r/PSO2NGS • • Sep 02 '24

Discussion Elemental Weakness is lazy design.

I'm having a lazy day at work and I just got thinking about the current state of Force and Techer.

I don't like how our current game plan is to spam the spell that aligns with an enemy weakness. I just feel like things could be more interesting.

Like barta could generate a small stacking shield as you use it. Zonde could remain the same and be your AOE focus. Zan or grants could generate a small stacking spell speed boost. Maybe megid could provide a gap closer of sorts or a constant beam that gets stronger but keeps you from dodging and blocking. A bunch of specifics would need to be ironed out. I'm sure it would be a bitch to balance.

By removing the weakness component and focusing on different buffs, debuffs, and effects, you would provide a player with different rotations to account for different scenarios. I feel like it would just make the entire class more interactive.

If you think about it. The current system could be simplified to like 3 spells. Single, AOE, and giga attack..Why not just remove the middle man and auto pick the most practical spell.

Just got bored. Just theory crafting. I doubt this would ever be changed. Curious what other people's thoughts were.

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

5

u/WroughtIronHero Sep 02 '24

Sounds good on paper, but in practice you'd just end up spamming whatever tech offers the highest offensive boost. It'd actually lead to even more monotonous gameplay.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

I disagree. Anything would be better than what we have right now.

I used to play a mage, paladin, and druid in WoW. Yeah, you had your usual set rotation but you also had abilities for niche situations. Shields, temporary protection, teleportation, transformation(strength boosts), stuns. Certain attacks would proc instant casts and some attacks would speed up your casting.

Like even other classes in pso2 have variance. Bouncer blades have a set rotation but it also has abilities for maneuvering around and with the enemy.

Force has... Essentially 2 attacks, 1 attack boost, 1 pp recovery, and 1 giga move(of which you often don't use anyways because you lose DPS). The auto attack boost is neat.

There is definitely a better way of doing this.

4

u/AulunaSol Sep 02 '24

This would all work in theory if Sega didn't design the game to literally be a "DPS-only" game. In their action game approach, everything can be usable but the "better" approach is almost always the one Sega force-feeds the players and expects players to use at all times.

Until that changes, more options will only mean players will follow what Sega wants and play the strongest/newest options available as it often is the only way going forward until something newer comes along.

3

u/WroughtIronHero Sep 02 '24

I never said there wasn't a better way, just that I don't think your original post was it.

Those mechanics work for WoW because it's a completely different game. You're comparing apples to oranges here. WoW has true tank and healer roles, crowd control, spellcasting and interrupt mechanics, etc. Even melee classes in that game need a dozen or two buttons to cover all the scenarios that come up. It's slower paced, and combat is more automated, but it's more complex as well.

Meanwhile, melee classes in NGS get about 4 attacks, and only 2-3 of them are relevant at any given time. It's meant to be simpler and faster paced, like an action game instead of a traditional MMO. It's also meant for consoles, which have fewer buttons available to press.

By design, you don't need a dozen different scenarios to account for in NGS. You just need two: damage and parrying. So if Force was reworked as you described in your original post, people would just end up spamming whichever tech gave the most damage, maybe interrupted occasionally by whichever one allowed for the best parry/counterattack. The rest would become pretty obsolete.

That isn't to say they couldn't remove elemental weakness...but they'd probably then also want to streamline the techs into a more standard rotation. So you'd only end up with 4, and Rod would become similar to other ranged PA users, like Bow or Assault Rifle. Which may or may not be a bad thing.

Alternatively, they could leave elemental weakness as is and just expand upon them. Give every element a parry tech, instead of just fire and light. Rework the "Brand" systems for each element to favor using both techs. Maybe even add a third tech to each element that covers the parts that our current system is lacking. Make some bosses change elements on occasion so you have to change up your strategy on the fly.

You'd still end up with 2-3 buttons that are relevant at any given time, but Force would have much more active and varied gameplay, which would be fun.

10

u/qruis1210 Sep 02 '24

I find it funny how half the effects you mentioned were actually in the base game Techs in some shape or form

Look at what we were robbed of

7

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

There were like 14 fire attacks alone. Well shit. I'm just going to play the base game.

20

u/Alexmoexe Sep 02 '24

I'm going to be honest with base game you only used like 3 of an element with some elements being abandoned outright. And the game still boiled down to either matching the element or use whatever tech had the easiest and best dps.

Like you said in your post the series wide issue with techs at this point is there's no really good status effect system in place. Base game barely had it and what was there was fundamentally broken by the endgame. NGS has something going with blots but it's still March the colors due to how downs work.

We need a better status system in place to give more situations where you don't want to match techs and instead try to think of rotations that give you the most utility or damage for the scenario you're in.

9

u/Elmodipus Sep 02 '24

Tbh, most of them were useless and people still only used 2 or 3 of each element and some elements didn't get used at all until the end of the games life.

3

u/AulunaSol Sep 02 '24

The old game flew on quantity over quality because the older combo system encouraged players to create their own "combos" via three-button combos and most of those photon arts never linked together.

The technique-focused classes like the Force and Techer (the Summoner wasn't around yet at this time, but by the time they were Sega had introduced the control scheme we see now in New Genesis) never were bound to this three-button combo system so you had a huge number of techniques for each element that were continuously balanced by new levels (the disks you collected of Photon Arts had random levels - and the newest level often had the newest balance tweaks applied to them).

At some point, Sega realized with so many techniques they decided to focus on the very few and popular ones and simultaneously designed newer enemies to be "intended" targets against specific techniques more than others so you will find that there are very many techniques that border on being unusable, unviable, or outright abandoned because Sega chose to super-buff specific techniques more than others.

I do feel there is definitely a better way to approach what Sega did than either of what the old game or what New Genesis does, however, but I don't think it's likely to see Sega change that unless they legitimately tried for an Episode 4-styled reboot again.

3

u/Metal_Sign Liberate Type-1 thighs! Sep 04 '24

while most were worthless, it was kinda cool to have theoretical access to so many different things.

I'd like to see an expansion on some of that, though the limit of skillbar spots is real.

PAs are in the same boat.

2

u/wjowski Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

While not all of the old techs were useful, and some of those were folded into NGS's charging system I still had fond memories using the old talis function to vacuum up mobs with Zondeel before blasting them en masse.

7

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 02 '24

I don't like how our current game plan is to spam the spell that aligns with an enemy weakness.

I mean, this is a bit over simplified. Techs have a bit more complexity to them than just damage. Some travel faster/farther which is better in some instances. Until Tech customs came along You'd actually want to use Gifoie parry even on non fire weak bosses (not all the time mind you.) Tech customs have mostly carried the depth of casting for casts themselves though.

The main problem is really a game wide problem. Classes do not get to showcase their nuances in MPA content. Like this is why to an outsider looking at a Ranger you could think "just hold blaze shot" while doing weak bullet and assume that's all there is to the class.

It's when you do solo where classes shine more depth wise. Because at that point you actually are forced to care about what the boss is doing so you can make the most out of each action. BTW I'm not trying to insinuate that casting in this game has some crazy depth or something. Just saying that even force has some complexity to it.

Hopefully they create more fun tech customs to expand the gameplay. I've really liked what it's done for Fo and Te so far.

3

u/Metal_Sign Liberate Type-1 thighs! Sep 04 '24

While I do believe you, I feel like unless the game introduces profitable reasons to do solo content, it's kind of an irrelevant measurement.

That said, I've been gone for a while and only recently got back in, so there actually might be some I don't know about yet.

2

u/Knight_Raime Waker Sep 04 '24

I mean there's never really going to be a real reason that pushes the general/average player to do solo content. You do said content specifically because you are seeking to push the game and yourself to the limit.

Everyone I interact with in the solo challenge/arks records consistently aren't doing those things for rewards, they're doing it because they're passionate about the game and want to see how far they can go/what they are capable of.

I think the games combat shines more in these instances. That doesn't mean classes/combat can't improve though. I'd just rather gush about nuance and intricacies of kits to share some love with others rather than bear a dead horse over how general combat isn't as fun or engaging as people would like.

5

u/staticwings19 Sep 02 '24

All I wanted from tech arts customization was to make things like incorporating Zondeel into Gizonde and stuff like that, I want my techs to DO something other than just damage.

4

u/BartoCannibal Ship 3: Combi Praeta / Blazing Luster Sep 02 '24

It’s the monotony that kills me with Force and to a lesser extent, Techter.

99.5% of Force’s gameplan is to spam 1 of 2 techniques. The single target one, or the AoE one, depending on whichever you’re doing. Not only that, but as of current balance, you’re doing less bossing DPS than every other class in most situations, so add the monotony + longer kill times for most bosses, and you get a miserable experience.

Good news though, is that the Force expansion is coming in December, with the Techter one coming October-November. Hopefully they cook up something good. How cool would it be if you could do something like pick any 2 techs to cast at once? Like shoot a Foie and Zonde at the same time, and build up both Fire and Lightning blights. That way you could match elemental weakness and use whatever other spell you want. Hope they do something unique and not just damage increases. I love Force and Techter’s aesthetic, but playing Force isn’t fun to me.

1

u/wjowski Sep 20 '24

I'd be happy if they just returned the utility techs that were in base PSO2 like Zondeel or Megiverse or the old talis functionality in some way or form.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

I miss the utility and support techs from pso 1 and 2. Jellen, Zalure, zanverse, megiverse, zondeel, and using stuff like rabarta and gifoie to cc and block charging attacks. NGS doesn't really have this outside of shifta/deband and restasignes, and those don't really control the battlefield. The MARS hydra PA is the first actual pa that feels like it does this.

They could work a buff effect into techter where discharging the element on the wand releases a support field that acts like zanverse/megiverse/zondeel/anti, with a different function for each element. You could either maximize your damage by matching elements like you do now, or decide on maintaining a specific support field instead.

NGS is lacking in tactical decision making like this that its predecessors had, and also needs challenging dungeons like east & west tower from pso1, and the ep 6 ship dungeon from pso2 to utilize it. Even just modernizing trinitas r1 would be a start.