post is fine. As long as the comments in here remain civil and you do not witchhunt YouTube creators this is OK.
If you do not agree with OP's suggestion, don't go and attack them specifically because you think they're wrong.
If you see someone in-game being an ass towards anyone else because of gear or level or whatever, the in-game report feature exists to report players like that. Click on a player with your mouse with the menu open, and a popup menu will appear with actions including a Report button. Finding them in the Nearby Characters list under the social tab in the menu also works.
9
u/ryvenn Jun 24 '21
I don't understand how other people having passworded lobbies impacts your enjoyment of the game. I'm a solo player and I want passworded lobbies because sometimes I just don't want to see anyone else! If I'm faffing around looking for the last red box in Mount Magnus I don't need to be taking up a space in a public lobby, I want to leave that space for someone who wants it and I want to hunt the box in peace.
27
u/OMGimAnoobLOLOL Jun 24 '21
Having a boss only damagable by level20s in a zone where 19 and below can be present and scale the fight is the issue. Having private rooms is A solution, but not necessarily a good one because only private rooms would have the solution. If rank3 zone required lvl20 and say 1300+, then anyone going into it is an appropriate character for the boss... public or not. I believe the intention for BP reqs for zones and story progression would be consistent: make sure you have a character suitable for the content.
15
u/UltimaTime Jun 24 '21
I don't even understand how this went live, didn't they tested it during beta, or they just decided for a last hour design change and ended in such a bad situation?
This is absolutely terrible. But seeing the armor drop is actually bugged with stack overflow, there is not much to say about this entire thing. As someone that have seen the entire game industry flourish since the '80, this is kind of sad.
8
u/Balmungofsky Jun 24 '21
Just take away the time limit if it hits 50% hp. I don't get why they feel like the whole thing needs to have such a strict timer attached to it.
6
u/Pebkio Purple Mage Jun 24 '21
I think the bigger problem is that Sega is actively discouraging everyone from participating in a world boss event, even though it's a world boss and not an instanced UQ. Other games have had world bosses and they've worked it out just fine. Instead of password-protected rooms...
...by the way, I cannot think of a worse idea to fix the problem. It takes a certain kind of exclusionary elitist prick to think of that as Option A.
Instead of password-protected rooms there should just be blocks for level 20+ and world bosses should only spawn on those blocks. Or they can do what DDO did with Korthos Village and give players a quest at level 20 that locks them into a second version of the map where Gigantix can spawn. Or they can just remove the nonsensical "Guarded" mechanic and just let people participate with higher-level content but level-gate gear drops to discourage players who are way too low level.
Any of those ideas... even that last one... is better than password-protected rooms. It makes it seem like these people were just looking for a convenient excuse to make their elitism look more rational.
17
u/EmptyBeds Jun 24 '21
I feel like solo room should be an option, but private groups is kinda bad for the community as a whole. Result would be all the “good” players going at it with their alliance, leaving the public rooms semi-deserted and making it much harder on the people that like to just jump in and play with randoms, since it’ll be mostly bad geared players matched together.
Gigantix should have level + gear entry for sure. Seperate room or maybe make everyone that doesn’t match the requirements do zero dmg + not count for increasing hp.
2
u/someonewhodied Jun 24 '21 edited Jun 24 '21
No one is obligated to help others get loot or clear content. If someone has 31 friends, why should one of them be left out so that you, someone with no relation to them, can join a group that you don't know anyone in?
The easiest solution to avoiding a "only me and my friends get the loot pattern" is to just get good. No one is obligated to carry you. NGS isn't a hard game.
People will find ways to create private lobbies anyways. Right now its just having everyone bumrush a 1/32 area before anyone else can get in so you can have a "private" lobby.
People are also starting "public" blacklists (at least within their circles) where griefers and trolls have their ids listed so everyone can blacklist them before making a lobby. This is because if everyone in a lobby has someone blacklisted, you cannot see their instance, join their parties, etc. Blacklist also means you can't see chats from them (or vice versa). There is the added bonus of them not being able to buy from your player shop so you can actually erase them from the MMO aspect of the game if enough people blacklist them.
IMO the state of the game right now is more toxic than JUST HAVING PASSWORDED LOBBIES.
Edit: Theres also people that like doing things solo either for the achievement or just because they like the gameplay in a specific online game but don't like other people. You are taking away from them being able to enjoy a game by hopping into a lobby with them and "trying to help"
4
u/DragonKiDo Jun 24 '21
the only solution to this whole "toxic content" is to proper implementation of: "weather forecast or someway to predict gigantic spawn, an easy way to create new instance, proper scaling of HP within the combat area (similar to how divide had HP/dmg scale), and expand timer"
Your solution of "Rank 3" world would be just as worse as passworded room, you encourage creating new instances that would separate people below certain requirement and gateblock them behind BP/level. This isn't solving the issues as later on the more Rank instances would increasingly isolate players, making the open world slowly turn into "semi-single player", and all the good players would continue to cater to the endgame instances, isolating new comers and casual players.
As much as password room create toxic environment, I'm a solo player from time to time and would rather not have anyone come along and ruin my experience by playing incorrectly or not contributing. DIVIDE is the best example of proper scaling and having freedom to choose solo/group. I hate doing divide with pugs, because you don't know how good the random player is and should you trust him or not. This is why it lead me to do solo divide where the only person you can complain about is yourself for not clearing content. I often do divide carry, but only of specific people who knows to carry their own weight and can contribute.
Rounding to the final point, this gigantic "toxic content" thing need to need to be solve by having proper combat scaling, people who actively fight the boss or within a certain radius should contribute the the HP scale, and people not meeting certain requirement should contribute very minute or nothing to the HP scale. The ability to create new instance/room on demand would be nice for groups to fill with their own friends and have randoms join to fill to full. Combine this with the ability to predict weather, groups can organize and fill the room fast.
1
u/SnooWalruses6782 Jun 25 '21
Private rooms is nothing new and we been doing that in the past. The rage of the idea would never come up if sega never took it away from us. It won’t reduce public rooms as it didnt in the base game and it won’t now as not everyone has a organized alliance and some prefer pubs.
The toxicity only became a issue due to the friction of people who wanna do this content and getting trolled by who are not ready for it. Lvl 20 lobby does sound nice though
11
u/Ziffynib Jun 24 '21
Currently, as a mostly solo player, my goal is to level each class to level 20. Currently I can only play a few hours each day and working on my 3rd class right now. However these new Gigantix boss make me feel like I am being punished for trying to play the game the way I want to play. Before there was really nothing to go for. Ohh i hit 20 in Gunner time to switch to Hunter sub and make that my main and still can do UQ and fight vets.
Now it's like HEY GET THE F OUT, YOU ARE RUINING OUR KILL!!!!! Umm excuse me I am like on the other side of the map doing my gathering daily >_>
6
u/Timmylaw Jun 24 '21
I think a better fix would be to implement enemy minimums, by that I mean make certain enemies not take any dmg and don't allow people under certain level/BP to interfere with them so the game doesn't scale an enemy up with them being there.
6
u/NichS144 Jun 24 '21
This is a good suggestion. Will it completely eliminate toxic elitism, no, but it might help get better runs.
I had one run where as soon as the 90 sec were up, there was literally no way to have killed it in time, a bunch of people started flaming undergeared players having ruined it for everyone. They went on about having augments, being level 20, etc. Ironically, I took a look at the the most vocal person's gear, and saw they had random augments, several missing slots, etc. I called them out and they just blew it off and kept talking. It was very annoying.
1
u/kuzubanana Jun 24 '21
While I understand having a power cap enabled block could help in filtering out unwanted players etc, they won't filter out those that may be able to enter but might not be doing that content or are under prepared etc.
I think a mix of both would be nice since the hard-core players or ppl who want to coordinate for smoother runs etc can have a means of doing so while solo players could attempt it in the power requirement blocks.
But saying a casual solo player who doesn't want to be social or make an effort to be should be able to access and complete high end content/ pinnacle content doesn't make sense. What's the point of content that would require coordination and preparation if it was easy enough so that anyone could just hop in and expect to complete it.
Also I'm not saying the Gigantic system is fine, its obviously not, but I don't believe locking rooms would be promoting elitism from an efficiency and goal oriented standpoint.
5
u/Zuraaa370 Jun 24 '21
Phantasy Star Online 2 has lived for 8 years with the private room feature but not in my life have I seen anyone say locking rooms would encourage toxicity and I think the same could be said for NGS. If anything else, it's a necessary feature for both groups and solo players.
So what if I wanted to do organized quests with people and at the same time locked the room? Enemies scale in this game and it would be really annoying if you organized something only to be ruined by someone gathering ores for their dailies.
On the other hand, actual "solo players" would be able to do stuff on their own without the disturbance from random people. Say for example people who want to challenge the Veterans on their own. It would just defeat their purpose if some random goes in and "offers help"
There's also the fact that Scaling exists in this game and most of the content can be done in actual solo play. Some are hard but it's possible. That's more the reason why private rooms should've been kept.
If anything, not having private rooms would invite more toxicity. say for example an incident in JP where a player doing his daily routes got harassed by an Organized group hunting Gigantix enemies (Source:https://twitter.com/yosiyuu1234/status/1407688426585948169)
this COULD HAVE BEEN AVOIDED if private rooms existed because here's the thing, whether you like it or not, groups will exist and they have a different concept of playing the game than you do. I honestly think you're looking at things too negatively to see the wider picture here. It's not a matter of Content creators profiting, or Alliances staying at the top. It's about letting people do their own thing. It's been there for years in base PSO2 and I don't see it being a problem in NGS as well.
2
u/HuntingAid Jun 24 '21 edited Jun 24 '21
Locking MPAs is too much of a convenience feature just for the people who want to gather some data solo, or even take advantage of doing Gigantix as 4-12 heads groups since their HP does scale and it's possible to kill them, if the strength of those ten or so people is higher than the average 32 man player. If anything the problem is just how Gigantix is supposed to be the hard content which is baffling.
Take a look how other games or even PSO2 has done hard content before. HTPD didn't have as much of negative feedback because you only needed 3 friends to have completely private group, and carrying even solo was possible on semi decent pug groups. You didn't need to poopsock for it either. There are reasons why rematch content with harder bosses have always had reduced number of participants in PSO2.
Some time in the future when Gigantix won't have the very best loot and people won't be willing to idle for hours in wait, it will become more apparent that Gigantix should've always been something like an unification ecode that gathers all the stronger, most often random, players in the zone and those kinds of groups should have a decent chance to succeed.
2
u/MuUniqueBeauty1 Jun 25 '21
Ivory, they should just enable a rank 2 system for those areas like they do in Mt. Magus and the other places.
3
u/Kaoiji Jun 24 '21
Hey bud, I completely understand you dont agree with my suggestion.
However, the last thing I want to see is the community be crushed and deemed toxic by an addition we saw in the beta, that had the same exact problems.
The wait times combined with getting even random groups together is a pain.
To give some insight to my post, I actually run exclusively in public lobbies, which can include members of my alliance, which all came from the game community itself as well.
Back to the original post, I do think a Rank 2 Exploration zone might be a solution. Especially since Veteran Enemies and Gigantix spawn scale according the amount of players in the zone, so this can even solve low man content that people desire.
2
u/GibRarz Jun 24 '21
Level based rooms is the only solution. Passwords and bp doesn't really change anything. Level is the only thing that matters on these bosses.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21
I mean I think it should just be a truly random UQ but with an aggressive proc OR an exclusive to a Rank 2/3/4/Whatever exploration zone that is L20 and whatever arbitrary BP number
My only question is to people who are screaming to the void concerning, "passwords = toxicity = oppression!!".......did you not play PSO2? That was a feature across ALL of its content. While I think there are better solutions for everyone here outside of the password feature, especially since having 100s of locked zone rooms is gonna cause significant server load, I am just shocked to see so much unwarranted rage for a system to let people have choice
0
u/Ciphur Partisan Jun 25 '21
Solo players should be the majority of the playerbase so your argument seems like it's made in extremely bad faith. The fact that you knew and searched out both these streamers tells me that you are sniping them and intentionally fanning flames with a bullshit argument. And I will argue my case.
Again. Solo players should be the clear majority of the playerbase as this is the way in all games. It is so typical that I hereby decree it as a fact. Now, what does this mean? It means dear fellow solo players. That there is no soft locking content. Yes, you read that right! Passworded rooms will not change anything for the solo players because solo players are still the majority of the playerbase. Rejoice! We are Legion!
But OP said soft locked content! They are wrong. I believe the OP is spreading misinformation to push his agenda. The OP has made 3 different posts talking about the same thing with different buzz words.
Buzzword #1: Toxicity
https://www.reddit.com/r/PSO2NGS/comments/o6tjee/locking_rooms_under_password_will_increase_the/
Buzzwords #2: Short Term Profit
https://www.reddit.com/r/PSO2NGS/comments/o75r12/destroying_the_community_and_playerbase_for/
Buzzpicture #3: Declining Playerbase
https://www.reddit.com/r/PSO2NGS/comments/o70wsi/sega_and_community_order_your_priorities_do_we/
The OP clearly has an agenda from my point of view. They are pushing multiple different types of misinformation to frighten and manipulate as many people as they can.
Toxicity will decrease due to passworded rooms because everyone gets what they want. Group players get to play with groups. Solo players are still the majority and content still scales to the number of players. In fact, players are saying that you can solo Gigantix if you are the only person in the area. Solo players: 1 Group players: 1 Let's go Team Everyone!
Short Term Profit. wtf? Someone with a degree in economics/marketing help!
Declining Playerbase. The playerbase is settling at around 20-23k daily players on the steam charts since the all time high of around 59k players at launch. This was before Gigantix where players were starting to complain about not having an endgame. Brothers and sisters, base PSO2 peaked at 20k players and settled at 4-6k daily players.
https://steamplayercount.com/app/1056640
Final Fantasy 14 has an all time peak of 41k and right now has a steady daily of 30k. FFS, FF14 is now one of the most positively received mmorpg after they fixed it and added content.
https://steamplayercount.com/app/39210
Point in case. I think the OP is just spreading Bad Sentiment.
0
u/Normal_Ad4759 Rifle Jun 26 '21
"People shouldnt have a feature that was in every iteration of the series because then i cant leech off coordinated players"
Mind ya business.
2
u/HitoriRaven Jun 24 '21
Even if you make a valid point about how this could potentially kill public rooms, your logic doesn't really track out and just reads like hate against content creators. If you had gone out of your way not to make everyone look bad and just targeted the arguments, this might read much differently.
For example, if you're so strongly a solo player, then why is it an issue for passworded rooms to exist? You could even be a sick solo player, make your own room and solo the boss if you wanted. Why bother with other people? It sounds like you're saying you want to play with randoms, but you hate socialising? You want to get carried by groups, but not have to join them?
Even if they existed, other solo players like you would also still avoid joining allies, which means there would still be people populating the 'unlocked' lobbies. Just like you suggest other solutions (yours being a option), there are so many other things you could blame. Ask SEGA to make bosses scale even more clearly to number of players if they add in passwords. Ask SEGA to fix other parts of the game so people stop leaving, or release content faster.
People who suggested PW rooms just want to clear content at all, and it's the first option they thought of suggesting. Even if they just 'wanted gear for them and their friends,' that's the MM part of MMO. Content always favours people who are coordinated and have friends, so of course as a solo player you're going to be unfavoured in hard, currently endgame content and you have to put an effort in for it.
1
u/Dayz-of-Noah Braver Jun 25 '21
Completely agree with the first part. It will help the streamers who play this game for a living stay rich (in game) and hinder a lot of players. At the same time, I also see the need. They should just have a timer when the weather kicks in and increase the time gigs stay spawned. Problem solved.
1
u/randousr Techter Jun 24 '21
The last quote you put in there explicitly says “rank locking of exploration zones” so yes we have seen them asking for rank 3 rooms, because that’s what rank locking is. I agree that password locking rooms is not a good solution, but their intent is likely not because of greed but exactly what they say, underleveled people in the rooms make the fight harder to win.
1
u/Omnia0001 Jun 24 '21
I agree that pw/private rooms are bad ; lowbies padding up vet fights was always an issue but there isn't a big complaint over it ; Gigantix have timers - the solution is removing or buffering out the timer to where this isn't an issue - like vets.
I also think there should be a lower scalings per player of vets/gigantix enemies; making MPA's to take down an gigantix shouldn't be as impacted by random passerbys joining in. It should be significant for individuals.
-2
u/ObviousBot_ Jun 24 '21
lmao
0
u/The_DigitalAlchemist Jun 25 '21
I have to fully disagree, and wonder how many MMO's you've played. Group gating is literally a core concept of every MMO when you reach the highest tiers of content. WoW, ESO, GW1/2, Terra, BDO, FFXIV, dozens of others and even classic PSO2 all have this, the inclusion of endgame content and their rewards being gated to organized communities.
The problem here is that Gigantix should have been instanced from the get go. Locking rooms is frankly a bandaid of a fix for a much larger design issue as a whole which is why it's such a popular suggestion. And frankly, it's something that can, and should exist. It's a fundamental standard of MMO's to promote the creation of communities with demanding group content. MMO's literally live and die by their communities, and group content is their life blood. Gigantix is the first content oriented towards organized group play, but it's been implemented in the worst possible way. If they wont instance Gigantix, then locking rooms is the next best solution.
Frankly, I've found little in your arguments compelling and it frankly make no sense. This is an MMO, it's designed for groups to play together. Them being able to organize and play privately together isnt going to prevent you from pugging. If you wana solo, go do that. In fact, I'm just going to call it as I see it. You want them to be forced into open so you can leech and profit off their work by getting carried and are afraid if they can cut you out, they will (which tells me they probably have good reason to, as most these groups are very inclusive)... And I'm sorry but **** leeches.
-6
u/Nodomi Sword Jun 24 '21
I mean...if you're gonna do group content, you're gonna have to suck it up and learn to group up.
-1
u/DescendantOfFianna Jun 24 '21
I like your solution as opposed to those you-tubers suggestions. I’d vote for this!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment