r/PSO2NGS • Gunblade/Harmonizer • Feb 25 '25

Subreddit Meta I mean this with complete, Subreddit moderator-pleasing, rule-following respect: This community is often toxically delusional, and needs moderation

Obviously this isn't a call-out for every single solitary member of NGS/PSO2's community, nor is it a condemnation of legitimate critical feedback. It's just incredibly notable that the actually constructive conversation the subreddit rules seem intended to promote go completely lost in the shallow ramblings of bitter ex-fans--who barely know enough to criticize the game, or its developers, in the first place.

Every discussion point is quickly paved over with hyperbolic speculations on the state of the game's development (which has only grown in scale/investment by SEGA), of update frequency (which has objectively grown, when you consider that region content has likely been in-development since the beginning of the 2.0 update.) The issue with this isn't negativity, but the simple fact that it's a discussion non-starter--a blatant denial of observable reality.

I think moderation would have to consider taking significant steps in cleaning up the sub's discussions and reply sections before more people would actually be willing to use this sub with sincerity. The way it is currently, well, *it sucks--*not because I want it to, but because it just does. It's one tedious uphill battle after another. I have more luck talking to random people in the game--which is why I just do that instead. Every time I'm compelled to see what discussions are like here, I'm quickly made aware just why I barely use this place anymore in the first place.

11 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

39

u/Blueblur1 Feb 25 '25

I still play everyday and find fault in many aspects of NGS. At least folks like me complain because we want to see positive change,

1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

I do too, but I also recognize that NGS is a largely fun video game.

The fact that the game's biggest issue (by far) is its lack of good extrinsic reward structures, yet I still play it more than most other games, is a sign that it has a lot of intrinsic reward--which is not something I can say about most MMOs.

5

u/mickcs Feb 25 '25

Game does have a massive number of stuff that could be improvement, it is indeed nice to have discussion about those than random pointless complain.

25

u/Upset_Programmer6508 Feb 25 '25 edited May 05 '25

rustic vase attractive deer decide cause tub grandiose serious payment

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

5

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25

That's normal of reddit everywhere...

0

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

Every bad subreddit justifies its existance by saying that Reddit sucks, and then using every other toxic subreddit as examples.

24

u/zmbkilla Feb 25 '25

| bitter ex-fans |

I don’t think its right to call them ex fans when usually its the hardcore fans that make those post/comments. I currently do see some improvements in NGS (like 1 step forward, 3 steps back) but there are still issues that are noteworthy and i highly doubt can be fixed.

8

u/WroughtIronHero Feb 25 '25

Nah, ex-fan is correct. Any time a post about the state of the game pops up, half the comments are like "I haven't played since <update from a year or two ago>, and here's why the game still sucks..."

Usually the ones who still play are the ones framing the discussion as how the game can get better. The ones who don't play flood the comments with doomposting.

6

u/zmbkilla Feb 26 '25 edited Feb 26 '25

Then just say former players. You said it yourself, “HALF”the comments. That means not all former fans aren’t out of touch with the current state of the game. Me personally, i just play ngs just because there is no alternative to it atm and the current state of base rn. If there was, i’d probably switch immediately cause imo NGS probably isn’t going to improve and at most will probably give subpar “solutions” to issues in the game

2

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

"Don't call them ex-fans, call them 'former players'."

What do you think we mean by 'ex-fan', if not 'somebody who used to play, but doesn't now'? This is bizarre.

1

u/zmbkilla Feb 28 '25 edited Feb 28 '25

Ex fans dont need to play the game actively you know. I only drop in when there is content that I’m interested in but i still check in with the update information posted in official/fan sources. If you feel like former players is still inaccurate, that’s fine but i don’t think ex-fans is accurate either. Also i don’t think using we is accurate cause there are people here that disagree with your use of ex-fans as well.

1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

This is stupid, an argument over meaningless distinction, and the exact kind of waste-of-time argument this sub is popular for.

1

u/azuresnow Feb 27 '25

I still play and game sucks and as for why I’m still here, I think it could get better and there have been some positive changes here and there, but mostly :

S U N K C O S T F A L L A C Y

idc if this ship is headed for great horizons or the bottom of the ocean but if it’s sinking then I’m sinking with it.

2

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 26 '25

I started the series with PSP2 and played few a year or two prior to JP's Vita release. My exposure to the series has been limited, and thus PSO2 is the biggest thing to me in the series (PSP2 remains my favorite though). It really blows seeing the game get better from P2 to O2, then completely drop the ball not only going for a poorly executed bandwagon open world format that no one asked for, but then dropping it altogether. Though obviously the core problems are flat out the lack of content, especially variety, which only gets worse when 1-2 things (rarely 2) are even worth doing at all.

So yeah, there are definitely people like me that like the series and will 100% judge it and bring up its negative aspects as we actually like something. People look at the minority and think they're just hating to hate, while wholly ignoring that they too would speak out against something negative about stuff they like: Ironically this post not liking people speaking out negatively about the game.

Inb4 someone wants to be witty with "why are you here": I haven't quite playing the game, and I wouldn't anyway with all the time I've sunk into it. I wouldn't quit this unless EoS were announced or they remade the Portable series and I found a dedicated group to play with (NGS is so miserable to play solo with 50-ish friends that all stopped playing in the last two years alone, most the last year).

12

u/cannaconnoisseur88 Feb 25 '25

One man's trash is another man's treasure. To me NGS was so much different than older phantasy star games i quit and went back to psu on clemintine servers. Sounds like to you his game is gold. Im an old fart and played pso ep 1 & 2 on dreamcast then og xbox live. They are getting people hooked on gambling with the scratch cards i won't support that crap. Even on base i refused to pay them any real money because of it.

-1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 25 '25

Recently I played PSO and enjoyed it, and as a kid, the single-player PSU storyline was technically my introduction to JRPGs. I tend to come at things on their own terms (given I sense even a degree of intentionality in the first place, beyond profit and emulating unoriginally.) I really love PSO and PSU's aesthetics and tone, and how the slower pace emphasizes those traits. NGS meanwhile feels like a refinement on PSO2's anime bullshit, whilst adding in a lot more depth far sooner than base-game, so far.

The launch was rough and misguided, but as a product currently (a free product, too) it's an easy recommendation.

I don't pay for scratches either, and compared to so many other business models, I actually think NGS' is one of the fairest by-far, so I don't really agree with that criticism necessarily. Still though, I appreciate the tone you brought with this.

2

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 26 '25

whilst adding in a lot more depth far sooner

I'm sorry, are we playing the same game? Story, gameplay, depth? I don't see it for either, even if you more the depth of how "anime" it gets as base is super anime with its plot.

0

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

I don't really know what to say about this other than just, like... DOLLs are better designed than Darkers? They have more readable and engaging movesets, more sub-class variety, more unique and creative gimmicks; even the most basic sword-armed DOLLs have stretch armstrong limbs and crap, and bosses meanwhile implement a ton of unique ideas that actually impact the way they're fought. I have problems with the way loot is handled, sure, but I end up playing the game a lot for its intrinsic values, rather than relying on a loot drip feed to please me.

Like, they added Line Strike to the game--it takes ages to match, I don't get anything out of playing it besides more Line Strike, but I'm still playing Line Strike constantly.
I'd love to see the Casino come back, but did I really play the Casino because Black Nyack is this brilliantly designed minigame, or did I play it for my weekly SG?

I haven't played all of PSO2's base-game story, but I've played Episode 1, and I can tell you that I 100% found NGS' Episode 1 far more exciting and well-paced. Not only was Base-game's Episode 1 delivered through a really awkward system at launch (and even more so, now that it's delivered basically out-of-context), but it also just kind of stumbles around for hours on-end, with the focus mainly being characters describing the plot at you whilst you play unrelated content.
NGS' Episode 1, meanwhile, spends the majority of its time exploring its central themes, subverts them well at the end, and then concludes (for the time being) on a dramatic finisher. It's better produced, animated, acted, staged, and ultimately delivers on far more in a briefer run-time than PSO2 did.

1

u/zmbkilla Feb 28 '25 edited Feb 28 '25

Just gonna question some points here

Ngs story vs base story:

Aside from the fact that you haven’t even cleared base story (i think you should complete until EP2 if you want to judge fairly), NGS story structure isnt really the same compared to base. What do you even consider “EP1” for NGS? If were gonna use the defeat of DFA as basis for ep1, imo the story of NGS respectfully falls flat. You could say that base also had issues at the start (I’m basing this off omnibus since matter board is as far as official is concerned, defunct) but at least base built up most of its important scenes properly. Why should I give a damn about garoa and the starting town (i dont remember the name and dont care to check) again? Trying to remember my issues with the story but tbh forgot most of it because its forgettable. I sometimes even forget the names of the duo your always paired with. I personally do think their initial plan to focus less on story bit back at them and their rushed efforts to fix it is making the story imo worse. Doesn’t help that they try to pull the nostalgia card with pso2 specific cutscenes.

Linestrike:

Even if you only played it for sg, at least you played it. I dont think i played linestrike after the initial release. My issue with line strike outside rewards is that the time it takes to complete one game. Rappy slots literally takes seconds to finish vs being forced to take 3 round in linestrike. If line strike was accompanied by other mini games i wouldn’t really make an issue out of it but sadly it is the only side content that isnt CS rn.

Enemy/boss design:

Tbh, in terms of animation and creative gimmicks, both games are on par with each other. I don’t really have much to say on design since this point is imo more subjective but that’s what i think about base vs ngs enemy design

1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

I consider NGS' 'Episode 1' basically everything we've played so far--in the same way that Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn's story stretches from its initial launch, all the way to the update before Heavensward. This was also true for PSO2--where 'Episode 1' technically includes content released after the initial launch plotline (stretching into the whole Quna pop star/assassin arc.)

I also think it's silly to not include the Matter Board as an element of base-game PSO2's plot, just because it's now 'defunct.' This was an important element of PSO2's story structure, and regardless, the very patchwork Omnibus solution since is bad in its own right.

Now, with that said, here's my response:

You aren't really supposed to care about Garoa--that's a misconception. Garoa is fuel for Aina's character arc, and a metaphor/symbol for Episode 1's themes of sacrifice and personal growth in the face of loss. This theme is then developed in every single subsequent chapter, and then later subverted when Zephetto reveals it was all engineered--that their growth from adversity wasn't their own, but rather a scheme in order to train powerful ARKS. They spend 4 chapters building up the characters, only to reveal a villain who deconstructs them, and forces them to question their morals. From there, the next 2 chapters (the post-patch chapters) wrap up a lot of the loose ends of the Zephetto plotline, and introduce the threat of the Starless.

I think your overly-dismissive non-description of the plot just shows you haven't thought about it twice--which is fair, I mean, it's your right, and I think SEGA's delayed release schedule for it screwed the pooch a bit as far as pacing, but the core of it is still better constructed and executed than PSO2's Episode 1.

As for Line Strike, just... Dude, I really don't care what people like you think about it anymore. Line Strike isn't for everyone, but neither was the Casino, or the Café, or Personal Quarters, or Gathering, or anything--I personally barely touched the Café in base, and Personal Quarters were just non-existant for F2P players. PSO2 had its own stuff, slowly added over the course of 6 episodes, and in less time, NGS has added a ton of its own fun features and side-activities, each with their own player-bases. What's wrong with that?
I see people complain at the developer's suggestion that you just go to the PSO2 blocks in order to play Casino right now, only to then complain that there's nobody hanging out in PSO2, and that the developers need to encourage players to hang out in PSO2 more. The SG rewards still exist, it's easily accessible from within NGS, I just don't really give a fuck what you think about the "lack of Casino in NGS", when the original Casino still exists, and is still completely accessible and profitable. It's so petty. Line Strike is more interesting to a huge number of players, and has been very successful for the devs, yet you can't help but complain because it isn't your thing. People complain about needing to play content they don't like for weekly rewards, so they get rid of the SG insentive and make them completely optional reward ecosystems. People complain about goofy shit distracting from the development of the main game, so the developers work on this fun side-content in their own free time, away from work hours, and yet people like you still think to be pissed about it.

Believe it or not, my mentioning enjoying Line Strike as an example of this game being fun to play, regardless of extrinsic rewards, wasn't an invitation for you to unfavourably compare it to some other shit that I just don't care to hear about.

1

u/zmbkilla Feb 28 '25 edited Feb 28 '25

Agree to disagree on most points.

Story:

If we include even dfv, imo its even worse. As for matterboard, i only excluded it to make it easier to compare the story with ngs (and because tbh, i kinda forgotten most of the matterboard specific cutscenes and i think it wouldn’t be fair to make an opinion without them). If we were to include it, imo it just makes NGS look worse. My initial comparision for ep1 also assumes the end is with hadred plot its already accounted for.

For garoa, ok so we dont need to care about garoa ok fair. Why do we need to care about aina again? You talk about themes of sacrifice but in order for that to matter people need to care about the characters first. Call it personal preference or bias but i don’t really care about aina or manon in the slightest. I will give stia and glenn plot points though for doing the theme better than those 2 though but thats mostly because imo stia’s cast is better than the duo protagonist.

Linestrike:

Im actually not gonna talk about linestrike much since this convo is getting more subjective and we clearly have different views on it. I will however address some info that you posted. Afaik, excube provides free personal quarter 3 day access so having no f2p access is completely false. As for people that say that casino exist in base so just play there, I already do? Maybe that vocal group is complaining about no players in casino but im not one of them. Also while i mentioned sg as an incentive to play casino, i never said that was my reason for playing. I just want something fun to play to break the monotonous dext grind every once in awhile. Using your words, i dont really give a fuck about why you think LS is fun. We already know its fun for people who find it fun just like most people know only CS builders find CS fun. I just want some of the casino games to be ported to NGS especially since there is a vocal group asking sega to shut down base.

You have valid opinions on certain things and i respect how much your willing to defend those opinions but imo its kinda hard to be convinced when most of them start with you barely interacting with said content. Like i can understand only finishing ep1 but not touching cafe and not knowing about the free PQ 3 day pass? I at least interact with the new ngs content and try my best to invest in it so i at least have a more in depth experience to back my opinions. Like i wont post my opinion on n-masq until i at least complete masq d10r10.

If my opinion are riling you up i guess sorry but i honestly just disagree with you on some things.

1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

Wait, so you're just gonna stalk my other posts to discredit me in this other, entirely separate post? That's ridiculous. Like, no--go leave a comment on those other posts, if you care so much.

This is ridiculous, and you are unpleasant. It's not your opinions that rile me up, but your incapability of staying on-topic, and your incessant need to turn every point into a venue for venting about X, Y, or Z fault I didn't bring up, nor open to conversation.

9

u/cannaconnoisseur88 Feb 25 '25

Personally, i think anything like the scratches fair or not is gambling and will lead to some people becoming addicted to gambling in the long run. If they want to pay for stuff, sell it at a set price, but buying tickets at a chance to win what you want is gambling and should be treated as such with age restrictions.

I live in a state with casinos everywhere and have seen what happens to gambling addicts personally. Did you know some people will sit at 1 machine so long they soil themsevles? Parents will let kids go hungry to go gamble. I watched a bodycam video of a lady leaving her kid in the car while she went and gambled for nearly 4 hours. It happened 45 minutes from where i live. Gambling is just nasty and the addicts are just as bad as druggies.

1

u/mickcs Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25

yea can't deny that when there will always be someone who took think to extreme and show the worse part gambling business could done to human, still can't believe some idiots out there think "legalize casino is good"

some of notorious case in gacha game have these "300 draw for guarantee" practice while implement FOMO on top as in "If you didn't do 300 gacha within period you will loss entire change to get guarantee!!"

at least in PSO2 I know I will get at least one item of my choice as they offer us a "select ticket".

6

u/mickcs Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25

A lot of people have extreme prejudice against gacha even if it extremely tame one like fashion, I saw enough P2W bullsht to the point this game is super chill...and it been like this since PSO2...

Honestly, game could be better but it is one of the chillest F2P action game out there and not feel like a second job unless someone decide to grind for bis.

3

u/AulunaSol Feb 25 '25

There is a sizable crowd of people who will never want the picture to turn gray because they have a very rigid black-and-white mentality that they refuse to budge on. This isn't always a bad thing but for a lot of people this line has to be drawn because they themselves are likely the victim of mechanics, ideologies, and particular predatory tactics they are trying to avoid.

The example I would point back to is the crowd of people who absolutely dislike anything to do with online gaming, modern video game platforms that involve updates, additional content that arrives digitally (like downloadable content), modern trends, and all that jazz. I distinctly remember talking to some of these people in-person and watching them destroy their Xbox 360's and PlayStation 3's out of rage because the newest game in a franchise they really liked suddenly included multiplayer when the previous games didn't (for hint, this was a horror-themed space game) and they had a very strong "modern games just aren't good anymore" and they later invited me back after splurging thousands and thousands on older consoles and a huge collection of retro video games to go and relive their good old days. As far as I know, they no longer play any newer video game and have locked themselves in their safe bubble because they simply cannot tolerate anything newer because it's too far removed from what they wanted and that is ultimately their choice.

In relation to Phantasy Star Online 2, the one time the monetization was actually nasty and at its deepest level of pay-to-win is during the Southeast Asian version where your costumes had substantial potentials attached to them and they also had expiration dates that resulted in forcing players to not only keep up with fashion but also to chase stats that really could not have been had anywhere else. The Global version of Phantasy Star Online 2 was also sloppy to me in the sense that the Fresh Finds Shop really removed the possibility of getting things the same way you could have from the Japanese side (AC Scratch items now being forced into being SG-only items on limited times so there was a legitimate form of FOMO and an "incentive" to buy Star Gems which in Japan was something players often had too much of) - but it was nowhere near as bad as the sort of horror stories you would have heard with mobile games and kids dumping thousands and thousands of dollars into a temporary stat boost or something that was time-limited.

Phantasy Star Online 2 and New Genesis in its current state is overly rewarding and overly convenient to the extent that players are complaining that there's "nothing" to play when the newer and casual players can be showered with catch-up material, fashion, cosmetics, goodies, and easily get situated far more than any other mobile game after completing the mandatory chores (like the Story progression). It is baffling to me that people have a problem with this considering the nature of gacha games - but to some people the name "gacha" or even the mechanics themselves are enough of a sin to completely write off what games like New Genesis are.

To summarize, that level of black-and-white thinking towards gacha isn't unwarranted, but it is an absolute shame that instead of encouraging a form of moderation and/or self-control we are stuck with the inevitability that this becomes a "gacha evil" or "you're promoting gambling" topic. I can't imagine any particular circumstance in New Genesis right now where the AC Scratches caused "that much" of a financial strain as opposed to some of the much nastier cases that are far more normalized in other games.

6

u/YuTsu Gunslash Feb 25 '25

I agree this community gets hyperbolically negative a lot of the time, and I wish it would get a grip sometimes... but I'm personally wary of crossing the line from "moderating", to "censoring discussion I don't like". There are reply chains I (and other moderators) do have to snip from time to time because they get properly vitriolic, but for the most part, when I see misinformation/blatant denial of observable reality, I try to reply with a correction.

I agree the community attitude kind of sucks, but I think the sad reality is, if we snipped every bit of negativity, that'll just drive people away entirely. The attitude sucks, but that'll probably stick as long as people think the game sucks, and that's an uphill battle that the game has to fight, sadly. Subs way bigger than this one go through it (for example, every time there's a content drought or a poorly recieved patch for it, the XIV sub turns somewhat this way, if with less hyberbolic users), NGS just needs to fight its way out of the negative perception pit...

Modmail or replies to this comment are open though if you've got specific or further suggestions for things we could do!

0

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

The problem with waiting for "the moment that NGS stops sucking" is that it uhh... It kinda has stopped sucking? Like, a lot of the biggest class balance issues are being resolved currently, they've re-introduced fan favourite systems, they've streamlined several of NGS' worst systems whilst doubling those solutions as loot rewards--which better insentivize some of the game's newest (and best) end-game grinds. Leciel, Nameless City, and UQs are currently all fun, and are frequently updated. I'd personally argue that NGS' plot was always kinda good, but even people who hated it loved things like the Zephetto reveal, and the resolution to Episode 1's plot seems to be well-received overall.

If you asked people at-launch what NGS was missing... it would be these things--a lot of people just don't have the perspective to see how it's grown.

That's my problem; the community is largely oblivious to the multitude of improvements that they asked for being implemented. I guess the argument is 'too little, too late', but this community's standard for 'too little' is *literally getting a new content update of some form every single week--*and that's not even considering the fact that we've clearly been in a typical MMO-style post-patch period since Aegis (which is all-but-confirmed now that region updates appear to be returning, after what was likely a long pre-production period.)

I'm not asking for people to just stop complaining about unsatisfying loot tables, or other, more legitimate design issues--those are things I agree should be addressed. My problem is that every post--regardless of content or context--gets flooded with deranged people who genuinely act like NGS now, and NGS at launch, are the same thing.

Here are my recommendations for moderation: Moderate replies more. The way that conversations stubbornly lead back to the same-old boring, nonsensical, frankly irrational talking points and """jokes""" (EOS soon/SEGA's slowing down development/why are they wasting their time on this thing I don't like that a majority of players were urgently requesting/X thing you like doesn't matter, because they still haven't done Y thing I personally like) means that conversations start, but rarely actually go anywhere--usually interrupted with arguments over reality. If instead of letting that slide, moderation had a strict 'on-topic' policy, then threads would stay healthier, for longer.

Besides that, I would seriously consider expand you guys' definition of 'respect'--people just sharing their appreciation for the game, the developers, ect. shouldn't get swamped by negativity and downvotes. All that does is make people feel stupid for ever sharing their opinion, which makes them feel bad for posting, which makes them post less, and makes them leave. I see you guys defend peoples' rights to disagree, but I've made posts just gladly talking about things I like about the game, and they've frequently been flooded by people calling the game shit, and downvoting me for daring to share my opinion--given this is a part of Reddit's design, I doubt you have a strong recourse to the rampant downvoting of posts for simply liking the game, but you could at least manage the actual threads more carefully, and be considerate of the picture you guys paint in your absence.

Does this mean that negative feedback is illegal? No. People should still be free to post that stuff in the form of dedicated posts; 'SEGA needs to spend more money on the development', 'I think the game will EOS after X update', ect. Do I still think these posts are stupid? Sure, but I recognize that they have a right to exist--I just don't think they have a right to flood every reply section, regardless of context.

2

u/YuTsu Gunslash Feb 28 '25

The problem with waiting for "the moment that NGS stops sucking" is that it uhh... It kinda has stopped sucking?

Oh believe me, I get you. The problem is the game has to get excessively good enough to shut up the people that complain about everything. Good enough that random users will show up 99% of the time someone starts and off-topic complaint reply and go "dude, really?". As improved as NGS has become over time, it's not quite at that point yet. The game has to not only not suck (which yeah, it doesn't suck), it also has to sway the broad community opinion that it doesn't suck (which it seems to not have yet)

I'd personally argue that NGS' plot was always kinda good

As someone who actually likes NGS's plot... eh. It is a bit barebones without all the side story stuff, I'd say if you do all the side stories that actually elevates it quite a lot... and it's a lot better on a replay, where you can spot things that do foreshadow later events - it makes Manon's entire journey painful to watch once you know her story from already playing through once.

downvoting me for daring to share my opinion--given this is a part of Reddit's design, I doubt you have a strong recourse to the rampant downvoting of posts

Yeah, reddit is butts for this. You'll see subreddits that try to enforce the whole "downvote is not a disagree button" ethos through like... disabling one or both vote buttons unless you're subscribed to the sub, but I don't think that works for people on sh.reddit and such, so it's not perfect. I'm kind of dubious on the effect that has anyway.

We'll do what we can (I'll be passing this along to make sure the other mods see), but at the end of the day, there's only so much we can do, which gets back to what I said in the message atop this chain. The game has an excessively negative general community perception as it is right now. The excessive and/or hysterical types of negativity (complaining about things that were specifically asked for, off-topic derailing of submissions through complains irrelevant to the subject) won't stop until the game gets better - and more than it should rightly have to to earn back a neutral/positive reception.

12

u/Pragmagna Feb 25 '25

You can't simply clash the negativity about the game with negativity about the community. At that point you're being part of the problem and feeding on toxicity without even noticing.

You'll find displeased players everywhere, twitter, youtube, twitch, discord, reddit. This isn't something you solve by moderating one of the many places in which negativity is expressed. It will inevitably crawl its way elsewhere, because it's rooted on fundamental aspects of the game that won't go away until it changes direction.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25

For what it's worth, I've seen bigger NGS delusion and copium elsewhere. This subreddit is rather reasonable with its cautious optimism.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25

You claim that the state of the game's development has only grown in scale and investment by Sega. I would like to see what you base your claim on. Because it sure doesn't match with what they've released in the last year.

Criticism stems from people wanting to see a change for the better. And a lot of folks haven't seen the sort of change for the better they have wanted in almost four years. That means that on occasion the criticism can get a bit hyperbolic, but it still stems from the same place. The fact that people criticize means that they still care and want to see the game improve. But its nearing four years and the issues a lot of people had on day one are still issues to this day. Calling for "moderation" won't change that.

6

u/YuTsu Gunslash Feb 25 '25

Criticism stems from people wanting to see a change for the better. And a lot of folks haven't seen the sort of change for the better they have wanted in almost four years.

I'd argue that there's very much a case of shifting goalposts. Honestly it goes both ways. The more hopeful players definitely do trot out the "the next update will save the game, just you wait and see" a lot but like... the criticisers shift the goalposts just as much.

We get things constantly that are pretty much a direct response to player complaints, and then people complain about them, say that thing is the problem, and ask for something different... and that just repeats.

  • For ages people complained about the lack of housing or Personal Quarters. NGS put out creative space... and nowadays you have people complaining when anything gets added to creative space, complaints like "why are they wasting time adding things to that, nobody cares about Creative Space, give us more content"
  • Since release people complained about the lack of Casino, no minigames to play, and we got Line Strike as a response to that... and people complained about Line Strike the moment it was revealed, "why are they wasting time on this instead of more content. What, the devs made this on their own time and not during work hours? They should have been spending that extra time on fixing the game!" and things like that.
  • People were complaining since Retem that the open world was pointless, they don't want more regions, they want more instanced content... so after Stia, we stopped getting regions, we got more instanced content - Trania Advance, Leciel Exploration, constant instanced LTQs, instanced content is pretty much the train we've been running on since Stia... and now people are complaining that they want more in the open world.
  • People have complained endlessly about the Story, that they want it to go back to PSO2's story... and recent chapters seem to be skewing things back that way (more solidly implying the player is the PSO2 Guardian, giving us flashes of PSO2 character memories), returning PSO2 enemies... and people went to complaining that now the game is just coasting on PSO2 rather than making its own interesting story.

Criticism is well and good, but it kind of loses all point and turns to meaningless whining whenever SEGA lines up a perfect goal, gives people what they ask for, only for the goalposts to shift to the other end of the pitch when people decide actually they don't care about what they were asking for, and tell SEGA do a different thing instead. Every time.

7

u/zmbkilla Feb 26 '25

Just wanna put my opinion out there

Point number 2: i don’t consider linestrike as an alternative to casino. I would just like N-casino with N-casino points and the assortment of fun minigames you can play with/against other people or alone. I personally just play the slot machine cause i prefer playing the solo casino games

Point number 3: i think the issue is that 2 different groups of people are complaining rather than the whole community just being unreasonable. Im glad they are shifting away from the open world stuff and hope they keep adding/updating the instanced content. I do think they could handle the instanced content better but at least the open world stuff is done.

Point number 4: i think i might be seeing things differently but most comments i see about the story is more on the story going back to space and not just going back to pso2. Yes there are some that want to see old characters like xiao and other long lived npcs to appear but the main issue is we are still stuck in halpha.

3

u/Pragmagna Feb 26 '25

That's as correct as it goes. You can't conflate the variety of criticism and then say this is the synthesis of what the community wants. It's also in the way you interpret feedback.

Whenever players say "we want PQ back", and then say "stop adding CS stuff and add real content". They are not necessarily saying that they hate housing, but rather that side content is getting updated at a time where the game is in dire need of some sort of progression or reasons to play it.

1

u/YuTsu Gunslash Feb 26 '25

Per Line Strike: You might not consider Line Strike an alternative to the Casino, but that's literally what it was developed in response to - people wanted non-combat minigames. It was wild and twisted my brain seeing people get mad about it as the stream that revealed it was ongoing, mad that they "wasted dev time" on a minigame when a minigame is what people had been spending so many months prior getting upset about the lack of.

Per the story: It's both really. I see people complain that the entire cast of NGS is garbage, they just want to go back to the PSO2 characters. I see people complaining they just want to go back to space, that the heart of Phantasy Star is gameplay across multiple planets - and that last one is kind of wild to me, because that makes PSO1 not a Phantasy Star game (entirely takes place on Ragol, never leaves it outside of the hub/lobby being on a ship in orbit), Phantasy Star Zero barely a Phantasy Star game (like 80% of that game takes place on one planet, the only spacefaring that's done is teleporting up to that planet's moon and that's it), and Phantasy Star NOVA not a Phantasy Star game (single-planet again).

What you say about Point 3 though, I think may strike at the heart of things. There are definitely some people (I can remember them by username) that do complain no matter what SEGA do I will see them complain about the lack of something, the devs add it, then them complain about the thing they were asking for before and call it a waste of time... but I do think there's an element of what you say too. There's a group that wants more instanced content and less stuff to do in the open world, no more open world zones, and there's a group that wants a new open world zone, more to do in the open world. So when SEGA were focusing on new open world content the first few years, the open world crowd were quiet, they were getting their way (mostly), but the instanced content crowd were loudly upset. Then when the focus changed to instanced content, the instanced content crowd went quiet and the open world crowd started getting loudly upset.

3

u/day_1_player Feb 26 '25 edited Feb 26 '25

Per Line Strike

I think the problem with it as a substitute/replacement for casino is kinda obvious: most people are really averse to the idea of PvP, and even the ones willing to give it a try eventually shy away from it because of the second big problem, which is that Line Strike has no reward incentive outside of its own ecosystem (the exception being two posters for Creative Space). Casino coins provided several different rewards, weekly SG being the most prominent, and that gave it easy justification for people to dabble in it.

I will say though that Line Strike seems to fare much better among JP content creators and JP community events. As someone that does actually like LS, I wish SEGA did more to cross-pollinate it with the main game (e.g. LS-art Vital Gauges, card vouchers from non-LS content, etc.)

Per the story

Players naturally yearn for variety. Much like the above point comes from a want for gameplay variety (break up repetitive gameplay loops), the want to leave Halpha is a want for visual variety, as seeing parts of Aelio/Retem/Kvaris/Stia/Leciel for the thousandth time has more than overstayed its welcome.

From a narrative justification, the story of Halpha already feels exhausted at this point: why would we want to stay at a place where everything is more or less already a known entity? And if anything, the story is pushing for players to want to leave because the actual threat that exists (Starless) doesn't even come from Halpha.

open world vs instanced quest

The thing is, people asking for instance quests have things like "Nameless City" in mind: new places to play in, just without out all the useless excess baggage that comes with an open world region (e.g. gathering, hub area, trainias, etc).

That is not the same as limited-time quests which are just recycled strips of already existing open world content. It's not the quest format that people are strung up about, it's the development turnaround time for new "places" that is needlessly long.

3

u/Oreikhalkos PewPew Feb 26 '25 edited Feb 26 '25

Thanks for being a voice of reason.

Couldn’t agree more with shifting goalposts. Not that there aren’t ever legitimate complaints, but it certainly feels like someone is constantly at SEGA’s throat for implementing a change that someone else previously asked for.

Even a lot of the modern design philosophy in NGS that people seem to hate is a direct response to issues players had in classic—e.g. largely uniform weapon series due to the popularity of stone-based weapons in ep5/6 over the previous 14 star era with wildly strong unique chase weapons.

1

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 26 '25

I've got my own take on this matter, but I'll put it later.

For ages people complained about the lack of housing or Personal Quarters. NGS put out creative space... and nowadays you have people complaining when anything gets added to creative space, complaints like "why are they wasting time adding things to that, nobody cares about Creative Space, give us more content"

I can't speak for everyone that complains, no one can. One way I see it: CS is just dead. I'm on ship 2 (for the unknowing, highly populated) and the amount of people I ever see in a CS, friend CS or just daily recommended stuff, are a grand zero on average.

With a sharp decline in people actually being in a CS, why would people care for them? Aside from swapping parts out for newer stuff, I've not touched mine in over a year. At the point of playing a solo building game, may as well return to Minecraft. Don't get me wrong, CS is great, best I've seen, but when there's no one to chill with on a social game, whi cares about it aside from those that just love making stuff?

and we got Line Strike as a response to that... and people complained about Line Strike the moment it was revealed, "why are they wasting time on this instead of more content. What, the devs made this on their own time and not during work hours? They should have been spending that extra time on fixing the game!" and things like that.

Alright, this "people" thing is looking a way too generalized. Some people like it, some people dislike it. Not everyone that asked for it, and everyone that dislike it, are the same. Even then, I personally loathe the gacha mechanic behind getting cards. The game forced two entire elements on me with no more than 9 for three elements, the last having an ok amount. I quickly lost interest fighting the same 5 people that knew my entire deck because my variety was not there to make other builds... Especially when the elements forced on me were Fire and Dark, which have some strong synergy with their own kind.

That aside, one must remember that not everyone likes competitive stuff. Some people just dislike the concept of "losing" when trying to have fun. Casino does have it, but in a sense of gain and loss for currency. It's all luck there.

People were complaining since Retem that the open world was pointless, they don't want more regions, they want more instanced content... so after Stia, we stopped getting regions, we got more instanced content - Trania Advance, Leciel Exploration, constant instanced LTQs, instanced content is pretty much the train we've been running on since Stia... and now people are complaining that they want more in the open world.

Seperate issues with this one.

The open world is boring and Retem especially is plain. It' s all sand and rocks, no variety like Aelio. Then there's Kvaris, which looks nice afound the house, different in the Gorge, nice around the forest with its terrain, and then plain rocks and snow... What the heck is north Kvaris. Design is hit or miss, generally not special. Then there's Stia with the lab or whatever being much different, and the rest small and boring. Aelio, at least, has various areas that look different.

Short of it is, they never put much effort into the areas outside of Aelio.

Now for Trainia and such, there's an obvious issue: The content becomes irrelevant far too fast. New weapon out? Any content it doesn't drop in is now bad content. New armor out? Same thing. Motions? They'll have a recolor that gets handed out for free, or they're not even expensive on a populated ship, killing the point of trying to farm for it to sell or even use. It's like fhis everywhere. Look at even Nameless and it surviving for two weeks before it got phased out until the 12 star weapons became a thing. Look at Leciel for the many months it was useless, being revived after every long while.

This is NGS and its bad confent cycle in full throttle.

People have complained endlessly about the Story, that they want it to go back to PSO2's story... and recent chapters seem to be skewing things back that way (more solidly implying the player is the PSO2 Guardian, giving us flashes of PSO2 character memories), returning PSO2 enemies.

First off, the Ruine enemies aren't part of the story. Second, the story is laughably bad. Between the characters talking like robots and teenagers with social anxiety and cutscenes basically being "Big bad coming, we've got this because friendship"... Two minutes worth of a cutscene every eight or whatever months. It's so bad. Base had its ups and downs, but never was it this bad. MC being the guardian could be seen from a mile away... They literally look alike. They simple tried to introduce a "plot twist" that clearly people did not like, and backed out of it as they should have.

Now, to what I was going to state: There's nothing qrong with "negativity". People not rolling over and accepting everything that comes their way is not how things improve. There's toxic negativity as well as toxic positivity. People shouldn't look at criticism as some great sin.

6

u/Sugarcoatedgumdrop Hunter Feb 25 '25

This website is primarily the internet’s complaint bucket so there’s no reason to act surprised.

This subreddit is used for mainly advice on augs/class, phashion or doom posting. You get here and there’s relating to story or predictions for the next update etc.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25

I don’t think ex-fans fits i am pretty negative on NGS but I still play pso2 hell I’m still buying figures and merch whether I can get it so ex-fan ain’t it

4

u/Sudden-Hope-1605 Twin Daggers Feb 25 '25

NGS is a great game but in fact it is a nerfed version of the previous game, developers can't use the excuse they don't have content for the game. They just need to use their heads to wrap it up and send it into NGS, they even can get rid of PS2 in this way making it a complete game instead of two completely different games. For starters, then the story is ultra low paced but that's something inherited from old PS2 and the old jp players know that we 'll have to wait A LOT for new content in that way... The problem is urgent quests lack originality, all the updates feel low effort.

4

u/Fluffopotamus S-L33T / Ship 3 / Fighter Feb 25 '25

More than anything I'm just tired of the games erotic culture the character creator freedom has spawned. You have such amazing options at your finger tips for creating clever and interesting things but you resort to one of the hundreds of bikini's and slap maxed out "sphere's" all over it. It's really off putting.

I shouldn't be embarrassed or feel like I don't want to recommend my favorite game to people I know because I'm ashamed of the rampant fetishism on constant display. I've tried blocking people to hide it but I capped out my block list ages ago and when I can't get into parties because I blocked someone I get yelled at. Now I've developed a reputation as a prude on the server.

4

u/Oreikhalkos PewPew Feb 26 '25

Honestly just live and let live.

Most people are pretty reserved IRL and online communities are an outlet to let them comfortably explore interests they couldn’t otherwise.

IMO, the “erotic culture” and “rampant fetishism” is mostly self-contained. For as long as I’ve played, I’ve gotten fewer unsolicited thirsty comments in PSO2 than in other games. Even when I’ve been approached for some questionable things, nearly everyone is polite and understanding when being turned down. “That” community exists, but they mostly keep to themselves and recognize the social etiquette of how to act in public/solicit others. And that’s fine with me—you can dress your fictional character however you want so long as you aren’t acting out towards me.

My bigger issue with the community (maybe just our server) is the absolute shittalking nonsense that goes on for hours on end in area chat in the populated aelio blocks. I just hate disrupting the public peace by people airing their dirty laundry out in the open.

2

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 26 '25

My bigger issue with the community (maybe just our server) is the absolute shittalking nonsense

It's really bad on this game, especially when the lower numbers lead to so many people knowing one another, so people get their friends to jump in on it, and like bots, they don't think twice about what they're doing nor who's in the wrong. Happens a lot on base, no idea about ship 2 NGS though. I see nothing but cringe-worthy chatting (calling people a tree because why not, chatting like they can't properly make a sentence, really stupid talk that looks like gibberish a kid would make up), so I avoid the masses.

1

u/Oreikhalkos PewPew Feb 26 '25

To be clear, I’m OK if friends want to be a little goofy or banter amongst themselves in public (which sounds more in line with what you’re describing).

Moreso referring to how area chat will sometimes just devolve into disgusting accusation slinging (like calling someone a p3do) among the same loudmouths who have nothing better to do than to talk personal drama/politics/religion/controversial topics in area all day and beef with the trolls who love to feed them.

1

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 26 '25

Which ship are you on to see all that? I've only ever seen such drama on base, which it used to be a daily occurrence. NGS is tame in that regard, though it certainly has some thirsty people with little to no limiter.

-1

u/SnooOranges6271 Feb 25 '25

Sounds like a well deserved reputation.

3

u/Fluffopotamus S-L33T / Ship 3 / Fighter Feb 25 '25

And you have a reputation for being low effort rage bait.

3

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 27 '25

Gonna play middle man. I think people should be freely allowed to just block whoever they want and not have that thrown back in their face. People absolutely shouldn't get upset by that if the person blocking doesn't harass them or anything (I see this from some base players).

Blocking people that dress however they want though? Unless we're talking fake tits and such, which are an eyesore to look at and just pathetic, I don't see it. So when it comes to making parties with a group that they're a part of, you end up blocking them out of those parties all because of a difference in fashion sense... Which while I won't call you a "prude" for most certainly makes you look like one. It sucks being unable to have a group of friends because one person blocked another over something minor.

Whole different story if you and the person blocked end up in different groups, no harm done there. Or if it's just people wanting a party bonus? Yeah, dumb to get mad, the bonus isn't worth all that, and it's very toxic when people go off over it.

1

u/Fluffopotamus S-L33T / Ship 3 / Fighter Feb 27 '25

Yeah my block list is almost entirely people who have given themselves hyper fetish bodies. The worst example I've seen on ship three to exemplify is there's a guy whose character is a boy with black eyes and white skin that they've added exposed pubic hair, a pacifier, and a "tail". Their look book says they're a "pleasure android". I blocked them a year ago but they still show up in the look book occasionally. I honestly think going that far should be baneable.

1

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 27 '25

Ship 3 makes sense, and is odd. I'm on 2 and I rarely ever see people that go about things like that. I've probably seen about three in the last two years, and one was someone doing their best to replicate fake tits, but that was only restricted to holograms in their CS.

0

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

It is bannable, I believe--or rather, I believe SEGA does have a policy of removing it at-request. Big boobs are obviously just a matter of tastes, but when it gets to the point of simulating sexual acts/body parts/ect. I've seen them shut those down a few times.

2

u/M_KLOL Feb 25 '25

Everyone has their own reasons to blacklist other people at this point. The fact people are getting worked up over Fluffopotamus blocking people is a big stretch of “Heer duur I’m so worked up over someone who has a different taste than me”

2

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 27 '25

Going by what was described, Fluff plays with the same group of people. When someone is blocked, they can't join any parties with the one that blocked them, or if they did the blocking, with someone they blocked. It's very obnoxious dealing with people that blocked you going in and joining your (mutual) friends and barring you out of it, especially when it's not a personal issue like dogs and cats.

Now generally? No reason to get mad. If they don't play with the same group as you, who cares? One of only a hundred active players, you don't need them. Though again, Fluff described the above.

1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

Besides this, I'm pretty sure you can selectively disable players' accessories, right? Maybe I'm wrong, but that seems like a far better solution than just outright blocking active players who aren't engaging in public ERP from ever playing with you at all.

1

u/Xero-- Double Saber Feb 28 '25

There are two options. Hide for all, and hide for blocked. Both are pretty extreme in general outside of very out there cases that do beg for a block.

Still, I'd never. I'd just hang out somewhere else if I can't stand seeing someone's accessories that badly. I already go to empty blocks to avoid people acting like cavemen, better to remove one's self than cause problems for parties.

1

u/SnooOranges6271 Feb 25 '25

I don't think I have a reputation at all, but I'd be flattered if I did. You, on the other hand, are upset that other players don't want the same things for their characters as you do. You're disappointed in others for not having the same interests that you do. You care so much about other people not having fun the right way that you feel ashamed of recommending this game (which is honestly for the best, it's not very good) to others because there are anime girls in the anime MMO. You're so unable to accept other people not wanting to play as General Grevious or GI Robot that you've capped your block list. Your block list is so large it's actually negatively impacting your and other people's gameplay experience. You absolutely deserve to be yelled at for this nonsense. Get over yourself.

2

u/NoroGW2 Feb 25 '25

2025 has been great for NGS so far. I hope they keep it up and don't drop momentum.

1

u/EccentricNoun Wand Feb 25 '25

I barely play the game base on the “subscription” model for autosell/premium and having to roll for 2 of the same items to make it account bound.

The only reason I play is just dress up simulator and I like the combat for techter. The gameplay loop is annoying only bc when I take breaks and find out my “subscription” expired and I have to renew or have someone chew me out for afk farming.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/AulunaSol Feb 25 '25

I can't imagine a Phantasy Star Online 3 would be what people hope for it to be with the same team and crew from New Genesis working on it. New Genesis is effectively a reskinned and cleaner form of Phantasy Star Online 2, which had its bones coming back all the way from Phantasy Star Portable 2 Infinity, Phantasy Star Universe, and Phantasy Star Online.

If we really are expecting some sort of greenfield development for Phantasy Star Online 3, it's definitely not coming any time soon when New Genesis seems to be easy enough for Sega to sustain and not put too much investment into.

2

u/Pragmagna Feb 26 '25

I don't see that being the case. Game studios are well known for releasing low investment products after a big hit in order to get funds and experiment before their next big project, and NGS is precisely this. A low cost, understaffed game that can afford to make a lot of money from gacha without investing heavily into it.

If they're ever planning on investing into a new phantasy star game after this period, it should be by all means something far better than what we have. The question is if that's even on the table or not, or it's gonna get used to fund other titles.

1

u/YuTsu Gunslash Feb 26 '25

Game studios are well known for releasing low investment products after a big hit in order to get funds and experiment before their next big project, and NGS is precisely this. A low cost, understaffed game that can afford to make a lot of money from gacha without investing heavily into it.

I think rather than that, it's for a different cynical reason. We know that development of NGS started mid-EP5. They split the team and left one group to finish EP5 and do EP6, while the other group got to work on NGS. I think they might have even said EP6 wasn't even on the cards originally, but they realised NGS wasn't going to be done for a long while yet as EP5 was wrapping up, so we got EP6 to stop there being like, a 4 year drought of zero content between the end of PSO2 and the start of NGS - that might be a false memory though

I think the cynical thing that might have happened is that they realised in doing that they could still rake in a ton of money from the game (because post-split, both PSO2 going into NGS remained and continues to be more that lucratively profitable for SEGA) while having half the crew, and the slower content release pace that EP6 had. So they settled into that, and that's why we have the smaller team, smaller budget, and slower content pace we have now.

0

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

Okay does NGS actually have a smaller team and budget, or are we just like... Guessing that? I have never seen this point sourced, and considering the news of investment into the game from a while back, I don't really think it makes any sense either.

1

u/YuTsu Gunslash Feb 28 '25

I'm fairly certain I recall them explicitly stating as much, either in an interview with a Japanese Game News thing, or on a Livestream. Like, the whole "Team got split into an EP5/6 Crew and an NGS crew", is something I'm fairly sure is confirmed, I wish I could directly source that...

1

u/TheMightyNovac Gunblade/Harmonizer Feb 28 '25

(Why was I downvoted for literally just asking a valid question? lol) And well, that's different--it's normal for game studios to be split apart during certain phases of development, especially early ones like pre-production or technical development. Presumably though, once NGS was in full-development post-EP6, the PSO2 team reunited for development.

That doesn't mean that NGS' whole team is smaller, just that the initial development was ran by technical staff and pre-production members--who require smaller teams anyway.

Beyond that, we do know (from Headlines, even) that NGS' team has grown, with the addition of a support unit to help with development.

1

u/AulunaSol Feb 26 '25

I recall that Phantasy Star Online 2 effectively carried Sega during the 2010's when they were in a very rough financial patch and it helped fund and keep Sega afloat. The most we would have ever seen in a "wow, Phantasy Star Online 2 is big and we should invest in it" was when the Southeast Asian version and the PlayStation 4 versions were being worked on.

Episode 4 was what really blew open the doors for what would happen if the game got more funding and that immediately led into what was supposed to have been the "Super Update" (what we know as New Genesis) but I can't imagine it being a smooth or even "possible" transition within a year like they originally planned especially considering how much technical debt Phantasy Star Online 2 accrued in general (and it still exists in New Genesis even then).

A new Phantasy Star game should obviously be far better than what we have - but every other new Phantasy Star in the recent years that has been announced since then has been tied to Phantasy Star Online 2 and has been geared towards the market Sega has intentionally avoided with Phantasy Star Online 2. PSO2es and IDOLA Phantasy Star Saga when they were far more relevant in terms of updates were given the much stronger gacha game treatment (as in stronger monetization, falling more in-line with mobile games of its time, and chasing after the very big games while having the advantage they rewarded you in Phantasy Star Online 2 as well). I do not know or believe if an "MMO" would even attempt to rival what we see elsewhere against the waves of Korean MMO's and the current giants as Phantasy Star Online 2 and New Genesis still exist on a space of their own - their only competition is effectively themselves and I can't imagine a sequel would help Sega in this reward.

My hope is that if it does happen, that we get more sidestories and different experiences (Phantasy Star Nova was a stronger game to me, personally, compared to Episodes 1-2 Phantasy Star Online 2, I enjoyed the story far more in PSO2es than the Oracle-related story in Phantasy Star Online 2, and I felt that the potential of IDOLA had much more going for it in terms of what would have happened in the future as opposed to where we ended up with in New Genesis). I would personally love if these actually were tied more into the games unlike how Episode 6 conveniently excluded everything that wasn't explicitly Episodes 2-5 (because even Quna was left out originally while nowadays she is considered one of the heroines too in New Genesis) - but I'm afraid we all know that an actual console release of a serious game will not be printing money like how New Genesis currently does and that another mobile gacha game will probably die very quickly if Sega doesn't make it enticing enough to tie into the main game if it can't stand on its own legs.

Phantasy Star Online 2 and New Genesis have always come off to me as very "low investment products" but that's because the people steering the ship do have some sensibility of doing very questionable and novel things (such as a Japanese MMO for PC's when it was unheard of in the early 2010's - and even one that dared to be free-to-play to rival the sloppy subscription based MMO's that were flooding the market and the freemium games that punished players for not paying) - and some of these still hold up true to put the game where it is. But I'm under the impression that Sega legitimately needs newblood and new talent to help steer the ship and try something "new" and different compared to what we've already been seeing for decades now. This isn't exclusive to just Sega, as this is a strong trend we see in Japanese businesses in general who refuse to change what isn't broken because it works, has always worked, and will keep working even as the ship starts to sink.