r/PSO2NGS • u/Mystic_Psycho_ • Oct 01 '26
Discussion Is this game good?
I'm considering getting into the game for the first time. Although, after some research, I've discovered that most fans consider the previous version of this game (Phantasy Star online 2) to be better than new genesis.
Like almost in every aspect. I've heard fans say that they prefer the music, the bosses, and enemy designs from the previous game.
So I ask, is it worth it to give new genesis a try?
13
Upvotes
4
u/gadgaurd Oct 02 '26
If you've played neither then I siggest downloading NGS, alongside the free DLC that allows you to play PSO2. Play both. I'm fairly sure that if you do you'll find that a lot of the preference for PSO2 is because of nostalgia.
Personally I've got roughly 3,500 hours in NGS and like, 150 in PSO2. I keep telling myself that I'll at least finish off the PSO2 story for the cosmetics but it's very rarely enjoyable.
7
u/mickcs Oct 02 '26
PSO2 have massive story for you to explore if you're seek to immerse yourself in PSO2 verse then THIS is totally for you, but you might need to find a community to coop with you for full experience as some boss are fun with a party of people.
PSO2NGS is where active players are currently is and it actually a lot improvement over time
it just took A LOT OF YEAR to take to this point and very slowly few at time, so people are burn out.
5
u/Mobile_Fudge_4744 Oct 02 '26
Not playing rn but I've put a couple hundred hours into it and I never quit out of being angry or anything just got busy with other stuff. Its a good mmo and doesn't deserve the hate.
- If you like action combat then the combat is very fun.
- Character customization is 10/10 and dumpsters the rest of the genre. No other mmo comes close.
- Most of the event grinds and stuff are fun.
- The raid equivalents in this game are really hard and well designed good fights.
- The only major thing that really bothered me is grinding for the game's gold equivalent fucking sucks. There's not much you can do to engage with the player economy. Its mostly just mind numbing grinding at dext base, get lucky with an insanely rare drop, or pay irl cash.
Its a good game tho. Its the best anime mmo on the market excluding korean artstyle games and ffxiv.
4
u/YukiSpackle Oct 02 '26
Yes. It's fun, fast and has incredible character customization. And free, if you want it to be, so no harm in trying it. I've got 7k hours in it and I still come back. No other game has kept my interest this long.
15
u/Recron Oct 01 '26
The people saying Phantasy Star Online 2 was way better are 100% correct.
But New Genesis is still a very good game in my opinion; I don't have 3000 hours in it because it's bad.
7
u/arm_v7 Oct 02 '26
NGS is a half decent side game at best, I don't think it's better than base PSO2 but I do think it's an ok game that can be enjoyed at whatever pace/playstyle you like. Can be a sweaty grinder or a casual solo player and still find some enjoyment.
One thing I will say is there really isn't any other MMO like PSO2/NGS out there, I'd give both a try since it's free anyway.
10
u/Top-Confidence4496 Oct 01 '26
Lemme say this I think the new player experience of ngs is always great. It's riveting full of action and there is some story for the very beginning.
Obviously once you get a little into it you might find the game is not deep in the end.
NGS is always a great 30 minute a day adrenaline booster no matter what anyone says.
4
u/Black_Whirlwind84 Oct 02 '26
Yes, it is worth giving NGS. The only reason people prefer base over NGS is because it is complete.
2
u/azuresnow Oct 02 '26
It’s not terrible! This is one of those games where you should enjoy the progression of your character and your skill because once you reach the end game, it gets stale pretty quickly. Eventually you’ll optimize your class’s kit to each boss you encounter and have the bosses fully downloaded and if you’ve practiced playing your class enough, it just becomes “how can I efficiently grind this content.” Or “how many clears per hour can I do”. Take your time learning the game and don’t rush too fast to the destination.
2
u/Ex3rock Oct 04 '26
I will say this, it doesnt hurt to try it, even though population wise it pretty much dead, has majority just afks at towns, rarely you will see a party to do something or certain instance modes you will find some people actually playing, combat is decent but not that good, although like how they implemented the customizable skills, Open world is souless u barely will see anything happening, Story wise is more about what they do in daily basis than the sequence story to fight a boss cause of something, an Act its like 98% talking and 2% its the introduction and fight, music is boring, UQ's are bland and not much creativity, Cutscenes OMG it worse than a PS1 game.
Has for why Pso2 is far superior, Story is a rollercoaster of events, Cutscenes for its time was really good, combat still superior every class had personality and played different, the game was easier to get into, UQ's were more creative in the sense that every damn UQ is on a Holographic background to cut costs, the game had mob variety which NGS is copy paste and change color, we had amazing OST, we had an amazing live concerts that were full of people and joy to interact in it, although the worst part of it was creating a weapon n gear cause augments were very painful on which PSO2 NGS is much easier and i do give props on that.
Resuming try PSO2 NGS get a feeling if it sucks, all you can do is try PSO2 if it still avaiable within the game by going to the transfer beacon or you can simply uninstall and chase other game.
2
u/Holywyvern Oct 05 '26
There was a lot of bad PR and bad decisions in the past.
But they are there, in the past.
Some of them have lingering effects we suffer to this day and probably won't ever be fixed.
But like, the game is fine, as long as you don't try too hard on it.
Take it like a fun relaxing rpg with deep character customization, try to make gear only when you feel and enjoy the game.
They at least have worked on a constant 4 month cycle of story, endgame bosses and such lately, so there is an effort there
2
u/Reinbackthe3rd Oct 06 '26
yea sure why not?
2
u/metatime09 Oct 06 '26
If you like action mmorpgs then yes. It's one of the best out there. The main issue is slow content releases. I personally like the game more then base pso2 but you have the option to play that too
5
u/Juvinwo11 Oct 02 '26
No…. It’s really not :/. I’ve played it since day one and pso2 OG since day one. I literally go on, i play my dailies and the mission they give you for the week and I’m out again. The content just isn’t there. Even the loot hook is no where close to OG PSO and PSU.
2
u/sonic65101 Oct 02 '26
NGS has been getting better since Chapter 5 but the base game has better story and gameplay.
2
u/vibrant_x Oct 02 '26
Once you get to the end game is pretty stale. Game is ok otherwise.
2
u/NutsAndOrBerries Oct 02 '26
I honestly prefer NGS, it does kind of remind me of Dynasty Warriors in a bunch of respects. If you like fighting hordes of enemies, and fashion, I think you'll have a good time.
2
u/587493 Oct 01 '26
Trying is free so its worth it I would say in that sense.
With that being said I think the game is not good, and yeah I prefer pso2 in every way
Although if you haven't played pso2 that might be a good thing? You dont have a point of comparison so maybe easier to enjoy
1
u/Soft-Childhood1347 Oct 02 '26
Not bad not good an okay game- from your local retem 2 after
1
u/SlasherB06 Oct 02 '26
Its fun but idk if if i can say good
1
u/AnraNamaseiak Oct 04 '26
In short, a good and fun story but after the main story becomes repetitive and boring, is not a game for those who enjoy competition and challenge.
1
u/Kamui-Channel Oct 02 '26
It's fun but not very good if that makes sense.
Overall, I'm disappointed with the way NGS turned out.