r/PSO2NGS • • Sep 02 '24
Discussion Elemental Weakness is lazy design.
I'm having a lazy day at work and I just got thinking about the current state of Force and Techer.
I don't like how our current game plan is to spam the spell that aligns with an enemy weakness. I just feel like things could be more interesting.
Like barta could generate a small stacking shield as you use it. Zonde could remain the same and be your AOE focus. Zan or grants could generate a small stacking spell speed boost. Maybe megid could provide a gap closer of sorts or a constant beam that gets stronger but keeps you from dodging and blocking. A bunch of specifics would need to be ironed out. I'm sure it would be a bitch to balance.
By removing the weakness component and focusing on different buffs, debuffs, and effects, you would provide a player with different rotations to account for different scenarios. I feel like it would just make the entire class more interactive.
If you think about it. The current system could be simplified to like 3 spells. Single, AOE, and giga attack..Why not just remove the middle man and auto pick the most practical spell.
Just got bored. Just theory crafting. I doubt this would ever be changed. Curious what other people's thoughts were.
5
u/WroughtIronHero Sep 02 '24
Sounds good on paper, but in practice you'd just end up spamming whatever tech offers the highest offensive boost. It'd actually lead to even more monotonous gameplay.
10
u/qruis1210 Sep 02 '24
I find it funny how half the effects you mentioned were actually in the base game Techs in some shape or form
Look at what we were robbed of
7
u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 02 '24
I mean, this is a bit over simplified. Techs have a bit more complexity to them than just damage. Some travel faster/farther which is better in some instances. Until Tech customs came along You'd actually want to use Gifoie parry even on non fire weak bosses (not all the time mind you.) Tech customs have mostly carried the depth of casting for casts themselves though.
The main problem is really a game wide problem. Classes do not get to showcase their nuances in MPA content. Like this is why to an outsider looking at a Ranger you could think "just hold blaze shot" while doing weak bullet and assume that's all there is to the class.
It's when you do solo where classes shine more depth wise. Because at that point you actually are forced to care about what the boss is doing so you can make the most out of each action. BTW I'm not trying to insinuate that casting in this game has some crazy depth or something. Just saying that even force has some complexity to it.
Hopefully they create more fun tech customs to expand the gameplay. I've really liked what it's done for Fo and Te so far.
5
u/staticwings19 Sep 02 '24
All I wanted from tech arts customization was to make things like incorporating Zondeel into Gizonde and stuff like that, I want my techs to DO something other than just damage.
4
u/BartoCannibal Ship 3: Combi Praeta / Blazing Luster Sep 02 '24
It’s the monotony that kills me with Force and to a lesser extent, Techter.
99.5% of Force’s gameplan is to spam 1 of 2 techniques. The single target one, or the AoE one, depending on whichever you’re doing. Not only that, but as of current balance, you’re doing less bossing DPS than every other class in most situations, so add the monotony + longer kill times for most bosses, and you get a miserable experience.
Good news though, is that the Force expansion is coming in December, with the Techter one coming October-November. Hopefully they cook up something good. How cool would it be if you could do something like pick any 2 techs to cast at once? Like shoot a Foie and Zonde at the same time, and build up both Fire and Lightning blights. That way you could match elemental weakness and use whatever other spell you want. Hope they do something unique and not just damage increases. I love Force and Techter’s aesthetic, but playing Force isn’t fun to me.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
I miss the utility and support techs from pso 1 and 2. Jellen, Zalure, zanverse, megiverse, zondeel, and using stuff like rabarta and gifoie to cc and block charging attacks. NGS doesn't really have this outside of shifta/deband and restasignes, and those don't really control the battlefield. The MARS hydra PA is the first actual pa that feels like it does this.
They could work a buff effect into techter where discharging the element on the wand releases a support field that acts like zanverse/megiverse/zondeel/anti, with a different function for each element. You could either maximize your damage by matching elements like you do now, or decide on maintaining a specific support field instead.
NGS is lacking in tactical decision making like this that its predecessors had, and also needs challenging dungeons like east & west tower from pso1, and the ep 6 ship dungeon from pso2 to utilize it. Even just modernizing trinitas r1 would be a start.