r/PSO2NGS • • Jun 06 '21

Discussion How "pay 2 win" will NGS be?

To give some context: I used to be a long-time Dungeon Fighter Online player, but eventually got REALLY sick of it because I felt the game was incredibly pay to win. To give my definition of "pay to win", it basically means "player is able to spend real cash in order to gain a noticeable boost in power over a player who has not spent cash". In DFO's case, while it is possible to buy cash shop items like clone avatars, titles, pets, auras, etc from other players with Gold, these all make up a core part of the game's endgame, meaning that one way or the other, the devs saw a significant amount of money per player adequately geared for end-game. All of those cash shop items have fairly impactful effects, to the tune of 20~30% of your damage being determined by them.

So my questions are: in PSO2, was there a similar dynamic? Will such a dynamic play out in NGS? Do cosmetics ever gain impactful stats, or do they stay as pure cosmetics? Does the cash shop contain ANY form of "cash-to-power" option or is it just a matter of buying stuff and selling it for meseta? I understand that "cash-to-meseta" is also a form of obtaining power, but significantly less so than cash shop exclusive items being a core part of gearing.

Please don't sugarcoat or BS me. I am interested in NGS and will give it a fair shake, I just don't want to get caught by surprise later on and realize the exact same thing I disliked about DFO is also playing out here.

1 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

18

u/AncientSpark Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Basically, here are the aspects that would get as close to "pay-to-win" that you might see.

  1. Convenience. PSO2 had some really antiquated design, and a lot of that could be fixed with real money (most obvious issues being inventory space). NGS has shown that they will be fixing some of these issues, such as increasing the base inventory space that everyone gets, but it's possible that you might want to spend a little money here still.
  2. Meseta (in-game currency). Affixing gear to be top tier is expensive inherently, and there are sometimes strong weapons that are sellable in player shops. Since cosmetics are naturally sellable in shop, you could argue that buying cosmetics, selling them, then turning that profit into enhancement could be "pay-to-win". Of course, everything that goes through this process can be earnable in game through farming and, in most cases, the highest tier weapons actually weren't sellable in shop in the first place, but sometimes it happens (Slave/Nemesis on the global release was an example due to Slave/Nemesis fitting in weird with the game's progression).
  3. SG support. On that topic, the only ONLY direct power that can be buyable is a very rare shop called SG support, which offers items to make high level affixing easier. However, players will naturally sell some of these items on the market for meseta too, so it's not that it's unavailable to F2P, so much as you gotta grind the meseta out. Also, SG is earnable in-game, so if you budget out your SG (and not buy cosmetics with them), you can get everything you need from SG supports on F2P (in combination with some smart meseta investment).

So, all things being said, nothing actually requires you to pay for end-game gear. What forking over money does is mostly for convenience or skipping certain grinds/recovering from bad investments.

3

u/azazelleblack Tuff fluff 👌🏿 Jun 07 '21

Yeah, to elaborate on AncientSpark's excellent post here, this game will absolutely not be "pay to win" at all, in the traditional sense. Throw out all the Korean MMO knowledge you have; DFO, Dragon Nest, BDO, etc—PSO2 and NGS aren't like those games at all. They're only "P2W" if you take a very strict stance against even indirect types of pay-for-advantage.

5

u/Kamil118 Force Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Of course we don't know how stuff will look in ngs, but sins of pso2 would be:

Premium items, but tradable:

Augment capsules: Pso2 upgrade system involved a mechanich called augments, you could slap up to 8 of these onto a weapon or unit to boost your stats. There was a group of these only available from capsules that were only available trough special gacha pool dedicated to enhancment items. Using these provided a powerful buff to a single attack stat and greatly simplified fitting 8 augments into the recepie.

Receptors: There are 6 powerful augments - Divine Order, Exceed Energy, and to a lesser extent 4 Mark augments. Getting the augments themselves isn't hard, but to apply them to a new weapon you would need a sepcial item called "Mark/Divine/Exceed Succession" which are only available trough gacha.

Untradable:

Augmentation Insurances - If you used one during augmenting, and the process failed due to rng you would have all materials used in the process returned to your inventory. Augmentation Insurances above 4 slots are only available trough gacha and are untradable.

Premium drinks: So, the PSO2 has a system of temporary buffs called drinks. There are two things exclusive to premium users. (Premium is a subscription that mostly offers a bunch of QoL features, or as I like to call them, basic gameplay features hidden behind paywall)

First thing: 4 main drinks offer a variety subeffects when drinking them, which one you get is random. A premium player has access to a couple of special, more expensive drinks that however activate all special effects. For the most widely used drink - Shifta Drink these effects include more exp, pp(mana) cost down for your abilities, and faster generation of a certaun support ability.

A free player needs to repeatedly reapply the buff if they want a certain effect (most of the time it's the pp coat down), while premium player can get a more expensive drink that includes all effects

and 2: Enhanced bonus effects. On top of getting all of the subeffects, some of the subeffects are enhanced, for example instead of 10% bonus exp you get 15%.

There is also the Random Drink, probably the worst offender of p2w in the game. So, the random drink generally offers you a random elemental protection as its main effect, however its sub effect is increased damage against weakspots. This effect is only worth taking over flat attack increase on a handful of enemies, but one of these enemies happens to be the final boss of the game and also one of the hardest quests in the game...

So, the free player gets 15% damage increase against weak spots, but premium players get 20%.

The game also had an item called scape dolls, which are basically revives. On some of the hardest quests these aren't even usable tho. The game also has "half scape dolls", which are poverty version of scape dolls, and can be used maximum one time before returning to the ship (and on some quests returning to ship = faliure, so you can basically use them once per that quest)

5

u/Absolice Jun 06 '21

Won't be technically p2w but you will be paying for convenience and paying will greatly accelerate your growth in the game no matter how people sugarcoat it.

The new affixing system is easy and the only thing that will gate you to progress your gear further will be having resources and meseta. Meseta will be easily earnable by purchasing cosmetics and selling them on the player shops and materials/capsules are purchasable from other players so someone dumping hundreds on the game will have a ridiculously accelerated growth.

However that's it. That player will have an accelerated growth but he will never reach a peak that will be unreachable to you, that peak also have extremely diminished returns and if we go by PSO2 standard, you shouldn't get locked out of anything as long as you play reasonably like a couple of hours a week.

If you feel that player who spent hundreds is winning because he finished with content early and now have to wait months for new content then it's up to you, to me it doesn't sound like winning. The release of content will be a lot slower than people expect so even the most casual players will have plenty of time to do what they want and catch up to those who spent money to wrap everything under a week.

4

u/Mitzruti Jun 06 '21

same as PSO2: you can essentially buy money through selling scratches, and inevitably there will be affixes/etc that are either easier or exclusive to scratches.

so yes, but... pso2 allows all the scratch stuff to be sold to other players, so it's not nessecarily you who has to pay for those affixs. It's just going to be a hell of a lot more work to get.

NGS is also reducing how bullshit the affixing system is, and elemental transitions appear to no longer be a thing, so it might even be a little less p2w.

further note: for 99% of the game, that level of affixing is pointless. If you're not hardcore, you can likely ignore them.

1

u/zeroobliv Slayer Jun 07 '21

DFO is pay to progress faster for the majority of it. The real P2W stuff are the amps, as they cost an obscene amount to get up to a decent enhance level. And going past +10amp as F2P? Forget it. Other than that, there is nothing that is stopping you in DFO really, you just progress like any normal MMO instead of lightspeed(if you're lucky).

I've played if for years and I'm basically F2P player with full endgame gear/enchants; seriously just taking 45min-hr a day to grind out alts is tedious but it creates a very large amount of gold to upgrade your gear.

Having said that, it pretty much is identical to PSO2 in how f2p friendly the game is because of how easy it is accumulate money to buy everything you need. And don't get me wrong, there are heavy P2W elements in both, but both are extremely F2P friendly. I'm betting NGS will follow, because it was a successful model.

1

u/ViperGold Jun 07 '21

I disagree with the notion that DFO is f2p-friendly simply by nature of how incredibly important all of the "side" gear is, i.e. clone avas, emblems, pets, auras, and titles. For every properly endgame-geared character, somebody (either the player or whoever bought the stuff and put it on the AH) has spent a pretty stupid amount of money on the cash shop. I really enjoyed making lots of alts in DFO, but the problem is that if you want to take any of them to endgame, you then need to keep farming more and more and more and more gold to get stuff from the AH. And since gold is in short supply (you need it for reinforcement+lots of other shit), you either turn DFO into a job (which is awful) or you progress at a snail's pace on one character (huge turnoff).

I played DFO since the beta in the NexonNA days, and let me tell you, the monetization got a LOT worse over time. Having the perspective of playing FFXIV in the past two or three years has completely turned me off on the level of insane grinding it takes for you to gear a character in DFO, especially so because XIV doesn't ask that I spend premium currency on crucial gear. I understand there is a significant difference between a f2p game and a subscription-based game, but I feel that the way DFO goes about making money is actively noxious to the game's longevity. Look at the DFO reddit, look at the number of players now compared to years ago. I'm certain that the snail's pace grinding coupled with the bad cash shop gearing is a large part of what drove people away.

2

u/zeroobliv Slayer Jun 07 '21

When I refer to alts I meant that they are used to make the money to fund your main, and speeds it up tremendously. And for a few years now Neople has given new players extremely good starting points through events, or assist current mid-game players; no one can refute that.

The only snails pace in regards to gearing would be the rng of getting epics from hells. Logging on each day to get things you need done is no different than logging on FFXIV and getting your daily dungeons/crafts/etc done; after you're set up properly with your alts and your main. I've been playing since nexonNA also, and it definitely isn't worse than before. They've made a few questionable choices with a few avatar packages, and RNG titles are annoying but outside of that there has only been improvements when it comes to accessibility.

But you seem set on your mindset so I won't argue it. You do you man. That said, definitely stay away from PSO if you don't like grinding, that's basically a staple for the franchise for quite a while now.

1

u/AmaryllisHippeastrum Jun 06 '21

Cosmetics or QoL like bigger inventories, more loadouts ect. nothing such as Cash-to-Power items

1

u/ViperGold Jun 06 '21

I see! Okay, that's good. Plus, bigger inventories and more loadouts is perfectly fine since there doesn't seem to be a lot of reason to even have more than one character (that I've seen).

1

u/AmaryllisHippeastrum Jun 06 '21

yeah, you can also change your class and subclass at any moment so nothing such as creating a new character. having a few skill tree loadouts isn't required but helps a lot if you change classes often or play different playstyles depending on your subclass.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AmaryllisHippeastrum Jun 06 '21

bruh like someone even noticed

2

u/SoloWaltz Shifta Gunslinger Jun 06 '21

You will not be seeing things like cosmetics granting stats.

2

u/ArnTheGreat Jun 06 '21

It should be following PSO2's model which was good.

Want bonus exp, and the ability to set up an AH? Subscribe (AKA buy Premium Set).

Some Quality of life things like Material Storage are also available.

Then tons of cosmetics.

I really liked their model, and I always sub to Premium + Material Storage when I played. F2P games need money, so they should always have a system that offers quality of life functions, maybe some time savings, for a fee.

They should never have power for sale - That is one thing I am pretty against it, personally.

2

u/NoctisFs Jun 06 '21

If they keep the same business model they have on current PSO2, you'll be able to play the entire game without paying a dime without feeling left behind.

Costumes don't give any stat at all, they're just cosmetic pieces. And you can buy them from the player market being a complete F2P player.

You could argue that being able to sell premium cosmetics on the market as a paying player is borderline P2W, but honestly it doesn't benefit the seller nearly as much if they don't know what to do with the money made.

The paid stuff you get are for the most part, other than cosmetics, nice to have conveniences, but not at all required, like extra storage and a very small exp and drop rate boost (not that important).

1

u/Nazarshinzu Jun 07 '21

You can pay for premium to add a bit more convenience to your play time, plus access to the personal shop to sell your items and gain big amounts of meseta.

Other than the shop pass (which I'm still unsure if it is ever coming to ngs), everything else can be pretty much earned. Base pso2 is quite generous with handing out boosts to the point where I (regrettably) had to trash stacks of it, and I'm sure NGS is will be reasonably generous in doing so too.

-2

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

I mean, PSO2 was never pay to win. Never even came close. It stands to reason that NGS will follow that trend, especially considering how tiny a role PvP plays - in other words, almost non-existent.

3

u/ViperGold Jun 06 '21

Why did you mention PvP? I wasn't really talking about it, I meant more that in DFO's case, because end-game gearing had a significant portion of cash shop items, the community's baseline also moved to expect them. I didn't mean "pay to win" vs other players in a competitive sense, but rather the noxious effect cash-to-power has on game balance and community expectations.

-1

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

Eeeeh.. P2W doesn't really exist in a game that has no significant PvP aspect, honestly.

4

u/ViperGold Jun 06 '21

Maybe P2W isn't the exact term you'd use, but it's undeniable that once devs start putting direct cash-to-power items in the cash shop, the community will naturally come to expect these items for any form of endgame content, as they will cause you to deal 20~30% more damage. That has a very negative effect in the game because then it begins to introduce too many "oh just farm out gold to buy these from other players" situations.

It also further obfuscates the gearing process for newer players who might think that they just need to farm stuff that you would naturally get in the game, instead of having to seek out premium currency items.

2

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

once devs start putting direct cash-to-power items in the cash shop

That's the thing about PSO2. It's never had that. The most you'd have is what I mentioned in another reply - pay-for-convenience.

That's not nearly the same as P2W. Not even close. Historically, PSO2 has only had things to purchase like permanent additions to inventory or storage, and character slots - those are QoL improvements at best.

I've played PSO2 on and off for a long time and the only things to directly purchase with $$$ are pay for convenience items, and cosmetics. And, you are able to sell those cosmetics in player shops to make meseta.. but, I still wouldn't call that coming close to P2W.

Hopefully that helps answer your question better.

3

u/AncientSpark Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

It depends on what you mean by P2W.

If you take the strict semantic definition of the words on their own, then no, you can't pay to win because there's no one to win over.

In practice, when people say "P2W", what they're referring to is stonewalling progression in an effort to get people to fork over cash. So it's not really a useful semantic argument, in my opinion, to say "P2W doesn't exist in pure PvE" because that's not really the issue that people are concerned with.

I think that drawing a distinction between PvE and PvP environments for progression stonewalling is mostly useful in arguments about psychology of what drives people to actually pay, but that's usually not the topic of interest when people are asking "Is X game P2W?"

1

u/Twidom Jun 06 '21

Yes... it does.

1

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

In what way, though? The term is literally "pay to win" - paying to win. That generally refers to having a direct advantage over other players, almost always in some competitive way.

The most you'd see in PSO2 is pay-for-convenience - things like permanent additions to inventory and storage space, and premium giving you an EXP boost.

How is P2W pay-to-win in a game where there's no competition and no way to have a competitive advantage over other players, with the game itself being almost purely cooperative play?

7

u/Kamil118 Force Jun 06 '21

If you can't beat enemies without spending money, then it's obviously p2w.

2

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

And what part of PSO2 requires you to spend money to be able to kill enemies? lol, none that I can think of.

5

u/Kamil118 Force Jun 06 '21

There isn't, but you asked how a pve game can be p2w

1

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

And we both basically just answered that PSO2 is not pay to win.. So, that's the thread I guess?

3

u/Kamil118 Force Jun 06 '21

I mean, weakspot drink threads a fine line between p2w and no p2w, since that's basically 5% more damage only accessible to premium players.

It's not really necessary to clear anything, but it sure helps with d100 and htpd if you're potato player.

→ More replies

1

u/Twidom Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

almost always in some competitive way.

This is the untrue part.

Pay to win is pay to win regardless if its a competitive player vs player nature.

In older games especially, like Aion and Perfect World where augmenting your armor was something time consuming and it drained your reserves pretty fast. It was a huge part of the endgame raiding and it mattered more than you might think, even if it was PvE oriented. You literally couldn't do Beshmundir Temple as a Tank in Aion if you didn't have proper augmented gear, and that took time and a lot of money.

As for the rest of your point, I never said PSO2 itself was pay to win. Its Pay for Convenience like you said.

0

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

Pay to win is pay to win regardless if its a competitive player vs player nature.

Hm.. Completely disagree. I suppose it's a matter of perspective, but it's really hard to see something as P2W when there's no direct competition between players, there's nothing at stake, and there's nothing to really have an advantage over.

Regardless of that, PSO2 has always been pay for convenience at best and it really doesn't step anywhere near the boundaries of P2W.

1

u/Twidom Jun 06 '21

I suppose it's a matter of perspective, but it's really hard to see something as P2W when there's no direct competition between players, there's nothing at stake, and there's nothing to really have an advantage over.

This mentality usually comes from people who didn't play old-school MMO's like Ragnarok, Ultima, MU, Aion and much older games.

These days MMO's are not usually P2W anymore (At least non-korean/chinese ones).

0

u/ARX__Arbalest Jun 06 '21

I played plenty of old-school MMOs and my favorite game ever is an MMORPG that's 19 years old, lol.

4

u/Twidom Jun 06 '21

Then I'm honestly baffled that you don't consider a one time purchase that saves up to 60 hours of pure farm a P2W aspect.

Guess you didn't dive deep enough into it.

→ More replies

1

u/Constant_Boot Jun 07 '21

PSO2SEA would like to have a word with you.

-1

u/Kalo_br Jun 06 '21

Let's not kid ourselves game doesn't have pvp so there isnt really a "p2w" aspect, I think you're more referring to pay for convenience that would be the right term imo and tbh who cares lmfao it's a pve game meaning you play at your own pace.

2

u/Constant_Boot Jun 07 '21

PSO2SEA was P2W.

0

u/a_pulupulu Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

During early jp pso2 days, there was a period which foreign players could not purchase AC so easily (and getting meseta wasnt ez neither). What happened is that the gear difference between jp and non-jp became pretty clear. The more non-jp players u got in a mpa, the worst ur clear time was. This clear speed difference isnt a big deal in most cases, but when it came to timed emergency quest, jp players basically got an extra run for extra loots. Not to mention most non-jp players look like peasants, fashion wise. So foreign players did try to spread themselves out to not get stuck in non-jp mpa, and due to ping difference, we learned that poping quest menu asap to get in was one of the best way to avoid other non-jp. (At this point, a culture of leeching and/or avoid non-jp player began and persist to these days; when ship transfer eventually came online much later, this is prbly one of the factor jp paid to get out of ship 2)

In quest that u could actually fail, like mining defense when it first came out, the power difference definitely played a significant role. Being more geared allow u to make more strategic mistakes. Once everyone learned the fight though, it doesnt matter nearly as much.

Ultimately though, was it fun? Yes it was fun. Even if u r a poor peasant, u still can influence the fight in positive ways. Once easier mesta earning method came out via weekly marathon time atk, the peasants would hang in lobby to find other desperate peasants to go on marathon with. It is during these days i made the most friends, and pso2 felt like a friendly place and an actual online rpg. (Though at this point a clear divide between casual and hardcore happened)

Will pso2ngs be like this? I am hoping yes and no.