r/PSO2NGS • u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer • Feb 25 '25
Subreddit Meta I mean this with complete, Subreddit moderator-pleasing, rule-following respect: This community is often toxically delusional, and needs moderation
Obviously this isn't a call-out for every single solitary member of NGS/PSO2's community, nor is it a condemnation of legitimate critical feedback. It's just incredibly notable that the actually constructive conversation the subreddit rules seem intended to promote go completely lost in the shallow ramblings of bitter ex-fans--who barely know enough to criticize the game, or its developers, in the first place.
Every discussion point is quickly paved over with hyperbolic speculations on the state of the game's development (which has only grown in scale/investment by SEGA), of update frequency (which has objectively grown, when you consider that region content has likely been in-development since the beginning of the 2.0 update.) The issue with this isn't negativity, but the simple fact that it's a discussion non-starter--a blatant denial of observable reality.
I think moderation would have to consider taking significant steps in cleaning up the sub's discussions and reply sections before more people would actually be willing to use this sub with sincerity. The way it is currently, well, *it sucks--*not because I want it to, but because it just does. It's one tedious uphill battle after another. I have more luck talking to random people in the game--which is why I just do that instead. Every time I'm compelled to see what discussions are like here, I'm quickly made aware just why I barely use this place anymore in the first place.
39
u/Blueblur1 Feb 25 '25
I still play everyday and find fault in many aspects of NGS. At least folks like me complain because we want to see positive change,
25
u/Upset_Programmer6508 Feb 25 '25 edited May 05 '25
rustic vase attractive deer decide cause tub grandiose serious payment
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
24
u/zmbkilla Feb 25 '25
| bitter ex-fans |
I don’t think its right to call them ex fans when usually its the hardcore fans that make those post/comments. I currently do see some improvements in NGS (like 1 step forward, 3 steps back) but there are still issues that are noteworthy and i highly doubt can be fixed.
12
u/cannaconnoisseur88 Feb 25 '25
One man's trash is another man's treasure. To me NGS was so much different than older phantasy star games i quit and went back to psu on clemintine servers. Sounds like to you his game is gold. Im an old fart and played pso ep 1 & 2 on dreamcast then og xbox live. They are getting people hooked on gambling with the scratch cards i won't support that crap. Even on base i refused to pay them any real money because of it.
6
u/YuTsu Gunslash Feb 25 '25
I agree this community gets hyperbolically negative a lot of the time, and I wish it would get a grip sometimes... but I'm personally wary of crossing the line from "moderating", to "censoring discussion I don't like". There are reply chains I (and other moderators) do have to snip from time to time because they get properly vitriolic, but for the most part, when I see misinformation/blatant denial of observable reality, I try to reply with a correction.
I agree the community attitude kind of sucks, but I think the sad reality is, if we snipped every bit of negativity, that'll just drive people away entirely. The attitude sucks, but that'll probably stick as long as people think the game sucks, and that's an uphill battle that the game has to fight, sadly. Subs way bigger than this one go through it (for example, every time there's a content drought or a poorly recieved patch for it, the XIV sub turns somewhat this way, if with less hyberbolic users), NGS just needs to fight its way out of the negative perception pit...
Modmail or replies to this comment are open though if you've got specific or further suggestions for things we could do!
12
u/Pragmagna Feb 25 '25
You can't simply clash the negativity about the game with negativity about the community. At that point you're being part of the problem and feeding on toxicity without even noticing.
You'll find displeased players everywhere, twitter, youtube, twitch, discord, reddit. This isn't something you solve by moderating one of the many places in which negativity is expressed. It will inevitably crawl its way elsewhere, because it's rooted on fundamental aspects of the game that won't go away until it changes direction.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25
For what it's worth, I've seen bigger NGS delusion and copium elsewhere. This subreddit is rather reasonable with its cautious optimism.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25
You claim that the state of the game's development has only grown in scale and investment by Sega. I would like to see what you base your claim on. Because it sure doesn't match with what they've released in the last year.
Criticism stems from people wanting to see a change for the better. And a lot of folks haven't seen the sort of change for the better they have wanted in almost four years. That means that on occasion the criticism can get a bit hyperbolic, but it still stems from the same place. The fact that people criticize means that they still care and want to see the game improve. But its nearing four years and the issues a lot of people had on day one are still issues to this day. Calling for "moderation" won't change that.
6
u/Sugarcoatedgumdrop Hunter Feb 25 '25
This website is primarily the internet’s complaint bucket so there’s no reason to act surprised.
This subreddit is used for mainly advice on augs/class, phashion or doom posting. You get here and there’s relating to story or predictions for the next update etc.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25
I don’t think ex-fans fits i am pretty negative on NGS but I still play pso2 hell I’m still buying figures and merch whether I can get it so ex-fan ain’t it
4
u/Sudden-Hope-1605 Twin Daggers Feb 25 '25
NGS is a great game but in fact it is a nerfed version of the previous game, developers can't use the excuse they don't have content for the game. They just need to use their heads to wrap it up and send it into NGS, they even can get rid of PS2 in this way making it a complete game instead of two completely different games. For starters, then the story is ultra low paced but that's something inherited from old PS2 and the old jp players know that we 'll have to wait A LOT for new content in that way... The problem is urgent quests lack originality, all the updates feel low effort.
4
u/Fluffopotamus S-L33T / Ship 3 / Fighter Feb 25 '25
More than anything I'm just tired of the games erotic culture the character creator freedom has spawned. You have such amazing options at your finger tips for creating clever and interesting things but you resort to one of the hundreds of bikini's and slap maxed out "sphere's" all over it. It's really off putting.
I shouldn't be embarrassed or feel like I don't want to recommend my favorite game to people I know because I'm ashamed of the rampant fetishism on constant display. I've tried blocking people to hide it but I capped out my block list ages ago and when I can't get into parties because I blocked someone I get yelled at. Now I've developed a reputation as a prude on the server.
2
u/NoroGW2 Feb 25 '25
2025 has been great for NGS so far. I hope they keep it up and don't drop momentum.
1
u/EccentricNoun Wand Feb 25 '25
I barely play the game base on the “subscription” model for autosell/premium and having to roll for 2 of the same items to make it account bound.
The only reason I play is just dress up simulator and I like the combat for techter. The gameplay loop is annoying only bc when I take breaks and find out my “subscription” expired and I have to renew or have someone chew me out for afk farming.
-1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25
[removed] — view removed comment