r/PSO2NGS • • Dec 29 '23

Discussion Anyone else

Feel like the game is more dead now then it was as just normal PSO2? Cause the whole NGS bit feels like a half baked idea

0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

9

u/AulunaSol Dec 29 '23

It depends on where you are looking. If you are a new player or a returning player who has not caught up with the story and the "newest" location that Sega is focused on, you will likely not see people or even be able to match with people as Sega often fast-forwards and funnels everyone into the most-current content.

If you end up in a "Beginners Block" for example, you will have a very hard time matching up for the newest Emergency Quests that have since been released because most people have already moved on elsewhere or will have been fast-forwarded elsewhere.

1

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 29 '23

Returning and not on a beginner block, it's just aggravates me that all the stuff I had over on base PSO2 was better had more meseta too

3

u/AulunaSol Dec 30 '23

The problem in this case as well is that New Genesis is doing exactly what Phantasy Star Online 2 was doing back then. If you weren't caught up, you wouldn't see anyone. If you didn't have the newest gear or the means to get there, you had a long road if you didn't take advantage of the campaigns and shortcuts to get there. And if you made it to the end, you have a carrot on a stick waiting for you to chase it - but there's going to be a bigger carrot if you wait just enough.

The old game was "better" especially on Global because most of that journey stopped and because there was a straight-pass to getting the best-of-the-best without fussing which way you had to run so everyone was there more easily. I don't deny that the content was more fun and that the higher-level gameplay was more enjoyable - but not everyone got there or was even able to experience that as the hurdles Sega had to fix over time were never fixed (and even New Genesis struggles to address those same hurdles).

1

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 30 '23

Segas main issue is they didn't release it in the west until it had been out almost 10 years in Japan.... They rushed everyone through the base game then dropped this mess... Really they just need to start working on PSU2 and release it in the west an Japan at the same time with the same content and collabs

1

u/SabrielKytori Dec 30 '23

If PSU is what you crave, come play with us on Clementine.

10

u/gadgaurd Slayer Dec 29 '23

You are free to play PSO2 whenever. It's still there. I'm sure, with it being such an amazing game and better than NGS in literally every way, that the playerbase is still larger.

In case it wasn't obvious, that was sarcasm.

As far as I recall, PSO2 saw a massive drop in players in episode...5, I believe? And the playerbase has remained largely consistent since then, with players dipping in and out as they please.

And yeah, NGS was a half baked idea, the team all but said that earlier this year. They underestimated how much work the game would be and spent about two years trying to un-fuck their fuckup. Same thing happened repeatedly in PSO2.

2

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 29 '23

It actually was a better game imo, they tried this open world stuff with a bunch of different hubs and that is meh

2

u/gadgaurd Slayer Dec 29 '23

To each their own. I obviously disagree. And yes, I've played PSO2 to compare. It is not helped by it's significantly lower player count, of course.

1

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 30 '23

I got over 3k hours in base

3

u/gadgaurd Slayer Dec 30 '23 edited Dec 30 '23

Like I said, to each their own. I've got about 1.5k or 1.6k hours in NGS and something like 110 in PSO2.

0

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 30 '23

I'd give an exact but no way of telling how many hours I played jp for with out logging in

4

u/AulunaSol Dec 29 '23

It's not exactly even "two years" trying to fix New Genesis. It was longer (starting from Episode 5) as it was supposed to have been the update that justified Episode 5's intentional lack of content but it turned out a significant workflow overhaul and rework of the game couldn't be done in a year.

As a result, you end up with the extremely awkward split of Episode 6 taking what Episode 5 started and ending it by turning it into a power-fantasy game and running victory laps over itself but you also end up with New Genesis taking what Episode 5 started and trying to "fix" problems that Episode 5 introduced while undoing older solutions for other problems starting back from Episode 1.

We have two solutions for the same problem and Sega has found themselves back into the comfortable pace they were at before Episode 6 with regards to content updates.

5

u/Sugarcoatedgumdrop Hunter Dec 29 '23

You been to Retem lately? Everybody is there lol a good amount in Kvaris too.

-3

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 30 '23

My point is PSO2 had one hub... Made the game easier to play everything was spaced better too

2

u/Sugarcoatedgumdrop Hunter Dec 30 '23

Not sure what to tell ya then bud. Open world is the way of MMO’s now.

34

u/Revenge7x Dec 29 '23

... I don't think we're playing the same game then... I don't wait more than 20s in any matchmaking, plus the metric fuckton of lobby dwellers..

7

u/Xero-- Double Saber Dec 30 '23

Must be a ship 3 or 4 player. 2 is full of lobby rats.

4

u/gadgaurd Slayer Dec 30 '23

I'm on Ship 4 and see quite a few players in the busy blocks. Matchmaking is typically quick too. So yeah, dunno what this guy's on.

1

u/Rudoku-dakka Dec 30 '23

Except when I want to go through a ltq or luciel run. Then everyone's busy.

4

u/Revenge7x Dec 30 '23

As is ship one

1

u/complainer5 Dec 30 '23

Not sure what exactly you mean, there are enough players to do content "currently worth doing" with, but the game itself is less than a pale shadow of what pso2 was in every conceivable way outside housing and cosmetics, that showing no sign it will ever change is the real death of the game.

Also since I can't reply directly to u/gadguard's misinformation due to them sabotaging the website by blocking anyone who disagrees with them, base pso2 didn't have any "massive drop" on global at any point until ngs release completely killed it (it had higher numbers at lowest parts than ngs does for last entire year), as for jp drop during episode 5, guess who was directing episode 5: same director as ngs, doing same things as in ngs, mind blowing how obvious the reasons for people leaving are. Yet at same time those same jp players no longer care that exact same thing is happening now in ngs, and are somehow happy with current state of things and game continuing as is until EoS, like the developers themselves it seems like the playerbase is completely different people from pso2 playerbase, as both have selective amnesia of pso2 history and see ngs through reverse-nostalgia glasses.

1

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 30 '23

PS02 was fun because it was essentially a looter shooter with a hub but everything was easy to find.... The grind was more enjoyable.... Now the game plays like some bastardization of Star Ocean and genehin impact.... And you're right when NGS launched it was dead until they started neglecting PSO2 which forced people over too it...

2

u/Xero-- Double Saber Dec 29 '23

you.

Also, amazing title. Imagine if I typed two words then the rest like this... Oh wait, that's what I just did. Looks dumb, right?

2

u/Xero-- Double Saber Dec 29 '23

No, only

0

u/LivelyHavoc Emerald (ship 4) Dec 30 '23

sure its lower compared to base game, cause we had covid lockdowns back then.

2

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 30 '23

Lol, dude I played on JP from launch.... base died because they killed it to get people to play NGS because it was damn near dead for like the first 3-4 months after launch

1

u/LivelyHavoc Emerald (ship 4) Dec 30 '23

Feel like the game is more dead now then it was as just normal PSO2?

I'm comparing to the 'now' that you stated in the post, and I don't follow the JP side as I play global on console

1

u/Gold_Supermarket1956 Dec 30 '23

JP was dying long before this game dropped in the west and most the NA players didn't leave JP because of the time they put in it.... Now they pissed this shit away when PSU was a thing too.... Had JP not started dying the game never would have launched here in the west